Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Julio M. Ottino
Ask about this conversation
hello and welcome everyone to
influential Minds an eei international
conversation series my name is
and I'm a senior analyst for
international programs at eei
influential Minds is our virtual
conversation series which aims to
discuss ideas that move the needle
towards a more sustainable future with
thought leaders from across the globe
today eei International programs is
excited to welcome Julio otino an artist
researcher author and Dean of the
McCormick School of Engineering and
applied science at Northwestern
University
he joins us today to discuss his latest
book the Nexus augmented thinking for a
complex world the new convergence of art
technology and science where he will
dive into a new modes of thinking to
expand our creativity and augment our
Insight he will be joined in
conversation by our host eei vice
president of international programs Dr
Lawrence Jones throughout the session
please feel free to ask questions using
the chat feature Dr Jones will aim to
incorporate as many of them as possible
into the conversation without further
Ado I will turn this over to Lawrence to
get started
thank you alikia and good morning Julio
welcome to the eu's influential Minds
delighted to be with you let me first of
all congratulate you for the very very
well written book the Nexus augmented
thinking for a complex world uh we
indeed live in a complex world and I
think what you're trying to do in this
book is very fascinating in terms of the
convergence of art technology and
science but I think let's begin first of
all by talking about why you wrote This
Book
yeah
wow I think the
short answer
was the time have come to do it but
it had a long long Inception I mean I
had been
collecting materials for
a book like this for a long long time
and I saw
there were a few times
what I saw
things converted in such a way that gave
me
a glimpse that this was a good idea just
to give you one example I can give you
two or three that are very similar I was
a senior advisor for Unilever the
company Dutch Anglo company for
like 12 years
and when they
gave me the title of senior advisor they
said we want you to be a provocator we
want you to look at what we are doing
question what we're doing so I had
access to
the research technology also the
Knowledge Management that was discussed
I had access to the management science
research
and at one point
I convinced them that
we should do something in complexity we
should organize this imposing complexity
because
the thinking in complexity was going to
affect lots of the things that Unilever
was around from research to management
and
yeah we put something together we
invited
lots of people there was a senior editor
from nature I think there was a Nobel
prize from chemistry that got invited
but what I did not
know
is the venue that Unilever picked
to do the event
they got the Tate mother in London and
they got a room
they paid modern is enormous a Rome that
was overlooking the Millennium bridge
and the Globe Theater and at that moment
I could say
I could see the intersections between
art technology and science since then
I have had several ideas I did an event
for
Accenture where they actually rented all
the modern wing of the Art Institute in
Chicago
and I was the only talk it was a talk
for
the top 40 Partners people who are
managing either
sector or a country and again I I have
been doing this
and throughout all of these
since 2006 when I saw a show that Bruce
Mao had put in Chicago
that took over the entire uh
missionary Contemporary Art we had been
having coffees for 12 years
discussing ideas actually the central
idea that I was a customer would end up
being chapter four in the book The
comparisons between art technology and
science instructors
and then
the pandemic hit us
and I had time to assemble the notes put
them together
and that was when the time came to kind
of say yeah we will
do a book
I contacted MIT press and then I brought
Bruce again
and that's how that happened I mean it
was not
a southern thing it had been brewing for
yeah you would say the entire life my
entire life interesting well look it's
it's fascinating how you you talk about
the Nexus and and you bring our
technology and science together in a way
that I have not seen done before so so
talk a little bit about
this Divergence that has occurred now we
see today our technology and science are
almost seen as opposites they don't come
together but in the book you talk about
the Divergence just briefly when did our
technology and science diverge in
history and are we seeing a convergence
occurring today
yeah so the the convergence today is
that
now more than at any point in the past
artist and it's a very broad diverse
group okay
um I mean first of all artists now
even the ones who are
trained
in places like the Art Institute here in
the school of the artist in Chicago or
Yale
if they need to learn something they
will learn it I have seen that in
courses that we have done
with people from engineering if they
need to learn how to code they will
learn it okay so you could go back to
the point in which
our technology and science work together
and you can talk about Leon Batista
birthday and Alberti and Leonardo and so
the Renaissance there was no different
the word science had not been invented
art in Korean science they were all
together
eventually
the things started to separate when
people who are managing States
principalities
they saw the value that some things in
math
and pre-technology
were useful to that
ballistic trajectories
divert the course of rivers Leonardo was
doing a little bit of this okay
yeah DaVinci so but there were people
like Nicola tartaglia for example in
Italy who wrote a book on ballistics and
there was money that they were putting
on this pre-technology kind of thing
they were technology was invented
1900 kind of
and at that point
art and philosophy sort of started going
one way and Technology
supported a a lot by
military needs
started diverging and then then there
was another Divergence and it was like
in in many books especially math
figures started Vanishing from the books
in fact there was a famous book I
mentioned in in my own book by a fellow
named LaGrange yes who boasted that you
shall find no pictures in this book
because pictures were supposed to be
crutches that you use but then
the real argument was independent of it
you'll remove them so
that lasted for a long long while
but now I think it's an opportunity of
bringing things more together because
artists are more entrepreneurial than
ever before I mean they are
groups
that
are massively large now in art
in Modern Art
and they they will use whatever
technology is out there
to their needs I mean we can get into
long discussion about Ai and art now but
artists are more entrepreneurial so the
opportunity of connecting with them
is as good as it has ever been yeah so
so in the so the title of the book is
augmented thinking that's one of the
sort of top themes and talk about for
the audience who's listening
what do you mean by Nexus thinking and
and and how does one become a Nexus
thinker yeah so they they
we get educated and
we go through life
equipping
our brains with the library of knowledge
and the library that you acquire if you
become a scientist
has different volumes
not completely different but it's an
overlap that if you become an engineer
or you become a lawyer for example you
have a mental Library
and that mental library is the one that
when he's the one that provides you a
lens to see the world
and is what provides the first draft of
ideas that you may have to solve
problems in front of you
there is no question that to go to quote
line of spoiling here he said the best
way to have a good idea is to have lots
of ideas okay
lots of different ideas so if you have
a mental library that is let's say
coming from science
all your ideas will emerge I mean they
can be a very diverse set but they will
be there will be different than the
library that an artist will have looking
at this emission and the question is
could you
train yourself
to have an augmented
mental space that somehow incorporates
those two domains it doesn't mean that
if you're a scientist you become an
artist or vice versa but if you could
sort of make an effort to understand
how the other domains think
then
your brain will become expanded really
and metaphorically speaking and is it
has to do with
first avoiding misconceptions that one
side has about the other one people in
science
they tend to think I'm speaking kind of
stereotyping here that artists create
they do things when there are moments of
Inspirations there and artists will tend
to think that science is all rational
and logical and they don't see the
passions that drive people
so and moreover we tend to equate
the domains with the outputs that they
produce okay
an architect will equate it with the
final building or is or a sculpture with
biggest culture Anish Kapoor with things
that he has done for example and
scientists we equate them with whatever
product emerge a vaccine or something
but it's more important to understand
the process that led to those things
Kavita they thought how is that they
came up with ideas they discarded them
they modified them it's not like it's
always forward
you have setbacks how do you handle so I
think understanding how others think
I think the book I tried to make a case
and again we are speaking in general
terms here that technology by whatever
measure you pick
borrows a little bit from science
and a little bit from our heart because
both is not as codified as science and
is not as free as art
but it borrows elements of both and the
more you sort of try to understand
how others think the better it will be
so it's all about extracting the thought
process from the art World from the
technology World from the Science World
and bringing it together so well put
it's exactly that yeah so what most
people don't know Julia is that you are
a I would call it an acclaimed artist uh
you've done fabulous paintings you sent
me some of them I looked at them and it
was if I looked at the painting they
didn't know you were a professor I would
think you're an artist and when I read
the book I didn't see the painting I
would think you're a professor
talk about yourself your experience your
journeying into becoming a Nexus
thinking when did that trigger when did
you get that inspiration to say you know
what I'm going to practice what I preach
I myself are going to be a Nexus
thinking one day Nexus thinker when did
that happen in your life in
retrospective
I mean everything looks clear in
hindsight okay but
there were times in which I was able to
put the two things together for example
I wrote a monograph that is sort of made
my career in science in which is a lot
of math
but this picture this book needed
pictures
that need to be drawn
by hand and I drew almost every picture
in the book it's a Macbook Okay so
but
I was lucky I was my father was someone
who did
lab work he had a
elaboratory with microscopes
and he was very matching to histology
staining samples
so I grew up surrounded by something
like that and microscopes
and my mother was a classically trained
someone classically training art
she never really had an independent
career as an artist but I remember
looking at her work and all all the
things that she had done
and so I had those two things
but I grew up in Argentina and Argentina
was a little bit like many countries
maybe think of India where
doctor engineer I'm exaggerating it here
okay but it's not like you have 50
possibilities
you have broad drugs so at some point I
had to decide
uh I
I was painting
painting in some sense
helped me a lot
because growing up
Argentina had a compulsory military
service and only a few people very very
small number
if you finish a degree
like engineering medicine economics law
you could go through training and you
become an officer
and I did that two years in the Navy
but while I was there
there was one of these periodic
Revolutions in Argentina the government
was overthrown I was in the middle of
this
it was a very difficult time
people were banishing right and left
but I managed to have a solo show
at that point
and so my
instead of drifting to politics like
many people in the University my
all my sort of
whatever's cathartic sort of thinking
went into
art God and
immediately after finishing that
is when
we got married my wife had just finished
high school
and we came to the U.S and
I got in Mercy into my PhD
the Earth was always there I kept
painting but I was not connecting
directly into my work even though what I
did
in research
I was helped a lot by being really
visual I I started working on chaos
Theory
and having visual imagination
was
of incredible help on that that's why I
ended up drawing those pictures in the
book so so you always have it and in
retrospective you say
yeah it was clear at that moment that I
had all the elements but sometimes
putting it all together
like in this book as I said
I I was one of the ones who benefited
from the lockdown I was
cut I know five or six successive
weekends with nothing to do
uh well nothing to do it will be an
exercise I have my work yeah but but
I was traveling much less yeah so I was
able to give some structure to the ideas
and that's how the book emerged so it's
interesting so obviously your childhood
grown up in Argentina your your mother
your father had a big inspiration uh on
how your career immersed and your focus
on Art and technology and science for
that matter just before we get into some
of the complex issues facing the world
and how Nexus thinking can help uh for
those listening
how can they become Nexus thinker by the
way can anybody become a Nexus thinker
or do you have to have a certain set of
basic skills to go down that path or can
we all become Nexus thinkers
I think in some sense you can but you
have to have something that you have to
force yourself to
to train yourself
and
I think I can teach people how to be
creative I had I can
I can tell you what how is that you
should think
or some things that you should have kind
of
in front of your glasses that you
I think what we need the most is being
curious he's being curious is try to
understand
how people who do things do what they do
and it's not
essential that you learn
at some point for example I I heard a
talk recently from someone who I admire
about calculus okay and how calculus
mathematics made the world that we live
now
in order to admire cultures
you probably don't have to learn
calculus but know a little bit about how
is that the ideas
underlining
the main Concepts
came into being and got the implications
are so
if you are a someone in science or
technology I don't think that you need
to kind of
learned how to paint or sculpt
but having
some degree of awareness or connecting
with people
maybe new friends who do that kind of
thing
understanding what the drivers are
how do they pick
what they want to do because as an
artist
you could pick anything okay and
understanding that component is
essential and the same thing will go for
people in art if you want to connect
with someone who does
science
and you should try to kind of
get deeper into what drives them what
are the Ambitions that they have because
yeah from the outside
science could look at something that is
really cold
and sort of you have a methodology
people who know just a bit about science
will think about well is the scientific
method yeah no it's science
more than anything else is a habit about
problems to pick
you need intuition yeah okay that's how
you pick things
so you know I I want to get into you
know the other thing about the book
talks about living in a complex World
there are a lot of complex Global
challenges facing the world I just want
to spend a few minutes talking about
from your perspective
how can Nexus thinking be applied in
three environments one in business
uh and then in government because a lot
of the things affecting the world today
requires policy makers and government
leaders to make decisions uh and then
and then also on a personal level uh in
communities so let's talk a little bit
about from your view uh if a public if a
business leader is reading this book how
can they apply Nexus thinking in their
business in the same for policy maker or
politician and then also for a community
leader let's talk about that yeah so
find a book to those those three areas
yeah so
a let's start by
asserting that if you have
a mental space that is augmented because
components of science and art
in some instances what will happen is
that
the ideas that will emerge on how to
tackle something
will be
diametrically opposed they would be
in conflict with each other
and the consequence of this is that
you have to be mentally prepared
to resolve
conflicts is what I call complementarity
borrowing the term from quantum
mechanics the ability to resolve
D conflicts ideas that
you have to find a resolution
I think that there are so many problems
now more than ever that requires people
to
manage conflicting viewpoints so that's
one aspect the other aspect in my view
which is super important and it probably
the main idea coming from the complex
systems side
is that
I would say that the definition of a
leader or part of the definition of a
leader is
people who provide conditions for
successful emergence and by emergence
what I mean is the property of complex
systems that when there are many
interacting components
what happens as a result of those
interactions is much more than the sum
of the parts okay
um typical example but this is starting
probably with the most com complex of
them all will be you can study neurons
to death
but you'll never be able to capture
Consciousness
connect with each other for a minute a
much simpler example would be you can
study a fish to death
and never never imagine how
a whole collection of fish will assemble
into school that seems to function like
a giant organism moving in the same
thing with local part so
the ability to handle conflicts
and the ability of exploit emergence I
would say those are two Central things
that Business Leaders should capture out
of this and the fact that organization
an emergence
need not to be in conflict
I I think you need plans
but you also need to provide conditions
for those plans to give rise to more
what you are putting in the plan
that idea of emergence I like it because
if we look at some of the global
challenges facing let's say two of them
climate change and
supply chain issues facing the world
today it speaks to this interconnection
or interdependency of different systems
so from a policy making perspective as a
policy maker what do I need to do when I
think about designing public policy to
tackle say climate change so supply
chain or even some of the other
geopolitical issues we're facing in the
world today what can leaders learn from
this concept of emergence
I do not know if I can give you a list
of bullet points but
I think what
understanding complex systems
prepares you
is to be less surprised
when things happen for example
we live in a world that is much more
interconnected now than was
40 years ago I mean 40 years ago 50
years ago
the problems affecting even with the
pandemic China would have stayed
confining there but now
Transportation Supply chains of
different kinds make the problem more so
connectivity is good but there are
several hidden consequences of
connectivity I mean no one ever thought
I haven't researched this we're not at
the beginning of the internet
when people thought or they will be a
Brotherhood
everybody will connect with each other
will be it will be some good if
everybody
so
some of the consequences
of this connectedness okay so
some of the problems that we have seen
with Supply chains
is that
we
Focus so much on efficiency
and just in time Concepts
that fragility
increase
and at
if you had accounted for this
Black Swan events probably you have
sacrificed a little bit of efficiency in
terms of more robustness
but some of the things that we see now
of
consequences of
how the world is
all energies connected now and we can
see the consequences of in real time
what's going on in Ukraine affecting all
of us Supply chains of food energy
everything
uh I think you have to be prepared for
those things and accounted in your
thinking when you
create new structures if all the
structure is driven by
efficiency
in which
uh just in time delivery kind of makes
things great if everything goes great
but something happens
and you are in trouble
I think the thinking needs to be more on
accounting for those things more than in
the past
we live through years in which
everything was going great the world was
flat everything was going
uh but we are seeing now the
the consequences of having a much more
interconnected world than we had before
so if not like
there's a list of dos and don'ts that is
very very clear
but having
some
thinking that accounts for the
consequences of
how small changes can produce drastic
consequences
or how
you have to be prepared for
emergence
in some cases you want to produce that
in some case
you would like to prevent it for example
having people who have been I I have
said that in my work
within I mean this is a much smaller
system managing School the training in
complex systems was probably the best
training in anybody could have in
creating new things
let's talk about that training in
complex systems so so what you've said I
think is a very good lesson here is that
as you're planning whether it's in the
business environment in the government
environment in any sort of a
decision-making environment you should
always uh think about the the hidden
connections you should also keep
fragility in mind and assume that things
we may not always go as you plan so
let's talk about the skills you know let
me first say to the audience if you have
any questions please type it into the
chat box and we'll we'll try to take as
many as possible uh Julio let's talk
about you know the environment for
developing this sort of a Nexus thinking
in the book you you talk about different
environment you talk about the known as
Society you talk about Bell labs and you
talk about you know Black Mountain
College
how does one create an environment where
Nexus thinking can flourish can you talk
about that
well
the environment
universities are probably the best place
that you could experiment with these
kinds of things
because
yeah at the top of the organization you
have
people who have jobs and titles
that
do not easily transform into another one
you you you have someone with a chief
legal counsel you don't expect that that
person will become the chief marketing
officer
but below
at the level of individual groups
research groups
basically and this is what makes the
university different than other
organizations in other organizations
yeah the the jobs are the top are fixed
but so are the jobs
at the bottom okay the people who work
in the mail room they they can progress
but they will not morph into something
completely completely different but in a
university by definition
groups visual groups you are giving them
a license and I'm talking mostly about
science and technology engineering a
license to pursue whatever research they
want to pursue
subject to the constraint that you have
to raise the money to support that work
okay so and that's how Innovation can
happen in there
so if you are creating
an organization
and at the beginning
in a startup
everybody knows how to do everything
that's
by definition kind of a startup hub
people who can are journalists in the
sense that they can do all the
components in this small organization
but once you start growing and you need
to Outsource things and you need to hire
someone who is an experienced CEO or
something like that if you don't plan
for having some
chaos
at the edges
some peripheral bets
that could eventually grow into become
part of the central things that what you
do in the organization
because what
makes you good now in any in any
industry any organization is not what is
going to make you great 50 years from
now okay so you have to have
plans that allow for the emergence of
things
at the periphery not all of them will be
good bets that eventually you can bring
more
inside the organization in some
cases this has gone by the name skank
Works in some physical space that you
have to have that the normal tendency of
people
is to have everything kind of perfectly
lined up and for a while that will be
great
but eventually you'll pay the price for
that you need to live with some chaos at
the agents chaos at the edges so we have
a question uh from uh from Miss Allison
nabueri uh from from Senegal very
interesting question uh this is the
person you and I were discussing earlier
this this we started the call and the
question she's asking I think is an
intriguing One how can we nurture Nexus
thinking in children from infancy so you
talk about Nexus ticket at the
University I think her question is even
more interesting because now she's
saying how can we do it from infancy
given where the world is today the Next
Generation that's going to take over and
run the world how can we Infuse Nexus
thinking within them so that we can have
a world that is run by Nexus thinkers
that's a difficult question because the
truth is that
even in the most successful societies
the ones that have the lecture of
providing
the best education
in high schools
Preparing People to go to universities
I would say that most
children
everywhere
they are unaware that there are
differences
in thought between science technology
artists it's all one thing
and at some point
in middle school we start
kind of confining this a little bit more
and then
in the most advanced societies
we are preparing people to go to the
best universities and
maybe you had some inclinations about
theater but you are really good in math
so we're going to really make you great
enough and
you start
becoming
disconnected from the people who are
your friends doing some theater
and and the question is by the time that
you reach the University
how many people you have and this is
enough I can tell you this
based on demand that
the bifurcation has not been
complete they have not been lobotomized
okay they still have an inkling of
putting things together so but if you
are managing the educational system
in a country
you normally have lots and lots and lots
of constraints that this kind of rough
explanation doesn't take into account so
the idea would be maybe you can have
a trap for people that they're really
good at thinking deep in going deep in
some things okay let's say science math
but they still have
this
desire of
thinking more broadly they don't go just
deep down they have they can do the Deep
dive but they have this ability to
connect more horizontally do you think
do you think Julia there's a role for
parents because it could this be
something I mean if you take sub-Saharan
Africa for example or Argentina where
you grew up and your parents were very
instrumental in sort of giving you that
environment could it be something that
we probably see not just the educational
system but maybe Society more broadly
begin to embrace and celebrate more
public math people who are thinking more
broadly like yourself
I I think that the way that you are
being brought up
were not
your parents take you to concerts or
theater or I mean this is
I mean there are things that is very
hard
to catch up on demand I mean
um I'm sure you know people who have had
very successful careers in business
and they reach I know 65 they retire
and the whole life was based on
work
and suddenly you don't become
interesting literature because you have
free time you have to have had some
some of the building blocks there
uh in
and it has to be more than just an
ambition of
going and playing golf there are many
things
that
the world will offer that you can
appreciate that will enrich your mind
but you have to have had
the building blocks kind of place early
in your life
that would allow you to grow into those
things it's it's not like you can come
for a text for a test and suddenly
you'll become interesting philosophy or
or or or
art it has to be from the beginning
well do you before I ask the next
question I just want to read a comment
that was put in the chat from Peter
Cummings uh basically he's saying that
it's always wonderful to hear you every
time he hears you it's it's inspiring
basically you're a fantastic scientist
engineer an artist so when I call you an
artist here somebody who is basically uh
justify or validated my statement that
you're a fantastic artist so Peter is
going to jump off but he sends his
regards it and really uh didn't have a
question but just had a comment in terms
of saying that your work is fantastic uh
we have about three minutes uh seven
eight minutes left uh Julia I want to
hit three three three questions the
first one given the world and we should
live we live today it's a lot of
polarization
in different countries we have a lot of
issues from a political standpoint and
you talk about sort of a thinking about
how the other person uh sort of thinks
about things getting into their space
how can Nexus thinking help us address
some of the polarization we see going
around the world today
I have kind of comments from
I mean the one of the best comments that
you get
about the book if people will tell you I
mean these are people who have run
companies
wow I never thought
of thinking about myself in this way but
now that I see it in your book I am like
that okay that that will be at the top
top level okay
let's face it there are people who have
a lens to see the world
and that lens will never change
but
they probably Middle Ground there or
people who
I mean it's so easy to see the war with
a single lens
but what we want in here are people who
are willing to
discuss debate
sort of learn that
yeah there are people who have a lens
that a different than yours and maybe a
better solution can be achieved if you
try to see it through other
other people lenses so sometimes this is
obviously a metaphor that Library brain
lens that
I have seen in some cases that it helps
people framing ideas
because
this is obvious we all go through life
piling up information
and sometimes
we don't have time
a common problem in my view is
is living some space
in your brain
for ideas that do not exactly fit in the
mental library that you have
but leave it somewhere in there ask
to be filed in the future or maybe at
some point you discover
well this is not worth filing
but avoiding the problem of rapid fire
if if it fits you put it there
you become more of an accentuated
version of yourself
and he doesn't feed you this character
because what that does
is
the the lens that you have becomes
smaller and smaller and smaller and what
doesn't fit
just gets his character and I think
that's
the problem
people having one single Viewpoint I
mean it's so easy you see the world with
well that's okay
is everything is easy you just have a
single Viewpoint yeah what we're
advocating in here is
and
an expansion of that but more important
I think the most important thing is
not everybody can become a Nexus thinker
okay but the point is you can think of
Nexus teams
but for something to become a Nexus team
you need enough
number of people who can be Nexus
thinkers and connectors in such a way
that the team
produces the outcome that the team could
produce that would be impossible if all
of these people are disconnected there
are tons of examples that you can give
of the importance of these Nexus teams
and thinkers I I think as you were
talking uh you talk about in the book as
well and when you talk about left brain
right brain and I think what you're
saying is you need a you need a space in
your brain that is neither left nor
right but it's sort of that empty space
where you put sort of opposing views
that doesn't fit in the left or the
right but in the middle almost like you
need a you need to split your brain into
three parts not into two parts like
we've had yeah yeah you need you need a
for some things
rapid convergence is good for some
things rapid convergence is bad
so you what you want to avoid is rapid
bifurcation
um
you need to contemplate things more
before you we are right or left and and
sometimes having people within a team
that
can keep things together
I mean there are two extremes that are
bad one is
having lots of technical know-how
I'm framing a question
in such a way that you can solve it
but you discover that you framed the
wrong question
okay and there is no big price for
solving correctly what turns out to be
the wrong problem on the other hand
you cannot have a team that is always
producing new ideas
but never converges on anything
so you need both you need both
interesting both Divergence and
convergence so so uh just briefly let's
talk about energy electricity uh this is
the Edison Electric Institute we do a
lot of work around electricity and
energy but I bring this up because in
the book you talk about Thomas Edison
and and you talk about Edison and a
couple of other individuals in the book
who to some extent were not necessarily
Nexus thinkers per se but they were
polar math they were exploring different
ideas so talk about this idea of people
like Thomas Edison uh you know you talk
about Galileo you talk about all of
these folks who who to some extent were
I would call and see my Nexus thinkers
uh but but yet and still they had a big
impact on the world can you talk a
little bit about them and then also
before I forget electricity I'd love for
you to talk about James Watt and the
steam engine uh so let's talk Edison
first and then James I mean any son
I think there are two parts already son
it's just to be very very simplistic one
is
the obsessive
need to produce new things as an
individual
and never giving up but the the other
one is basically
this is not creating an organization
not one person
like Nicola tester Tesla an organization
that was
whole purpose was
of producing new Innovations so you have
the Innovations the person then the
organization okay in the case of Galileo
um
yeah he was an amazing
Steve Hawkins credits Galileo much more
than Newton have been about being the
inventor of
new physics but Galilei also had
an influence that had to do with how
well he could Market his ideas
he crossed the line
with the church
but he was able to
Market the ideas and also see
connections that other people didn't see
but I think the story of Galileo and the
optical tubes
and looking at the moon
and being supported by the whole
environment of Renaissance Padua or
Florence is one perfect idea of the
intersection of art technology and
science the case of what
is really interesting because I don't
know when I learned this
um
what of course
is credited with invention of the steam
engine and so on and so forth but
apparently no one knew
of his
secret attic that he had at home where
he was trying to basically
reproduce sculptures sort of
primitive versions of like 3D
reconstruction of options yeah at some
point
they discovered that he got that they
they move every object
and he was also looking at Crystals they
said all connected they move the whole
museum is moved to some place in London
I had to contact that museum to get some
images from them
but he had this sort of hidden
component probably would have been
better if that component would have been
more
visible
but
um I mean there's going to be always a
role
for the in-depth specialist
there's no question about it but at
given moments in time and in history
there are these people who are able to
transcend the domain
sometimes even before the domain is
named
that can provide this
connections and what I mean the most
important individuals of them all are
the ones that
is what I call break with not
breakthroughs because if it's something
really really important
that you come up with
sometimes what you have to do in order
to do this new thing
is abandoned most of the implicit thing
in an assumptions
associated with the prior domain and
that's what I call a break with
a break with is
and by the way incidentally this is one
of my main problems that I see about AI
generated anything
so let me give you one
sort of practical example let's say that
you're an architect
and in 1970 and you are designing a
skyscrapers and
I know
hotels with big atriums and so on and so
forth and you can store every
design and information about every prior
building that has been done up to 1970
and he said
go give me ideas
I don't think you'll ever come up with I
guess the name of this fellow was John
Portman
who decided to put the elevators outside
the building
or inside the atrium but making them
visible because that
broke
an assumption that no one no one said
well you cannot put the elevators
outside but implicit in every design
was that they were inside
so in the same way that you can store
all the history of physics prior to 1900
and never ever to be able to come up
with quantum mechanics because
could have thought that energy could be
discreet okay so the the ability to come
up with something that is a break with
I think an inherently human thing maybe
can be
at some point mobile or Incorporated but
in the way that things are now
in AI
is not there you cannot come up with
something new you recreate things from
the past
I I have learned something today from
you that I didn't know Julio is the
concept of break with Technologies
because a lot of people talk about
breakthrough Technologies and I think
what you're advocating here is very
interesting come up with break with
Technologies which means you need to
have break with ideas uh the last three
minutes we have I just want to reflect
on two things here uh one I like to get
your thoughts on the idea of
you know prediction and choicist to also
end of the book you talk about taking
the big picture stepping back and
understanding the difficulty with making
predictions and the choices you're going
to have to make when you face critical
decisions in your life
how critical is that in terms of using
Nexus thinking to manage making
prediction and also dealing with choices
yeah I don't know that if this comes
directly from Nexus thinking but let's
assert
that
predicting something
used to be completely connected with
understanding something
but now you can predict things
without understanding that
and again AI is at the root of all of
this
okay so you can you can predict things
and this is at the root on how AI makes
decisions and people want to open the
book You can predict things without
understanding them
but
I I would say that
again the choices
again is the issue of bifurcations in
here okay so one example that I give in
there which is not coming from physics
is
marketing been
possibly driven all by data
or all by intuition
okay and that's a choice that you have
to make on how you are going to balance
those two things
a company like Facebook is the one that
has probably the most amount of data of
any company in the planet
but in terms of marketing I think you'll
agree with me that they don't have the
marketing in the planet okay
whereas there are companies that
um
they will be perceived as being driven
by more artsy intuition I'm talking
about maybe Louis Vuitton okay they have
the the mark the the the data driven
part more hidden but it's a choice that
you have to make in between those two
balancing points and but I do not like
these answers part of what you are
hinting I think it gets a little bit to
what we were what I was trying to get at
uh we're coming to the top of the hour
uh again the book the Nexus the
convergence of art technology and
science uh by my friend you know
Professor otino uh you know Julie before
we end one last question so the book is
out and I always like when we talked to
authors on the influential minds they
all have a new project so so uh two last
quick questions one what is your next
project uh and then two uh a year from
now if I were to talk to you what would
you hope this book would have
accomplished in society
so regarding new projects I
I injected some ideas about Ai and art
because
some people have driven me in that
direction I have to comment on that
but again
too independent people
drove me to think and in fact I'm giving
a talk friday
about
Nexus and the metabolas hmm
so maybe in the future there will be
something
tangible about
connecting Nexus and the metaverse
because the Nexus in some senses about
augmentation of
spaces and thinking increasing our
ability to sense things
and the metaverse like to do that so
I would like to
see
people who have been
affected in their thinking especially
people in the positions of
decision making
and I share with you the notes from
someone comes from the world of music
and never expected someone from that
space to be so taken by the ideas
but
what another hopes is that you have
altered the way that
some people think
and
I want to see consequences of that
but
the book itself can Branch into so many
directions
sometimes because
people ask you one question and somehow
in trying to answer that question you
say wow I wish I could have said more
about that okay yeah well look the book
is fascinating and again I recommend
this book to a lot of people out there I
must say what makes this book easy to
read are the images and the pictures uh
if you have an eight-hour flight from
from Washington to Europe uh as I did on
uh last week you can actually finish the
book uh so if you plan on not sleeping
on a flight you should get a copy of
this book it will keep you captivated
and alive and awake throughout the fly
so Julia thank you so much for joining
us thank you again for the book
congratulations and I look forward to
meeting you in a not too distant future
thank you Lawrence I very much
appreciated the discussion thank you so
much thank you bye bye everybody bye
Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Episode 12Jesper Brodin
How IKEA links affordability, circular design and renewable energy with climate action, purpose-led leadership and sustainable growth.
Episode 07Sebastian Mallaby
How venture capital, risk-taking and connected networks turn bold ideas into startups and spread entrepreneurial culture.