Episode 0756 minWatch on YouTube

About this conversation

How venture capital, risk-taking and connected networks turn bold ideas into startups and spread entrepreneurial culture.

Ask about this conversation

This conversation only
Answers are grounded in indexed transcripts only.

Transcript

00:02

hello and welcome everyone to today's

00:04

influential Minds an eei international

00:07

conversation series my name is

00:11

senior analyst for international

00:13

programs influential minds are is our

00:17

virtual conversation series which aims

00:19

to discuss ideas that move the needle

00:21

towards a more sustainable future with

00:23

thought leaders from across the globe

00:25

today eei International programs is

00:28

excited to welcome Sebastian Malibu

00:31

senior fellow for international

00:32

economics at the Council on Foreign

00:35

Relations he joins us today to discuss

00:37

his latest book The Power law venture

00:40

capital and the making of the new future

00:42

to help us navigate the world of venture

00:44

capital and discuss its role in the

00:46

energy transition he will be joined in

00:49

conversation by our host eei vice

00:52

president for international programs Dr

00:54

Lawrence Jones throughout the session

00:56

please feel free to ask questions using

00:59

the chat feature Dr Jones will aim to

01:01

incorporate as many of them as possible

01:04

into the conversation without further

01:07

Ado I will turn this over to Lawrence to

01:09

get started

01:14

thank you Alicia and good good afternoon

01:17

Sebastian I was going to say good

01:19

morning but you're in London so good

01:20

afternoon for you

01:21

thank you

01:23

well afternoon to you as well it is it

01:26

is well Sebastian let me first of all

01:28

again welcome you to influential Minds

01:30

this is the first in our series for the

01:33

fall so uh no pressure on the

01:35

conversation we're going to have today

01:37

let me Begin by saying congratulations

01:39

to you on the book uh they said to you

01:42

before we started you've kept my head

01:45

scratching the entire couple of weeks

01:47

since I've been reading this book

01:48

because it's very well written and

01:51

really captures a lot of things I think

01:52

we want to talk about today given where

01:54

the world is

01:55

but before we do that you know I want to

01:58

go back and just ask you to tell us a

02:01

little bit about Sebastian you've

02:03

written multiple books you wrote a book

02:05

on off that apartheid you wrote a book

02:07

more money to God about hedge funds uh

02:10

you wrote a book about Alan Greenspan

02:12

you wrote a book about the world's

02:14

bankers and now you have this book out

02:16

on the power law

02:18

writing all of those books which all

02:20

seem to be very different what have been

02:22

some of the common themes you've come

02:24

across because they all seem to have

02:26

some correlation that they're written by

02:28

a guy who's an economist so what are

02:30

some of the key themes youth chapter

02:32

haven't written all those books

02:34

well I guess you know there is an

02:37

evolution there in the themes and I

02:39

suppose it tracks my professional

02:40

interests I was a young reporter working

02:43

for The Economist magazine as the Africa

02:46

correspondent uh back in 1989 1990 and I

02:51

was fortunate to be outside Nelson

02:53

Mandela's Jail uh when he walked out in

02:56

February 1990 and

02:59

um I realized two things instantly one

03:01

was this was the most exciting moment I

03:04

could possibly experience as a

03:05

journalist I thought my career would be

03:07

downhill

03:09

uh thereafter even though I was only 25

03:11

because because nothing could match the

03:13

moment of Mandela's Freedom uh I also

03:16

realized rather more opportunistically

03:18

that um all the other books about South

03:20

Africa were magically and instantly out

03:22

of date so I wrote this book about South

03:25

Africa after apartheid

03:28

um and that was in my 20s

03:30

um and then a period went by without me

03:32

writing a book but when I wrote the next

03:34

one it was also sort of about Africa

03:36

because it was about the World Bank and

03:39

the world bank's involvement in

03:40

developing countries and it looked at

03:43

that question through the period when

03:46

Jim Wilkinson was the president of the

03:48

World Bank from 1995 to 2005 and it kind

03:51

of told a story about the efforts of the

03:54

rich world to be sort of constructively

03:57

engaged in development in Asia Africa

04:00

Latin America and so on and so there was

04:02

a book about globalization and the

04:04

finance behind globalization

04:06

and then I move more into pure Finance I

04:09

wrote this book about hedge funds

04:12

um more money than God which came out in

04:15

2010

04:16

so that's a story about public market

04:18

investing then I did a book about

04:20

central banks the biography of Alan

04:22

Greenspan

04:24

um so that's not hedge funds that's

04:26

that's the central bank but of course

04:29

they interact the central bank is often

04:31

fighting against the hedge funds and the

04:33

hedge funds are trying to destroy some

04:34

currency Peg and the central banks

04:36

trying to defend it so in a way that was

04:38

the other side of the same

04:40

um narrative and now this new book

04:45

um is another jump

04:48

um into the world of venture capital a

04:50

very different kind of financial

04:51

specialty where it's not about investing

04:54

in stocks and bonds or about being a

04:56

central Banker it's about startup

04:58

companies uh you know which begin from

05:01

nothing with a technology idea and the

05:03

first question is how do you even think

05:05

about investing in them right because

05:07

there's no you know the other investing

05:09

you've got the price earnings ratio well

05:13

I mean there's no earnings when

05:15

two entrepreneurs walk into your office

05:17

with a dream and you're the venture

05:19

capitalist and you're deciding if you

05:21

should back them so it's a very

05:22

specialized kind of Finance I think it's

05:24

a kind of Finance with a lot of impact

05:26

on the world because it's behind all the

05:28

big Innovations

05:30

um and so that's my most recent

05:32

Adventure

05:34

well the title of the book The Power law

05:37

uh venture capital and and the making of

05:40

the new future so so as a as a scientist

05:44

or well

05:46

used to be scientists because I don't

05:48

know a lot of research these days but in

05:50

in physics there are a lot of power laws

05:52

you know law you know gravitational

05:54

forces Newton's law you know you got

05:57

Stefan boseman's law you have laws on

05:59

the decay of heat a lot of these

06:01

physical laws we learn in physics have

06:03

some sort of a power law Dimension to it

06:06

even though they're deterministic and

06:08

then you have the sort of a statistical

06:09

power laws that really is not an input

06:12

output kind of thing right so talk about

06:16

power law in the context of venture

06:18

capital what is it describe it for the

06:20

audience uh so they can understand what

06:23

do you mean by power law in the context

06:25

of venture capital that's a that's a

06:27

great question

06:28

um the easiest way to to communicate the

06:31

idea is I think to start with what the

06:33

power law isn't in statistics I mean in

06:36

statistics you have this familiar normal

06:39

distribution which is the other kind of

06:41

distribution

06:43

um and that's the one with the bell

06:45

curve where the average

06:48

um the mean is the same as the median

06:50

and then around that median Point

06:54

um most of the observations in a in a

06:56

data set will cluster pretty close to

07:00

that average and so you get this big fat

07:03

Bell in the middle and then the you know

07:05

it tapers off into these thin Tails uh

07:09

at at the left side on the right side

07:12

um and so if you think about you know

07:14

the height of men in America

07:17

the average man is five foot ten

07:20

um the the modal man is five foot ten

07:24

and two-thirds of all the men clustered

07:27

between five foot seven and six foot one

07:29

so pretty close to that uh to that

07:32

average and you know there are some

07:35

outliers there are six foot seven NBA

07:37

stars or six foot ten NBA stars or

07:38

whatever they are but even they are only

07:40

really 20 away from the average it's not

07:42

a big difference so if you had a movie

07:44

theater right with a hundred men sitting

07:47

there watching the movie and the NBA

07:49

star at the back gets bored and he walks

07:51

out halfway through the movie the height

07:54

of the kind of average residual man in

07:57

the movie theater isn't going to shift

07:59

very much only a tiny bit because that

08:02

big guy who walks out is only 20 bigger

08:05

than the average now now flip the flip

08:07

the example right we're not talking any

08:10

more about the average height of

08:12

American men but the average wealth of

08:15

American men and the distribution of the

08:17

wealth and we've got the same movie

08:19

theater and there's 100 men there but

08:20

the person at the back is Jeff Bezos

08:22

right and he gets bored he walks out of

08:25

the movie the residual American man the

08:28

average in the movie theater of the

08:30

other 99

08:31

the average wealth is going to plummet

08:33

not just go down a tiny bit plummet

08:35

because in a parallel distribution which

08:38

is what the wealth of American men

08:41

observes

08:43

um you know you've got Jeff Bezos who's

08:45

got multiples more uh not 20 more but

08:48

you know 20 or 2 000 times more than the

08:52

average right and so there are some of

08:55

these distributions where you know some

08:57

people call it the 80 20 rule uh where

09:00

you know 20 of the cities have 80 of the

09:03

people or 20 of the flowers in the

09:06

garden the flower plants in the garden

09:07

generate 80 of the of of the flowers and

09:11

that's what it is like in Venture

09:14

Capital

09:15

um a small minority of the Investments

09:17

That a venture capitalist does

09:20

um will generate the Lion's Share of the

09:23

return so if you have a veggie

09:25

capitalist who makes 10 Investments

09:28

um maybe seven or eight will lose money

09:31

because startups are really difficult to

09:33

do and new technologies sometimes fail

09:35

and so you don't get your money back but

09:38

the hope is for the investor that one or

09:41

two will do more than 10x

09:44

the sum that you invest so a return of a

09:46

thousand percent or better than that and

09:49

so it's a power law distribution and

09:51

that's completely unlike what a hedge

09:54

fund investor faces in the stock market

09:55

or the bond market

09:57

and that really differentiates uh

10:00

venture capital and it also

10:03

um I mean I'll shut up in a minute here

10:04

but just let me add one one point which

10:07

is that when you have a parallel

10:08

distribution you have to think

10:09

differently

10:10

you have to be willing to take these

10:13

High uh High you know High outcome but

10:18

low probability bets the real long shots

10:20

and you've you've got to be shooting for

10:23

that right hand tail of the distribution

10:25

uh where you're making more than 10x and

10:28

that's what it's all about it's no good

10:30

trying to be cautious in place bets that

10:33

probably will pay off but in a more

10:34

modest fashion

10:36

so in the book one of the things that

10:38

fascinated me are the stories you have a

10:41

lot of stories in the book I mean for

10:43

for someone who haven't read the book I

10:44

must tell you if you love history if you

10:46

love storytelling this is the perfect

10:48

book to read Because almost every every

10:50

page comes into a story about something

10:53

that had to do with the evolution of

10:56

venture capitalism and so talk to the

10:59

audience a little bit about how you were

11:01

able to get access to all of these

11:04

people I mean you're you're talking

11:05

about the who's who in Venture

11:07

capitalism today and you're able to get

11:10

behind the scenes and narrate all of

11:14

these exchanges with these folks for for

11:16

several decades of of History how did

11:19

you do it how did you get access and how

11:21

do you go about doing this research

11:24

well the short answer is time I'm I take

11:27

a long time over these books like five

11:30

years and most of that time is because

11:32

it does take a while to persuade people

11:35

to sit down and open up and talk to me

11:38

not just for an hour or so but maybe for

11:40

four or five hours uh you know I go back

11:43

two or three times to see them and we

11:45

have long in-depth conversations and

11:46

they follow up with emails and maybe we

11:50

have another phone call at the end and

11:51

it's a big commitment for people who are

11:53

very busy and they don't necessarily

11:55

like talking about their investment

11:58

sequence and they don't particularly

11:59

like the media so it is a challenge to

12:02

get the access but once you've got the

12:04

access that's what makes my books

12:06

different because I really have

12:09

um sat down with with the you know the

12:11

the All-Stars

12:13

um and I'm in a position to explain how

12:15

they do their Investments I mean the

12:18

secret is partly time and taking the

12:19

effort to really lay out you know what

12:22

I'm doing and and and but it's also it's

12:25

time in the sense that often I'm going

12:28

at the beginning of the project you know

12:29

I I I I know somebody who

12:32

um has liked my previous books and who

12:35

has five friends in Silicon Valley so I

12:37

say please can you introduce me to those

12:39

five friends and I don't care who it is

12:41

I just go see them and before I see them

12:43

I read everything about them and I learn

12:45

everything I can and I go in super

12:48

informed and super prepared in order to

12:50

communicate the message that when people

12:53

speak to me I'm grateful for that time

12:55

that they are allotting and I really do

12:57

my homework and then that wins them over

12:59

and then they say at the end wow you

13:02

really do your homework who can I

13:04

introduce you to and then they pass me

13:06

on to five more people

13:07

and then my network starts to build but

13:10

it takes time and it takes you know a

13:12

couple of years before I really I've

13:13

seen the people who know the people who

13:15

know the other people who really know

13:16

the people

13:18

bit by bit I Network my way into the

13:21

into the sort of middle circle

13:24

it's also about building trust right

13:25

building because you're getting some

13:27

very very intriguing pieces of

13:30

information so it's all about building

13:31

trust with the with your interview

13:34

candidates so to speak so let's let's

13:37

get into some of the interesting stories

13:38

uh first of all talk about the Rebels

13:41

the eight Rebels who I would say

13:43

transform Silicon Valley who are these

13:46

eight individuals and tell us a little

13:48

bit about their story and how they

13:49

basically are the ones who got us

13:51

Venture capitalists more or less yeah so

13:54

this is a an interesting story for many

13:56

reasons but

13:58

um there was this um renowned scientist

14:03

um called William Shockley who won a

14:05

Nobel Prize for his contribution to the

14:07

invention of the semiconductor

14:10

um and he had been at Bell Labs he'd

14:13

moved to the West Coast uh so from the

14:15

east coast to West Coast you'd set up a

14:17

company called Shockley semiconductor

14:19

and because he was this renowned

14:21

physicist with a Nobel Prize he could

14:24

pretty much call any PhD in the country

14:27

and say will you come and work for me

14:30

and and they would say sure and they

14:32

would come because they were honored to

14:33

get that phone call it was like picking

14:35

up the phone and receiving a call from

14:37

God uh as one of them uh said later so

14:40

they came and worked for Shockley and

14:42

then as soon as they got there uh to the

14:44

West Coast they realized that Shockley

14:46

might be a genius but he was also a very

14:49

difficult guy I mean he would humiliate

14:51

you he would make fun of you you know

14:55

um one person came to work for him and

14:58

then he just laughed when the guy showed

15:00

up and said ha you settled for a really

15:02

low salary it shows you have no idea how

15:04

to negotiate and then another person

15:06

said that he would like to maybe do some

15:08

research and you know publish an

15:10

academic paper and so Shockley said yeah

15:13

I'm not sure you're you're really up to

15:15

it but I'll give you an idea and he

15:16

scribbled an idea down on a piece of

15:18

paper and said here you can write this

15:19

up and publish this

15:21

um so he was he was very annoying to

15:24

work for and it became insufferable and

15:27

so eight of these young

15:29

um you know brilliant young researchers

15:31

uh kind of banded together and they

15:33

wanted to go join a different company

15:36

um and they didn't know quite how to do

15:39

this but they asked one of them had a

15:41

father who had some money and was

15:43

connected to a Wall Street

15:45

um financier so they wrote to to this

15:48

financiers company and said do you know

15:50

anybody who would like to hire eight

15:52

physicists who would like to work on

15:54

semiconductors as a team and the letter

15:57

got passed around and it was given to a

15:59

guy called Arthur Rock who was a young

16:01

wall Streeter and he flew out to the

16:04

West Coast and met with these eight uh

16:07

physicists and said Gee you know it's a

16:10

great idea to leave Mr Sharpie but why

16:13

don't you start your own company that

16:15

way you won't have another bad boss you

16:18

can work for yourselves and if you

16:19

invent something fantastic and you

16:21

really do well you will share in the

16:24

financial fruits of your own Brilliance

16:26

and so this was a new idea and they

16:29

didn't you know at first the the eight

16:32

physicists were scared of that Prospect

16:34

and rock said you know don't worry I've

16:37

got the money to help you and they said

16:38

but we don't know how to form a company

16:39

and rock said well I'll help you to do

16:41

that uh and they and he basically he

16:43

took them into it and said you know I

16:45

will I will hold your hand about the

16:48

business side of this you guys know the

16:50

the physics side and we'll be a team uh

16:53

and and we'll do this together and

16:55

that's how Venture Capital began on the

16:57

west coast they were called the the

16:59

eight traitors because back in 1957 when

17:02

all this happened it was highly unusual

17:05

uh to quit a company you know this was

17:08

the era of big companies and Big labor

17:11

and big government and the classic book

17:13

of the period was called uh organization

17:16

man because everything was a bit

17:18

bureaucratic and people joined these

17:19

organizations and worked there until

17:21

they retired on their 60th birthday with

17:23

a gold watch but this moment of the

17:26

eight traitors kind of opened up a new

17:28

way of

17:29

um of doing companies and and that was

17:31

the birth of West Coast startups well

17:34

we'll come back to Mr Rock because he's

17:36

figured throughout the book in different

17:37

places but you mentioned West Coast so

17:40

let's talk about the west coast East

17:41

Coast library right so you have Boston

17:43

with MIT you have Silicon Valley which

17:46

Stanford

17:48

what made the difference why did Silicon

17:50

Valley win so to speak in Boston or the

17:53

East Coast

17:55

why did they lose it's more or less this

17:57

is this is a huge and fascinating debate

18:00

you know when I began my research

18:01

sometimes people were telling me you

18:03

know well Silicon Valley is really

18:06

Stanford Valley uh Stanford is where all

18:08

the ideas come from and then people spin

18:11

out and they do these great companies

18:12

and it's all about Stanford being

18:14

excellent

18:15

and I kind of nodded my head and then

18:17

when I actually did some reading and

18:19

research I realized that at the time

18:21

when Silicon Valley really took off back

18:24

in the 60s the 70s and even the early

18:26

80s MIT was by far and away a better

18:30

Engineering University than Stanford and

18:33

that's not true anymore today Stanford's

18:35

probably slightly ahead but uh back back

18:38

in the early period that was absolutely

18:40

not the case and if you want to throw

18:43

um you know Berkeley into the mix as the

18:46

explanation for why Silicon Valley did

18:48

well you know I can throw Harvard into

18:50

the mix for the Boston ecosystem and so

18:53

I don't think it was because of academic

18:55

excellence and there are places like

18:56

Carnegie Mellon which were wonderful

18:59

engineering universities but never

19:00

really had a tech startup scene so I

19:03

don't think it's about the Academia

19:05

rather it's it's actually about the

19:08

business culture there was this

19:10

go-getting business culture on the west

19:11

coast and I really do think that was

19:13

because of the Venture Capital The

19:15

Venture capitalists

19:16

were willing to underwrite the extreme

19:19

risk on the west coast whereas on the

19:22

East Coast there were some Venture

19:23

capitalists but they were more cautious

19:24

they wanted to back a company only when

19:27

it already had a product maybe had a

19:29

customer

19:30

certainly had you know a business

19:32

founder as well as a technical founder

19:36

um whereas on the on the west coast you

19:38

could have a single person who had a

19:40

brilliant idea for the daisy wheel

19:42

printer or something had no idea how to

19:45

do the business side the sales side and

19:48

the VCS would say no problem you know

19:50

we'll come to us we'll back you we'll

19:52

find you a partner to do the business

19:54

side

19:55

um and we'll be there with you all the

19:57

way as you recruit great commercial

19:59

people sales people

20:01

um and so they would back the company at

20:04

a much earlier stage take much more risk

20:06

be willing to see a bunch of their

20:09

companies fail that was the power law

20:11

mentality I was talking about before and

20:13

so I really think the business sculpture

20:15

of the West Coast distinguished it and

20:18

allowed it to overtake the ecosystem in

20:21

Boston and it was because of the venture

20:22

capital

20:24

so interesting so so in the in the book

20:26

though Sebastian you you talk about many

20:28

different interesting individuals that

20:31

will spend two weeks going through and

20:33

we did all of them on this call but this

20:36

there one there's another one I want to

20:37

talk besides autobrock let's talk about

20:39

both Matt clef and I like Bob matka

20:42

because obviously his his theory or his

20:44

law math class law is one that I believe

20:46

in that you know the more things you

20:47

connect to a network the value increases

20:49

by the square so just talk about Matlab

20:53

why is he such an intriguing figure in

20:55

the context of venture capitalism

20:58

well partly because he actually was an

21:00

MIT graduate

21:02

[Music]

21:03

um and he came out of MIT he moved to

21:05

the West Coast and he was spent some

21:07

time

21:08

um at uh Xerox Park which was you know

21:12

the research subsidiary of of

21:15

um Xerox

21:16

and he got very frustrated at Xerox park

21:19

because of this thing the innovator's

21:20

Dilemma you know where lots of good

21:23

invention can happen inside a big

21:24

Corporation but if it's going to

21:26

threaten the core product of the parent

21:29

company

21:30

probably those Innovations will not be

21:32

commercialized and Bob Metcalf himself

21:34

invented ethernet and that technology

21:38

for you know hooking up your computer

21:40

with your printer with

21:43

um your disk drive with other people in

21:45

your local area network it's been a bit

21:47

superseded now that we all have you know

21:49

Wireless connectivity

21:52

um but back in the day ethernet was a

21:54

core invention that allowed networking

21:56

to happen

21:58

um and basically you know Xerox plays

22:01

around with it a bit but was not really

22:03

going to commercialize it and so

22:05

um Bob Metcalf got frustrated he set up

22:07

his own company 3com to commercialize

22:11

his own invention

22:13

and because he was you know originally

22:15

from MIT and he kind of preferred the

22:18

east coast and he thought West Coast VCS

22:21

were too pushy and arrogant he said

22:23

right I'm not going to raise venture

22:25

capital from these arrogant Services uh

22:28

in in California and I will go raise

22:30

from from the nice genteel you know

22:33

sensible people uh in Boston so he went

22:36

off to Boston he found somebody who

22:37

would back his company 3com and before

22:40

he signed the deal

22:42

he discovered what he called later the

22:45

oh by the way syndrome as in oh by the

22:49

way we just thought of one more

22:50

condition that you need to meet before

22:53

we sign this deal with you and the first

22:55

thing was oh by the way we need you to

22:57

find another investor to share the risk

22:59

with us because the Boston VCS were not

23:02

all that risk hungry and so Bob metcar

23:05

scrabbles around he goes and finds

23:07

another VC in New York and the New York

23:09

VC says that you know he's happy to

23:11

invest as well and Metcalf goes back

23:14

triumphantly to the Boston guy and said

23:15

okay I've got another investor

23:17

and the the Boston guy says oh by the

23:20

way I really meant a California investor

23:24

and so Metcalf scrabbles around and

23:26

finds their California investor who's

23:28

willing to put some money in and then

23:30

it's oh by the way we really meant a

23:33

California investor who put a lot of

23:35

money in

23:36

and so Metcalf scrabbles around and

23:38

finds somebody and then you know it just

23:40

goes on like this and there are all

23:42

these conditions and eventually Metcalf

23:44

realizes that he spent so much time

23:46

trying to raise funds that he's actually

23:48

run out of the little money he had to

23:51

get started by himself and you know for

23:53

an entrepreneur time is money it's the

23:55

time is the most valuable resource and

23:58

so he ended up just getting completely

24:01

fed up and going to the to the West

24:03

Coast Venture capitalists doing a deal

24:05

with them in inside of 24 hours and

24:09

um saying to them look I've got one

24:11

condition which is that Boston VC it was

24:14

Fidelity Ventures

24:16

um that promised me money we're not

24:19

going to take any money from them at all

24:20

I'm just so sick of them and then he

24:22

called up the Fidelity Ventures and said

24:24

you're right I don't need you get lost

24:26

and they said but we were the only ones

24:29

who were willing to back you and nobody

24:31

else would and Metcalf said you were the

24:34

only ones who lied to me where nobody

24:37

else would and so to me this is a story

24:40

about how you know the West Coast

24:42

Venture capitalists were far more risk

24:45

friendly and far more fast to provide

24:48

capital and that explains why in the

24:51

1980s when Recon got started it really

24:54

was a case of you know the West Coast

24:56

overtaking the East Coast not because

24:58

the science was better but because the

25:01

business culture was more go-getting

25:02

interesting I want to I want to stay on

25:05

the issue of business culture because I

25:08

think fundamentally the way the world is

25:09

today we're going through a lot of

25:11

changes there's a lot of discussions

25:12

about you know the need for capital

25:14

investment in the clean tech space and

25:17

and when we look back and try to

25:19

understand some of the successes in

25:22

Silicon Valley one of the things you

25:23

talk about in the book is weak ties and

25:26

you get into this whole discussion

25:28

around uh porous boundaries that existed

25:30

between the companies in the east coast

25:32

I mean the West Coast Visa be the East

25:34

Coast how important is it for clean tech

25:38

that we have more porous boundaries

25:41

between startup companies for us to

25:44

accelerate the development of pain

25:46

technology can you talk a little bit

25:47

about that

25:48

sure I mean maybe I'll talk a bit about

25:51

the importance of loose ties in general

25:53

for Tech and then we can move on to the

25:55

clean tech specifically but my point

25:58

really is that

26:00

um you can have two ecosystems uh and

26:03

they might have the same number of

26:04

talented people in them

26:06

but one will be more productive than the

26:08

other and this is a bit of a mystery in

26:10

economics you know economics has various

26:12

things to say about clusters

26:14

and why clusters of talented people are

26:17

productive

26:18

but it doesn't really tell you why one

26:20

cluster of the same size would be better

26:22

than the other one

26:23

and so I was kind of scratching my head

26:25

about this and eventually I found the

26:27

answer or the best answer I could find

26:29

it was in sociology not in economics and

26:32

it was basically about how you know if

26:35

you have a lot of

26:36

um sort of connective tissue within one

26:40

cluster where if you imagine a sort of a

26:43

diagram of the cluster with all the

26:45

nodes representing different talented

26:47

people and then there are lines between

26:49

the nodes and if the nodes are more

26:51

connected

26:53

um it means that they're kind of sharing

26:55

ideas and and insights and sort of

26:59

theories and and hypotheses together

27:02

more uh and so just like in the brain if

27:05

the neurons are more connected up you'll

27:07

be more creative intellectually it's the

27:11

same thing with clusters if they're more

27:12

connected up you know the ideas and the

27:15

money and the people will flow around

27:18

the ecosystem more dynamically and and

27:22

result in more experiments

27:24

and a sociologists from Berkeley called

27:26

Emily saxonian had pointed all this out

27:28

in a book in the 1990s and I think what

27:30

I contributed was to say

27:33

why are these uh connections so fertile

27:36

on the west coast it's not just because

27:38

you have startups that have sort of low

27:42

boundaries between the startup and the

27:45

other startups it's also because the

27:47

Venture capitalists are people who are

27:49

financially incentivized right to get up

27:53

in the morning and have breakfast with

27:55

one person who might be an entrepreneur

27:57

or somebody that an entrepreneurial

27:59

company might want to hire whatever and

28:02

after that breakfast to have 17 cups of

28:05

coffee you know hopefully decaffeinated

28:07

before they go to bed with other

28:10

entrepreneurs other potential financiers

28:12

you know

28:14

10 people who might be good candidates

28:16

to be hired by the companies that the VC

28:19

back last month you know it's all about

28:21

connecting people that's what Venture

28:22

capitalists do and so this

28:25

interconnectedness of the West Coast

28:27

meant for made for a more creative

28:29

experimental ecosystem than the vertical

28:33

hierarchies of the East Coast where

28:36

somebody would join a big company like

28:37

deck or Wang and and basically stay

28:40

within that company and and circulate

28:42

only within that company so that would

28:44

give you strong deep ties but not lots

28:48

of looser weak ties and as you say

28:50

Lawrence it's the weak ties that are

28:53

more fertile interesting so so let's

28:56

let's talk about we're going to pick one

28:58

of them but for those who haven't read

29:00

the book

29:01

Paulo Yahoo Apple Cisco Google Amazon

29:06

Facebook all of them benefited from

29:09

Venture capitalism correct let's talk

29:12

about Apple because I think the Apple

29:13

Store is very interesting in terms of

29:16

who decided to fund apple or who didn't

29:19

fund Apple in terms of placing bets so

29:21

just talk a little bit about that whole

29:23

Apple story and what happened and where

29:25

things stand today right so we have to

29:28

go back to the 1970s of course when

29:30

Apple got started uh and remember that

29:34

Steve Jobs at the time

29:37

um was not the you know absolute sort of

29:40

um Kingpin of you know the kind of

29:43

embodiment of West Coast creative

29:46

entrepreneurial genius which is what he

29:48

became later

29:49

at the time he was this extremely

29:51

scruffy College Dropout

29:54

um who went around with bare feet he was

29:56

said to you know wash his feet

29:58

occasionally in the toilet uh to eat a

30:01

fruitarian diet you know just generally

30:03

look as if he'd you know been in some

30:06

sort of you know as one venture

30:07

capitalist told me he'd just been off to

30:09

see his Guru in India I think that was

30:11

actually literally true he had just been

30:13

off to see some gurus in India the early

30:15

event he didn't you know from a 1970s

30:17

perspective he didn't look like the kind

30:19

of engineer that you would want to back

30:20

right in fact he wasn't even an engineer

30:23

he had this friend Stephen Wozniak who

30:25

was a real engineer but who was kind of

30:28

tongue-tied and shy and so there were

30:29

these two Steves and most of the people

30:32

who who met them in the early days

30:33

thought no way am I going to invest in

30:35

these characters I mean who are they

30:37

right

30:38

um and so Steve Jobs went to try to

30:41

raise money from a bunch of different

30:43

people and each of them would do this

30:45

networking weak ties kind of thing where

30:50

they would say yeah gee I'm sorry I I

30:52

don't want to invest right now but you

30:55

know if if you want to really do this

30:57

company I could introduce you to a

30:59

couple of people uh and then they would

31:02

make a couple of introductions and Steve

31:04

Jobs would meet with another couple of

31:06

people and he would be passed around

31:09

um the the Silicon Valley ecosystem In

31:12

This Very networky strength of weak ties

31:15

kind of way and eventually he meets this

31:18

guy called Mike marcolo who's not really

31:21

a VC but who is a an exited entrepreneur

31:24

who retired young having made a bunch of

31:26

money uh by being a senior salesperson

31:29

at a couple of different semiconductor

31:31

companies and Mike Marcola you know gets

31:35

out you know he's made some money so

31:36

he's got this kind of rather gaudy I

31:39

think it was a gold colored Corvette and

31:42

he drives up to this garage where Steve

31:44

Jobs and Steve Wesner go hanging out and

31:47

he gets that he's got a sort of big

31:49

flashy Lounge suit and he walks in and

31:51

there are these scruffy slightly sort of

31:53

smelly young characters

31:56

but he gets past them and he looks at

31:58

the circuit board that Steve Wozniak is

32:01

building for the Apple computer

32:04

and because Mike marklin knows about

32:08

circuit boards he's an engineer himself

32:10

he ignores the Steves and looks at the

32:12

second board and says gee this is one

32:15

elegant circuit board

32:17

and so finally uh through a process of

32:21

like introduction after introduction

32:22

after introduction the Steve's get lucky

32:24

and the character with a flashy Lounge

32:27

suit is the one who connects with them

32:29

because he doesn't actually look at them

32:30

he looks at the engineering and the

32:33

wiring

32:34

um and so so may Marcola is so enthused

32:37

by the circuit board that he says okay

32:39

I'm going to make an investment I'm

32:42

going to help you out I'm an engineer

32:44

I'm going to work with you pretty

32:45

Hands-On and you have no idea what

32:48

you're doing in terms of building a

32:49

company but I will help you out and all

32:52

of a sudden Mike Machina States starts

32:54

connecting with you know Venture

32:56

capitalists and with other people like

32:59

the famous Silicon Valley

33:01

publicity guy back in the day Regis

33:04

McKenna who was the person who would

33:06

design your logo and get you some

33:09

publicity get you on the cover of a

33:10

magazine and and you know Regis McKenna

33:13

had said no way would he work with this

33:15

guy with no shoes but when Mike Michael

33:17

asked him you know then he was part of

33:19

the network and sure of course he would

33:21

do it you know and so it was that kind

33:23

of thing and that's how

33:25

um Steve Jobs eventually went from this

33:28

Silicon Valley you know Renegade uh to

33:32

being part of the magic circle that

33:34

raised money and that you know got

33:36

advertising was on the cover of

33:37

magazines and that you know managed to

33:40

build Apple so if when you look at all

33:43

of these companies the big ones who were

33:45

able to benefit from Power law right

33:47

we've mentioned some of them before you

33:49

can add to the list Uber and and uh and

33:53

uh Tesla and a few others right right

33:56

and if you were to talk to a young

33:58

venture capitalist today there's a

33:59

question in the audience in the chat

34:01

about uh what advice would you give

34:03

right so based on all these companies

34:05

you've looked at all these stories what

34:07

are three things you would tell a young

34:09

VC who's getting a clean tech space for

34:12

example one of three things they should

34:14

be thinking about uh in in terms of

34:16

wanting to seek funding to promote that

34:19

idea

34:21

ah so are you talking about

34:24

um somebody wants to get into the uh

34:27

entrepreneurial side or the funding side

34:29

no someone's someone who wants the money

34:31

someone someone wants to money right so

34:33

so in the book you talk about Network

34:35

you talk about weak ties you know there

34:37

are a lot of different

34:38

different stories in fact each of these

34:40

companies went down their own Journey

34:42

they had their own iterative mistakes or

34:45

successes but if you were to identify

34:47

three things Sebastian that seemed to be

34:50

common for all of these organizations

34:52

who were looking for money what would

34:54

those three things be

34:56

sure so the first thing you need for a

34:58

startup in this in this technical space

35:01

is you need a technical idea

35:04

um so you need to have a convincing

35:06

story about a a technology that doesn't

35:10

exist yet but that if it were to be

35:12

built

35:14

um really would address a need

35:18

um that there would be product Market

35:20

um and uh that's the first that's really

35:23

the first thing and it's got to be a big

35:26

market now that's the second thing is is

35:28

the commercial side

35:29

that if you built this thing Not only

35:31

would it be needed but it would be

35:33

needed in quite large quantities such

35:35

that you could sell a lot of it

35:38

um and you know talk about revenues that

35:41

would quickly run into the millions and

35:43

then the tens and millions and then the

35:45

hundreds of millions because remember

35:46

the power law you know the power law

35:49

means that most startups fail most ideas

35:52

for new technologies fail that's the

35:55

unfortunate brutal logic and so every

35:59

single one that gets backing needs to

36:01

have a chance of being a 10x plus

36:05

outcome that you know if it raises let's

36:09

25 million dollars of investment capital

36:12

is going to be worth more than 250

36:15

dollars 50 250 million dollars uh within

36:18

five or six years that unless you can

36:20

plausibly tell that story you're not

36:23

going to get funding so number one is

36:26

that you've got this technology that

36:28

you've understood that you know how to

36:29

build it number two is it's going to be

36:31

a big enough market and then number

36:33

three is be resilient don't give up if

36:37

you think you've got those first two

36:38

things

36:39

don't be discouraged when the first 10

36:41

people tell you you're crazy they're not

36:43

going to fund you that you know you only

36:45

need one or two people to believe in you

36:48

and then it will turn out that the 50

36:51

who did not believe in you just don't

36:53

matter hmm interesting interesting so

36:56

you mentioned failure right one succeeds

36:59

nine failed

37:01

how do we get our culture to embrace

37:05

failure because in one of your

37:06

conversations I listen to you talk about

37:08

how failure should be valuable how

37:11

should we value failure because I think

37:12

we don't how do we do that

37:15

well again

37:17

um you know when I think you're right

37:18

first of all it is a

37:20

um sort of counter instinctive thing for

37:24

human beings to be okay about failure I

37:27

mean behavioral economists tell us that

37:30

we have uh loss aversion we don't like

37:32

to fail we don't like to lose what we've

37:35

um we will take far more put far more

37:38

effort and take more risk to sort of you

37:41

know preserve what we have

37:44

um then you know then to shoot for the

37:46

upside right

37:48

so most people don't want to be

37:49

entrepreneurs because they don't want to

37:51

fail they'd rather do something safer

37:53

and most investors actually don't want

37:56

to back entrepreneurs because they're

37:58

scared of the failure too so as a

38:01

culture to have entrepreneurship and to

38:03

have Venture Capital we have to overcome

38:04

that instinct I think the good news is

38:07

that Venture Capital has now you know

38:09

since those early days that we just

38:11

talked about with the traitor say back

38:13

in the 50s and in the 60s you know the

38:16

world has come a long way and there is

38:17

this karda

38:19

of venture capitalists who have

38:20

understood that failure should be okay

38:23

and they're willing to underwrite firms

38:25

startups that very well might fail

38:29

um so I think the way to overcome the

38:31

sphere of failure is to have plenty of

38:32

venture capital

38:34

um and that's what turns failure by an

38:37

entrepreneur into a disaster into a

38:40

learning experience because actually a

38:42

venture capitalist made well back the

38:45

second company that a venture capitalist

38:47

who failed the first time wants to do in

38:49

fact some VCS say we love people who

38:52

come back with a second idea because if

38:54

you are somebody who did a first company

38:58

battled hard for three years ultimately

39:01

you know sold it for maybe less than the

39:04

money that was put in

39:06

um but you really gave it all you had

39:07

and now you're coming back for a second

39:09

company wow you are one tough individual

39:13

and we believe in that we believe in

39:15

struggle

39:16

um so you know the first company that

39:19

fails can be a learning experience

39:21

because of venture capital so it's

39:24

almost like an iterative process right

39:26

you feel you come back you feel you come

39:28

back and at some point you're gonna

39:30

strike gold and you'll be okay right so

39:34

let's go out of the US for a second in

39:36

the book you talk about you know

39:37

different countries you interview people

39:39

in China and in Asia so what surprised

39:42

you about the Venture Capital culture

39:44

that you saw in say in China in Europe

39:46

and then just quickly talk about Israel

39:50

and Africa what's the potential of

39:52

venture capital in those countries as

39:54

well or that that continent but also in

39:56

Israel yeah

39:58

well the thing that surprised me the

40:00

most about all of my research for this

40:02

book was going to China and the reason

40:06

is that

40:07

um before I went to China you know I

40:09

read um some books about the technology

40:11

sector in China and I read that the

40:15

government had been supportive in making

40:18

this digital industry arise and I

40:21

figured that kind of made sense because

40:23

the government plays a big role in

40:24

everything in China it's state

40:25

capitalism after all

40:27

um and so then I went to China and I

40:29

spoke to all the people who were

40:31

involved in the early takeoff of Alibaba

40:35

and Baidu and tencent and Cena and Soho

40:37

and all these digital companies in the

40:39

early days

40:40

and what was amazing to me is that it

40:43

wasn't really a story about government

40:45

support

40:46

actually all of these early companies

40:49

again Alibaba Baidu 10 cents

40:52

Secrets whatever each net all of them

40:55

they all had American Style Adventure

40:57

capital

40:58

and in fact they had been pretty much

41:00

ignored by the government because you

41:02

know the government's Tech policy was

41:04

they wanted to back you know kind of

41:07

more complicated deep Tech Hardware they

41:10

were very keen on backing a

41:12

semiconductor industry back in the 1990s

41:14

and that stuff mostly failed

41:19

um in the in the consumer internet

41:21

area which is of course where I Alibaba

41:24

and Baidu and all that stuff you know

41:26

they were consumer companies the

41:28

government thought oh consumer internet

41:30

who cares and so they kind of didn't

41:31

focus on it and that left the field open

41:34

to Silicon Valley type investors

41:37

who Incorporated those startups under

41:39

New York with dispute settlement under

41:42

New York law with parent companies

41:44

offshore in the Cayman Islands and the

41:46

ability to do stuff like issue stock

41:48

options for the early employees and this

41:50

was crucial

41:51

so Alibaba for example became a

41:54

world-class company because it could

41:56

hire world-class people and they could

42:00

hire those people because it could issue

42:02

stock options because the American

42:05

Venture capitalists had shown up with

42:07

Americans Silicon Valley lawyers would

42:10

structured the companies with the

42:12

ability to do uh Equity stock options

42:15

which really were not a thing in China

42:17

in fact you couldn't translate them into

42:18

Chinese at the beginning

42:20

so I think my point is here that you

42:23

know the reason why Silicon Valley took

42:25

off was Venture Capital the reason why

42:29

China internet took off was Venture

42:32

Capital Venture Capital turns out to be

42:34

the missing ingredient in all of these

42:37

Tech ecosystems

42:39

um and Israel is kind of the same thing

42:42

yet again it's a you know it's a little

42:44

bit different in the sense that the

42:45

government did very cleverly kick-start

42:48

The Venture Capital business in Israel

42:52

um it it basically issued a promise that

42:55

any private Venture capitalists that

42:56

wanted to set up in Israel would get a

42:58

lot of subsidies for their first funds

43:00

to get them started and that did attract

43:03

a lot of private Capital into Israel

43:05

there was also the fact that the Israeli

43:08

Army and I have some of the smartest

43:12

young scientists and and mathematicians

43:15

when they're 18 and brings them into a

43:17

special army unit and those people kind

43:21

of work together they bond together

43:22

they're trained in computer science and

43:24

cryptography and all of these key skills

43:27

and they do that for the Israeli

43:29

military for a while and then they spin

43:31

out and do their own companies and when

43:33

they spin out they all know each other

43:34

because they've worked together so it's

43:35

a bit like that strength of weak ties

43:38

kind of thing you know like in Silicon

43:39

Valley you can do due diligence on a

43:42

potential Tech founder in Israel very

43:44

easily because they're all part of this

43:46

military originated Network

43:48

and those things plus the government

43:50

support for veg Capital

43:52

kick-started the the network and now

43:55

today Israel actually has more sort of

43:58

VC and more startups per capita

44:02

than any other country in the world so

44:04

it's a small country obviously but

44:06

whether it punches way above its weight

44:10

and then if we go to chat for if we go

44:12

to Africa or southeast Asia and Latin

44:14

America what I'm seeing there is sort of

44:16

a repeat of the story where you know VCS

44:19

are moving in they're usually

44:22

um American trained VCS and they

44:26

understand the parallel and they are

44:29

repeating their magic I had a wonderful

44:31

conversation with an Indian uh veggie

44:34

capitalist uh if you if you indulge me

44:36

for a second I'll tell you an anecdote

44:37

that is not in my book

44:40

um where I was chatting after my book

44:42

came out uh with a

44:44

bangalore-based vegetables for Excel and

44:48

he explained to me that he'd been in

44:50

America he'd been to American Business

44:51

School he worked for Intel he was an

44:53

engineer

44:55

um and then he'd come back to his native

44:56

India and he started doing venture

44:57

capital and so I said okay so 2010 you

45:00

come back to India 2022 uh we're

45:03

speaking to each other tell me how

45:05

things changed between 2010

45:08

and 2022 and so he said to me okay well

45:11

in 2010 I did some Investments and after

45:13

a while one of the founders who I backed

45:16

came to me and said I need some help

45:19

and as a VC the VC says sure I always I

45:22

helped my Founders that's what I do

45:25

and the founder said okay I need some

45:27

help what I need is I want to get

45:29

married

45:31

and the VC goes it's been surprising you

45:34

know sure he's there to help but not

45:35

normally for marriage intermediation

45:38

Services right uh but the VC says you

45:43

want to get married okay sure what can I

45:45

do and the startup founder says well

45:49

um so I'm on I'm an entrepreneur and my

45:52

girlfriend's father thinks that

45:54

entrepreneurs are all losers

45:56

but you missed a venture capitalists

45:58

you've been to American Business School

46:00

you went for Intel you're a person of

46:02

high standing and stature and so if you

46:05

call my prospective father-in-law and

46:07

explain to him that entrepreneur does

46:08

not equal loser

46:10

then he'll let me marry his daughter so

46:12

the VC says okay I get it and he makes

46:14

the call the marriage goes ahead and I

46:17

say to him that's a great story now tell

46:20

me about 2022 are you still making those

46:22

phone calls so that marriages can

46:25

proceed and he says today

46:27

I don't need to anymore because all of

46:29

the father-in-laws are watching uh the

46:33

movie I mean the TV series about VC uh

46:37

Shark Tank and they are watching Shark

46:39

Tank in Hindi the Hindi version uh and

46:43

the point here again is that when you

46:46

have Venture capitalists or active in a

46:48

country for 10 or 12 years you change

46:51

the culture you change entrepreneurship

46:53

from something that looks like dangerous

46:55

failure and losers and you change that

46:58

into something which is high status and

47:00

people actually want

47:01

to be entrepreneurs and they're happy

47:03

for their daughters to marry

47:04

entrepreneurs they're happy for their

47:06

daughters to become entrepreneurs

47:07

hopefully

47:09

um and so I I do think that you know

47:11

Venture Capital becomes a machine for

47:14

manufacturing entrepreneurial carriage

47:16

I like that the machine for

47:18

manufacturing entrepreneurial courage

47:20

well we got about 10 minutes left uh

47:23

Sebastian which makes me upset because

47:25

we haven't even gotten into all the

47:26

other parts of the book but it is what

47:28

it is I want to move to the last chapter

47:30

in the book and spend the rest of our

47:32

time because a lot of stuff in there

47:35

specifically let's talk about feedback

47:37

effects and and and and and just just

47:40

talk a little bit about how important

47:43

the success leads to success but in the

47:47

risk of reputation of failure how is

47:49

that important for anyone trying to

47:51

either borrow money or get money for VCS

47:54

or get into the VC space how important

47:56

is reputational risk or reputational

47:58

effects

47:59

yeah I mean

48:02

um this is a huge question about uh any

48:05

business

48:06

um or creative Endeavor

48:08

where you know when a whole bunch of

48:11

people like something and and you you

48:14

get a good reputation you're much more

48:16

likely to get more followers more fans

48:20

more people who buy in right and this

48:23

again gets back to this parallel stuff

48:24

right feedback loops allow whoever is

48:27

the leader in a particular field like

48:29

the biggest influencer on Instagram

48:32

um will get even more uh followers

48:35

because you know you've got so many

48:37

followers already they talk to other

48:39

people and they become your followers

48:42

um and there's this terrific social

48:44

science experiment which kind of proved

48:46

this point by

48:48

um constructing a bunch of songs uh on a

48:51

song list on a computer

48:53

and then asking somebody to to listen to

48:56

the songs

48:57

and download the two

49:00

um that the first listener liked the

49:02

best so that you know there's 20 songs

49:04

to listen to the songs and then you

49:06

repeat that process with you know 50

49:09

other people who come on the site and

49:11

they they listen and each time the next

49:13

person who comes can see how many likes

49:16

and downloads the pre the you know the

49:19

previous listeners have awarded

49:21

and of course it happens that you know

49:23

there's social proof and so the songs

49:26

that already have the most likes carry

49:29

on getting more and more likes as you go

49:31

through the experiment and after 100

49:32

people there's this parallel effect

49:34

where there's this outlier winner

49:36

clearly the best song it's got you know

49:39

70 downloads and then the number two has

49:42

got 30 and there's a whole bunch of got

49:43

like seven

49:46

um and

49:47

um so it looks like it's clear which is

49:49

the best song but then the researcher

49:52

repeats the whole experiment with the

49:53

same list of songs the precise same list

49:55

and again there's a parallel winner but

49:57

there's a totally different one and what

50:00

that's telling us is that in venture

50:02

capital

50:03

there could be a thing going on where a

50:06

whole bunch of investors starting one

50:07

year in in Year One

50:09

and then you know three of them get

50:11

lucky and they have this they back some

50:14

company that turns out to be a unicorn

50:16

so then they have this wonderful

50:17

reputation all of the best entrepreneurs

50:20

go to them

50:21

and through no skid of their own they

50:24

carry on doing well because the best

50:26

founders of startups are coming to them

50:28

and wanting their money not somebody

50:30

else's money so I was a bit skeptical

50:33

about uh Vega capitalists when I began

50:36

writing my book and I almost didn't

50:38

write the book because I thought hey

50:39

well maybe it's just luck right

50:43

um and it was only when I really uh

50:45

drilled down more into the subject and I

50:47

started to spend time with these

50:49

investors and they gave me these very

50:51

kind of logical reasons as to how they

50:54

do the investment how they have had Ali

50:56

add value uh and help companies that

50:58

they invest in that I understood it was

51:01

not just luck and path dependency and it

51:04

was not just reputational effects there

51:06

is really a skill in being a good

51:08

venture capitalist and there's also

51:10

scale in being the right entrepreneur to

51:14

sort of pick the right venture

51:15

capitalist because it's a marriage right

51:17

those two things have to look at the

51:18

stories of the book you had a lot of

51:20

tension between the VC and an

51:22

entrepreneur

51:23

um we got about three minutes I saw a

51:25

guy about five minutes left I want to

51:26

try and squeeze in three quick questions

51:27

the first one is sort of abroad in this

51:29

conversation so you you were the Council

51:31

on Foreign Relations uh talk a little

51:34

bit about the geopolitics of venture

51:35

capitalism I think it was one of the

51:37

most fascinating sections in the book

51:39

reading about the geopolitical politics

51:41

of VC and what it means for the world

51:43

can you just say a few words about that

51:46

yeah so just quickly I I mean my point

51:48

is that that

51:49

um geopolitical Power uh is completely

51:53

connected to technological power I mean

51:56

if you imagine the power of the United

51:59

States without a company like you know

52:01

Microsoft or Intel

52:03

it would be much less

52:05

if you imagine the power of China

52:07

without Huawei uh or a company like

52:09

sense time it would be much less

52:12

so to have National Power you need a

52:16

national technology base and for that

52:19

it's helpful to have a great Venture

52:22

Capital business as well

52:24

okay two quick questions to wrap up

52:26

first one you could have alluded to when

52:28

you talk about Israel but the idea of

52:31

government-backed science right now

52:33

we're looking at a lot of governments

52:34

investing in clean tech the energy

52:36

transition is attracting a lot of money

52:38

from the privates from the government

52:39

how is important is the Synergy between

52:42

government-backed signs and Venture

52:44

capitalism

52:45

I think it can be super productive but

52:48

you have to get it right government

52:49

money should go into basic research

52:51

that's really important and constructive

52:53

government money should go into

52:57

um training climate scientists and phds

53:00

that are going to be helpful that's

53:01

really good

53:03

I don't think it's so great to put

53:05

government money into the investment

53:06

funds too much because we've had

53:09

experiences of that and you know in

53:11

Europe for example one of the problems

53:14

for the tech sector has been actually

53:16

too much government money that tends not

53:18

to be the most go-getting sloshing

53:21

around so I think you have to be careful

53:22

how you allocate the government's money

53:24

okay so this is a question that I that

53:27

I've been thinking about since I read

53:29

the book and it's about the fact that

53:32

you say Network's important the density

53:35

of the population in terms of Silicon

53:37

Valley for example is important but then

53:39

you have a lot of countries around the

53:40

world that have small population so I

53:42

had this idea and I want to see what you

53:44

think about it and I talk about creating

53:46

a virtual VC world where instead of you

53:49

physically being in Silicon Valley you

53:52

can bring together this sort of a

53:54

metaverse of VCS and still create the

53:56

same sort of environment what do you

53:57

think about that idea I think that's a

54:00

fantastic idea

54:01

um and I hope that's exactly what's

54:03

happening in Africa for example where

54:06

you have a lot of small markets and you

54:07

need a VC system that is cross-border

54:10

and that knits together different groups

54:13

and you can do that now with modern

54:15

Communications and so I'm hopeful that

54:17

we will see VC flourish in Africa okay

54:20

well so I always like to end these

54:22

conversations by having a little preview

54:25

into the mind of the author so in this

54:28

case tell us what's next for you because

54:30

I have a very brilliant idea I think

54:33

that I would love you to write on but

54:34

let me see what you have in my first

54:36

before I give you another assignment so

54:38

what's next for for Sebastian in terms

54:40

of writing another book well I can't

54:42

wait to hear what your assignment is but

54:44

uh my idea for the movement is to try to

54:46

write something about artificial

54:47

intelligence

54:49

um I've also looked at crypto but I'm

54:51

I'm slightly more drawn to artificial

54:53

intelligence

54:54

so so here is one that I think will be

54:56

very fascinating for you the world has

54:58

billions of people who like access to

55:00

energy billions of people who have

55:02

access to water and we talk about

55:05

raising those billions into sort of uh

55:07

the world and having them part of the

55:10

world society how can we sort of uh

55:12

change How We Do Development coming back

55:16

to your original book about the World

55:17

Bank and you have a lot of other books

55:19

being written how do we really raise

55:22

billions of people out of poverty and

55:25

create wealth without sort of what

55:28

burning the planet even further I think

55:30

that will be a fascinating book if you

55:31

could take that on for five years and

55:33

I'll have you back in five years to talk

55:35

about the book okay terrific thank you

55:37

so much for having me well thanks for

55:39

passion and thanks for joining us and

55:41

I'll turn over to elikia to give you

55:42

information how you can get access to

55:44

this information I'll see in DC by the

55:46

way when you do show up in the next

55:47

month or so okay terrific thank you all

55:50

right thanks Sebastian

Next in the archive

Influential Minds: A Conversation with Sebastian Mallaby — Influential Minds