About this conversation

How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.

Ask about this conversation

This conversation only
Answers are grounded in indexed transcripts only.

Transcript

00:01

welcome to influential Minds an eei

00:04

international conversation series which

00:06

aims to discuss ideas that move the

00:08

needle towards a more sustainable future

00:10

with thought leaders from across the

00:12

globe here's your host senior vice

00:14

president of international programs at

00:16

eei Dr Lawrence Jones

00:19

thank you good afternoon good evening

00:21

good morning wherever you are welcome

00:23

thanks for joining us here Dr Ann

00:25

Christine doing from Massachusetts

00:28

thank you for having me this is going to

00:30

be an interesting conversation let me

00:32

first of all congratulate you on the

00:34

book uh minding the climate how

00:36

Neuroscience can help solve our

00:38

environmental crisis

00:41

let's begin Christine by you perhaps and

00:43

Christine just telling us

00:45

what got you involved in Neuroscience or

00:47

in the brain to begin with why the brain

00:49

of all things in the world

00:51

of all things in the world the brain is

00:54

so the brain to me is the

00:58

reason that we Are Who We Are and is the

01:02

answer to all questions uh or virtually

01:05

all questions about why we behave the

01:07

way we behave and from very early in my

01:10

life this was an overriding curiosity

01:14

um if one has this sort of curiosity you

01:16

may go in many directions you may become

01:18

a philosopher you may become someone in

01:20

religion you may become someone in

01:22

science and I ended up on the science

01:25

and Neuroscience pathway just because

01:27

the brain was just so very interesting

01:30

and an endless source of awe and

01:33

Fascination yeah so so let's talk a

01:35

little bit about the book

01:37

um this is one of the few books I've

01:39

seen that's sort of a link links climate

01:43

to the brain

01:45

talk about that what drove you to make

01:48

that connection between the climate and

01:50

the Brain

01:52

if you are in the neurosciences and as

01:56

you know I'm a neurosurgeon

01:59

um you think about everything in terms

02:01

of the brain just like a chef thinks

02:03

about everything in terms of ingredients

02:05

and recipes and someone who's in

02:07

construction thinks about how things are

02:09

built if you are immersed in that world

02:12

you see the world through the lens of

02:15

that area

02:17

and to me

02:18

the climate crisis which I see as our

02:22

biggest existential threat

02:25

can be viewed through the lens of the

02:28

brain and Neuroscience simply because we

02:31

humans are the cause of the problem and

02:34

we humans will be the solution to the

02:36

problem should we be smart enough to

02:39

figure one out or figure multiple

02:41

simultaneous Solutions out so looking at

02:45

that connection between how the brain is

02:47

designed to operate

02:49

why it's designed that way

02:51

through the tutelage of evolutionary

02:54

pressures

02:55

and how that design has influenced both

02:58

the cause and the potential Solutions

03:00

seems a very logical connection to me as

03:04

I was reading the book I was intrigued

03:05

by the examples you give regarding just

03:08

understanding the complexity of the

03:10

brain being an engineer myself I love

03:13

the examples about the secretary of the

03:15

brain so for the audience just tell us

03:18

how does the brain actually work

03:21

well I can tell you that in 30 seconds

03:22

you'll get it but

03:26

in the book

03:28

um I had to do my own exploration to try

03:30

to answer these questions now obviously

03:32

as a neurosurgeon I have to know

03:34

something about how the brain works

03:35

because otherwise I couldn't do my job

03:38

but I think a different way to answer

03:41

your question is why does it work the

03:43

way it works and if you ask the why

03:46

question you'll get to the how question

03:49

the brain started like all of biology

03:52

with simpler organisms that then became

03:55

more and more complicated over time

03:57

and I had to go back to single cells

04:01

because

04:03

I know you have children I had children

04:05

that grew up in the era of Harry Potter

04:09

and it was as though you could have a

04:12

magic wand that would simply make magic

04:14

occur and that's how things happened

04:17

but when you think about biology and you

04:19

think about the brain

04:20

it had to start somewhere and get more

04:23

complicated

04:24

how did it start in terms of something

04:27

like decision making at the simplest

04:30

level

04:31

and I had to go all the way back to

04:33

single cells to bacteria to say how does

04:36

a cell know to move towards a source of

04:39

nutrition like sugar and away from a

04:41

source of a toxin like ammonia how does

04:44

it do that

04:46

well at the Single Cell level it does it

04:49

with the same principle

04:50

that scales all the way up to the brain

04:54

in that the way it works is this there

04:57

is some molecule on the surface of that

05:00

single cell that bacteria and that

05:03

molecule just by chance by random things

05:08

that occur eventually a molecule ended

05:11

up on the cell surface that when it

05:14

interacts with some other molecule out

05:16

there in the world

05:18

the molecule on the cell surface changes

05:20

shape

05:21

so that certain kinds of substances

05:24

typically charge substances can get into

05:26

the cell or can get out of the cell and

05:29

it changes what's on the inside of the

05:31

cell and over time over time over time

05:35

a cell that happened to have molecules

05:38

that could move away from the toxin or

05:40

towards the sugar at a survival example

05:43

a survival advantage and it's an example

05:46

of how things work by biochemical

05:50

interactions that create what we call

05:53

Behavior it does this instead of that it

05:56

does this under these circumstances and

05:58

that under those circumstances

06:02

now our brains evolving over

06:06

as you know millions of years

06:09

um have those same principles inside

06:11

cells inside organs such that chemical

06:16

reactions occur that make things happen

06:19

and they end up as Behavior so it's

06:23

under evolutionary pressures that we

06:26

just that we that Evolution that time

06:29

designed the brains we have today and

06:32

how they work is based on those basic

06:34

principles

06:36

in the book we talk about the reward

06:38

system

06:39

people tend to think that reward means a

06:42

pat on the head or an extra prize or

06:46

extra money that's my reward that's how

06:48

we use the word reward in common

06:50

conversation

06:52

but in the brain the reward system is

06:56

the system

06:58

of interactions in the brain

07:01

largely run on the power of

07:05

electrochemical connections and

07:07

processes that helped us learn

07:11

what we needed to learn to survive

07:14

as a species and so

07:17

the scaffolding from single cells where

07:20

you do this or that depending on

07:22

external chemicals to internal cognitive

07:26

processes and decision making

07:28

that happens with millions of

07:30

simultaneous or closely linked events

07:33

for every decision happen based on the

07:36

same principles of what will help us

07:39

survive so like that single cell moving

07:42

towards the nutrition and away from the

07:43

toxin helped it survive in our brains

07:47

decisions that helped us survive that

07:50

were mediated by neurotransmitters

07:52

aligned with the evolution of the reward

07:55

system is how we make our decisions

07:57

today

07:58

all based on the same principles that

08:00

have gotten more complicated but the

08:02

same basic principles underlie all of

08:04

these functions we'll get into the

08:06

reward system but just instead of a

08:08

summary so basically we have what 86

08:11

billion neurons in the brain uh lots of

08:14

complex systems and it's not one single

08:17

thing that affects the decisions that we

08:19

make I was intrigued when I was reading

08:21

the book when you talk about the fact

08:23

that sometimes decisions are being made

08:25

you're not even aware of what's happened

08:27

in the background talk about that where

08:29

you know I mean people sitting here even

08:32

even as they sit here this conversation

08:34

is having an impact on the decision it

08:36

might make tomorrow talk about what I

08:38

would call the latency of decision

08:41

making where you may not even be aware

08:43

that you're making a decision made on

08:45

something you saw heard felt touch smell

08:47

decades ago a year ago how does that

08:50

work because each thing that happens to

08:53

you internal external the internal

08:56

influences of are you hungry did you get

08:58

a good night's sleep last night the

09:00

external influences of what happened

09:02

that is in your memory but might not be

09:04

in your conscious awareness all the

09:06

things that have happened to you each

09:08

change your brain and so things that

09:10

happen to you in childhood things that

09:12

happened last week a movie you saw three

09:15

months ago each of these things in some

09:17

way has changed the connections the

09:20

strength of the connections the

09:22

predispositions in your brain so you are

09:24

carrying around a lifetime

09:27

in your own lifetime as well as genetic

09:30

influences and epigenetic influences

09:32

going back you know forever

09:36

um that influence the decisions that you

09:38

make at any one time now you think we

09:40

all think because we you know can

09:43

consciously reflect on this that these

09:45

decisions are logical I know why I did

09:47

that but in fact things are influencing

09:50

you all the time that are below your

09:51

level of conscious awareness you are who

09:53

you are because of all the things that

09:55

have happened to you some of which had a

09:57

bigger impact than others because they

09:59

were

10:01

influential for a variety of reasons

10:04

that made them stronger than other

10:06

things and the genetic influences which

10:08

you can sometimes recognize you say I

10:11

was just like my dad when I said that

10:13

and uh and things that that come down

10:17

through the centuries that you're not

10:19

aware of and so our decision making is a

10:22

complex multi-million

10:26

event process at any one time we we

10:29

don't know that but the book goes into

10:32

understanding that at sort of a more

10:34

visceral level yeah I enjoy this chapter

10:37

on uh reward system right because there

10:40

are rewards that affect what we do uh

10:43

and you talk about some of the different

10:44

reward schemes like money is a reward

10:46

for some people let's tie it back to

10:48

climate change right

10:50

um in the book you talk a lot about the

10:53

difficulty to change our behavior and

10:56

it's part of the reward system link

10:58

climate change this difficulty in making

11:00

decisions to change our Behavior back to

11:03

understanding the brain what's the

11:05

linkage there

11:06

climate change in particular

11:09

plays to our weaknesses

11:11

and this is because if you think about

11:14

what we needed to survive during

11:16

evolutionary time when our brains were

11:18

being designed

11:19

most of our decisions for survival were

11:22

short-term immediate decisions

11:25

climate change is difficult because it

11:28

is more long-term we've never faced a

11:30

problem like this we don't have

11:32

Collective

11:34

um societal cultural understanding of

11:37

these problems they've not occurred

11:39

before so we we don't have cultural

11:41

history to call upon and we

11:46

were designed on a on a chassis so to

11:49

speak of decision making that by and

11:53

large while we have the ability to think

11:54

ahead to some extent

11:56

more of our survival decisions were

11:58

short-term and immediate and we had

12:02

also the additional reward besides

12:05

resources and security and things that

12:09

now are represented by monetary or

12:13

financial gain we had acquisitiveness in

12:17

our pre-history that was a parallel to

12:20

that but when you made a decision

12:24

you got an immediate sense that it was

12:27

the right decision so in the book as you

12:30

might recall there's a section that

12:32

talks about a classic decision in human

12:35

decision making about I'm walking

12:37

through the woods nighttime is coming I

12:39

need to get to shelter I cross I come

12:43

upon a river and there's a Fallen Tree

12:45

over the river

12:47

we're really well designed for that you

12:49

know how to push on the tree to see how

12:52

secure it is you know how to judge the

12:54

strength you know your own history of

12:56

can you swim you have some sense of the

12:58

temperature and how cold that water is

13:00

and how cold the air is you have some

13:02

sense of how quickly the light is fading

13:04

all of this plays to your personal

13:06

experience and your sensory capabilities

13:09

think about climate change we can't even

13:12

perceive in our senses carbon dioxide we

13:16

did not need in evolutionary time to

13:19

learn how to sense carbon dioxide in our

13:22

senses we can we can sense the color

13:24

spectrum we can sense uh certain toxins

13:28

some are invisible to us but some that

13:30

were evolutionarily important we can

13:32

sense we have tactile sensation we can't

13:36

perceive climate change except for its

13:38

effects and in addition those effects

13:41

are vague enough and have other

13:44

potential causes that it's easy to it's

13:48

easy to discount them in addition the

13:52

time frame is long beyond our individual

13:55

experiential time frame so it is a

13:59

particularly tough problem for us to

14:01

make rational or even as I would say

14:05

emotional decisions about it and it will

14:08

come to us as information which is newer

14:11

evolutionarily from people we don't

14:13

necessarily know personally from

14:15

experience that we don't have viscerally

14:18

which is really just another way of

14:20

saying in your brain but we sense it as

14:21

a visceral kind of a response and it

14:24

really plays to our weaknesses as

14:26

decision makers so so so stay on that

14:29

for a second though uh and Christine

14:32

the urgency so we heard yesterday that

14:35

the ipcc came up with a report saying

14:38

that we might get to 1.5 degrees

14:40

increase in temperature by the year

14:43

2035. one would expect this urgency or

14:47

this sense of urgency to drive us to

14:49

change our Behavior but in the book you

14:51

talk about that might not necessarily be

14:53

the case so why is it that even though

14:55

we're told of this urgency we still

14:57

cannot change

15:00

wouldn't say we can't but it's a

15:02

challenge

15:02

and in in part it's a challenge because

15:05

as you know it's easy to say we have to

15:08

do it by this time or we have to do it

15:10

by that time

15:12

is in the future we have trouble with

15:14

that we can intellectually feel it but

15:17

it's not the same as I'm hungry I want

15:19

to go get something to eat right now or

15:22

you know I need to go somewhere I know

15:25

how to get my my self transported to

15:27

that place these decisions these actions

15:30

these uh uh priorities are much easier

15:34

for us than something that we perceive

15:37

theoretical and in the future it's just

15:40

hard for us to both perceive of that

15:42

urgency in ways that are not just

15:45

intellectual which is a challenge for us

15:49

sometimes urgency

15:51

for it it gets into our brains as fear

15:55

as fear of something that is imminent

15:59

um but even fear is difficult one of the

16:02

ways that many people that have gotten

16:04

involved in climate action uh get

16:08

involved is because they have fear for

16:09

their children

16:10

and that is a that is a human reaction

16:13

but even there it's something future and

16:16

theoretic nonetheless it can be a

16:18

motivator so fear can be a motivator

16:21

but the urgency of climate change as a

16:24

concept is less compelling to most

16:27

people than the urgency of some of its

16:29

consequences like a storm or a wildfire

16:32

as more of these events that are linked

16:35

to climate change become apparent to

16:37

people more people are afraid more

16:39

people feel a sense of urgency but it's

16:42

still not the same kind of urgency as I

16:43

got to get out of this building because

16:45

it's on fire you wish it were

16:47

intellectually we can make that leap but

16:49

it's still a challenge for the way we

16:51

work okay so let's talk about one

16:53

urgence that we had as a globe not too

16:55

long ago which was the pandemic

16:58

that brought about immediate change I

17:02

mean today stay at home work from home

17:04

uh you know all these societal changes

17:07

what made the covet pandemic the changes

17:10

we've made why were those easier to make

17:13

compared to climate change that's a

17:15

great question and isn't it a little bit

17:17

heartening that we were able to change

17:20

like that it shows that we can do it

17:23

illness is something we know

17:25

illness is something as old as people

17:27

and so the Specter of an illness that

17:30

can affect me

17:32

or my loved ones that is scarier than

17:36

the Specter of carbon dioxide elevation

17:38

that I can't perceive and I've never

17:41

known anybody to die of carbon dioxide

17:44

I'd known somebody to die of an illness

17:47

that looks like covet

17:48

and so it's just more in our experience

17:52

it's more in our culture

17:54

nonetheless we did have to make big

17:56

pivots because the scale of a pandemic

17:59

is so big

18:00

and so we did have to call upon our

18:05

intellectual resources our Cooperative

18:07

resources which are not always easy to

18:11

do and we did have to think globally

18:13

were we really good at it not

18:16

necessarily but we we did we you know

18:20

people did

18:22

in fits and starts and with varying

18:24

degrees rise to the challenge there were

18:27

incredible Technologic resources that

18:30

went into creating the vaccines very

18:32

quickly disseminating them nonetheless

18:34

we weren't perfect at it and one can uh

18:38

level a lot of criticisms to how slow we

18:40

were and how inequitable we were about

18:43

our response nonetheless we did make

18:46

that pivot I think in part it's because

18:48

it was something we understood as an

18:51

immediate threat we saw people dying and

18:54

nobody wanted to die and so that drove

18:56

people to change so so in the book

18:58

intriguingly enough for those who

18:59

haven't read the book if you want to

19:01

understand that we're addicted to

19:03

consumption who are going to have a

19:05

conversation about addiction and our

19:07

addiction to consumption you talk about

19:09

behavioral change and how consumption of

19:13

especially people in the high income

19:15

countries drive what is happening around

19:17

climate

19:18

talk about this acceleration of

19:20

consumption and

19:22

the addiction we have as a society to

19:25

consuming things and the reward that we

19:29

feel we get we feel we get from

19:31

consuming more stuff

19:33

talk about that

19:35

there have been people who have tried to

19:37

make that

19:40

um conjunction between addiction as we

19:43

think of it medically addiction to

19:45

substances and then sometimes addiction

19:48

to behaviors like gambling gambling is

19:51

not a substance but people

19:53

believe many people believe some people

19:55

question this that you really can become

19:58

addicted in the same way to a behavior

20:00

like uh gambling and the other common

20:04

example that's used is video addiction

20:07

some people can actually become

20:09

clinically addicted to shopping and the

20:11

link that I think is interesting to

20:13

shopping shopping oh okay and the link

20:16

uh that some people make is that there

20:19

are pathological conditions this is one

20:22

of the things that links it back to my

20:23

field uh where people actually can

20:26

become addicted to certain behaviors

20:28

like shopping under certain conditions

20:30

of pathology and to me one of the

20:32

Intriguing links was uh the disease

20:35

Parkinson's disease where it's not the

20:38

disease that gets you addicted it's the

20:39

treatment of the disease so in

20:42

Parkinson's disease there is a very

20:44

specific decrease in a particular

20:47

neurotransmitter that many people have

20:48

heard of dopamine in a very particular

20:51

very localized spot in the brain and in

20:54

that particular spot where the disease

20:56

affects the cells that create the

20:59

dopamine

21:00

it manifests itself as changes in how

21:03

people are able to control their

21:05

movements it's the motor system

21:09

but dopamine is a transmitter that goes

21:12

throughout your brain and is heavily

21:14

also involved in reward circuitry

21:18

and the treatment for Parkinson's

21:20

Disease which is that local loss in a

21:24

particular part that invests mostly into

21:26

the motor system

21:28

increases the dopamine in other

21:30

locations so what was found is that the

21:34

increase in dopamine in other locations

21:38

push people into these behavioral

21:41

obsessions slash addictions

21:44

things like consumption and shopping

21:46

this was the link that I found

21:49

intriguing between what we might

21:52

consider normal behavior and something

21:55

driven by a pathology or a treatment of

21:57

a pathology so what was happening to

21:59

these patients and and still happens to

22:02

some patients so we understand it better

22:03

and can prevent it a little better is

22:05

that the increase in dopamine in one

22:07

part of the system

22:09

was having an overdose in other parts of

22:12

the system

22:13

and what that helps link is to people

22:18

who don't have Parkinson's don't have

22:20

extra dopamine given to them as a

22:22

medical treatment

22:23

but get into these behavioral addictions

22:26

to things like video gaming shopping and

22:28

certain other conditions

22:30

which are basically

22:33

excesses of consumption or excesses of

22:37

the reward of consumption

22:42

um people in the field have taken this

22:45

as an evidence that our society as a

22:48

whole in the wealthy industrialized

22:50

societies have become quote unquote

22:52

addicted I'm going to use that word a

22:54

little bit Loosely here

22:56

to consumption

22:58

and when you think back to how our

23:01

brains evolved we

23:05

get a reward and again I'm not talking

23:08

about

23:09

um the kind of rewards you get because

23:11

you use your credit card and you get

23:12

points towards flying or something like

23:14

that I'm using the reward in the

23:16

biologic sense

23:17

by acquiring something that gives you a

23:21

survival advantage or security

23:24

in modern uins this translates to

23:26

financial reward oftentimes and it also

23:30

can translate to

23:32

material reward and this addiction to

23:37

shopping or gambling is another way of

23:40

saying that we are getting a particular

23:43

type of neural reward to consuming and

23:48

acquiring certain things

23:50

now here's the problem

23:53

that kind of reward is very short-lived

23:56

biologically it is designed to be

23:58

short-lived because the whole point of

24:01

the dopaminergic reward system in our

24:04

biology is that it teaches you what you

24:07

need to survive so if you're walking

24:09

through a landscape and you're hungry

24:12

and you're tired and you're thirsty and

24:14

you come upon a patch of berries

24:17

that you've never seen before you've

24:19

never been in this place before your

24:21

reward system is designed to say ah wow

24:24

those are the best berries I ever had

24:26

this is like wonderful and in that

24:30

neural mechanism you will make

24:33

associations between those berries how

24:36

you feel that you know you get your

24:38

hunger and thirst satisfied and the

24:41

other features of that landscape so that

24:43

next time you're in that circumstance

24:45

you now know where to look for berries

24:48

either come back to that place or if

24:50

you're a nomad you look for similar

24:52

features in the landscape that's what

24:54

you needed to learn to survive

24:57

you also need to learn new things so

25:00

once you've learned those associations

25:01

you don't need to learn them anymore now

25:04

you're gonna yeah you're gonna like the

25:05

berries but your reward system is

25:07

designed to teach you the next thing you

25:09

need to know to survive in the next

25:11

adapted landscape that you encounter

25:14

the problem in Modern Life is that those

25:18

rewards of consumption that are an

25:21

outgrowth of the way the system was

25:22

designed to work in the prehistory of

25:24

humans

25:25

and it's not just humans we were built

25:27

on the landscape of animals that came

25:30

before us and had this same system all

25:32

the way back to invertebrates

25:35

it's very very temporary so in Modern

25:38

Life when you get a reward you go

25:40

shopping on Amazon it's delivered to

25:43

your door it's great

25:45

for a short time the reward then goes

25:49

away because that's how it's designed

25:51

it's designed to be transient so I think

25:53

in the book I use the example of a

25:55

furniture store

25:57

so you know you get a new sofa well now

25:59

you want to complete the look and they

26:01

tell you that in the sales you know

26:04

people well if you've got a carpet that

26:07

went with that sofa it would be even

26:08

better and if you've got an easy chair

26:11

that went with that sofa it would be

26:13

even more rewarding and each time you

26:15

get a reward but it goes away

26:17

so to keep the same satisfaction you

26:19

have to get more and more and more and

26:21

this plays to our biology in a way that

26:24

increases our consumption it ties back

26:26

then to climate and our consumption

26:28

because we need those highs throughout

26:32

our lives to feel that we're making it

26:34

and so change to affect our lifestyle

26:37

that will take away those highs is

26:39

difficult they're difficult for us to do

26:41

they are difficult but the interesting

26:43

thing is and you may be planning to get

26:46

to this is that it doesn't make us happy

26:49

so those rewards were designed that

26:51

whole system was designed for short-term

26:54

survival

26:55

but study after study has shown that

26:57

long-term happiness is not based on

26:59

these highs and lows of immediate reward

27:01

it's based on two main other things

27:05

a sense of purpose

27:07

and relationships

27:08

and those two things are mediated quite

27:11

differently in our neural circuitry and

27:15

that's what gives what we call happiness

27:17

or long-term life satisfaction so this

27:20

chasing Rewards

27:22

doesn't get us where most of us think we

27:25

want to go these two long-term life

27:27

satisfaction but then and Christine so

27:29

so let's talk about value then right

27:31

because part of this ties back to our

27:33

value system right I mean you know you

27:36

you're told when you're going to school

27:37

get a job make money get rich buy a big

27:41

house get a wife multiple kids multiple

27:44

dogs multiple cars it's more more more

27:47

more right and that's how Society values

27:50

you you know say oh you're a great guy

27:52

look at this guy you had a multi-million

27:53

dollar house he's great he's successful

27:56

how do we change the value system

27:58

because unless we change the value

27:59

system

28:00

the reward is what's driving the drive

28:03

the value so how do we bring about

28:05

an understanding I know it's not easy to

28:07

change but how do we change our value

28:09

system so we stop looking at those

28:11

things that are transient and start

28:13

looking at things that are much more

28:14

sustainable over the long run

28:16

well I don't know that I can answer that

28:18

I mean I'm just a neurosurgeon but not

28:20

just I mean it's not neurosurgeon it's

28:22

just

28:23

but here's what a neuroscience approach

28:27

helps us do here's the only value to

28:30

this whole exploration in my mind which

28:34

what Neuroscience allows you to do is

28:36

give an arm's length view to the way we

28:40

we are the way we are for reasons that

28:43

are understandable and comprehensible

28:47

it allows us to say

28:50

are these societal values

28:52

which is what your question is about

28:55

do they make sense did they come from on

28:58

high did they come from

29:00

Harry Potter's magic wand or are these

29:03

all an outgrowth of the way we work

29:06

neurologically and if it gives you that

29:09

arm's length

29:12

you don't have to be judgmental about it

29:15

you don't have to say this is bad and

29:17

this is good this is these people are

29:19

bad to have these values these people

29:20

are good to have these values you can

29:22

say where did this come from

29:25

and having that Neuroscience View

29:29

gives you the ability to say we are not

29:32

necessarily forced into this narrow idea

29:36

of what's valuable

29:39

we can look at it objectively and say ah

29:42

there's a reason that we may feel this

29:44

way but we're not compelled to feel this

29:47

way there's a reason that getting that

29:50

house may feel rewarding

29:52

but you know what for Life satisfaction

29:54

I might be more rewarded if I have a

29:57

smaller house and I volunteer and help

30:00

people who have less than me because we

30:02

also know that the human reward system

30:04

is not all about material reward

30:08

we are also rewarded by many other

30:10

things and each of us has our own traits

30:13

where some things are more rewarding to

30:15

us than others Evolution designed us to

30:18

be different from one another by Design

30:19

because that way as a group as a society

30:23

we are better able to problem solve and

30:26

adapt but there are other rewards

30:28

including as you and I have discussed

30:31

agency the ability to make something

30:33

happen

30:36

the ability to solve a problem and come

30:39

up with a a good solution the ability to

30:42

connect to other people social rewards

30:44

are extremely powerful for humans both

30:48

early in life and later in life

30:50

the reward of helping somebody now you

30:54

know in your own life as people in the

30:56

audience there are people who are really

30:58

driven by that altruistic reward there

31:01

are other people that's not their thing

31:02

their thing may be problem solving their

31:04

thing may be something else thank

31:06

heavens were different from one another

31:08

because if we weren't we would not have

31:10

made the kinds of successes that we

31:13

so we are not constrained

31:17

to necessarily believe that what someone

31:20

else tells us is rewarding like the

31:22

bigger house is necessarily what is

31:25

going to give us that long-term life

31:27

satisfaction and we can look at where it

31:31

comes from and question it we do have an

31:34

extraordinary ability to question

31:36

assumptions

31:37

and that's why you're an electrical

31:39

engineer you could question these things

31:42

that's why some of the people that I met

31:43

today your interns and your staff people

31:47

each of them has questioned certain

31:49

things we have that ability and we can

31:51

bring that to bear in crises like the

31:54

climate crisis we do not have to be

31:56

constrained

31:57

by a reward system that can only look at

32:01

one reward a few more questions and then

32:04

we'll open up to the audience see if we

32:05

have any questions in the chat box as

32:07

well I want to talk about behavioral

32:09

change and and in the book you you talk

32:12

about some behaviors that matter most

32:14

and you also talk about behaviors that

32:17

are difficult to change and some that

32:19

are much easier talk a little bit about

32:21

the ones that are difficult to change

32:22

and some that are easier to change

32:25

so when I went down this road of

32:27

exploring the relationship between

32:28

neuroscience and our planet crisis the

32:31

big question I had is how flexible is

32:33

our brain how can we change and I

32:35

decided to look at some of those things

32:37

in the health and public health world

32:39

that were known to be difficult and

32:43

addiction and overeating are some of the

32:46

ones that are linked and particularly

32:49

difficult and I wanted to know what has

32:52

been shown lots of things have been

32:53

tried what has been shown to work the

32:56

best and then as a corollary to that

32:58

question I needed to know in my own mind

33:00

which are the behaviors that are

33:03

contributing most to climate change

33:05

and most of the research has been done

33:07

on individual behaviors but we can scale

33:10

this to the behaviors of people in other

33:14

spheres of influence so in the public

33:19

health and health World addiction is the

33:21

classic example of something that's

33:23

difficult to change and what has been

33:24

shown to work

33:26

there's a few basic principles

33:28

number one positive is better than

33:30

negative in general whether it's in

33:33

education addiction or or other spheres

33:37

of difficult Behavior change

33:38

people on average do better with

33:41

positive

33:43

um interactions than negative so phrase

33:46

versus punishment for example

33:50

you do better making difficult Behavior

33:52

change happen by substituting

33:55

a reward

33:57

that is going to be active and

34:00

substitute for the reward you're taking

34:02

away so the classic example are the

34:05

12-step programs in addiction

34:07

where you are substituting social reward

34:11

which is very powerful for humans or

34:14

the reward of the drug

34:17

or the alcohol or whatever it is that

34:20

you're giving up that you're addicted to

34:21

sometimes it's a behavior it's gambling

34:22

it's video games

34:24

social rewards are incredibly powerful

34:27

for human beings so in 12-step programs

34:29

you have a community you have people

34:32

that are rooting for you you have

34:35

um people who understand what you're

34:37

going through

34:38

and this is why these things tend to

34:40

work so it's substituting one reward for

34:43

another and

34:46

it's it's getting you out of a context

34:49

of habit where again these kinds of

34:52

Habitual connections are very powerful

34:54

in humans and they're a big part of

34:55

addiction so it's getting you out of

34:57

that context where the habit

35:00

goes into more detail about this is a

35:02

neural circuit that is very challenging

35:04

to break it's why recidivism is high but

35:07

it's getting you out of that context so

35:09

that you can create new habits uh and

35:12

substitute for the old ones

35:14

in the world of climate change

35:17

there are behaviors that are the biggest

35:20

contributor and if anybody wants to know

35:23

you just type in carbon calculator and

35:25

it will tell you in your own life you

35:27

fill in some blanks and it'll tell you

35:29

in your own life where your carbon

35:30

footprint is coming from and for most

35:35

people it varies from person to person

35:37

but for most of us the big ones are not

35:39

the ones we think of you know you learn

35:40

in school to recycle well recycling is

35:42

important but it's a pretty small part

35:44

of most people's carbon footprint and

35:46

the big ones tend to be how you get

35:49

around your transportation

35:51

how you heat and cool your house

35:53

what kind of food you eat how much meat

35:55

versus how much plant-based food

35:57

agriculture is a big part of this

36:00

um how many air flights you take

36:03

and how many children you have so these

36:05

are the things in people's individual

36:07

lives where the carbon footprints for

36:09

most of us are the biggest

36:12

some people have said Why Try To Change

36:15

Behavior individual behavior is not the

36:17

answer to climate change and that's

36:18

absolutely

36:19

pretty true I had to look this up

36:21

because I didn't know and I had to read

36:23

a lot and get some sense in my own mind

36:26

as to where this comes down and about

36:28

half the carbon problem from high

36:30

industrial countries comes from

36:32

Individual choices we make and about

36:33

half comes from things we don't have

36:35

much control over that said Behavior

36:38

change does not just apply to our

36:41

individual personal choices it also

36:44

applies to our choices in the workplace

36:46

if you are the president of a college if

36:49

you're an educator if you are the CEO of

36:52

a company if you're the middle manager

36:54

in an industry

36:55

you have to make these choices

36:58

that affect many people

37:00

and the same equation about climate

37:04

change

37:04

uh will factor in and so these Behavior

37:09

change decisions

37:11

can follow the same principles

37:13

substitute positive for negative so if

37:16

you are an industry leader and you have

37:19

to make a tough choice that will re

37:21

reduce your profit margin

37:24

but improve your carbon footprint or

37:26

your environmental profile

37:29

it's going to be a tough choice on your

37:31

own you're used to being rewarded by

37:33

your shareholders saying great profit

37:36

margin this quarter

37:37

[Music]

37:38

how do you substitute for that when you

37:41

substitute potentially by having other

37:44

industry leaders other people in your

37:47

strata who do this together and you get

37:50

the social reward so it's substituting

37:52

social reward

37:54

or what you're used to making your

37:56

decisions based on which is the old

37:58

reward

37:59

and these I'm not saying this is easy

38:02

but if you don't have that social

38:04

network or substitute a new reward maybe

38:06

it's your kids saying wow you did that

38:09

that's my future maybe it's some other

38:11

kind of reward but you have to realize

38:14

that the rewards that you're used to are

38:17

not going to apply to this problem it's

38:20

too new a problem for us as a society

38:22

it's not something we have a long

38:24

history with in fact it's a first of its

38:27

kind problem so the equations for

38:30

decision making need to be new equations

38:36

recognizing that no one's going to make

38:39

a new decision with no reward you just

38:42

have to find some new ones and recognize

38:45

that agency

38:46

caring for others

38:49

social rewards these are the ones that

38:51

we can call on

38:53

to substitute for the old rewards which

38:55

are largely material and we were saying

38:57

this now in in many places around the

38:59

world uh you know workers are asking

39:02

employees employers employees are asking

39:04

for a different value system want to

39:06

work from home they want flexibility so

39:08

flexibility is now a new value that most

39:11

corporations are having to Grapple with

39:13

one last question for you and then we

39:15

take one or two questions from the

39:16

audience I want you to talk a little bit

39:18

about

39:19

at what point

39:21

everything you've talked about here in

39:24

terms of understanding the brain and the

39:25

circuitry

39:27

how do we apply it in a you know take an

39:30

example like start your day take me

39:32

through a day where I show up to work I

39:34

have to eat lunch and I skip lunch I

39:36

think you have an example of that in the

39:37

book help the audience and those

39:39

listening to to go back today and apply

39:42

what they're hearing from you in terms

39:44

of oh Dr Dwayne said I should pause

39:46

before I eat one more cookie or I should

39:49

I should do this before I do that walk

39:51

us through this activity in the brain

39:54

just take an example of how the brain

39:56

will work between now and by the time we

39:58

get home

40:01

well if you have absorbed anything from

40:05

today's talk you may reflect on the fact

40:08

that you're making decisions at multiple

40:11

levels every step of the way and what

40:15

influences you uh will not be

40:18

immediately available to you whether you

40:21

take a right or a left I'll give you an

40:23

example you're going to walk home from

40:24

here and you're either going to go this

40:25

way or that way and you could go either

40:27

way you might go towards the Sunny Side

40:29

because it's a little chilly out you're

40:31

not thinking of that you just

40:33

do it what gets you to go towards the

40:35

city side is it the reward of being in

40:37

the sun that's nice okay so that's the

40:39

reward the reward is the heat yes okay

40:41

exactly

40:43

um or you know you might you might

40:45

deflect down towards uh the Basin where

40:48

the cherry blossoms are and you don't

40:49

think about it necessarily consciously

40:52

but that's the way your steps take you

40:53

so it's not always at a level where

40:55

you're saying it I'm going to do this

40:57

you know and every decision that you

40:59

make is like that it it's going to have

41:01

multiple layers now whether anyone is

41:04

influenced by this discussion or not I

41:06

don't know but you may think to yourself

41:09

you may

41:11

do I really need that thing do I really

41:13

need it uh I'm going to get a short-term

41:16

reward

41:17

it's not going to pay off but more

41:19

importantly and at a bigger scale if you

41:21

were a leader in any capacity where you

41:24

make decisions that may affect many

41:26

people

41:27

you may be able to consciously reflect

41:29

and say oh I I need to

41:33

change my priorities I need to change my

41:36

equation a little bit because there is

41:39

this overwhelmingly

41:42

urgent even if it doesn't feel that way

41:44

important life-altering Globe oriented

41:49

crisis that is difficult for me to

41:52

perceive

41:53

my equations need to change

41:57

for the future of all of us

42:01

I can do that I have the brain that can

42:05

make that happen I have that capacity to

42:08

change the equation it is not going to

42:10

feel that decision is not likely to feel

42:14

rewarding in the same way that I have

42:17

relied on to make all my decisions up to

42:20

this point

42:21

I've relied on an entire human history

42:24

and personal history of equations that

42:29

have

42:30

that have directed my decisions

42:33

this

42:34

time and these decisions are different

42:38

from anything in my history

42:40

and anything in our Collective history

42:42

and it is not going to feel the same I

42:44

am not going to feel the same certainty

42:47

that this decision that is a

42:49

pro-environmental decision

42:52

um is going to have the same

42:55

visceral feel

42:57

and I have to make that tough decision

42:59

anyway make it easier I'm going to find

43:02

like-minded people I'm going to look at

43:04

my children and my grandchildren I'm

43:06

going to get some cognitive input as to

43:09

how this may have ramifications in the

43:12

future

43:14

I can't rely on the same

43:18

reactions that I have always relied on

43:22

and I'm aware of that and I'm taking

43:24

that into account and I'm making that

43:26

tough decision anyway thank you question

43:29

an audience

43:35

um so you're a neurosurgeon as well as

43:38

an advocate so I wanted to know

43:40

how how has your practice shaped your

43:45

theory so how have your experiences with

43:48

patients affected

43:50

uh how this book came about

43:53

thanks

43:56

I think part of it is that

43:59

in a field like mine in neurosurgery

44:01

particularly pediatric neurosurgery

44:03

where I take care of children

44:06

there is nothing more important

44:09

that I've ever seen

44:11

to a person than their child

44:15

that particular

44:17

bond that particular

44:21

Obsession and concern is the most potent

44:25

Force I've ever experienced

44:30

for this reason

44:33

um it's clear to me that there is

44:35

something

44:37

evolutionarily

44:40

predisposed in The Human Condition

44:43

because of the utter power of that Bond

44:47

and that concern

44:49

parents would much rather they were the

44:51

one with the brain tumor than their

44:53

child by the brain tumor they would put

44:55

themselves in their child's position in

44:57

a Millicent the vast majority of them

44:59

this is so consistent

45:02

um and I think that that convinced me

45:05

that our brains are the way they are for

45:08

evolutionary reasons and that they are

45:11

extraordinarily potent

45:14

and I've also had the privilege of

45:17

witnessing the grace

45:20

and utter

45:23

um awesome Humanity of people even under

45:27

circumstances of terrible terrible

45:30

tragedy

45:33

so I have faith in humans

45:36

I think I have faith in the human brain

45:40

and in the way our brains were designed

45:43

to work based on those

45:46

intense somewhat artificially intense

45:50

um because the circumstances are

45:51

artificial

45:52

but I have utter conviction

45:56

of the essential goodness and capacity

45:59

of human beings

46:01

to adapt change and to

46:04

and to rely on these human interactions

46:08

and the power of them and so I think

46:11

that's maybe the way I can answer that

46:13

question I think I have faith

46:16

in the biology of the human brain and

46:19

its capacity based on some of these

46:21

experiences and also on the plasticity

46:24

and adaptability of the human brain

46:27

um as a function profession

46:30

so so let me ask a question on that you

46:32

you in the book you talk about the grain

46:34

the grain Children's Hospital you spend

46:38

a lot of whole chapters dedicated to

46:40

that project you just

46:42

share with the audience you know how

46:44

that came about and what was the key

46:45

takeaway from that that project

46:49

the green Children's Hospital project

46:50

was a test case

46:52

and if one believes that the way to

46:56

encourage pro-environmental behaviors to

46:59

make it rewarding

47:01

could I as an experiment

47:04

influence the leadership of my hospital

47:07

to do something I thought was helpful

47:09

for children

47:11

and also pro-environmental

47:14

by appealing to the things that they

47:16

might find rewarding

47:18

they meaning the administration

47:20

Administration the leadership the

47:22

finance people and so forth and what

47:23

would be rewarding to them the idea of a

47:25

children's hospital was not that

47:26

rewarding to them because they make

47:28

their profit largely off the adult

47:30

practices

47:31

pediatric practices in a general

47:33

hospital just because of the way our

47:36

Health Care system is have a lower

47:37

profit margin so while people all want

47:40

to have pediatric care for a variety of

47:43

reasons to be a general hospital

47:46

it's not their biggest profit maker I

47:49

don't want to cut you over and Christine

47:50

I think is ironic that the children are

47:53

supposed to be the future of the world

47:55

but this should be more profitable

47:57

actually yes that's not the way the

47:59

Healthcare System the person works

48:01

unfortunately okay unless you are a

48:03

freestanding children's hospital where

48:04

you have in some cities a monopoly and

48:07

UK it's about Contracting it's about the

48:09

business side we could get we could give

48:10

a whole talk on that

48:13

so I knew I needed I felt we needed a

48:16

new children's hospital and I wanted to

48:18

make it a prototype because we're small

48:20

enough to do this we could make a

48:22

hospital as a laboratory

48:24

so I had this whole Vision I had a whole

48:26

lot of collaborators in the engineering

48:27

school and in the business people and a

48:31

variety of people architecture people

48:33

from around the world really and and my

48:37

idea was we're gonna have this prototype

48:39

there's going to be a hundred bed

48:40

roughly Children's Hospital first of its

48:42

kind it was going to be Net Zero Energy

48:45

or even positive this is a challenge

48:47

this is an engineering challenge in a

48:50

Northeast urban city like ours Boston

48:52

and to make it rewarding to people who

48:55

didn't even care about climate change

48:57

remember this was this was in 2014 2015

48:59

okay it was a different political era at

49:01

that time and it may come back to that

49:03

kind of political era we will see but at

49:04

that time there was a lot of climate

49:06

denial still and even in the healthcare

49:09

field it was like climate change is not

49:10

our shift this is somebody else's

49:12

problem

49:13

so to appeal to people for whom climate

49:16

change was not as urgent a problem as it

49:18

was in my mind the idea was this would

49:20

be besides being a prototype first of

49:23

its kind it would be absolutely

49:24

stunningly beautiful by appealing to our

49:28

natural

49:29

tendency to be attracted to Nature so

49:32

this would be the absolutely most

49:34

biophilic most nature-filled facility

49:36

ever invented

49:38

and it would be like walking into a

49:39

forest as a hospital

49:41

and for kids and their families I did a

49:44

lot of work with people in this in

49:46

related fields to see what the evidence

49:49

was that this was actually helpful for

49:51

healing and stress and it it clearly is

49:54

a natural environment has all sorts of

49:56

Health advantages the indoor air quality

49:59

would be better and so on so for

50:01

scientific reasons for attractiveness

50:04

reasons and for being the first of its

50:07

kind which I thought would appeal to our

50:09

leadership

50:10

we're at Harvard we like being first we

50:12

like being the best we like being the

50:14

only we like doing things first right

50:16

and so I thought that I could appeal to

50:18

our leadership on those grounds

50:22

it didn't

50:25

because what I needed was a huge donor

50:29

and I'm not much of a fundraiser and I

50:32

didn't have contact with those kinds of

50:34

people and if I did there were other

50:36

priorities that they were led to so it's

50:39

still awaiting that finding of a big

50:42

donor anybody out there let me know but

50:48

it did move the needle

50:51

so the lesson was after that and with

50:54

input from other like-minded people I'll

50:57

tell you social rewards are so important

51:00

we created a center for the environment

51:02

and health at our hospital that had not

51:04

existed before and that was a top down

51:06

and bottom up kind of a thing it was the

51:09

clinicians worried about climate change

51:10

and climate change's effect on health

51:12

and it was the leadership's recognition

51:15

that we had to make an energy transition

51:17

for financial reasons and for regulatory

51:21

reasons so they had an advantage at the

51:23

top they had an incentive we had an

51:25

incentive at the bottom we met in the

51:26

middle we created the center of which

51:29

I'm now associate director and we

51:32

created a whole new journal the Journal

51:33

of climate change and health so many

51:35

things tipped the needle moved the

51:38

needle our institution now is much more

51:40

environmentally focused than it was part

51:42

of it was this whole green Children's

51:43

Hospital push so while we have not yet

51:46

realized the vision of this Hospital

51:48

which I still am utterly committed to

51:50

and believe in and think would be

51:52

amazing

51:54

as a prototype

51:56

that would not in itself have a huge

51:59

climate impact but could be exported and

52:02

the technologies that we could develop

52:04

with our incredible Technologic

52:05

Partnerships and expertise energy and so

52:09

on could be transformative

52:12

I still believe in that Vision I'm still

52:13

trying to realize that Vision so while I

52:16

didn't get the administration totally go

52:18

there they went part of the way and that

52:21

was a huge lesson of the flexibility

52:23

even of people with other priorities

52:25

we've got about five more minutes I want

52:27

to hopefully get you three questions and

52:30

and I know this is a crunch time of year

52:32

but one has to do it Injustice in

52:35

society and how that ties back to this

52:37

conversation a lot of discussions around

52:39

environmental justice or Just Energy

52:41

transition we have the developed

52:44

countries consuming more the less

52:46

developed countries this comes to who

52:49

should change right how do we talk about

52:52

change and how to make change happen on

52:55

a much more global scale as opposed to

52:57

just the individual how do we get those

52:59

in the rich countries to change for the

53:02

benefit of the entire planet as opposed

53:04

to saying even those in the poorer

53:06

countries should also change how does

53:08

one do that

53:09

well that's the trickiest problem isn't

53:11

it and I don't even think we have to get

53:13

Global and international that's clearly

53:16

the critical part Even in our own

53:18

neighborhoods there is inequity that

53:21

climate change affects the core more

53:26

marginalized more underserved

53:28

communities

53:29

uh way before it affects others how do

53:32

you get people to behave collectively

53:34

it's it's a it's a challenge for humans

53:37

because they tend to

53:39

um make decisions based on immediacy and

53:43

proximity and

53:45

personal knowledge

53:47

so from a brain point of view these are

53:50

challenges and again I think the same

53:52

principles apply like-minded people

53:56

movements the movements for example the

53:59

youth movements have affected people

54:01

globally to realize this and

54:05

you know it's it's uh it goes without

54:08

saying that the wealthier countries are

54:11

going to have to

54:16

consider

54:18

that these problems are not local

54:20

problems these are Global problems we

54:22

can't solve the problem

54:24

without

54:25

recognizing things that occur beyond our

54:29

perspective and

54:32

it's going to come back the CO2 we put

54:35

in the in the atmosphere doesn't it goes

54:38

everywhere and so I think that um

54:43

it's the same principles of why

54:46

decisions that are not immediate or

54:48

difficult for us and why we have to

54:51

think more long-term than short term we

54:53

have to use our cognition

54:54

and I think we can appeal to some extent

54:57

to selfish Moments by recognizing that

55:00

stuff doesn't stay where it is this is a

55:01

global problem and we are in it together

55:03

[Music]

55:05

um finally there are rewards that we can

55:08

tap into about helping people with less

55:10

there is a whole

55:13

powerful reward to be gained from

55:16

helping others and

55:18

if it's a choice between more for me or

55:22

more for someone else when I have enough

55:24

we have to start

55:26

helping people feel the the actual

55:30

reward value of giving to others my

55:33

second to the last question I promise

55:35

this is the second to the last and I

55:36

have one last question but the second

55:38

one before we get there is

55:41

this conversation has been watched and

55:43

listened to by leaders uh some might be

55:45

policy makers some might be Business

55:47

Leaders

55:48

what do they get out of this

55:51

reading this book understanding the

55:53

brain circuitry and understanding why

55:55

it's important to look at the reward

55:56

system what would you want to tell a

55:58

policy maker or business leader watching

56:00

this why they should read this and apply

56:03

some of the principles in this book

56:06

I think that

56:09

I want to get away from the idea

56:13

that your brain is somehow hardwired

56:16

the brain's remarkably flexible

56:19

and if you know that

56:22

and you know where some of our decisions

56:24

come from

56:27

prehistorically

56:30

you will recognize your own capacity to

56:33

change

56:34

and your capacity to influence others to

56:37

change

56:38

so I think the take home message is one

56:41

of Hope and optimism and confidence

56:47

I think people get into a mindset that

56:50

this is quote unquote human nature and

56:52

we can't change

56:54

and I would challenge that we can I'm

56:57

not saying it's easy but there are

57:00

certain things that are in the book that

57:01

you can rely on to help you

57:04

change yourself change your priorities

57:06

change your attitudes and help others to

57:08

changes

57:09

good now my last question and Christine

57:14

the last chapter in the book is called

57:16

sustainable brain

57:19

um people watching this have kids

57:22

how do we work today as a society to get

57:25

young people today

57:27

to develop the sustainable brain or to

57:30

develop that sustainable mindset that

57:32

you talk about so that when they get to

57:34

a certain age

57:36

at least they have adapted some of the

57:38

things you've talked about how do we

57:40

develop the brain of kids to do at least

57:42

help them to develop a most sustainable

57:44

brain because I think for us it's the

57:46

time has passed my brain can be made

57:48

sustainable anymore right yes it can yes

57:50

it can I would challenge that okay first

57:53

of all I think you already have

57:54

okay

57:57

first of all uh this is change is not

58:00

confined to you

58:03

you continue to change up until you are

58:05

no longer alive

58:07

and we forget that it is true that

58:10

people you know there's there's adages

58:12

about we get more conservative as we get

58:14

older

58:16

there's some truth to that we tend to uh

58:19

like

58:23

novelty more when we're young and

58:25

familiarity more when we're older

58:28

but we continue to change throughout our

58:30

lives and we have that to pass but to

58:32

answer your question about children

58:34

I feel that in modern society we have

58:37

taken away some of children's agencies

58:40

we schedule them we teach them we give

58:43

them classes we don't let them alone to

58:47

figure it out on their own that was part

58:49

of evolutionary history that's how you

58:51

learned you learned from playing with

58:53

other kids in an unstructured

58:54

environment

58:55

there is a movement in the educational

58:58

world to try to restore

59:01

activities that give children agency

59:03

they figure it out on their own they

59:05

figure out their own talents so I would

59:07

say that's part of it

59:09

and the other big part of it is

59:12

remember that Rewards

59:15

are buried

59:17

and it's not all about one kind of

59:20

reward which is financial or material

59:22

reward

59:23

but encourage in children

59:26

rewards of social rewards and agency and

59:30

altruism and creativity

59:32

problem solving

59:35

and if we think of these things more

59:38

broadly

59:39

we I think can encourage both

59:41

sustainability and long-term life

59:44

satisfaction as opposed to immediate

59:46

material rewards and their short-lived

59:50

well then Christy and I have to say this

59:52

has been a fascinating conversation I

59:55

have enjoyed reading the book as I

59:57

revealed to you this morning that I I

59:59

actually went through it detail I think

01:00:02

it's really going to impact our industry

01:00:04

and the world as a whole because I think

01:00:06

this is one of the first books that have

01:00:08

looked at understanding the brain and

01:00:10

how it ties into climate change and some

01:00:12

of the other challenges which we haven't

01:00:14

got into today you know in vexing

01:00:16

population you have issues around

01:00:17

poverty a lot of other Global challenges

01:00:19

but I think mining the climate is the

01:00:21

first start and I hope we can mine other

01:00:24

challenges and try to get to the bottom

01:00:25

of this so congratulations on the book

01:00:27

please join me in thanking Dr M

01:00:29

Christine to him for being with us

01:00:32

thank you thank you everyone for joining

01:00:35

today's episode of influential Minds we

01:00:37

will be sending out a zoom recording to

01:00:39

all attendees and it will be uploaded to

01:00:40

our YouTube channel at a later date

01:00:42

where you can also find recordings from

01:00:44

other past conversations and webinars

01:00:46

for more information and to continue

01:00:48

engaging with eei International programs

01:00:50

please follow us on Twitter and visit

01:00:52

our website check out the chat the links

01:00:54

thank you and have a wonderful rest of

01:00:56

your day

Next in the archive

Influential Minds: A Conversation with Ann Christine Duhaime — Influential Minds