Episode 081 hr 2 minWatch on YouTube

About this conversation

Connecting art, science and technology to expand creativity, strengthen leadership and navigate a complex, interconnected world.

Ask about this conversation

This conversation only
Answers are grounded in indexed transcripts only.

Transcript

00:04

hello and welcome everyone to

00:06

influential Minds an eei international

00:09

conversation series my name is

00:12

and I'm a senior analyst for

00:14

international programs at eei

00:16

influential Minds is our virtual

00:18

conversation series which aims to

00:21

discuss ideas that move the needle

00:23

towards a more sustainable future with

00:25

thought leaders from across the globe

00:27

today eei International programs is

00:30

excited to welcome Julio otino an artist

00:32

researcher author and Dean of the

00:35

McCormick School of Engineering and

00:37

applied science at Northwestern

00:39

University

00:40

he joins us today to discuss his latest

00:42

book the Nexus augmented thinking for a

00:45

complex world the new convergence of art

00:48

technology and science where he will

00:50

dive into a new modes of thinking to

00:53

expand our creativity and augment our

00:55

Insight he will be joined in

00:57

conversation by our host eei vice

01:00

president of international programs Dr

01:02

Lawrence Jones throughout the session

01:04

please feel free to ask questions using

01:07

the chat feature Dr Jones will aim to

01:09

incorporate as many of them as possible

01:11

into the conversation without further

01:13

Ado I will turn this over to Lawrence to

01:15

get started

01:21

thank you alikia and good morning Julio

01:24

welcome to the eu's influential Minds

01:27

delighted to be with you let me first of

01:30

all congratulate you for the very very

01:33

well written book the Nexus augmented

01:36

thinking for a complex world uh we

01:38

indeed live in a complex world and I

01:41

think what you're trying to do in this

01:43

book is very fascinating in terms of the

01:45

convergence of art technology and

01:48

science but I think let's begin first of

01:51

all by talking about why you wrote This

01:54

Book

01:55

yeah

01:56

wow I think the

02:01

short answer

02:03

was the time have come to do it but

02:07

it had a long long Inception I mean I

02:10

had been

02:12

collecting materials for

02:15

a book like this for a long long time

02:19

and I saw

02:23

there were a few times

02:25

what I saw

02:28

things converted in such a way that gave

02:32

a glimpse that this was a good idea just

02:35

to give you one example I can give you

02:37

two or three that are very similar I was

02:40

a senior advisor for Unilever the

02:44

company Dutch Anglo company for

02:47

like 12 years

02:48

and when they

02:50

gave me the title of senior advisor they

02:54

said we want you to be a provocator we

02:57

want you to look at what we are doing

02:59

question what we're doing so I had

03:01

access to

03:02

the research technology also the

03:06

Knowledge Management that was discussed

03:09

I had access to the management science

03:11

research

03:13

and at one point

03:15

I convinced them that

03:19

we should do something in complexity we

03:21

should organize this imposing complexity

03:25

because

03:26

the thinking in complexity was going to

03:28

affect lots of the things that Unilever

03:30

was around from research to management

03:35

yeah we put something together we

03:38

invited

03:39

lots of people there was a senior editor

03:42

from nature I think there was a Nobel

03:44

prize from chemistry that got invited

03:48

but what I did not

03:50

know

03:52

is the venue that Unilever picked

03:56

to do the event

03:58

they got the Tate mother in London and

04:03

they got a room

04:05

they paid modern is enormous a Rome that

04:09

was overlooking the Millennium bridge

04:11

and the Globe Theater and at that moment

04:13

I could say

04:15

I could see the intersections between

04:17

art technology and science since then

04:22

I have had several ideas I did an event

04:26

Accenture where they actually rented all

04:29

the modern wing of the Art Institute in

04:31

Chicago

04:32

and I was the only talk it was a talk

04:36

the top 40 Partners people who are

04:39

managing either

04:40

sector or a country and again I I have

04:45

been doing this

04:46

and throughout all of these

04:49

since 2006 when I saw a show that Bruce

04:55

Mao had put in Chicago

04:57

that took over the entire uh

05:01

missionary Contemporary Art we had been

05:04

having coffees for 12 years

05:07

discussing ideas actually the central

05:10

idea that I was a customer would end up

05:12

being chapter four in the book The

05:15

comparisons between art technology and

05:17

science instructors

05:19

and then

05:21

the pandemic hit us

05:24

and I had time to assemble the notes put

05:28

them together

05:29

and that was when the time came to kind

05:32

of say yeah we will

05:34

do a book

05:36

I contacted MIT press and then I brought

05:39

Bruce again

05:40

and that's how that happened I mean it

05:44

was not

05:45

a southern thing it had been brewing for

05:49

yeah you would say the entire life my

05:53

entire life interesting well look it's

05:55

it's fascinating how you you talk about

05:58

the Nexus and and you bring our

06:00

technology and science together in a way

06:02

that I have not seen done before so so

06:05

talk a little bit about

06:07

this Divergence that has occurred now we

06:09

see today our technology and science are

06:12

almost seen as opposites they don't come

06:15

together but in the book you talk about

06:17

the Divergence just briefly when did our

06:20

technology and science diverge in

06:21

history and are we seeing a convergence

06:25

occurring today

06:26

yeah so the the convergence today is

06:30

that

06:31

now more than at any point in the past

06:36

artist and it's a very broad diverse

06:39

group okay

06:41

um I mean first of all artists now

06:45

even the ones who are

06:47

trained

06:49

in places like the Art Institute here in

06:51

the school of the artist in Chicago or

06:53

Yale

06:54

if they need to learn something they

06:58

will learn it I have seen that in

07:01

courses that we have done

07:04

with people from engineering if they

07:06

need to learn how to code they will

07:08

learn it okay so you could go back to

07:12

the point in which

07:13

our technology and science work together

07:15

and you can talk about Leon Batista

07:18

birthday and Alberti and Leonardo and so

07:22

the Renaissance there was no different

07:24

the word science had not been invented

07:26

art in Korean science they were all

07:28

together

07:29

eventually

07:31

the things started to separate when

07:36

people who are managing States

07:41

principalities

07:42

they saw the value that some things in

07:47

math

07:48

and pre-technology

07:51

were useful to that

07:53

ballistic trajectories

07:56

divert the course of rivers Leonardo was

07:59

doing a little bit of this okay

08:01

yeah DaVinci so but there were people

08:03

like Nicola tartaglia for example in

08:06

Italy who wrote a book on ballistics and

08:11

there was money that they were putting

08:13

on this pre-technology kind of thing

08:16

they were technology was invented

08:20

1900 kind of

08:22

and at that point

08:24

art and philosophy sort of started going

08:29

one way and Technology

08:32

supported a a lot by

08:36

military needs

08:39

started diverging and then then there

08:42

was another Divergence and it was like

08:45

in in many books especially math

08:50

figures started Vanishing from the books

08:54

in fact there was a famous book I

08:56

mentioned in in my own book by a fellow

08:59

named LaGrange yes who boasted that you

09:04

shall find no pictures in this book

09:06

because pictures were supposed to be

09:09

crutches that you use but then

09:12

the real argument was independent of it

09:16

you'll remove them so

09:19

that lasted for a long long while

09:22

but now I think it's an opportunity of

09:25

bringing things more together because

09:29

artists are more entrepreneurial than

09:31

ever before I mean they are

09:35

groups

09:37

that

09:38

are massively large now in art

09:41

in Modern Art

09:43

and they they will use whatever

09:46

technology is out there

09:50

to their needs I mean we can get into

09:53

long discussion about Ai and art now but

09:56

artists are more entrepreneurial so the

09:59

opportunity of connecting with them

10:01

is as good as it has ever been yeah so

10:05

so in the so the title of the book is

10:07

augmented thinking that's one of the

10:09

sort of top themes and talk about for

10:13

the audience who's listening

10:15

what do you mean by Nexus thinking and

10:18

and and how does one become a Nexus

10:21

thinker yeah so they they

10:26

we get educated and

10:28

we go through life

10:31

equipping

10:33

our brains with the library of knowledge

10:37

and the library that you acquire if you

10:41

become a scientist

10:45

has different volumes

10:47

not completely different but it's an

10:50

overlap that if you become an engineer

10:52

or you become a lawyer for example you

10:55

have a mental Library

10:57

and that mental library is the one that

11:00

when he's the one that provides you a

11:03

lens to see the world

11:05

and is what provides the first draft of

11:08

ideas that you may have to solve

11:10

problems in front of you

11:13

there is no question that to go to quote

11:17

line of spoiling here he said the best

11:19

way to have a good idea is to have lots

11:20

of ideas okay

11:22

lots of different ideas so if you have

11:25

a mental library that is let's say

11:28

coming from science

11:30

all your ideas will emerge I mean they

11:33

can be a very diverse set but they will

11:35

be there will be different than the

11:38

library that an artist will have looking

11:40

at this emission and the question is

11:43

could you

11:45

train yourself

11:47

to have an augmented

11:50

mental space that somehow incorporates

11:55

those two domains it doesn't mean that

11:57

if you're a scientist you become an

11:59

artist or vice versa but if you could

12:05

sort of make an effort to understand

12:09

how the other domains think

12:12

then

12:13

your brain will become expanded really

12:16

and metaphorically speaking and is it

12:19

has to do with

12:21

first avoiding misconceptions that one

12:24

side has about the other one people in

12:27

science

12:28

they tend to think I'm speaking kind of

12:31

stereotyping here that artists create

12:35

they do things when there are moments of

12:37

Inspirations there and artists will tend

12:41

to think that science is all rational

12:43

and logical and they don't see the

12:46

passions that drive people

12:49

so and moreover we tend to equate

12:53

the domains with the outputs that they

12:55

produce okay

12:58

an architect will equate it with the

13:01

final building or is or a sculpture with

13:04

biggest culture Anish Kapoor with things

13:07

that he has done for example and

13:09

scientists we equate them with whatever

13:12

product emerge a vaccine or something

13:15

but it's more important to understand

13:17

the process that led to those things

13:20

Kavita they thought how is that they

13:22

came up with ideas they discarded them

13:25

they modified them it's not like it's

13:28

always forward

13:29

you have setbacks how do you handle so I

13:33

think understanding how others think

13:38

I think the book I tried to make a case

13:43

and again we are speaking in general

13:45

terms here that technology by whatever

13:49

measure you pick

13:51

borrows a little bit from science

13:54

and a little bit from our heart because

13:57

both is not as codified as science and

14:01

is not as free as art

14:03

but it borrows elements of both and the

14:06

more you sort of try to understand

14:10

how others think the better it will be

14:14

so it's all about extracting the thought

14:17

process from the art World from the

14:20

technology World from the Science World

14:21

and bringing it together so well put

14:25

it's exactly that yeah so what most

14:27

people don't know Julia is that you are

14:29

a I would call it an acclaimed artist uh

14:33

you've done fabulous paintings you sent

14:35

me some of them I looked at them and it

14:37

was if I looked at the painting they

14:38

didn't know you were a professor I would

14:40

think you're an artist and when I read

14:42

the book I didn't see the painting I

14:43

would think you're a professor

14:45

talk about yourself your experience your

14:48

journeying into becoming a Nexus

14:49

thinking when did that trigger when did

14:52

you get that inspiration to say you know

14:54

what I'm going to practice what I preach

14:56

I myself are going to be a Nexus

14:57

thinking one day Nexus thinker when did

15:00

that happen in your life in

15:01

retrospective

15:03

I mean everything looks clear in

15:05

hindsight okay but

15:08

there were times in which I was able to

15:10

put the two things together for example

15:12

I wrote a monograph that is sort of made

15:17

my career in science in which is a lot

15:21

of math

15:23

but this picture this book needed

15:25

pictures

15:26

that need to be drawn

15:28

by hand and I drew almost every picture

15:31

in the book it's a Macbook Okay so

15:38

I was lucky I was my father was someone

15:44

who did

15:47

lab work he had a

15:51

elaboratory with microscopes

15:54

and he was very matching to histology

15:58

staining samples

16:01

so I grew up surrounded by something

16:04

like that and microscopes

16:06

and my mother was a classically trained

16:11

someone classically training art

16:15

she never really had an independent

16:19

career as an artist but I remember

16:22

looking at her work and all all the

16:25

things that she had done

16:27

and so I had those two things

16:30

but I grew up in Argentina and Argentina

16:33

was a little bit like many countries

16:38

maybe think of India where

16:41

doctor engineer I'm exaggerating it here

16:45

okay but it's not like you have 50

16:47

possibilities

16:49

you have broad drugs so at some point I

16:53

had to decide

16:55

uh I

16:58

I was painting

17:00

painting in some sense

17:04

helped me a lot

17:06

because growing up

17:10

Argentina had a compulsory military

17:12

service and only a few people very very

17:15

small number

17:17

if you finish a degree

17:21

like engineering medicine economics law

17:26

you could go through training and you

17:29

become an officer

17:32

and I did that two years in the Navy

17:36

but while I was there

17:40

there was one of these periodic

17:42

Revolutions in Argentina the government

17:44

was overthrown I was in the middle of

17:46

this

17:47

it was a very difficult time

17:50

people were banishing right and left

17:54

but I managed to have a solo show

17:57

at that point

17:59

and so my

18:02

instead of drifting to politics like

18:04

many people in the University my

18:07

all my sort of

18:10

whatever's cathartic sort of thinking

18:13

went into

18:15

art God and

18:18

immediately after finishing that

18:21

is when

18:23

we got married my wife had just finished

18:27

high school

18:29

and we came to the U.S and

18:34

I got in Mercy into my PhD

18:37

the Earth was always there I kept

18:40

painting but I was not connecting

18:43

directly into my work even though what I

18:48

in research

18:50

I was helped a lot by being really

18:53

visual I I started working on chaos

18:56

Theory

18:57

and having visual imagination

19:02

of incredible help on that that's why I

19:05

ended up drawing those pictures in the

19:07

book so so you always have it and in

19:09

retrospective you say

19:12

yeah it was clear at that moment that I

19:14

had all the elements but sometimes

19:17

putting it all together

19:19

like in this book as I said

19:23

I I was one of the ones who benefited

19:25

from the lockdown I was

19:28

cut I know five or six successive

19:31

weekends with nothing to do

19:34

uh well nothing to do it will be an

19:37

exercise I have my work yeah but but

19:41

I was traveling much less yeah so I was

19:44

able to give some structure to the ideas

19:46

and that's how the book emerged so it's

19:49

interesting so obviously your childhood

19:51

grown up in Argentina your your mother

19:54

your father had a big inspiration uh on

19:57

how your career immersed and your focus

20:00

on Art and technology and science for

20:01

that matter just before we get into some

20:03

of the complex issues facing the world

20:05

and how Nexus thinking can help uh for

20:09

those listening

20:10

how can they become Nexus thinker by the

20:14

way can anybody become a Nexus thinker

20:16

or do you have to have a certain set of

20:18

basic skills to go down that path or can

20:21

we all become Nexus thinkers

20:23

I think in some sense you can but you

20:27

have to have something that you have to

20:30

force yourself to

20:34

to train yourself

20:38

I think I can teach people how to be

20:40

creative I had I can

20:44

I can tell you what how is that you

20:47

should think

20:48

or some things that you should have kind

20:52

in front of your glasses that you

20:56

I think what we need the most is being

20:58

curious he's being curious is try to

21:02

understand

21:04

how people who do things do what they do

21:09

and it's not

21:11

essential that you learn

21:15

at some point for example I I heard a

21:18

talk recently from someone who I admire

21:22

about calculus okay and how calculus

21:26

mathematics made the world that we live

21:30

in order to admire cultures

21:33

you probably don't have to learn

21:35

calculus but know a little bit about how

21:38

is that the ideas

21:40

underlining

21:42

the main Concepts

21:44

came into being and got the implications

21:47

are so

21:49

if you are a someone in science or

21:51

technology I don't think that you need

21:54

to kind of

21:56

learned how to paint or sculpt

22:00

but having

22:03

some degree of awareness or connecting

22:07

with people

22:08

maybe new friends who do that kind of

22:11

thing

22:12

understanding what the drivers are

22:16

how do they pick

22:18

what they want to do because as an

22:21

artist

22:22

you could pick anything okay and

22:26

understanding that component is

22:30

essential and the same thing will go for

22:31

people in art if you want to connect

22:34

with someone who does

22:36

science

22:38

and you should try to kind of

22:41

get deeper into what drives them what

22:46

are the Ambitions that they have because

22:48

yeah from the outside

22:51

science could look at something that is

22:55

really cold

22:57

and sort of you have a methodology

23:01

people who know just a bit about science

23:04

will think about well is the scientific

23:06

method yeah no it's science

23:10

more than anything else is a habit about

23:14

problems to pick

23:16

you need intuition yeah okay that's how

23:20

you pick things

23:21

so you know I I want to get into you

23:24

know the other thing about the book

23:25

talks about living in a complex World

23:27

there are a lot of complex Global

23:29

challenges facing the world I just want

23:32

to spend a few minutes talking about

23:33

from your perspective

23:36

how can Nexus thinking be applied in

23:39

three environments one in business

23:41

uh and then in government because a lot

23:44

of the things affecting the world today

23:45

requires policy makers and government

23:48

leaders to make decisions uh and then

23:51

and then also on a personal level uh in

23:54

communities so let's talk a little bit

23:56

about from your view uh if a public if a

23:59

business leader is reading this book how

24:01

can they apply Nexus thinking in their

24:03

business in the same for policy maker or

24:06

politician and then also for a community

24:08

leader let's talk about that yeah so

24:11

find a book to those those three areas

24:13

yeah so

24:14

a let's start by

24:17

asserting that if you have

24:23

a mental space that is augmented because

24:27

components of science and art

24:32

in some instances what will happen is

24:35

that

24:37

the ideas that will emerge on how to

24:40

tackle something

24:42

will be

24:44

diametrically opposed they would be

24:48

in conflict with each other

24:51

and the consequence of this is that

24:56

you have to be mentally prepared

24:59

to resolve

25:01

conflicts is what I call complementarity

25:04

borrowing the term from quantum

25:06

mechanics the ability to resolve

25:09

D conflicts ideas that

25:12

you have to find a resolution

25:14

I think that there are so many problems

25:17

now more than ever that requires people

25:23

manage conflicting viewpoints so that's

25:25

one aspect the other aspect in my view

25:28

which is super important and it probably

25:32

the main idea coming from the complex

25:34

systems side

25:36

is that

25:40

I would say that the definition of a

25:42

leader or part of the definition of a

25:45

leader is

25:47

people who provide conditions for

25:51

successful emergence and by emergence

25:54

what I mean is the property of complex

25:57

systems that when there are many

26:00

interacting components

26:02

what happens as a result of those

26:05

interactions is much more than the sum

26:07

of the parts okay

26:10

um typical example but this is starting

26:13

probably with the most com complex of

26:16

them all will be you can study neurons

26:19

to death

26:20

but you'll never be able to capture

26:22

Consciousness

26:25

connect with each other for a minute a

26:28

much simpler example would be you can

26:31

study a fish to death

26:33

and never never imagine how

26:37

a whole collection of fish will assemble

26:41

into school that seems to function like

26:44

a giant organism moving in the same

26:48

thing with local part so

26:50

the ability to handle conflicts

26:54

and the ability of exploit emergence I

26:58

would say those are two Central things

27:01

that Business Leaders should capture out

27:05

of this and the fact that organization

27:10

an emergence

27:12

need not to be in conflict

27:15

I I think you need plans

27:20

but you also need to provide conditions

27:23

for those plans to give rise to more

27:26

what you are putting in the plan

27:29

that idea of emergence I like it because

27:33

if we look at some of the global

27:35

challenges facing let's say two of them

27:37

climate change and

27:40

supply chain issues facing the world

27:42

today it speaks to this interconnection

27:45

or interdependency of different systems

27:47

so from a policy making perspective as a

27:51

policy maker what do I need to do when I

27:54

think about designing public policy to

27:56

tackle say climate change so supply

27:58

chain or even some of the other

28:00

geopolitical issues we're facing in the

28:02

world today what can leaders learn from

28:04

this concept of emergence

28:06

I do not know if I can give you a list

28:10

of bullet points but

28:13

I think what

28:16

understanding complex systems

28:19

prepares you

28:21

is to be less surprised

28:24

when things happen for example

28:29

we live in a world that is much more

28:31

interconnected now than was

28:33

40 years ago I mean 40 years ago 50

28:36

years ago

28:37

the problems affecting even with the

28:40

pandemic China would have stayed

28:43

confining there but now

28:47

Transportation Supply chains of

28:49

different kinds make the problem more so

28:52

connectivity is good but there are

28:55

several hidden consequences of

28:57

connectivity I mean no one ever thought

29:01

I haven't researched this we're not at

29:04

the beginning of the internet

29:06

when people thought or they will be a

29:10

Brotherhood

29:11

everybody will connect with each other

29:13

will be it will be some good if

29:17

everybody

29:19

some of the consequences

29:22

of this connectedness okay so

29:27

some of the problems that we have seen

29:30

with Supply chains

29:33

is that

29:37

Focus so much on efficiency

29:42

and just in time Concepts

29:46

that fragility

29:49

increase

29:51

and at

29:53

if you had accounted for this

29:56

Black Swan events probably you have

30:00

sacrificed a little bit of efficiency in

30:03

terms of more robustness

30:06

but some of the things that we see now

30:12

consequences of

30:14

how the world is

30:15

all energies connected now and we can

30:19

see the consequences of in real time

30:22

what's going on in Ukraine affecting all

30:25

of us Supply chains of food energy

30:29

everything

30:30

uh I think you have to be prepared for

30:33

those things and accounted in your

30:35

thinking when you

30:36

create new structures if all the

30:40

structure is driven by

30:42

efficiency

30:45

in which

30:46

uh just in time delivery kind of makes

30:49

things great if everything goes great

30:52

but something happens

30:54

and you are in trouble

30:58

I think the thinking needs to be more on

31:02

accounting for those things more than in

31:05

the past

31:06

we live through years in which

31:08

everything was going great the world was

31:11

flat everything was going

31:13

uh but we are seeing now the

31:18

the consequences of having a much more

31:20

interconnected world than we had before

31:23

so if not like

31:26

there's a list of dos and don'ts that is

31:28

very very clear

31:30

but having

31:32

some

31:34

thinking that accounts for the

31:36

consequences of

31:39

how small changes can produce drastic

31:42

consequences

31:44

or how

31:46

you have to be prepared for

31:50

emergence

31:52

in some cases you want to produce that

31:54

in some case

31:56

you would like to prevent it for example

31:58

having people who have been I I have

32:02

said that in my work

32:04

within I mean this is a much smaller

32:07

system managing School the training in

32:10

complex systems was probably the best

32:11

training in anybody could have in

32:14

creating new things

32:16

let's talk about that training in

32:18

complex systems so so what you've said I

32:21

think is a very good lesson here is that

32:23

as you're planning whether it's in the

32:25

business environment in the government

32:27

environment in any sort of a

32:28

decision-making environment you should

32:30

always uh think about the the hidden

32:33

connections you should also keep

32:35

fragility in mind and assume that things

32:37

we may not always go as you plan so

32:39

let's talk about the skills you know let

32:43

me first say to the audience if you have

32:45

any questions please type it into the

32:46

chat box and we'll we'll try to take as

32:48

many as possible uh Julio let's talk

32:51

about you know the environment for

32:54

developing this sort of a Nexus thinking

32:57

in the book you you talk about different

32:58

environment you talk about the known as

33:00

Society you talk about Bell labs and you

33:03

talk about you know Black Mountain

33:04

College

33:05

how does one create an environment where

33:09

Nexus thinking can flourish can you talk

33:11

about that

33:13

well

33:16

the environment

33:18

universities are probably the best place

33:22

that you could experiment with these

33:23

kinds of things

33:25

because

33:28

yeah at the top of the organization you

33:30

have

33:32

people who have jobs and titles

33:36

that

33:38

do not easily transform into another one

33:41

you you you have someone with a chief

33:44

legal counsel you don't expect that that

33:46

person will become the chief marketing

33:48

officer

33:50

but below

33:53

at the level of individual groups

33:56

research groups

33:57

basically and this is what makes the

34:01

university different than other

34:02

organizations in other organizations

34:04

yeah the the jobs are the top are fixed

34:09

but so are the jobs

34:12

at the bottom okay the people who work

34:14

in the mail room they they can progress

34:17

but they will not morph into something

34:19

completely completely different but in a

34:22

university by definition

34:25

groups visual groups you are giving them

34:28

a license and I'm talking mostly about

34:30

science and technology engineering a

34:33

license to pursue whatever research they

34:37

want to pursue

34:38

subject to the constraint that you have

34:41

to raise the money to support that work

34:44

okay so and that's how Innovation can

34:48

happen in there

34:49

so if you are creating

34:51

an organization

34:54

and at the beginning

34:56

in a startup

34:58

everybody knows how to do everything

35:00

that's

35:02

by definition kind of a startup hub

35:07

people who can are journalists in the

35:10

sense that they can do all the

35:11

components in this small organization

35:13

but once you start growing and you need

35:16

to Outsource things and you need to hire

35:18

someone who is an experienced CEO or

35:21

something like that if you don't plan

35:23

for having some

35:26

chaos

35:28

at the edges

35:30

some peripheral bets

35:33

that could eventually grow into become

35:37

part of the central things that what you

35:39

do in the organization

35:41

because what

35:44

makes you good now in any in any

35:46

industry any organization is not what is

35:49

going to make you great 50 years from

35:52

now okay so you have to have

35:55

plans that allow for the emergence of

35:59

things

36:00

at the periphery not all of them will be

36:03

good bets that eventually you can bring

36:06

more

36:07

inside the organization in some

36:11

cases this has gone by the name skank

36:14

Works in some physical space that you

36:17

have to have that the normal tendency of

36:20

people

36:22

is to have everything kind of perfectly

36:25

lined up and for a while that will be

36:28

great

36:29

but eventually you'll pay the price for

36:32

that you need to live with some chaos at

36:35

the agents chaos at the edges so we have

36:38

a question uh from uh from Miss Allison

36:42

nabueri uh from from Senegal very

36:45

interesting question uh this is the

36:46

person you and I were discussing earlier

36:48

this this we started the call and the

36:50

question she's asking I think is an

36:52

intriguing One how can we nurture Nexus

36:55

thinking in children from infancy so you

36:58

talk about Nexus ticket at the

37:00

University I think her question is even

37:02

more interesting because now she's

37:03

saying how can we do it from infancy

37:05

given where the world is today the Next

37:08

Generation that's going to take over and

37:09

run the world how can we Infuse Nexus

37:12

thinking within them so that we can have

37:14

a world that is run by Nexus thinkers

37:16

that's a difficult question because the

37:19

truth is that

37:21

even in the most successful societies

37:26

the ones that have the lecture of

37:28

providing

37:29

the best education

37:32

in high schools

37:34

Preparing People to go to universities

37:38

I would say that most

37:40

children

37:42

everywhere

37:44

they are unaware that there are

37:47

differences

37:48

in thought between science technology

37:51

artists it's all one thing

37:54

and at some point

37:57

in middle school we start

38:00

kind of confining this a little bit more

38:04

and then

38:05

in the most advanced societies

38:08

we are preparing people to go to the

38:11

best universities and

38:14

maybe you had some inclinations about

38:16

theater but you are really good in math

38:21

so we're going to really make you great

38:23

enough and

38:26

you start

38:28

becoming

38:30

disconnected from the people who are

38:33

your friends doing some theater

38:35

and and the question is by the time that

38:39

you reach the University

38:41

how many people you have and this is

38:43

enough I can tell you this

38:45

based on demand that

38:48

the bifurcation has not been

38:51

complete they have not been lobotomized

38:55

okay they still have an inkling of

38:58

putting things together so but if you

39:01

are managing the educational system

39:04

in a country

39:07

you normally have lots and lots and lots

39:10

of constraints that this kind of rough

39:13

explanation doesn't take into account so

39:16

the idea would be maybe you can have

39:20

a trap for people that they're really

39:25

good at thinking deep in going deep in

39:28

some things okay let's say science math

39:33

but they still have

39:35

this

39:37

desire of

39:40

thinking more broadly they don't go just

39:44

deep down they have they can do the Deep

39:47

dive but they have this ability to

39:50

connect more horizontally do you think

39:53

do you think Julia there's a role for

39:55

parents because it could this be

39:58

something I mean if you take sub-Saharan

40:00

Africa for example or Argentina where

40:02

you grew up and your parents were very

40:04

instrumental in sort of giving you that

40:06

environment could it be something that

40:08

we probably see not just the educational

40:10

system but maybe Society more broadly

40:13

begin to embrace and celebrate more

40:17

public math people who are thinking more

40:19

broadly like yourself

40:21

I I think that the way that you are

40:24

being brought up

40:26

were not

40:28

your parents take you to concerts or

40:31

theater or I mean this is

40:34

I mean there are things that is very

40:37

hard

40:39

to catch up on demand I mean

40:42

um I'm sure you know people who have had

40:46

very successful careers in business

40:49

and they reach I know 65 they retire

40:55

and the whole life was based on

40:58

work

41:00

and suddenly you don't become

41:03

interesting literature because you have

41:05

free time you have to have had some

41:08

some of the building blocks there

41:12

uh in

41:14

and it has to be more than just an

41:17

ambition of

41:18

going and playing golf there are many

41:22

things

41:23

that

41:25

the world will offer that you can

41:28

appreciate that will enrich your mind

41:32

but you have to have had

41:34

the building blocks kind of place early

41:38

in your life

41:40

that would allow you to grow into those

41:43

things it's it's not like you can come

41:46

for a text for a test and suddenly

41:49

you'll become interesting philosophy or

41:52

or or or

41:54

art it has to be from the beginning

41:57

well do you before I ask the next

42:01

question I just want to read a comment

42:02

that was put in the chat from Peter

42:04

Cummings uh basically he's saying that

42:06

it's always wonderful to hear you every

42:09

time he hears you it's it's inspiring

42:11

basically you're a fantastic scientist

42:13

engineer an artist so when I call you an

42:16

artist here somebody who is basically uh

42:19

justify or validated my statement that

42:21

you're a fantastic artist so Peter is

42:23

going to jump off but he sends his

42:25

regards it and really uh didn't have a

42:27

question but just had a comment in terms

42:29

of saying that your work is fantastic uh

42:31

we have about three minutes uh seven

42:33

eight minutes left uh Julia I want to

42:35

hit three three three questions the

42:37

first one given the world and we should

42:39

live we live today it's a lot of

42:40

polarization

42:41

in different countries we have a lot of

42:43

issues from a political standpoint and

42:46

you talk about sort of a thinking about

42:49

how the other person uh sort of thinks

42:52

about things getting into their space

42:54

how can Nexus thinking help us address

42:57

some of the polarization we see going

43:00

around the world today

43:05

I have kind of comments from

43:08

I mean the one of the best comments that

43:11

you get

43:12

about the book if people will tell you I

43:15

mean these are people who have run

43:16

companies

43:18

wow I never thought

43:21

of thinking about myself in this way but

43:24

now that I see it in your book I am like

43:27

that okay that that will be at the top

43:30

top level okay

43:34

let's face it there are people who have

43:37

a lens to see the world

43:40

and that lens will never change

43:45

they probably Middle Ground there or

43:48

people who

43:49

I mean it's so easy to see the war with

43:52

a single lens

43:55

but what we want in here are people who

43:58

are willing to

44:01

discuss debate

44:05

sort of learn that

44:07

yeah there are people who have a lens

44:10

that a different than yours and maybe a

44:15

better solution can be achieved if you

44:19

try to see it through other

44:22

other people lenses so sometimes this is

44:26

obviously a metaphor that Library brain

44:30

lens that

44:32

I have seen in some cases that it helps

44:36

people framing ideas

44:40

because

44:42

this is obvious we all go through life

44:46

piling up information

44:48

and sometimes

44:51

we don't have time

44:53

a common problem in my view is

44:59

is living some space

45:02

in your brain

45:04

for ideas that do not exactly fit in the

45:07

mental library that you have

45:09

but leave it somewhere in there ask

45:13

to be filed in the future or maybe at

45:16

some point you discover

45:18

well this is not worth filing

45:21

but avoiding the problem of rapid fire

45:25

if if it fits you put it there

45:28

you become more of an accentuated

45:31

version of yourself

45:33

and he doesn't feed you this character

45:35

because what that does

45:41

the the lens that you have becomes

45:44

smaller and smaller and smaller and what

45:47

doesn't fit

45:48

just gets his character and I think

45:51

that's

45:53

the problem

45:54

people having one single Viewpoint I

45:57

mean it's so easy you see the world with

46:00

well that's okay

46:02

is everything is easy you just have a

46:05

single Viewpoint yeah what we're

46:07

advocating in here is

46:11

an expansion of that but more important

46:14

I think the most important thing is

46:19

not everybody can become a Nexus thinker

46:22

okay but the point is you can think of

46:25

Nexus teams

46:27

but for something to become a Nexus team

46:31

you need enough

46:33

number of people who can be Nexus

46:37

thinkers and connectors in such a way

46:40

that the team

46:42

produces the outcome that the team could

46:45

produce that would be impossible if all

46:48

of these people are disconnected there

46:50

are tons of examples that you can give

46:52

of the importance of these Nexus teams

46:55

and thinkers I I think as you were

46:58

talking uh you talk about in the book as

47:00

well and when you talk about left brain

47:02

right brain and I think what you're

47:04

saying is you need a you need a space in

47:07

your brain that is neither left nor

47:09

right but it's sort of that empty space

47:11

where you put sort of opposing views

47:14

that doesn't fit in the left or the

47:15

right but in the middle almost like you

47:17

need a you need to split your brain into

47:19

three parts not into two parts like

47:21

we've had yeah yeah you need you need a

47:25

for some things

47:27

rapid convergence is good for some

47:31

things rapid convergence is bad

47:34

so you what you want to avoid is rapid

47:38

bifurcation

47:41

you need to contemplate things more

47:44

before you we are right or left and and

47:49

sometimes having people within a team

47:53

that

47:55

can keep things together

47:58

I mean there are two extremes that are

48:01

bad one is

48:03

having lots of technical know-how

48:07

I'm framing a question

48:11

in such a way that you can solve it

48:14

but you discover that you framed the

48:16

wrong question

48:18

okay and there is no big price for

48:21

solving correctly what turns out to be

48:23

the wrong problem on the other hand

48:26

you cannot have a team that is always

48:31

producing new ideas

48:33

but never converges on anything

48:37

so you need both you need both

48:39

interesting both Divergence and

48:41

convergence so so uh just briefly let's

48:44

talk about energy electricity uh this is

48:48

the Edison Electric Institute we do a

48:49

lot of work around electricity and

48:51

energy but I bring this up because in

48:53

the book you talk about Thomas Edison

48:55

and and you talk about Edison and a

48:58

couple of other individuals in the book

48:59

who to some extent were not necessarily

49:04

Nexus thinkers per se but they were

49:07

polar math they were exploring different

49:09

ideas so talk about this idea of people

49:13

like Thomas Edison uh you know you talk

49:16

about Galileo you talk about all of

49:18

these folks who who to some extent were

49:22

I would call and see my Nexus thinkers

49:24

uh but but yet and still they had a big

49:27

impact on the world can you talk a

49:30

little bit about them and then also

49:31

before I forget electricity I'd love for

49:33

you to talk about James Watt and the

49:35

steam engine uh so let's talk Edison

49:37

first and then James I mean any son

49:40

I think there are two parts already son

49:42

it's just to be very very simplistic one

49:47

the obsessive

49:50

need to produce new things as an

49:53

individual

49:55

and never giving up but the the other

49:58

one is basically

50:00

this is not creating an organization

50:05

not one person

50:07

like Nicola tester Tesla an organization

50:11

that was

50:13

whole purpose was

50:16

of producing new Innovations so you have

50:20

the Innovations the person then the

50:22

organization okay in the case of Galileo

50:28

yeah he was an amazing

50:31

Steve Hawkins credits Galileo much more

50:35

than Newton have been about being the

50:37

inventor of

50:38

new physics but Galilei also had

50:44

an influence that had to do with how

50:48

well he could Market his ideas

50:51

he crossed the line

50:54

with the church

50:57

but he was able to

51:00

Market the ideas and also see

51:04

connections that other people didn't see

51:07

but I think the story of Galileo and the

51:11

optical tubes

51:13

and looking at the moon

51:15

and being supported by the whole

51:18

environment of Renaissance Padua or

51:20

Florence is one perfect idea of the

51:23

intersection of art technology and

51:25

science the case of what

51:28

is really interesting because I don't

51:31

know when I learned this

51:35

what of course

51:37

is credited with invention of the steam

51:39

engine and so on and so forth but

51:42

apparently no one knew

51:45

of his

51:47

secret attic that he had at home where

51:51

he was trying to basically

51:53

reproduce sculptures sort of

51:58

primitive versions of like 3D

52:01

reconstruction of options yeah at some

52:04

point

52:05

they discovered that he got that they

52:07

they move every object

52:10

and he was also looking at Crystals they

52:13

said all connected they move the whole

52:15

museum is moved to some place in London

52:18

I had to contact that museum to get some

52:21

images from them

52:22

but he had this sort of hidden

52:26

component probably would have been

52:28

better if that component would have been

52:30

more

52:31

visible

52:34

um I mean there's going to be always a

52:37

role

52:39

for the in-depth specialist

52:42

there's no question about it but at

52:46

given moments in time and in history

52:47

there are these people who are able to

52:50

transcend the domain

52:52

sometimes even before the domain is

52:55

named

52:56

that can provide this

52:59

connections and what I mean the most

53:03

important individuals of them all are

53:05

the ones that

53:07

is what I call break with not

53:10

breakthroughs because if it's something

53:13

really really important

53:16

that you come up with

53:18

sometimes what you have to do in order

53:21

to do this new thing

53:23

is abandoned most of the implicit thing

53:28

in an assumptions

53:29

associated with the prior domain and

53:33

that's what I call a break with

53:35

a break with is

53:39

and by the way incidentally this is one

53:42

of my main problems that I see about AI

53:45

generated anything

53:47

so let me give you one

53:49

sort of practical example let's say that

53:52

you're an architect

53:53

and in 1970 and you are designing a

53:58

skyscrapers and

54:01

I know

54:02

hotels with big atriums and so on and so

54:05

forth and you can store every

54:10

design and information about every prior

54:13

building that has been done up to 1970

54:17

and he said

54:19

go give me ideas

54:21

I don't think you'll ever come up with I

54:24

guess the name of this fellow was John

54:26

Portman

54:28

who decided to put the elevators outside

54:32

the building

54:34

or inside the atrium but making them

54:37

visible because that

54:40

broke

54:42

an assumption that no one no one said

54:46

well you cannot put the elevators

54:48

outside but implicit in every design

54:52

was that they were inside

54:55

so in the same way that you can store

54:58

all the history of physics prior to 1900

55:04

and never ever to be able to come up

55:07

with quantum mechanics because

55:09

could have thought that energy could be

55:11

discreet okay so the the ability to come

55:15

up with something that is a break with

55:19

I think an inherently human thing maybe

55:24

can be

55:25

at some point mobile or Incorporated but

55:28

in the way that things are now

55:31

in AI

55:33

is not there you cannot come up with

55:36

something new you recreate things from

55:39

the past

55:40

I I have learned something today from

55:42

you that I didn't know Julio is the

55:44

concept of break with Technologies

55:46

because a lot of people talk about

55:47

breakthrough Technologies and I think

55:49

what you're advocating here is very

55:51

interesting come up with break with

55:53

Technologies which means you need to

55:54

have break with ideas uh the last three

55:57

minutes we have I just want to reflect

55:59

on two things here uh one I like to get

56:02

your thoughts on the idea of

56:06

you know prediction and choicist to also

56:09

end of the book you talk about taking

56:12

the big picture stepping back and

56:14

understanding the difficulty with making

56:16

predictions and the choices you're going

56:18

to have to make when you face critical

56:20

decisions in your life

56:21

how critical is that in terms of using

56:24

Nexus thinking to manage making

56:26

prediction and also dealing with choices

56:29

yeah I don't know that if this comes

56:31

directly from Nexus thinking but let's

56:34

assert

56:36

that

56:38

predicting something

56:42

used to be completely connected with

56:45

understanding something

56:47

but now you can predict things

56:50

without understanding that

56:53

and again AI is at the root of all of

56:55

this

56:56

okay so you can you can predict things

57:00

and this is at the root on how AI makes

57:02

decisions and people want to open the

57:04

book You can predict things without

57:06

understanding them

57:09

I I would say that

57:12

again the choices

57:17

again is the issue of bifurcations in

57:19

here okay so one example that I give in

57:22

there which is not coming from physics

57:26

marketing been

57:30

possibly driven all by data

57:33

or all by intuition

57:36

okay and that's a choice that you have

57:38

to make on how you are going to balance

57:41

those two things

57:42

a company like Facebook is the one that

57:44

has probably the most amount of data of

57:46

any company in the planet

57:49

but in terms of marketing I think you'll

57:52

agree with me that they don't have the

57:54

marketing in the planet okay

57:57

whereas there are companies that

58:01

they will be perceived as being driven

58:05

by more artsy intuition I'm talking

58:08

about maybe Louis Vuitton okay they have

58:12

the the mark the the the data driven

58:15

part more hidden but it's a choice that

58:18

you have to make in between those two

58:21

balancing points and but I do not like

58:24

these answers part of what you are

58:26

hinting I think it gets a little bit to

58:29

what we were what I was trying to get at

58:31

uh we're coming to the top of the hour

58:33

uh again the book the Nexus the

58:36

convergence of art technology and

58:38

science uh by my friend you know

58:40

Professor otino uh you know Julie before

58:42

we end one last question so the book is

58:45

out and I always like when we talked to

58:47

authors on the influential minds they

58:49

all have a new project so so uh two last

58:53

quick questions one what is your next

58:56

project uh and then two uh a year from

59:00

now if I were to talk to you what would

59:02

you hope this book would have

59:03

accomplished in society

59:06

so regarding new projects I

59:10

I injected some ideas about Ai and art

59:12

because

59:14

some people have driven me in that

59:15

direction I have to comment on that

59:18

but again

59:22

too independent people

59:25

drove me to think and in fact I'm giving

59:27

a talk friday

59:29

about

59:31

Nexus and the metabolas hmm

59:35

so maybe in the future there will be

59:37

something

59:39

tangible about

59:41

connecting Nexus and the metaverse

59:43

because the Nexus in some senses about

59:46

augmentation of

59:49

spaces and thinking increasing our

59:52

ability to sense things

59:55

and the metaverse like to do that so

01:00:01

I would like to

01:00:05

people who have been

01:00:07

affected in their thinking especially

01:00:10

people in the positions of

01:00:13

decision making

01:00:15

and I share with you the notes from

01:00:18

someone comes from the world of music

01:00:21

and never expected someone from that

01:00:24

space to be so taken by the ideas

01:00:28

what another hopes is that you have

01:00:32

altered the way that

01:00:34

some people think

01:00:38

I want to see consequences of that

01:00:43

the book itself can Branch into so many

01:00:47

directions

01:00:49

sometimes because

01:00:51

people ask you one question and somehow

01:00:54

in trying to answer that question you

01:00:56

say wow I wish I could have said more

01:00:58

about that okay yeah well look the book

01:01:03

is fascinating and again I recommend

01:01:05

this book to a lot of people out there I

01:01:07

must say what makes this book easy to

01:01:09

read are the images and the pictures uh

01:01:13

if you have an eight-hour flight from

01:01:14

from Washington to Europe uh as I did on

01:01:18

uh last week you can actually finish the

01:01:20

book uh so if you plan on not sleeping

01:01:22

on a flight you should get a copy of

01:01:24

this book it will keep you captivated

01:01:26

and alive and awake throughout the fly

01:01:28

so Julia thank you so much for joining

01:01:30

us thank you again for the book

01:01:31

congratulations and I look forward to

01:01:33

meeting you in a not too distant future

01:01:35

thank you Lawrence I very much

01:01:37

appreciated the discussion thank you so

01:01:39

much thank you bye bye everybody bye

Next in the archive

Influential Minds: A Conversation with Julio M. Ottino — Influential Minds