Episode 12Jesper Brodin
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Jesper Brodin
How IKEA links affordability, circular design and renewable energy with climate action, purpose-led leadership and sustainable growth.
Ann Christine Duhaime
Ask about this conversation
welcome to influential Minds an eei
international conversation series which
aims to discuss ideas that move the
needle towards a more sustainable future
with thought leaders from across the
globe here's your host senior vice
president of international programs at
eei Dr Lawrence Jones
thank you good afternoon good evening
good morning wherever you are welcome
thanks for joining us here Dr Ann
Christine doing from Massachusetts
thank you for having me this is going to
be an interesting conversation let me
first of all congratulate you on the
book uh minding the climate how
Neuroscience can help solve our
environmental crisis
let's begin Christine by you perhaps and
Christine just telling us
what got you involved in Neuroscience or
in the brain to begin with why the brain
of all things in the world
of all things in the world the brain is
it
so the brain to me is the
reason that we Are Who We Are and is the
answer to all questions uh or virtually
all questions about why we behave the
way we behave and from very early in my
life this was an overriding curiosity
um if one has this sort of curiosity you
may go in many directions you may become
a philosopher you may become someone in
religion you may become someone in
science and I ended up on the science
and Neuroscience pathway just because
the brain was just so very interesting
and an endless source of awe and
Fascination yeah so so let's talk a
little bit about the book
um this is one of the few books I've
seen that's sort of a link links climate
to the brain
talk about that what drove you to make
that connection between the climate and
the Brain
if you are in the neurosciences and as
you know I'm a neurosurgeon
um you think about everything in terms
of the brain just like a chef thinks
about everything in terms of ingredients
and recipes and someone who's in
construction thinks about how things are
built if you are immersed in that world
you see the world through the lens of
that area
and to me
the climate crisis which I see as our
biggest existential threat
can be viewed through the lens of the
brain and Neuroscience simply because we
humans are the cause of the problem and
we humans will be the solution to the
problem should we be smart enough to
figure one out or figure multiple
simultaneous Solutions out so looking at
that connection between how the brain is
designed to operate
why it's designed that way
through the tutelage of evolutionary
pressures
and how that design has influenced both
the cause and the potential Solutions
seems a very logical connection to me as
I was reading the book I was intrigued
by the examples you give regarding just
understanding the complexity of the
brain being an engineer myself I love
the examples about the secretary of the
brain so for the audience just tell us
how does the brain actually work
well I can tell you that in 30 seconds
you'll get it but
in the book
um I had to do my own exploration to try
to answer these questions now obviously
as a neurosurgeon I have to know
something about how the brain works
because otherwise I couldn't do my job
but I think a different way to answer
your question is why does it work the
way it works and if you ask the why
question you'll get to the how question
the brain started like all of biology
with simpler organisms that then became
more and more complicated over time
and I had to go back to single cells
because
I know you have children I had children
that grew up in the era of Harry Potter
and it was as though you could have a
magic wand that would simply make magic
occur and that's how things happened
but when you think about biology and you
think about the brain
it had to start somewhere and get more
complicated
how did it start in terms of something
like decision making at the simplest
level
and I had to go all the way back to
single cells to bacteria to say how does
a cell know to move towards a source of
nutrition like sugar and away from a
source of a toxin like ammonia how does
it do that
well at the Single Cell level it does it
with the same principle
that scales all the way up to the brain
in that the way it works is this there
is some molecule on the surface of that
single cell that bacteria and that
molecule just by chance by random things
that occur eventually a molecule ended
up on the cell surface that when it
interacts with some other molecule out
there in the world
the molecule on the cell surface changes
shape
so that certain kinds of substances
typically charge substances can get into
the cell or can get out of the cell and
it changes what's on the inside of the
cell and over time over time over time
a cell that happened to have molecules
that could move away from the toxin or
towards the sugar at a survival example
a survival advantage and it's an example
of how things work by biochemical
interactions that create what we call
Behavior it does this instead of that it
does this under these circumstances and
that under those circumstances
now our brains evolving over
as you know millions of years
um have those same principles inside
cells inside organs such that chemical
reactions occur that make things happen
and they end up as Behavior so it's
under evolutionary pressures that we
just that we that Evolution that time
designed the brains we have today and
how they work is based on those basic
principles
in the book we talk about the reward
system
people tend to think that reward means a
pat on the head or an extra prize or
extra money that's my reward that's how
we use the word reward in common
conversation
but in the brain the reward system is
the system
of interactions in the brain
largely run on the power of
electrochemical connections and
processes that helped us learn
what we needed to learn to survive
as a species and so
the scaffolding from single cells where
you do this or that depending on
external chemicals to internal cognitive
processes and decision making
that happens with millions of
simultaneous or closely linked events
for every decision happen based on the
same principles of what will help us
survive so like that single cell moving
towards the nutrition and away from the
toxin helped it survive in our brains
decisions that helped us survive that
were mediated by neurotransmitters
aligned with the evolution of the reward
system is how we make our decisions
today
all based on the same principles that
have gotten more complicated but the
same basic principles underlie all of
these functions we'll get into the
reward system but just instead of a
summary so basically we have what 86
billion neurons in the brain uh lots of
complex systems and it's not one single
thing that affects the decisions that we
make I was intrigued when I was reading
the book when you talk about the fact
that sometimes decisions are being made
you're not even aware of what's happened
in the background talk about that where
you know I mean people sitting here even
even as they sit here this conversation
is having an impact on the decision it
might make tomorrow talk about what I
would call the latency of decision
making where you may not even be aware
that you're making a decision made on
something you saw heard felt touch smell
decades ago a year ago how does that
work because each thing that happens to
you internal external the internal
influences of are you hungry did you get
a good night's sleep last night the
external influences of what happened
that is in your memory but might not be
in your conscious awareness all the
things that have happened to you each
change your brain and so things that
happen to you in childhood things that
happened last week a movie you saw three
months ago each of these things in some
way has changed the connections the
strength of the connections the
predispositions in your brain so you are
carrying around a lifetime
in your own lifetime as well as genetic
influences and epigenetic influences
going back you know forever
um that influence the decisions that you
make at any one time now you think we
all think because we you know can
consciously reflect on this that these
decisions are logical I know why I did
that but in fact things are influencing
you all the time that are below your
level of conscious awareness you are who
you are because of all the things that
have happened to you some of which had a
bigger impact than others because they
were
influential for a variety of reasons
that made them stronger than other
things and the genetic influences which
you can sometimes recognize you say I
was just like my dad when I said that
and uh and things that that come down
through the centuries that you're not
aware of and so our decision making is a
complex multi-million
event process at any one time we we
don't know that but the book goes into
understanding that at sort of a more
visceral level yeah I enjoy this chapter
on uh reward system right because there
are rewards that affect what we do uh
and you talk about some of the different
reward schemes like money is a reward
for some people let's tie it back to
climate change right
um in the book you talk a lot about the
difficulty to change our behavior and
it's part of the reward system link
climate change this difficulty in making
decisions to change our Behavior back to
understanding the brain what's the
linkage there
climate change in particular
plays to our weaknesses
and this is because if you think about
what we needed to survive during
evolutionary time when our brains were
being designed
most of our decisions for survival were
short-term immediate decisions
climate change is difficult because it
is more long-term we've never faced a
problem like this we don't have
Collective
um societal cultural understanding of
these problems they've not occurred
before so we we don't have cultural
history to call upon and we
were designed on a on a chassis so to
speak of decision making that by and
large while we have the ability to think
ahead to some extent
more of our survival decisions were
short-term and immediate and we had
also the additional reward besides
resources and security and things that
now are represented by monetary or
financial gain we had acquisitiveness in
our pre-history that was a parallel to
that but when you made a decision
you got an immediate sense that it was
the right decision so in the book as you
might recall there's a section that
talks about a classic decision in human
decision making about I'm walking
through the woods nighttime is coming I
need to get to shelter I cross I come
upon a river and there's a Fallen Tree
over the river
we're really well designed for that you
know how to push on the tree to see how
secure it is you know how to judge the
strength you know your own history of
can you swim you have some sense of the
temperature and how cold that water is
and how cold the air is you have some
sense of how quickly the light is fading
all of this plays to your personal
experience and your sensory capabilities
think about climate change we can't even
perceive in our senses carbon dioxide we
did not need in evolutionary time to
learn how to sense carbon dioxide in our
senses we can we can sense the color
spectrum we can sense uh certain toxins
some are invisible to us but some that
were evolutionarily important we can
sense we have tactile sensation we can't
perceive climate change except for its
effects and in addition those effects
are vague enough and have other
potential causes that it's easy to it's
easy to discount them in addition the
time frame is long beyond our individual
experiential time frame so it is a
particularly tough problem for us to
make rational or even as I would say
emotional decisions about it and it will
come to us as information which is newer
evolutionarily from people we don't
necessarily know personally from
experience that we don't have viscerally
which is really just another way of
saying in your brain but we sense it as
a visceral kind of a response and it
really plays to our weaknesses as
decision makers so so so stay on that
for a second though uh and Christine
the urgency so we heard yesterday that
the ipcc came up with a report saying
that we might get to 1.5 degrees
increase in temperature by the year
2035. one would expect this urgency or
this sense of urgency to drive us to
change our Behavior but in the book you
talk about that might not necessarily be
the case so why is it that even though
we're told of this urgency we still
cannot change
wouldn't say we can't but it's a
challenge
and in in part it's a challenge because
as you know it's easy to say we have to
do it by this time or we have to do it
by that time
is in the future we have trouble with
that we can intellectually feel it but
it's not the same as I'm hungry I want
to go get something to eat right now or
um
you know I need to go somewhere I know
how to get my my self transported to
that place these decisions these actions
these uh uh priorities are much easier
for us than something that we perceive
as
theoretical and in the future it's just
hard for us to both perceive of that
urgency in ways that are not just
intellectual which is a challenge for us
um
sometimes urgency
for it it gets into our brains as fear
as fear of something that is imminent
um but even fear is difficult one of the
ways that many people that have gotten
involved in climate action uh get
involved is because they have fear for
their children
and that is a that is a human reaction
but even there it's something future and
theoretic nonetheless it can be a
motivator so fear can be a motivator
but the urgency of climate change as a
concept is less compelling to most
people than the urgency of some of its
consequences like a storm or a wildfire
as more of these events that are linked
to climate change become apparent to
people more people are afraid more
people feel a sense of urgency but it's
still not the same kind of urgency as I
got to get out of this building because
it's on fire you wish it were
intellectually we can make that leap but
it's still a challenge for the way we
work okay so let's talk about one
urgence that we had as a globe not too
long ago which was the pandemic
that brought about immediate change I
mean today stay at home work from home
uh you know all these societal changes
what made the covet pandemic the changes
we've made why were those easier to make
compared to climate change that's a
great question and isn't it a little bit
heartening that we were able to change
like that it shows that we can do it
illness is something we know
illness is something as old as people
and so the Specter of an illness that
can affect me
or my loved ones that is scarier than
the Specter of carbon dioxide elevation
that I can't perceive and I've never
known anybody to die of carbon dioxide
I'd known somebody to die of an illness
that looks like covet
and so it's just more in our experience
it's more in our culture
nonetheless we did have to make big
pivots because the scale of a pandemic
is so big
and so we did have to call upon our
intellectual resources our Cooperative
resources which are not always easy to
do and we did have to think globally
were we really good at it not
necessarily but we we did we you know
people did
in fits and starts and with varying
degrees rise to the challenge there were
incredible Technologic resources that
went into creating the vaccines very
quickly disseminating them nonetheless
we weren't perfect at it and one can uh
level a lot of criticisms to how slow we
were and how inequitable we were about
our response nonetheless we did make
that pivot I think in part it's because
it was something we understood as an
immediate threat we saw people dying and
nobody wanted to die and so that drove
people to change so so in the book
intriguingly enough for those who
haven't read the book if you want to
understand that we're addicted to
consumption who are going to have a
conversation about addiction and our
addiction to consumption you talk about
behavioral change and how consumption of
especially people in the high income
countries drive what is happening around
climate
talk about this acceleration of
consumption and
the addiction we have as a society to
consuming things and the reward that we
feel we get we feel we get from
consuming more stuff
talk about that
there have been people who have tried to
make that
um conjunction between addiction as we
think of it medically addiction to
substances and then sometimes addiction
to behaviors like gambling gambling is
not a substance but people
believe many people believe some people
question this that you really can become
addicted in the same way to a behavior
like uh gambling and the other common
example that's used is video addiction
some people can actually become
clinically addicted to shopping and the
link that I think is interesting to
shopping shopping oh okay and the link
uh that some people make is that there
are pathological conditions this is one
of the things that links it back to my
field uh where people actually can
become addicted to certain behaviors
like shopping under certain conditions
of pathology and to me one of the
Intriguing links was uh the disease
Parkinson's disease where it's not the
disease that gets you addicted it's the
treatment of the disease so in
Parkinson's disease there is a very
specific decrease in a particular
neurotransmitter that many people have
heard of dopamine in a very particular
very localized spot in the brain and in
that particular spot where the disease
affects the cells that create the
dopamine
it manifests itself as changes in how
people are able to control their
movements it's the motor system
but dopamine is a transmitter that goes
throughout your brain and is heavily
also involved in reward circuitry
and the treatment for Parkinson's
Disease which is that local loss in a
particular part that invests mostly into
the motor system
increases the dopamine in other
locations so what was found is that the
increase in dopamine in other locations
and
push people into these behavioral
obsessions slash addictions
things like consumption and shopping
this was the link that I found
intriguing between what we might
consider normal behavior and something
driven by a pathology or a treatment of
a pathology so what was happening to
these patients and and still happens to
some patients so we understand it better
and can prevent it a little better is
that the increase in dopamine in one
part of the system
was having an overdose in other parts of
the system
and what that helps link is to people
who don't have Parkinson's don't have
extra dopamine given to them as a
medical treatment
but get into these behavioral addictions
to things like video gaming shopping and
certain other conditions
which are basically
excesses of consumption or excesses of
the reward of consumption
um people in the field have taken this
as an evidence that our society as a
whole in the wealthy industrialized
societies have become quote unquote
addicted I'm going to use that word a
little bit Loosely here
to consumption
and when you think back to how our
brains evolved we
get a reward and again I'm not talking
about
um the kind of rewards you get because
you use your credit card and you get
points towards flying or something like
that I'm using the reward in the
biologic sense
by acquiring something that gives you a
survival advantage or security
in modern uins this translates to
financial reward oftentimes and it also
can translate to
material reward and this addiction to
shopping or gambling is another way of
saying that we are getting a particular
type of neural reward to consuming and
acquiring certain things
now here's the problem
that kind of reward is very short-lived
biologically it is designed to be
short-lived because the whole point of
the dopaminergic reward system in our
biology is that it teaches you what you
need to survive so if you're walking
through a landscape and you're hungry
and you're tired and you're thirsty and
you come upon a patch of berries
that you've never seen before you've
never been in this place before your
reward system is designed to say ah wow
those are the best berries I ever had
this is like wonderful and in that
neural mechanism you will make
associations between those berries how
you feel that you know you get your
hunger and thirst satisfied and the
other features of that landscape so that
next time you're in that circumstance
you now know where to look for berries
either come back to that place or if
you're a nomad you look for similar
features in the landscape that's what
you needed to learn to survive
but
you also need to learn new things so
once you've learned those associations
you don't need to learn them anymore now
you're gonna yeah you're gonna like the
berries but your reward system is
designed to teach you the next thing you
need to know to survive in the next
adapted landscape that you encounter
the problem in Modern Life is that those
rewards of consumption that are an
outgrowth of the way the system was
designed to work in the prehistory of
humans
and it's not just humans we were built
on the landscape of animals that came
before us and had this same system all
the way back to invertebrates
it's very very temporary so in Modern
Life when you get a reward you go
shopping on Amazon it's delivered to
your door it's great
for a short time the reward then goes
away because that's how it's designed
it's designed to be transient so I think
in the book I use the example of a
furniture store
so you know you get a new sofa well now
you want to complete the look and they
tell you that in the sales you know
people well if you've got a carpet that
went with that sofa it would be even
better and if you've got an easy chair
that went with that sofa it would be
even more rewarding and each time you
get a reward but it goes away
so to keep the same satisfaction you
have to get more and more and more and
this plays to our biology in a way that
increases our consumption it ties back
then to climate and our consumption
because we need those highs throughout
our lives to feel that we're making it
and so change to affect our lifestyle
that will take away those highs is
difficult they're difficult for us to do
they are difficult but the interesting
thing is and you may be planning to get
to this is that it doesn't make us happy
so those rewards were designed that
whole system was designed for short-term
survival
but study after study has shown that
long-term happiness is not based on
these highs and lows of immediate reward
it's based on two main other things
a sense of purpose
and relationships
and those two things are mediated quite
differently in our neural circuitry and
that's what gives what we call happiness
or long-term life satisfaction so this
chasing Rewards
doesn't get us where most of us think we
want to go these two long-term life
satisfaction but then and Christine so
so let's talk about value then right
because part of this ties back to our
value system right I mean you know you
you're told when you're going to school
get a job make money get rich buy a big
house get a wife multiple kids multiple
dogs multiple cars it's more more more
more right and that's how Society values
you you know say oh you're a great guy
look at this guy you had a multi-million
dollar house he's great he's successful
how do we change the value system
because unless we change the value
system
the reward is what's driving the drive
the value so how do we bring about
an understanding I know it's not easy to
change but how do we change our value
system so we stop looking at those
things that are transient and start
looking at things that are much more
sustainable over the long run
well I don't know that I can answer that
I mean I'm just a neurosurgeon but not
just I mean it's not neurosurgeon it's
just
but here's what a neuroscience approach
helps us do here's the only value to
this whole exploration in my mind which
is
what Neuroscience allows you to do is
give an arm's length view to the way we
are
we are the way we are for reasons that
are understandable and comprehensible
and
it allows us to say
are these societal values
which is what your question is about
do they make sense did they come from on
high did they come from
Harry Potter's magic wand or are these
all an outgrowth of the way we work
neurologically and if it gives you that
arm's length
you don't have to be judgmental about it
you don't have to say this is bad and
this is good this is these people are
bad to have these values these people
are good to have these values you can
say where did this come from
and having that Neuroscience View
gives you the ability to say we are not
necessarily forced into this narrow idea
of what's valuable
we can look at it objectively and say ah
there's a reason that we may feel this
way but we're not compelled to feel this
way there's a reason that getting that
house may feel rewarding
but you know what for Life satisfaction
I might be more rewarded if I have a
smaller house and I volunteer and help
people who have less than me because we
also know that the human reward system
is not all about material reward
we are also rewarded by many other
things and each of us has our own traits
where some things are more rewarding to
us than others Evolution designed us to
be different from one another by Design
because that way as a group as a society
we are better able to problem solve and
adapt but there are other rewards
including as you and I have discussed
agency the ability to make something
happen
so
the ability to solve a problem and come
up with a a good solution the ability to
connect to other people social rewards
are extremely powerful for humans both
early in life and later in life
the reward of helping somebody now you
know in your own life as people in the
audience there are people who are really
driven by that altruistic reward there
are other people that's not their thing
their thing may be problem solving their
thing may be something else thank
heavens were different from one another
because if we weren't we would not have
made the kinds of successes that we
so we are not constrained
to necessarily believe that what someone
else tells us is rewarding like the
bigger house is necessarily what is
going to give us that long-term life
satisfaction and we can look at where it
comes from and question it we do have an
extraordinary ability to question
assumptions
and that's why you're an electrical
engineer you could question these things
that's why some of the people that I met
today your interns and your staff people
each of them has questioned certain
things we have that ability and we can
bring that to bear in crises like the
climate crisis we do not have to be
constrained
by a reward system that can only look at
one reward a few more questions and then
we'll open up to the audience see if we
have any questions in the chat box as
well I want to talk about behavioral
change and and in the book you you talk
about some behaviors that matter most
and you also talk about behaviors that
are difficult to change and some that
are much easier talk a little bit about
the ones that are difficult to change
and some that are easier to change
so when I went down this road of
exploring the relationship between
neuroscience and our planet crisis the
big question I had is how flexible is
our brain how can we change and I
decided to look at some of those things
in the health and public health world
that were known to be difficult and
addiction and overeating are some of the
ones that are linked and particularly
difficult and I wanted to know what has
been shown lots of things have been
tried what has been shown to work the
best and then as a corollary to that
question I needed to know in my own mind
which are the behaviors that are
contributing most to climate change
and most of the research has been done
on individual behaviors but we can scale
this to the behaviors of people in other
spheres of influence so in the public
health and health World addiction is the
classic example of something that's
difficult to change and what has been
shown to work
there's a few basic principles
number one positive is better than
negative in general whether it's in
education addiction or or other spheres
of difficult Behavior change
people on average do better with
positive
um interactions than negative so phrase
versus punishment for example
you do better making difficult Behavior
change happen by substituting
a reward
that is going to be active and
substitute for the reward you're taking
away so the classic example are the
12-step programs in addiction
where you are substituting social reward
which is very powerful for humans or
the reward of the drug
or the alcohol or whatever it is that
you're giving up that you're addicted to
sometimes it's a behavior it's gambling
it's video games
social rewards are incredibly powerful
for human beings so in 12-step programs
you have a community you have people
that are rooting for you you have
um people who understand what you're
going through
and this is why these things tend to
work so it's substituting one reward for
another and
um
it's it's getting you out of a context
of habit where again these kinds of
Habitual connections are very powerful
in humans and they're a big part of
addiction so it's getting you out of
that context where the habit
goes into more detail about this is a
neural circuit that is very challenging
to break it's why recidivism is high but
it's getting you out of that context so
that you can create new habits uh and
substitute for the old ones
in the world of climate change
there are behaviors that are the biggest
contributor and if anybody wants to know
you just type in carbon calculator and
it will tell you in your own life you
fill in some blanks and it'll tell you
in your own life where your carbon
footprint is coming from and for most
people it varies from person to person
but for most of us the big ones are not
the ones we think of you know you learn
in school to recycle well recycling is
important but it's a pretty small part
of most people's carbon footprint and
the big ones tend to be how you get
around your transportation
how you heat and cool your house
what kind of food you eat how much meat
versus how much plant-based food
agriculture is a big part of this
um how many air flights you take
and how many children you have so these
are the things in people's individual
lives where the carbon footprints for
most of us are the biggest
some people have said Why Try To Change
Behavior individual behavior is not the
answer to climate change and that's
absolutely
pretty true I had to look this up
because I didn't know and I had to read
a lot and get some sense in my own mind
as to where this comes down and about
half the carbon problem from high
industrial countries comes from
Individual choices we make and about
half comes from things we don't have
much control over that said Behavior
change does not just apply to our
individual personal choices it also
applies to our choices in the workplace
if you are the president of a college if
you're an educator if you are the CEO of
a company if you're the middle manager
in an industry
you have to make these choices
that affect many people
and the same equation about climate
change
uh will factor in and so these Behavior
change decisions
can follow the same principles
substitute positive for negative so if
you are an industry leader and you have
to make a tough choice that will re
reduce your profit margin
but improve your carbon footprint or
your environmental profile
it's going to be a tough choice on your
own you're used to being rewarded by
your shareholders saying great profit
margin this quarter
[Music]
how do you substitute for that when you
substitute potentially by having other
industry leaders other people in your
strata who do this together and you get
the social reward so it's substituting
social reward
or what you're used to making your
decisions based on which is the old
reward
and these I'm not saying this is easy
but if you don't have that social
network or substitute a new reward maybe
it's your kids saying wow you did that
that's my future maybe it's some other
kind of reward but you have to realize
that the rewards that you're used to are
not going to apply to this problem it's
too new a problem for us as a society
it's not something we have a long
history with in fact it's a first of its
kind problem so the equations for
decision making need to be new equations
and
recognizing that no one's going to make
a new decision with no reward you just
have to find some new ones and recognize
that agency
caring for others
social rewards these are the ones that
we can call on
to substitute for the old rewards which
are largely material and we were saying
this now in in many places around the
world uh you know workers are asking
employees employers employees are asking
for a different value system want to
work from home they want flexibility so
flexibility is now a new value that most
corporations are having to Grapple with
one last question for you and then we
take one or two questions from the
audience I want you to talk a little bit
about
at what point
everything you've talked about here in
terms of understanding the brain and the
circuitry
how do we apply it in a you know take an
example like start your day take me
through a day where I show up to work I
have to eat lunch and I skip lunch I
think you have an example of that in the
book help the audience and those
listening to to go back today and apply
what they're hearing from you in terms
of oh Dr Dwayne said I should pause
before I eat one more cookie or I should
I should do this before I do that walk
us through this activity in the brain
just take an example of how the brain
will work between now and by the time we
get home
well if you have absorbed anything from
today's talk you may reflect on the fact
that you're making decisions at multiple
levels every step of the way and what
influences you uh will not be
immediately available to you whether you
take a right or a left I'll give you an
example you're going to walk home from
here and you're either going to go this
way or that way and you could go either
way you might go towards the Sunny Side
because it's a little chilly out you're
not thinking of that you just
do it what gets you to go towards the
city side is it the reward of being in
the sun that's nice okay so that's the
reward the reward is the heat yes okay
exactly
um or you know you might you might
deflect down towards uh the Basin where
the cherry blossoms are and you don't
think about it necessarily consciously
but that's the way your steps take you
so it's not always at a level where
you're saying it I'm going to do this
you know and every decision that you
make is like that it it's going to have
multiple layers now whether anyone is
influenced by this discussion or not I
don't know but you may think to yourself
you may
do I really need that thing do I really
need it uh I'm going to get a short-term
reward
it's not going to pay off but more
importantly and at a bigger scale if you
were a leader in any capacity where you
make decisions that may affect many
people
you may be able to consciously reflect
and say oh I I need to
change my priorities I need to change my
equation a little bit because there is
this overwhelmingly
urgent even if it doesn't feel that way
important life-altering Globe oriented
crisis that is difficult for me to
perceive
my equations need to change
for the future of all of us
and
I can do that I have the brain that can
make that happen I have that capacity to
change the equation it is not going to
feel that decision is not likely to feel
rewarding in the same way that I have
relied on to make all my decisions up to
this point
I've relied on an entire human history
and personal history of equations that
have
that have directed my decisions
this
time and these decisions are different
from anything in my history
and anything in our Collective history
and it is not going to feel the same I
am not going to feel the same certainty
that this decision that is a
pro-environmental decision
um is going to have the same
visceral feel
and I have to make that tough decision
anyway make it easier I'm going to find
like-minded people I'm going to look at
my children and my grandchildren I'm
going to get some cognitive input as to
how this may have ramifications in the
future
I can't rely on the same
reactions that I have always relied on
and I'm aware of that and I'm taking
that into account and I'm making that
tough decision anyway thank you question
an audience
um so you're a neurosurgeon as well as
an advocate so I wanted to know
how how has your practice shaped your
theory so how have your experiences with
patients affected
uh how this book came about
thanks
um
I think part of it is that
in a field like mine in neurosurgery
particularly pediatric neurosurgery
where I take care of children
there is nothing more important
that I've ever seen
to a person than their child
that particular
bond that particular
Obsession and concern is the most potent
Force I've ever experienced
and
for this reason
um it's clear to me that there is
something
evolutionarily
predisposed in The Human Condition
because of the utter power of that Bond
and that concern
parents would much rather they were the
one with the brain tumor than their
child by the brain tumor they would put
themselves in their child's position in
a Millicent the vast majority of them
this is so consistent
um and I think that that convinced me
that our brains are the way they are for
evolutionary reasons and that they are
extraordinarily potent
and I've also had the privilege of
witnessing the grace
and utter
um awesome Humanity of people even under
circumstances of terrible terrible
tragedy
so I have faith in humans
I think I have faith in the human brain
and in the way our brains were designed
to work based on those
intense somewhat artificially intense
but
um because the circumstances are
artificial
but I have utter conviction
of the essential goodness and capacity
of human beings
to adapt change and to
and to rely on these human interactions
and the power of them and so I think
that's maybe the way I can answer that
question I think I have faith
in the biology of the human brain and
its capacity based on some of these
experiences and also on the plasticity
and adaptability of the human brain
um as a function profession
so so let me ask a question on that you
you in the book you talk about the grain
the grain Children's Hospital you spend
a lot of whole chapters dedicated to
that project you just
share with the audience you know how
that came about and what was the key
takeaway from that that project
the green Children's Hospital project
was a test case
and if one believes that the way to
encourage pro-environmental behaviors to
make it rewarding
could I as an experiment
influence the leadership of my hospital
to do something I thought was helpful
for children
and also pro-environmental
by appealing to the things that they
might find rewarding
they meaning the administration
Administration the leadership the
finance people and so forth and what
would be rewarding to them the idea of a
children's hospital was not that
rewarding to them because they make
their profit largely off the adult
practices
pediatric practices in a general
hospital just because of the way our
Health Care system is have a lower
profit margin so while people all want
to have pediatric care for a variety of
reasons to be a general hospital
it's not their biggest profit maker I
don't want to cut you over and Christine
I think is ironic that the children are
supposed to be the future of the world
but this should be more profitable
actually yes that's not the way the
Healthcare System the person works
unfortunately okay unless you are a
freestanding children's hospital where
you have in some cities a monopoly and
UK it's about Contracting it's about the
business side we could get we could give
a whole talk on that
so I knew I needed I felt we needed a
new children's hospital and I wanted to
make it a prototype because we're small
enough to do this we could make a
hospital as a laboratory
so I had this whole Vision I had a whole
lot of collaborators in the engineering
school and in the business people and a
variety of people architecture people
from around the world really and and my
idea was we're gonna have this prototype
there's going to be a hundred bed
roughly Children's Hospital first of its
kind it was going to be Net Zero Energy
or even positive this is a challenge
this is an engineering challenge in a
Northeast urban city like ours Boston
and to make it rewarding to people who
didn't even care about climate change
remember this was this was in 2014 2015
okay it was a different political era at
that time and it may come back to that
kind of political era we will see but at
that time there was a lot of climate
denial still and even in the healthcare
field it was like climate change is not
our shift this is somebody else's
problem
so to appeal to people for whom climate
change was not as urgent a problem as it
was in my mind the idea was this would
be besides being a prototype first of
its kind it would be absolutely
stunningly beautiful by appealing to our
natural
tendency to be attracted to Nature so
this would be the absolutely most
biophilic most nature-filled facility
ever invented
and it would be like walking into a
forest as a hospital
and for kids and their families I did a
lot of work with people in this in
related fields to see what the evidence
was that this was actually helpful for
healing and stress and it it clearly is
a natural environment has all sorts of
Health advantages the indoor air quality
would be better and so on so for
scientific reasons for attractiveness
reasons and for being the first of its
kind which I thought would appeal to our
leadership
we're at Harvard we like being first we
like being the best we like being the
only we like doing things first right
and so I thought that I could appeal to
our leadership on those grounds
it didn't
fly
because what I needed was a huge donor
and I'm not much of a fundraiser and I
didn't have contact with those kinds of
people and if I did there were other
priorities that they were led to so it's
still awaiting that finding of a big
donor anybody out there let me know but
um
it did move the needle
so the lesson was after that and with
input from other like-minded people I'll
tell you social rewards are so important
we created a center for the environment
and health at our hospital that had not
existed before and that was a top down
and bottom up kind of a thing it was the
clinicians worried about climate change
and climate change's effect on health
and it was the leadership's recognition
that we had to make an energy transition
for financial reasons and for regulatory
reasons so they had an advantage at the
top they had an incentive we had an
incentive at the bottom we met in the
middle we created the center of which
I'm now associate director and we
created a whole new journal the Journal
of climate change and health so many
things tipped the needle moved the
needle our institution now is much more
environmentally focused than it was part
of it was this whole green Children's
Hospital push so while we have not yet
realized the vision of this Hospital
which I still am utterly committed to
and believe in and think would be
amazing
as a prototype
that would not in itself have a huge
climate impact but could be exported and
the technologies that we could develop
with our incredible Technologic
Partnerships and expertise energy and so
on could be transformative
I still believe in that Vision I'm still
trying to realize that Vision so while I
didn't get the administration totally go
there they went part of the way and that
was a huge lesson of the flexibility
even of people with other priorities
we've got about five more minutes I want
to hopefully get you three questions and
and I know this is a crunch time of year
but one has to do it Injustice in
society and how that ties back to this
conversation a lot of discussions around
environmental justice or Just Energy
transition we have the developed
countries consuming more the less
developed countries this comes to who
should change right how do we talk about
change and how to make change happen on
a much more global scale as opposed to
just the individual how do we get those
in the rich countries to change for the
benefit of the entire planet as opposed
to saying even those in the poorer
countries should also change how does
one do that
well that's the trickiest problem isn't
it and I don't even think we have to get
Global and international that's clearly
the critical part Even in our own
neighborhoods there is inequity that
climate change affects the core more
marginalized more underserved
communities
uh way before it affects others how do
you get people to behave collectively
it's it's a it's a challenge for humans
because they tend to
um make decisions based on immediacy and
proximity and
personal knowledge
so from a brain point of view these are
challenges and again I think the same
principles apply like-minded people
movements the movements for example the
youth movements have affected people
globally to realize this and
you know it's it's uh it goes without
saying that the wealthier countries are
going to have to
um
consider
that these problems are not local
problems these are Global problems we
can't solve the problem
without
recognizing things that occur beyond our
own
perspective and
it's going to come back the CO2 we put
in the in the atmosphere doesn't it goes
everywhere and so I think that um
it's the same principles of why
decisions that are not immediate or
difficult for us and why we have to
think more long-term than short term we
have to use our cognition
and I think we can appeal to some extent
to selfish Moments by recognizing that
stuff doesn't stay where it is this is a
global problem and we are in it together
[Music]
um finally there are rewards that we can
tap into about helping people with less
there is a whole
powerful reward to be gained from
helping others and
if it's a choice between more for me or
more for someone else when I have enough
we have to start
helping people feel the the actual
reward value of giving to others my
second to the last question I promise
this is the second to the last and I
have one last question but the second
one before we get there is
um
this conversation has been watched and
listened to by leaders uh some might be
policy makers some might be Business
Leaders
what do they get out of this
reading this book understanding the
brain circuitry and understanding why
it's important to look at the reward
system what would you want to tell a
policy maker or business leader watching
this why they should read this and apply
some of the principles in this book
I think that
I want to get away from the idea
that your brain is somehow hardwired
the brain's remarkably flexible
and if you know that
and you know where some of our decisions
come from
prehistorically
you will recognize your own capacity to
change
and your capacity to influence others to
change
so I think the take home message is one
of Hope and optimism and confidence
I think people get into a mindset that
this is quote unquote human nature and
we can't change
and I would challenge that we can I'm
not saying it's easy but there are
certain things that are in the book that
you can rely on to help you
change yourself change your priorities
change your attitudes and help others to
changes
good now my last question and Christine
the last chapter in the book is called
sustainable brain
and
um people watching this have kids
how do we work today as a society to get
young people today
to develop the sustainable brain or to
develop that sustainable mindset that
you talk about so that when they get to
a certain age
at least they have adapted some of the
things you've talked about how do we
develop the brain of kids to do at least
help them to develop a most sustainable
brain because I think for us it's the
time has passed my brain can be made
sustainable anymore right yes it can yes
it can I would challenge that okay first
of all I think you already have
okay
first of all uh this is change is not
confined to you
you continue to change up until you are
no longer alive
and we forget that it is true that
people you know there's there's adages
about we get more conservative as we get
older
um
there's some truth to that we tend to uh
like
uh
novelty more when we're young and
familiarity more when we're older
but we continue to change throughout our
lives and we have that to pass but to
answer your question about children
I feel that in modern society we have
taken away some of children's agencies
we schedule them we teach them we give
them classes we don't let them alone to
figure it out on their own that was part
of evolutionary history that's how you
learned you learned from playing with
other kids in an unstructured
environment
there is a movement in the educational
world to try to restore
activities that give children agency
they figure it out on their own they
figure out their own talents so I would
say that's part of it
and the other big part of it is
remember that Rewards
are buried
and it's not all about one kind of
reward which is financial or material
reward
but encourage in children
rewards of social rewards and agency and
altruism and creativity
problem solving
and if we think of these things more
broadly
we I think can encourage both
sustainability and long-term life
satisfaction as opposed to immediate
material rewards and their short-lived
well then Christy and I have to say this
has been a fascinating conversation I
have enjoyed reading the book as I
revealed to you this morning that I I
actually went through it detail I think
it's really going to impact our industry
and the world as a whole because I think
this is one of the first books that have
looked at understanding the brain and
how it ties into climate change and some
of the other challenges which we haven't
got into today you know in vexing
population you have issues around
poverty a lot of other Global challenges
but I think mining the climate is the
first start and I hope we can mine other
challenges and try to get to the bottom
of this so congratulations on the book
please join me in thanking Dr M
Christine to him for being with us
thank you thank you everyone for joining
today's episode of influential Minds we
will be sending out a zoom recording to
all attendees and it will be uploaded to
our YouTube channel at a later date
where you can also find recordings from
other past conversations and webinars
for more information and to continue
engaging with eei International programs
please follow us on Twitter and visit
our website check out the chat the links
thank you and have a wonderful rest of
your day
Episode 12Jesper Brodin
How IKEA links affordability, circular design and renewable energy with climate action, purpose-led leadership and sustainable growth.
Episode 08Julio M. Ottino
Connecting art, science and technology to expand creativity, strengthen leadership and navigate a complex, interconnected world.
Episode 07Sebastian Mallaby
How venture capital, risk-taking and connected networks turn bold ideas into startups and spread entrepreneurial culture.