Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Sebastian Mallaby
Ask about this conversation
hello and welcome everyone to today's
influential Minds an eei international
conversation series my name is
senior analyst for international
programs influential minds are is our
virtual conversation series which aims
to discuss ideas that move the needle
towards a more sustainable future with
thought leaders from across the globe
today eei International programs is
excited to welcome Sebastian Malibu
senior fellow for international
economics at the Council on Foreign
Relations he joins us today to discuss
his latest book The Power law venture
capital and the making of the new future
to help us navigate the world of venture
capital and discuss its role in the
energy transition he will be joined in
conversation by our host eei vice
president for international programs Dr
Lawrence Jones throughout the session
please feel free to ask questions using
the chat feature Dr Jones will aim to
incorporate as many of them as possible
into the conversation without further
Ado I will turn this over to Lawrence to
get started
thank you Alicia and good good afternoon
Sebastian I was going to say good
morning but you're in London so good
afternoon for you
thank you
well afternoon to you as well it is it
is well Sebastian let me first of all
again welcome you to influential Minds
this is the first in our series for the
fall so uh no pressure on the
conversation we're going to have today
let me Begin by saying congratulations
to you on the book uh they said to you
before we started you've kept my head
scratching the entire couple of weeks
since I've been reading this book
because it's very well written and
really captures a lot of things I think
we want to talk about today given where
the world is
but before we do that you know I want to
go back and just ask you to tell us a
little bit about Sebastian you've
written multiple books you wrote a book
on off that apartheid you wrote a book
more money to God about hedge funds uh
you wrote a book about Alan Greenspan
you wrote a book about the world's
bankers and now you have this book out
on the power law
writing all of those books which all
seem to be very different what have been
some of the common themes you've come
across because they all seem to have
some correlation that they're written by
a guy who's an economist so what are
some of the key themes youth chapter
haven't written all those books
well I guess you know there is an
evolution there in the themes and I
suppose it tracks my professional
interests I was a young reporter working
for The Economist magazine as the Africa
correspondent uh back in 1989 1990 and I
was fortunate to be outside Nelson
Mandela's Jail uh when he walked out in
February 1990 and
um I realized two things instantly one
was this was the most exciting moment I
could possibly experience as a
journalist I thought my career would be
downhill
uh thereafter even though I was only 25
because because nothing could match the
moment of Mandela's Freedom uh I also
realized rather more opportunistically
that um all the other books about South
Africa were magically and instantly out
of date so I wrote this book about South
Africa after apartheid
um and that was in my 20s
um and then a period went by without me
writing a book but when I wrote the next
one it was also sort of about Africa
because it was about the World Bank and
the world bank's involvement in
developing countries and it looked at
that question through the period when
Jim Wilkinson was the president of the
World Bank from 1995 to 2005 and it kind
of told a story about the efforts of the
rich world to be sort of constructively
engaged in development in Asia Africa
Latin America and so on and so there was
a book about globalization and the
finance behind globalization
and then I move more into pure Finance I
wrote this book about hedge funds
um more money than God which came out in
2010
so that's a story about public market
investing then I did a book about
central banks the biography of Alan
Greenspan
um so that's not hedge funds that's
that's the central bank but of course
they interact the central bank is often
fighting against the hedge funds and the
hedge funds are trying to destroy some
currency Peg and the central banks
trying to defend it so in a way that was
the other side of the same
um narrative and now this new book
um is another jump
um into the world of venture capital a
very different kind of financial
specialty where it's not about investing
in stocks and bonds or about being a
central Banker it's about startup
companies uh you know which begin from
nothing with a technology idea and the
first question is how do you even think
about investing in them right because
there's no you know the other investing
you've got the price earnings ratio well
I mean there's no earnings when
two entrepreneurs walk into your office
with a dream and you're the venture
capitalist and you're deciding if you
should back them so it's a very
specialized kind of Finance I think it's
a kind of Finance with a lot of impact
on the world because it's behind all the
big Innovations
um and so that's my most recent
Adventure
well the title of the book The Power law
uh venture capital and and the making of
the new future so so as a as a scientist
or well
used to be scientists because I don't
know a lot of research these days but in
in physics there are a lot of power laws
you know law you know gravitational
forces Newton's law you know you got
Stefan boseman's law you have laws on
the decay of heat a lot of these
physical laws we learn in physics have
some sort of a power law Dimension to it
even though they're deterministic and
then you have the sort of a statistical
power laws that really is not an input
output kind of thing right so talk about
power law in the context of venture
capital what is it describe it for the
audience uh so they can understand what
do you mean by power law in the context
of venture capital that's a that's a
great question
um the easiest way to to communicate the
idea is I think to start with what the
power law isn't in statistics I mean in
statistics you have this familiar normal
distribution which is the other kind of
distribution
um and that's the one with the bell
curve where the average
um the mean is the same as the median
and then around that median Point
um most of the observations in a in a
data set will cluster pretty close to
that average and so you get this big fat
Bell in the middle and then the you know
it tapers off into these thin Tails uh
at at the left side on the right side
um and so if you think about you know
the height of men in America
the average man is five foot ten
um the the modal man is five foot ten
and two-thirds of all the men clustered
between five foot seven and six foot one
so pretty close to that uh to that
average and you know there are some
outliers there are six foot seven NBA
stars or six foot ten NBA stars or
whatever they are but even they are only
really 20 away from the average it's not
a big difference so if you had a movie
theater right with a hundred men sitting
there watching the movie and the NBA
star at the back gets bored and he walks
out halfway through the movie the height
of the kind of average residual man in
the movie theater isn't going to shift
very much only a tiny bit because that
one
big guy who walks out is only 20 bigger
than the average now now flip the flip
the example right we're not talking any
more about the average height of
American men but the average wealth of
American men and the distribution of the
wealth and we've got the same movie
theater and there's 100 men there but
the person at the back is Jeff Bezos
right and he gets bored he walks out of
the movie the residual American man the
average in the movie theater of the
other 99
the average wealth is going to plummet
not just go down a tiny bit plummet
because in a parallel distribution which
is what the wealth of American men
observes
um you know you've got Jeff Bezos who's
got multiples more uh not 20 more but
you know 20 or 2 000 times more than the
average right and so there are some of
these distributions where you know some
people call it the 80 20 rule uh where
you know 20 of the cities have 80 of the
people or 20 of the flowers in the
garden the flower plants in the garden
generate 80 of the of of the flowers and
that's what it is like in Venture
Capital
um a small minority of the Investments
That a venture capitalist does
um will generate the Lion's Share of the
return so if you have a veggie
capitalist who makes 10 Investments
um maybe seven or eight will lose money
because startups are really difficult to
do and new technologies sometimes fail
and so you don't get your money back but
the hope is for the investor that one or
two will do more than 10x
the sum that you invest so a return of a
thousand percent or better than that and
so it's a power law distribution and
that's completely unlike what a hedge
fund investor faces in the stock market
or the bond market
and that really differentiates uh
venture capital and it also
um I mean I'll shut up in a minute here
but just let me add one one point which
is that when you have a parallel
distribution you have to think
differently
you have to be willing to take these
High uh High you know High outcome but
low probability bets the real long shots
and you've you've got to be shooting for
that right hand tail of the distribution
uh where you're making more than 10x and
that's what it's all about it's no good
trying to be cautious in place bets that
probably will pay off but in a more
modest fashion
so in the book one of the things that
fascinated me are the stories you have a
lot of stories in the book I mean for
for someone who haven't read the book I
must tell you if you love history if you
love storytelling this is the perfect
book to read Because almost every every
page comes into a story about something
that had to do with the evolution of
venture capitalism and so talk to the
audience a little bit about how you were
able to get access to all of these
people I mean you're you're talking
about the who's who in Venture
capitalism today and you're able to get
behind the scenes and narrate all of
these exchanges with these folks for for
several decades of of History how did
you do it how did you get access and how
do you go about doing this research
well the short answer is time I'm I take
a long time over these books like five
years and most of that time is because
it does take a while to persuade people
to sit down and open up and talk to me
not just for an hour or so but maybe for
four or five hours uh you know I go back
two or three times to see them and we
have long in-depth conversations and
they follow up with emails and maybe we
have another phone call at the end and
it's a big commitment for people who are
very busy and they don't necessarily
like talking about their investment
sequence and they don't particularly
like the media so it is a challenge to
get the access but once you've got the
access that's what makes my books
different because I really have
um sat down with with the you know the
the All-Stars
um and I'm in a position to explain how
they do their Investments I mean the
secret is partly time and taking the
effort to really lay out you know what
I'm doing and and and but it's also it's
time in the sense that often I'm going
at the beginning of the project you know
I I I I know somebody who
um has liked my previous books and who
has five friends in Silicon Valley so I
say please can you introduce me to those
five friends and I don't care who it is
I just go see them and before I see them
I read everything about them and I learn
everything I can and I go in super
informed and super prepared in order to
communicate the message that when people
speak to me I'm grateful for that time
that they are allotting and I really do
my homework and then that wins them over
and then they say at the end wow you
really do your homework who can I
introduce you to and then they pass me
on to five more people
and then my network starts to build but
it takes time and it takes you know a
couple of years before I really I've
seen the people who know the people who
know the other people who really know
the people
bit by bit I Network my way into the
into the sort of middle circle
it's also about building trust right
building because you're getting some
very very intriguing pieces of
information so it's all about building
trust with the with your interview
candidates so to speak so let's let's
get into some of the interesting stories
uh first of all talk about the Rebels
the eight Rebels who I would say
transform Silicon Valley who are these
eight individuals and tell us a little
bit about their story and how they
basically are the ones who got us
Venture capitalists more or less yeah so
this is a an interesting story for many
reasons but
um there was this um renowned scientist
um called William Shockley who won a
Nobel Prize for his contribution to the
invention of the semiconductor
um and he had been at Bell Labs he'd
moved to the West Coast uh so from the
east coast to West Coast you'd set up a
company called Shockley semiconductor
and because he was this renowned
physicist with a Nobel Prize he could
pretty much call any PhD in the country
and say will you come and work for me
and and they would say sure and they
would come because they were honored to
get that phone call it was like picking
up the phone and receiving a call from
God uh as one of them uh said later so
they came and worked for Shockley and
then as soon as they got there uh to the
West Coast they realized that Shockley
might be a genius but he was also a very
difficult guy I mean he would humiliate
you he would make fun of you you know
um one person came to work for him and
then he just laughed when the guy showed
up and said ha you settled for a really
low salary it shows you have no idea how
to negotiate and then another person
said that he would like to maybe do some
research and you know publish an
academic paper and so Shockley said yeah
I'm not sure you're you're really up to
it but I'll give you an idea and he
scribbled an idea down on a piece of
paper and said here you can write this
up and publish this
um so he was he was very annoying to
work for and it became insufferable and
so eight of these young
um you know brilliant young researchers
uh kind of banded together and they
wanted to go join a different company
um and they didn't know quite how to do
this but they asked one of them had a
father who had some money and was
connected to a Wall Street
um financier so they wrote to to this
financiers company and said do you know
anybody who would like to hire eight
physicists who would like to work on
semiconductors as a team and the letter
got passed around and it was given to a
guy called Arthur Rock who was a young
wall Streeter and he flew out to the
West Coast and met with these eight uh
physicists and said Gee you know it's a
great idea to leave Mr Sharpie but why
don't you start your own company that
way you won't have another bad boss you
can work for yourselves and if you
invent something fantastic and you
really do well you will share in the
financial fruits of your own Brilliance
and so this was a new idea and they
didn't you know at first the the eight
physicists were scared of that Prospect
and rock said you know don't worry I've
got the money to help you and they said
but we don't know how to form a company
and rock said well I'll help you to do
that uh and they and he basically he
took them into it and said you know I
will I will hold your hand about the
business side of this you guys know the
the physics side and we'll be a team uh
and and we'll do this together and
that's how Venture Capital began on the
west coast they were called the the
eight traitors because back in 1957 when
all this happened it was highly unusual
uh to quit a company you know this was
the era of big companies and Big labor
and big government and the classic book
of the period was called uh organization
man because everything was a bit
bureaucratic and people joined these
organizations and worked there until
they retired on their 60th birthday with
a gold watch but this moment of the
eight traitors kind of opened up a new
way of
um of doing companies and and that was
the birth of West Coast startups well
we'll come back to Mr Rock because he's
figured throughout the book in different
places but you mentioned West Coast so
let's talk about the west coast East
Coast library right so you have Boston
with MIT you have Silicon Valley which
Stanford
what made the difference why did Silicon
Valley win so to speak in Boston or the
East Coast
why did they lose it's more or less this
is this is a huge and fascinating debate
you know when I began my research
sometimes people were telling me you
know well Silicon Valley is really
Stanford Valley uh Stanford is where all
the ideas come from and then people spin
out and they do these great companies
and it's all about Stanford being
excellent
and I kind of nodded my head and then
when I actually did some reading and
research I realized that at the time
when Silicon Valley really took off back
in the 60s the 70s and even the early
80s MIT was by far and away a better
Engineering University than Stanford and
that's not true anymore today Stanford's
probably slightly ahead but uh back back
in the early period that was absolutely
not the case and if you want to throw
um you know Berkeley into the mix as the
explanation for why Silicon Valley did
well you know I can throw Harvard into
the mix for the Boston ecosystem and so
I don't think it was because of academic
excellence and there are places like
Carnegie Mellon which were wonderful
engineering universities but never
really had a tech startup scene so I
don't think it's about the Academia
rather it's it's actually about the
business culture there was this
go-getting business culture on the west
coast and I really do think that was
because of the Venture Capital The
Venture capitalists
were willing to underwrite the extreme
risk on the west coast whereas on the
East Coast there were some Venture
capitalists but they were more cautious
they wanted to back a company only when
it already had a product maybe had a
customer
certainly had you know a business
founder as well as a technical founder
um whereas on the on the west coast you
could have a single person who had a
brilliant idea for the daisy wheel
printer or something had no idea how to
do the business side the sales side and
the VCS would say no problem you know
we'll come to us we'll back you we'll
find you a partner to do the business
side
um and we'll be there with you all the
way as you recruit great commercial
people sales people
um and so they would back the company at
a much earlier stage take much more risk
be willing to see a bunch of their
companies fail that was the power law
mentality I was talking about before and
so I really think the business sculpture
of the West Coast distinguished it and
allowed it to overtake the ecosystem in
Boston and it was because of the venture
capital
so interesting so so in the in the book
though Sebastian you you talk about many
different interesting individuals that
will spend two weeks going through and
we did all of them on this call but this
there one there's another one I want to
talk besides autobrock let's talk about
both Matt clef and I like Bob matka
because obviously his his theory or his
law math class law is one that I believe
in that you know the more things you
connect to a network the value increases
by the square so just talk about Matlab
why is he such an intriguing figure in
the context of venture capitalism
well partly because he actually was an
MIT graduate
[Music]
um and he came out of MIT he moved to
the West Coast and he was spent some
time
um at uh Xerox Park which was you know
the research subsidiary of of
um Xerox
and he got very frustrated at Xerox park
because of this thing the innovator's
Dilemma you know where lots of good
invention can happen inside a big
Corporation but if it's going to
threaten the core product of the parent
company
probably those Innovations will not be
commercialized and Bob Metcalf himself
invented ethernet and that technology
for you know hooking up your computer
with your printer with
um your disk drive with other people in
your local area network it's been a bit
superseded now that we all have you know
Wireless connectivity
um but back in the day ethernet was a
core invention that allowed networking
to happen
um and basically you know Xerox plays
around with it a bit but was not really
going to commercialize it and so
um Bob Metcalf got frustrated he set up
his own company 3com to commercialize
his own invention
and because he was you know originally
from MIT and he kind of preferred the
east coast and he thought West Coast VCS
were too pushy and arrogant he said
right I'm not going to raise venture
capital from these arrogant Services uh
in in California and I will go raise
from from the nice genteel you know
sensible people uh in Boston so he went
off to Boston he found somebody who
would back his company 3com and before
he signed the deal
he discovered what he called later the
oh by the way syndrome as in oh by the
way we just thought of one more
condition that you need to meet before
we sign this deal with you and the first
thing was oh by the way we need you to
find another investor to share the risk
with us because the Boston VCS were not
all that risk hungry and so Bob metcar
scrabbles around he goes and finds
another VC in New York and the New York
VC says that you know he's happy to
invest as well and Metcalf goes back
triumphantly to the Boston guy and said
okay I've got another investor
and the the Boston guy says oh by the
way I really meant a California investor
and so Metcalf scrabbles around and
finds their California investor who's
willing to put some money in and then
it's oh by the way we really meant a
California investor who put a lot of
money in
and so Metcalf scrabbles around and
finds somebody and then you know it just
goes on like this and there are all
these conditions and eventually Metcalf
realizes that he spent so much time
trying to raise funds that he's actually
run out of the little money he had to
get started by himself and you know for
an entrepreneur time is money it's the
time is the most valuable resource and
so he ended up just getting completely
fed up and going to the to the West
Coast Venture capitalists doing a deal
with them in inside of 24 hours and
um saying to them look I've got one
condition which is that Boston VC it was
Fidelity Ventures
um that promised me money we're not
going to take any money from them at all
I'm just so sick of them and then he
called up the Fidelity Ventures and said
you're right I don't need you get lost
and they said but we were the only ones
who were willing to back you and nobody
else would and Metcalf said you were the
only ones who lied to me where nobody
else would and so to me this is a story
about how you know the West Coast
Venture capitalists were far more risk
friendly and far more fast to provide
capital and that explains why in the
1980s when Recon got started it really
was a case of you know the West Coast
overtaking the East Coast not because
the science was better but because the
business culture was more go-getting
interesting I want to I want to stay on
the issue of business culture because I
think fundamentally the way the world is
today we're going through a lot of
changes there's a lot of discussions
about you know the need for capital
investment in the clean tech space and
and when we look back and try to
understand some of the successes in
Silicon Valley one of the things you
talk about in the book is weak ties and
you get into this whole discussion
around uh porous boundaries that existed
between the companies in the east coast
I mean the West Coast Visa be the East
Coast how important is it for clean tech
that we have more porous boundaries
between startup companies for us to
accelerate the development of pain
technology can you talk a little bit
about that
sure I mean maybe I'll talk a bit about
the importance of loose ties in general
for Tech and then we can move on to the
clean tech specifically but my point
really is that
um you can have two ecosystems uh and
they might have the same number of
talented people in them
but one will be more productive than the
other and this is a bit of a mystery in
economics you know economics has various
things to say about clusters
and why clusters of talented people are
productive
but it doesn't really tell you why one
cluster of the same size would be better
than the other one
and so I was kind of scratching my head
about this and eventually I found the
answer or the best answer I could find
it was in sociology not in economics and
it was basically about how you know if
you have a lot of
um sort of connective tissue within one
cluster where if you imagine a sort of a
diagram of the cluster with all the
nodes representing different talented
people and then there are lines between
the nodes and if the nodes are more
connected
um it means that they're kind of sharing
ideas and and insights and sort of
theories and and hypotheses together
more uh and so just like in the brain if
the neurons are more connected up you'll
be more creative intellectually it's the
same thing with clusters if they're more
connected up you know the ideas and the
money and the people will flow around
the ecosystem more dynamically and and
result in more experiments
and a sociologists from Berkeley called
Emily saxonian had pointed all this out
in a book in the 1990s and I think what
I contributed was to say
why are these uh connections so fertile
on the west coast it's not just because
you have startups that have sort of low
boundaries between the startup and the
other startups it's also because the
Venture capitalists are people who are
financially incentivized right to get up
in the morning and have breakfast with
one person who might be an entrepreneur
or somebody that an entrepreneurial
company might want to hire whatever and
after that breakfast to have 17 cups of
coffee you know hopefully decaffeinated
before they go to bed with other
entrepreneurs other potential financiers
you know
10 people who might be good candidates
to be hired by the companies that the VC
back last month you know it's all about
connecting people that's what Venture
capitalists do and so this
interconnectedness of the West Coast
meant for made for a more creative
experimental ecosystem than the vertical
hierarchies of the East Coast where
somebody would join a big company like
deck or Wang and and basically stay
within that company and and circulate
only within that company so that would
give you strong deep ties but not lots
of looser weak ties and as you say
Lawrence it's the weak ties that are
more fertile interesting so so let's
let's talk about we're going to pick one
of them but for those who haven't read
the book
Paulo Yahoo Apple Cisco Google Amazon
Facebook all of them benefited from
Venture capitalism correct let's talk
about Apple because I think the Apple
Store is very interesting in terms of
who decided to fund apple or who didn't
fund Apple in terms of placing bets so
just talk a little bit about that whole
Apple story and what happened and where
things stand today right so we have to
go back to the 1970s of course when
Apple got started uh and remember that
Steve Jobs at the time
um was not the you know absolute sort of
um Kingpin of you know the kind of
embodiment of West Coast creative
entrepreneurial genius which is what he
became later
at the time he was this extremely
scruffy College Dropout
um who went around with bare feet he was
said to you know wash his feet
occasionally in the toilet uh to eat a
fruitarian diet you know just generally
look as if he'd you know been in some
sort of you know as one venture
capitalist told me he'd just been off to
see his Guru in India I think that was
actually literally true he had just been
off to see some gurus in India the early
event he didn't you know from a 1970s
perspective he didn't look like the kind
of engineer that you would want to back
right in fact he wasn't even an engineer
he had this friend Stephen Wozniak who
was a real engineer but who was kind of
tongue-tied and shy and so there were
these two Steves and most of the people
who who met them in the early days
thought no way am I going to invest in
these characters I mean who are they
right
um and so Steve Jobs went to try to
raise money from a bunch of different
people and each of them would do this
networking weak ties kind of thing where
they would say yeah gee I'm sorry I I
don't want to invest right now but you
know if if you want to really do this
company I could introduce you to a
couple of people uh and then they would
make a couple of introductions and Steve
Jobs would meet with another couple of
people and he would be passed around
um the the Silicon Valley ecosystem In
This Very networky strength of weak ties
kind of way and eventually he meets this
guy called Mike marcolo who's not really
a VC but who is a an exited entrepreneur
who retired young having made a bunch of
money uh by being a senior salesperson
at a couple of different semiconductor
companies and Mike Marcola you know gets
out you know he's made some money so
he's got this kind of rather gaudy I
think it was a gold colored Corvette and
he drives up to this garage where Steve
Jobs and Steve Wesner go hanging out and
he gets that he's got a sort of big
flashy Lounge suit and he walks in and
there are these scruffy slightly sort of
smelly young characters
but he gets past them and he looks at
the circuit board that Steve Wozniak is
building for the Apple computer
and because Mike marklin knows about
circuit boards he's an engineer himself
he ignores the Steves and looks at the
second board and says gee this is one
elegant circuit board
and so finally uh through a process of
like introduction after introduction
after introduction the Steve's get lucky
and the character with a flashy Lounge
suit is the one who connects with them
because he doesn't actually look at them
he looks at the engineering and the
wiring
um and so so may Marcola is so enthused
by the circuit board that he says okay
I'm going to make an investment I'm
going to help you out I'm an engineer
I'm going to work with you pretty
Hands-On and you have no idea what
you're doing in terms of building a
company but I will help you out and all
of a sudden Mike Machina States starts
connecting with you know Venture
capitalists and with other people like
the famous Silicon Valley
publicity guy back in the day Regis
McKenna who was the person who would
design your logo and get you some
publicity get you on the cover of a
magazine and and you know Regis McKenna
had said no way would he work with this
guy with no shoes but when Mike Michael
asked him you know then he was part of
the network and sure of course he would
do it you know and so it was that kind
of thing and that's how
um Steve Jobs eventually went from this
Silicon Valley you know Renegade uh to
being part of the magic circle that
raised money and that you know got
advertising was on the cover of
magazines and that you know managed to
build Apple so if when you look at all
of these companies the big ones who were
able to benefit from Power law right
we've mentioned some of them before you
can add to the list Uber and and uh and
uh
uh Tesla and a few others right right
and if you were to talk to a young
venture capitalist today there's a
question in the audience in the chat
about uh what advice would you give
right so based on all these companies
you've looked at all these stories what
are three things you would tell a young
VC who's getting a clean tech space for
example one of three things they should
be thinking about uh in in terms of
wanting to seek funding to promote that
idea
ah so are you talking about
um somebody wants to get into the uh
entrepreneurial side or the funding side
no someone's someone who wants the money
someone someone wants to money right so
so in the book you talk about Network
you talk about weak ties you know there
are a lot of different
different stories in fact each of these
companies went down their own Journey
they had their own iterative mistakes or
successes but if you were to identify
three things Sebastian that seemed to be
common for all of these organizations
who were looking for money what would
those three things be
sure so the first thing you need for a
startup in this in this technical space
is you need a technical idea
um so you need to have a convincing
story about a a technology that doesn't
exist yet but that if it were to be
built
um really would address a need
um that there would be product Market
fit
um and uh that's the first that's really
the first thing and it's got to be a big
market now that's the second thing is is
the commercial side
that if you built this thing Not only
would it be needed but it would be
needed in quite large quantities such
that you could sell a lot of it
um and you know talk about revenues that
would quickly run into the millions and
then the tens and millions and then the
hundreds of millions because remember
the power law you know the power law
means that most startups fail most ideas
for new technologies fail that's the
unfortunate brutal logic and so every
single one that gets backing needs to
have a chance of being a 10x plus
outcome that you know if it raises let's
say
25 million dollars of investment capital
is going to be worth more than 250
dollars 50 250 million dollars uh within
five or six years that unless you can
plausibly tell that story you're not
going to get funding so number one is
that you've got this technology that
you've understood that you know how to
build it number two is it's going to be
a big enough market and then number
three is be resilient don't give up if
you think you've got those first two
things
don't be discouraged when the first 10
people tell you you're crazy they're not
going to fund you that you know you only
need one or two people to believe in you
and then it will turn out that the 50
who did not believe in you just don't
matter hmm interesting interesting so
you mentioned failure right one succeeds
nine failed
how do we get our culture to embrace
failure because in one of your
conversations I listen to you talk about
how failure should be valuable how
should we value failure because I think
we don't how do we do that
well again
um you know when I think you're right
first of all it is a
um sort of counter instinctive thing for
human beings to be okay about failure I
mean behavioral economists tell us that
we have uh loss aversion we don't like
to fail we don't like to lose what we've
got
um we will take far more put far more
effort and take more risk to sort of you
know preserve what we have
um then you know then to shoot for the
upside right
so most people don't want to be
entrepreneurs because they don't want to
fail they'd rather do something safer
and most investors actually don't want
to back entrepreneurs because they're
scared of the failure too so as a
culture to have entrepreneurship and to
have Venture Capital we have to overcome
that instinct I think the good news is
that Venture Capital has now you know
since those early days that we just
talked about with the traitor say back
in the 50s and in the 60s you know the
world has come a long way and there is
this karda
of venture capitalists who have
understood that failure should be okay
and they're willing to underwrite firms
startups that very well might fail
um so I think the way to overcome the
sphere of failure is to have plenty of
venture capital
um and that's what turns failure by an
entrepreneur into a disaster into a
learning experience because actually a
venture capitalist made well back the
second company that a venture capitalist
who failed the first time wants to do in
fact some VCS say we love people who
come back with a second idea because if
you are somebody who did a first company
battled hard for three years ultimately
you know sold it for maybe less than the
money that was put in
um but you really gave it all you had
and now you're coming back for a second
company wow you are one tough individual
and we believe in that we believe in
struggle
um so you know the first company that
fails can be a learning experience
because of venture capital so it's
almost like an iterative process right
you feel you come back you feel you come
back and at some point you're gonna
strike gold and you'll be okay right so
let's go out of the US for a second in
the book you talk about you know
different countries you interview people
in China and in Asia so what surprised
you about the Venture Capital culture
that you saw in say in China in Europe
and then just quickly talk about Israel
and Africa what's the potential of
venture capital in those countries as
well or that that continent but also in
Israel yeah
well the thing that surprised me the
most about all of my research for this
book was going to China and the reason
is that
um before I went to China you know I
read um some books about the technology
sector in China and I read that the
government had been supportive in making
this digital industry arise and I
figured that kind of made sense because
the government plays a big role in
everything in China it's state
capitalism after all
um and so then I went to China and I
spoke to all the people who were
involved in the early takeoff of Alibaba
and Baidu and tencent and Cena and Soho
and all these digital companies in the
early days
and what was amazing to me is that it
wasn't really a story about government
support
actually all of these early companies
again Alibaba Baidu 10 cents
Secrets whatever each net all of them
they all had American Style Adventure
capital
and in fact they had been pretty much
ignored by the government because you
know the government's Tech policy was
they wanted to back you know kind of
more complicated deep Tech Hardware they
were very keen on backing a
semiconductor industry back in the 1990s
and that stuff mostly failed
but
um in the in the consumer internet
area which is of course where I Alibaba
and Baidu and all that stuff you know
they were consumer companies the
government thought oh consumer internet
who cares and so they kind of didn't
focus on it and that left the field open
to Silicon Valley type investors
who Incorporated those startups under
New York with dispute settlement under
New York law with parent companies
offshore in the Cayman Islands and the
ability to do stuff like issue stock
options for the early employees and this
was crucial
so Alibaba for example became a
world-class company because it could
hire world-class people and they could
hire those people because it could issue
stock options because the American
Venture capitalists had shown up with
Americans Silicon Valley lawyers would
structured the companies with the
ability to do uh Equity stock options
which really were not a thing in China
in fact you couldn't translate them into
Chinese at the beginning
so I think my point is here that you
know the reason why Silicon Valley took
off was Venture Capital the reason why
China internet took off was Venture
Capital Venture Capital turns out to be
the missing ingredient in all of these
Tech ecosystems
um and Israel is kind of the same thing
yet again it's a you know it's a little
bit different in the sense that the
government did very cleverly kick-start
The Venture Capital business in Israel
um it it basically issued a promise that
any private Venture capitalists that
wanted to set up in Israel would get a
lot of subsidies for their first funds
to get them started and that did attract
a lot of private Capital into Israel
there was also the fact that the Israeli
Army and I have some of the smartest
young scientists and and mathematicians
when they're 18 and brings them into a
special army unit and those people kind
of work together they bond together
they're trained in computer science and
cryptography and all of these key skills
and they do that for the Israeli
military for a while and then they spin
out and do their own companies and when
they spin out they all know each other
because they've worked together so it's
a bit like that strength of weak ties
kind of thing you know like in Silicon
Valley you can do due diligence on a
potential Tech founder in Israel very
easily because they're all part of this
military originated Network
and those things plus the government
support for veg Capital
kick-started the the network and now
today Israel actually has more sort of
VC and more startups per capita
than any other country in the world so
it's a small country obviously but
whether it punches way above its weight
and then if we go to chat for if we go
to Africa or southeast Asia and Latin
America what I'm seeing there is sort of
a repeat of the story where you know VCS
are moving in they're usually
um American trained VCS and they
understand the parallel and they are
repeating their magic I had a wonderful
conversation with an Indian uh veggie
capitalist uh if you if you indulge me
for a second I'll tell you an anecdote
that is not in my book
um where I was chatting after my book
came out uh with a
bangalore-based vegetables for Excel and
he explained to me that he'd been in
America he'd been to American Business
School he worked for Intel he was an
engineer
um and then he'd come back to his native
India and he started doing venture
capital and so I said okay so 2010 you
come back to India 2022 uh we're
speaking to each other tell me how
things changed between 2010
and 2022 and so he said to me okay well
in 2010 I did some Investments and after
a while one of the founders who I backed
came to me and said I need some help
and as a VC the VC says sure I always I
helped my Founders that's what I do
and the founder said okay I need some
help what I need is I want to get
married
and the VC goes it's been surprising you
know sure he's there to help but not
normally for marriage intermediation
Services right uh but the VC says you
want to get married okay sure what can I
do and the startup founder says well
um so I'm on I'm an entrepreneur and my
girlfriend's father thinks that
entrepreneurs are all losers
but you missed a venture capitalists
you've been to American Business School
you went for Intel you're a person of
high standing and stature and so if you
call my prospective father-in-law and
explain to him that entrepreneur does
not equal loser
then he'll let me marry his daughter so
the VC says okay I get it and he makes
the call the marriage goes ahead and I
say to him that's a great story now tell
me about 2022 are you still making those
phone calls so that marriages can
proceed and he says today
I don't need to anymore because all of
the father-in-laws are watching uh the
movie I mean the TV series about VC uh
Shark Tank and they are watching Shark
Tank in Hindi the Hindi version uh and
the point here again is that when you
have Venture capitalists or active in a
country for 10 or 12 years you change
the culture you change entrepreneurship
from something that looks like dangerous
failure and losers and you change that
into something which is high status and
people actually want
to be entrepreneurs and they're happy
for their daughters to marry
entrepreneurs they're happy for their
daughters to become entrepreneurs
hopefully
um and so I I do think that you know
Venture Capital becomes a machine for
manufacturing entrepreneurial carriage
I like that the machine for
manufacturing entrepreneurial courage
well we got about 10 minutes left uh
Sebastian which makes me upset because
we haven't even gotten into all the
other parts of the book but it is what
it is I want to move to the last chapter
in the book and spend the rest of our
time because a lot of stuff in there
specifically let's talk about feedback
effects and and and and and just just
talk a little bit about how important
the success leads to success but in the
risk of reputation of failure how is
that important for anyone trying to
either borrow money or get money for VCS
or get into the VC space how important
is reputational risk or reputational
effects
yeah I mean
um this is a huge question about uh any
business
um or creative Endeavor
where you know when a whole bunch of
people like something and and you you
get a good reputation you're much more
likely to get more followers more fans
more people who buy in right and this
again gets back to this parallel stuff
right feedback loops allow whoever is
the leader in a particular field like
the biggest influencer on Instagram
um will get even more uh followers
because you know you've got so many
followers already they talk to other
people and they become your followers
too
um and there's this terrific social
science experiment which kind of proved
this point by
um constructing a bunch of songs uh on a
song list on a computer
and then asking somebody to to listen to
the songs
and download the two
um that the first listener liked the
best so that you know there's 20 songs
to listen to the songs and then you
repeat that process with you know 50
other people who come on the site and
they they listen and each time the next
person who comes can see how many likes
and downloads the pre the you know the
previous listeners have awarded
and of course it happens that you know
there's social proof and so the songs
that already have the most likes carry
on getting more and more likes as you go
through the experiment and after 100
people there's this parallel effect
where there's this outlier winner
clearly the best song it's got you know
70 downloads and then the number two has
got 30 and there's a whole bunch of got
like seven
um and
um so it looks like it's clear which is
the best song but then the researcher
repeats the whole experiment with the
same list of songs the precise same list
and again there's a parallel winner but
there's a totally different one and what
that's telling us is that in venture
capital
there could be a thing going on where a
whole bunch of investors starting one
year in in Year One
and then you know three of them get
lucky and they have this they back some
company that turns out to be a unicorn
so then they have this wonderful
reputation all of the best entrepreneurs
go to them
and through no skid of their own they
carry on doing well because the best
founders of startups are coming to them
and wanting their money not somebody
else's money so I was a bit skeptical
about uh Vega capitalists when I began
writing my book and I almost didn't
write the book because I thought hey
well maybe it's just luck right
um and it was only when I really uh
drilled down more into the subject and I
started to spend time with these
investors and they gave me these very
kind of logical reasons as to how they
do the investment how they have had Ali
add value uh and help companies that
they invest in that I understood it was
not just luck and path dependency and it
was not just reputational effects there
is really a skill in being a good
venture capitalist and there's also
scale in being the right entrepreneur to
sort of pick the right venture
capitalist because it's a marriage right
those two things have to look at the
stories of the book you had a lot of
tension between the VC and an
entrepreneur
um we got about three minutes I saw a
guy about five minutes left I want to
try and squeeze in three quick questions
the first one is sort of abroad in this
conversation so you you were the Council
on Foreign Relations uh talk a little
bit about the geopolitics of venture
capitalism I think it was one of the
most fascinating sections in the book
reading about the geopolitical politics
of VC and what it means for the world
can you just say a few words about that
yeah so just quickly I I mean my point
is that that
um geopolitical Power uh is completely
connected to technological power I mean
if you imagine the power of the United
States without a company like you know
Microsoft or Intel
it would be much less
if you imagine the power of China
without Huawei uh or a company like
sense time it would be much less
so to have National Power you need a
national technology base and for that
it's helpful to have a great Venture
Capital business as well
okay two quick questions to wrap up
first one you could have alluded to when
you talk about Israel but the idea of
government-backed science right now
we're looking at a lot of governments
investing in clean tech the energy
transition is attracting a lot of money
from the privates from the government
how is important is the Synergy between
government-backed signs and Venture
capitalism
I think it can be super productive but
you have to get it right government
money should go into basic research
that's really important and constructive
government money should go into
um training climate scientists and phds
that are going to be helpful that's
really good
I don't think it's so great to put
government money into the investment
funds too much because we've had
experiences of that and you know in
Europe for example one of the problems
for the tech sector has been actually
too much government money that tends not
to be the most go-getting sloshing
around so I think you have to be careful
how you allocate the government's money
okay so this is a question that I that
I've been thinking about since I read
the book and it's about the fact that
you say Network's important the density
of the population in terms of Silicon
Valley for example is important but then
you have a lot of countries around the
world that have small population so I
had this idea and I want to see what you
think about it and I talk about creating
a virtual VC world where instead of you
physically being in Silicon Valley you
can bring together this sort of a
metaverse of VCS and still create the
same sort of environment what do you
think about that idea I think that's a
fantastic idea
um and I hope that's exactly what's
happening in Africa for example where
you have a lot of small markets and you
need a VC system that is cross-border
and that knits together different groups
and you can do that now with modern
Communications and so I'm hopeful that
we will see VC flourish in Africa okay
well so I always like to end these
conversations by having a little preview
into the mind of the author so in this
case tell us what's next for you because
I have a very brilliant idea I think
that I would love you to write on but
let me see what you have in my first
before I give you another assignment so
what's next for for Sebastian in terms
of writing another book well I can't
wait to hear what your assignment is but
uh my idea for the movement is to try to
write something about artificial
intelligence
um I've also looked at crypto but I'm
I'm slightly more drawn to artificial
intelligence
so so here is one that I think will be
very fascinating for you the world has
billions of people who like access to
energy billions of people who have
access to water and we talk about
raising those billions into sort of uh
the world and having them part of the
world society how can we sort of uh
change How We Do Development coming back
to your original book about the World
Bank and you have a lot of other books
being written how do we really raise
billions of people out of poverty and
create wealth without sort of what
burning the planet even further I think
that will be a fascinating book if you
could take that on for five years and
I'll have you back in five years to talk
about the book okay terrific thank you
so much for having me well thanks for
passion and thanks for joining us and
I'll turn over to elikia to give you
information how you can get access to
this information I'll see in DC by the
way when you do show up in the next
month or so okay terrific thank you all
right thanks Sebastian
Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Episode 08Julio M. Ottino
Connecting art, science and technology to expand creativity, strengthen leadership and navigate a complex, interconnected world.
Episode 06Michael Spence
How growth, innovation and good governance can reduce poverty and inequality while navigating climate and geopolitical shocks.