Episode 021 hr 9 minWatch on YouTube

About this conversation

Universal access to electricity and public services: who benefits, who pays, and how inclusion can reshape communities.

Ask about this conversation

This conversation only
Answers are grounded in indexed transcripts only.

Transcript

05:49

in the labor leaders were concerned that

05:53

kids in the workforce when there was a

05:55

lot of immigration into the United

05:56

States were depressing the wage pages

06:00

and so they were in favor of universal

06:03

education so all these factors came in

06:06

to kick-start Universal education so my

06:09

question thought became and what

06:11

something is obviously being missed out

06:13

right it's not only democracy and

06:16

everybody should have education uh so

06:19

that's what led to the book and then

06:21

what I started seeing even in the world

06:23

of communications was a people would

06:26

focus on the marginalized poor people or

06:30

people in rural areas and how uh

06:33

Universal service that was the words

06:35

used in those days

06:37

um but telephone service will benefit

06:38

them and then they'll talk about the

06:41

system benefit in very general terms

06:43

they would use the word network

06:45

externalities that is you know the whole

06:47

idea that the bigger the network the

06:49

more valuable for it is but it's kind of

06:51

in a very general way so I thought that

06:54

was not doing the whole not covering all

06:57

the issues involved so I started looking

06:59

uh the book basically argues you have to

07:02

look at not only to the benefits to the

07:04

beneficiaries and to the costs to the

07:06

systems so they will talk about how much

07:08

it'll cost in the benefit system but you

07:10

also have to look at the cost to the

07:12

beneficiary because the beneficiary also

07:14

has costs psychological financial and so

07:17

on so that's what the book is it says

07:19

and the and the Endeavor is you have an

07:22

honest conversation you have to

07:24

understand everything uh so that's I

07:27

mean I can go on but if you're giving me

07:29

too much a white right question so yeah

07:31

so so so you have a service yeah whether

07:35

it's education or electricity yeah you

07:37

have an intended beneficiary right

07:40

they have some gains but there are some

07:42

downsides to them they travail yeah

07:45

in general there are some benefits to

07:47

the system in providing that service and

07:49

there's some cost to the system but then

07:51

you also introduced another very

07:53

interesting concept

07:54

you call it re-centering on reversal

07:57

which I interpret to mean okay in

08:00

pursuit of this there were some

08:01

unintended consequences

08:04

and if we had focused on that peripheral

08:06

issue and put it at the center would we

08:08

have done something different right so

08:10

what happens in in the book is uh so if

08:13

you wanted to understand fully not only

08:15

what was discussed and articulated we

08:19

also want to understand what was not

08:20

articulated and so what we did was we

08:24

developed this methodology actually is

08:25

inspired by Phil I agree who was a

08:28

professor at University of California at

08:30

Irvine uh UCLA I make a big mistake he

08:34

was at UCLA uh and he was informed of

08:37

course by other Scholars uh but we made

08:40

it very explicit uh so we were very

08:43

interested in the biggest Point here and

08:45

I'll explain the methodology because

08:47

Ralph has found the methodology to be of

08:49

interest uh is that we wanted to

08:52

understand blind spots and what I also

08:56

did a search in the you know literature

08:58

on public policy and I've been around

09:00

public policy literature for last 35

09:02

years and I found They Don't Really

09:05

discuss blind spots you know people

09:07

discuss all the debates and this and

09:09

that and it's much later you realize

09:11

something everybody missed out right so

09:13

we wanted to understand blind spots so

09:15

what we did was uh and it basically the

09:19

idea is any thought pattern or any you

09:22

know settled way of thinking uh or a

09:25

paradigm has a generative you know meta

09:29

or something central idea out of which

09:32

all the secondary ideas are derived from

09:34

and the nature of that is that every

09:38

generator metaphor also has a blind spot

09:41

because that's the nature of metaphors

09:43

you know they illuminate some things and

09:45

other things get left out and what

09:48

happens is things which don't fit in

09:50

that framework are ignored you know

09:53

because they'll just rubbish it away or

09:55

they'll explain it away they won't pay

09:57

attention so what we did was whenever we

10:00

noticed there was something you know

10:02

amiss we use that as the anchor and try

10:06

to look at it look at the situation from

10:09

that anchor and what what we are saying

10:11

is the settle pattern is not wrong it's

10:14

only partial right so you have a

10:16

complementary pattern reality as human

10:19

beings we can never fully understand the

10:20

universe right so any pattern is going

10:23

to be bounded but you have old pattern

10:25

and then you have an alternative not an

10:28

another pattern which complements or not

10:30

compliments but expands and

10:32

understanding so that's what we did so

10:34

so in a way the book is a compilation of

10:37

not only what people said in any

10:40

situation wherever we could find we did

10:42

a very wide search but we also did this

10:45

reverse re-centering on reversal to

10:47

expand understanding

10:49

but before we talk about what we've

10:51

learned from the past and how it can be

10:55

applied in the future let's talk a

10:56

little bit about universal access to

10:58

electricity as described in the book so

11:02

in this case it was really a domestic

11:03

view it was a desire to facilitate

11:07

electrification in rural areas

11:10

some competition between

11:12

the the integrated utilities that more

11:16

of a metropolitan perspective and and

11:18

the rural service providers do you want

11:20

to describe the the so that was actually

11:23

the first new technology I studied so I

11:26

was doing telephone networks internet it

11:28

was not just beginning at that time uh

11:31

and I you know I remember telling my

11:33

professor you know we are so thinking on

11:35

Telecom and I can tell you why we did

11:37

why I was finding that constraining and

11:40

I said this electricity is kind of

11:42

similar you have these lines of across

11:44

landscape and in rural areas the

11:47

population is less you know we were

11:48

doing telecommunications in rural areas

11:50

and he started he thought it was very

11:52

interesting and so I started reading

11:54

about electrification in rural areas

11:56

it's amazing experience because it's an

12:00

American story in many ways what was

12:02

happening was that electrification

12:04

occurred in uh cities and the utilities

12:09

would not take it to rural areas and

12:12

they would say it's just not sustainable

12:13

it costs so much per mile and if the

12:16

farmers kept demanding they would insist

12:19

that the farmers pay for the line or

12:21

have contracts which are sufficient to

12:24

pay back the electricity and they were

12:27

looking at rural electrification

12:29

networks and linear networks of urban

12:31

networks and there were some very

12:33

Progressive Engineers this is the New

12:36

Deal error you know FDR is around and so

12:39

on and they were saying that you know

12:42

well it doesn't have to be hugely

12:44

profitable as long as it is economically

12:47

sustainable we should find a way which

12:48

is again a very American thing because

12:50

you don't want a government subsidy all

12:52

the time here and what this they started

12:56

poking around and they were utterly

12:59

unpersuaded by the cost accounting I'm

13:01

not a cost accountant but the cost

13:03

accounting done by the utilities and

13:05

they realize you know in any network

13:07

industry the fixed cost is very high and

13:10

the variable cost is low and how you

13:11

allocate fixed costs can vary because

13:14

they found different utilities were

13:16

doing cost accounting very differently

13:18

but anyway they came out with this

13:20

approach where they said you can't make

13:22

rural areas extensions you know you have

13:26

to make a rural system so they call it

13:28

area coverage they said they're going to

13:30

cover entire areas and you're going to

13:32

get economies of scale and the utilities

13:35

were saying the farmer will use

13:37

electricity only for 60 watts that was

13:40

the metaphor they were using 60 watts a

13:42

day in the night and they were saying no

13:44

and they executed and they you know

13:48

changed the economics of making polls

13:49

they said the polls don't have to last

13:51

forever they change the economics of

13:53

meters you know and they went around

13:56

meter reading they got you know Farmers

13:59

to do meter reading and then they

14:02

realized appliances are very important

14:04

and so they worked with the appliance

14:07

manufacturers who saw a rural market and

14:10

is the whole gamut of things and they

14:12

and the story is the utilities are

14:14

totally missed out the latent demand in

14:18

rural areas and the reality is in a

14:21

rural area a home is not only a place

14:23

where people live but it's also a place

14:26

of production you know where people are

14:28

conducting farm and doing other things

14:30

yeah well I was fascinated by one of the

14:33

unintended concerts this is both of

14:34

electrification yeah and some of the

14:36

other services you you looked at was

14:39

that uh there had been a decline

14:41

perceived in rural populations uh not

14:45

just perceived but reality so bringing

14:48

these conveniences whether it's

14:49

electricity or or broadcasting or

14:52

libraries uh to rural areas would

14:56

enhance the quality of life

14:58

and restore the population but in fact

15:00

by making Farms far more efficient right

15:04

there was less labor and therefore less

15:07

of a reason to stay it happened across

15:10

many systems you know like even the

15:12

postal system in some ways that expanded

15:13

it happened with telephone system and uh

15:16

the thinking was which is very

15:18

instructive for our times they Define

15:21

the rural problem as a rural deficit

15:24

basically the rural areas lacked

15:26

something which the urban areas had they

15:29

even use words like civilizational

15:31

deficit or and things like that uh and

15:34

the backdrop to it is it's around that

15:37

time when the U.S is going to become

15:39

more urban or Urban majority than rural

15:42

majority and there was this big fear

15:44

that as America loses its rural areas

15:47

American character will be lost uh the

15:49

similar thing that happened when the

15:51

American migration was occurring

15:53

occurring across the continent and the

15:57

West Was going away basically and there

15:59

was a big fear that once Americans

16:00

reached the Pacific the American Spirit

16:03

will be disappeared uh and so a lot of

16:06

these programs were driven by those

16:07

ideas the idea was that if you make a

16:10

rural life as good as urban life people

16:13

won't leave and the exact opposite

16:15

happened uh case after case uh because

16:19

one of the things was what Ralph said is

16:21

that they thought they looked at the

16:23

socket and they said if we have a socket

16:25

and then we can farmer can pump water

16:28

with this and can do this and that they

16:30

were so thrilled by what that socket can

16:32

do for the farmer the

16:35

forgot that if every farmer did that

16:37

there will be less need for Farm Workers

16:40

in the rural areas right and also they

16:43

looked at their benefits what they will

16:45

get they also forgot that they get

16:48

integrated into the Metropolitan economy

16:50

they may gain but there will be other

16:53

players in this integrated economy who

16:55

will gain much more than them and in

16:58

asymmetrical ways which will be not good

17:01

for them so they actually ended up not

17:04

only getting depopulated which is their

17:06

biggest fear it also this there's

17:08

actually this is a word certified the

17:10

rural area the rural areas are no longer

17:12

rural areas they became basically

17:15

extensions of urban life you know

17:18

sir let's stick with this basic having

17:22

access to a socket

17:23

by definition

17:26

pursuit of universal access suggests

17:28

that there's a population segment that

17:30

doesn't have access and they need to be

17:32

helped and oftentimes the socioeconomic

17:33

reasons sometimes this ideological

17:35

reason sometimes is geographic reasons

17:37

that have economic implications

17:40

but I forget the statistic there are

17:42

many people in the world who do not have

17:44

access to electricity that's not the

17:47

case the United States right now but

17:50

sub-Saharan Africa certainly you make

17:52

the case in your research that universal

17:55

access is an American export yet this

17:59

morning I think we heard a little bit

18:00

more about the importance of connecting

18:02

eight Billion Lives yeah how do you

18:04

from your research how do you see

18:06

electrification being pursued at the

18:09

very basic level in some parts so the

18:12

first before I get into that question

18:15

I'm not against Universities at all I'm

18:17

just saying you have to do it in a more

18:19

thought out manner uh so in the rest of

18:22

the world as I understand it uh till uh

18:26

you know 1980s all kinds of utilities

18:29

including telephones electricity were

18:31

all either run by Ministries or

18:34

government-owned public sector

18:36

corporations and uh the concept was

18:39

Public Service uh and the idea was that

18:43

because these are State oriented

18:46

Enterprises by their very nature they

18:49

have an obligation to serve everybody

18:51

but in practice I mean I I hope anyone

18:56

offend anybody but in most parts of many

18:58

parts of the world it didn't play out

19:00

for various reasons and I'm not going to

19:02

critique the reasons maybe later in the

19:04

evening if somebody wants I can give you

19:06

the reasons I think uh but uh what you

19:10

can see it in the world of telephones

19:11

landline phones you know till the 1980s

19:14

many parts of the world they were like

19:16

one or two per hundred it's kind of

19:18

crazy looking back right but in America

19:21

we have a very different model because

19:24

we have had private companies running

19:26

utilities for 100 years more than 100

19:29

years so we developed this concept of

19:33

universal access uh and uh so here the

19:37

utility

19:38

as a profit oriented entity is not by

19:42

inherent nature obligated to execute

19:46

public service but the compact it makes

19:50

with the society to be given certain

19:53

privileges like rights or ways and you

19:57

know monopolies and so on for laying

19:59

wires and so on has to execute so then

20:01

there's a super will supervision of

20:04

somebody held responsible in this is

20:07

decoupled and and there's a certain

20:09

energy of the American adversarial

20:12

system which yeah primes it so yeah so

20:17

I'm going to articulate a vision that I

20:20

think is probably commonly held by many

20:22

in this room I'll I'll do it by first

20:28

offering a quiz

20:30

it's not a test of your knowledge it's a

20:33

test of your honesty no one's ever

20:35

failed this quiz one person did once it

20:37

was an employee of mine

20:39

and uh and he was just being a smart

20:41

Outlook and the quiz is simply how many

20:44

people woke up this morning and said I

20:46

cannot wait to use a kilowatt hour

20:49

right that's typically the answer that I

20:51

get from people how many people woke up

20:53

this morning said if I do have to use a

20:55

kilowatt hour I hope it poisons the

20:57

planet

20:58

oh okay we raise the hand how many

21:01

people said that I hope that when I want

21:03

to use a kilowatt hour and I flip the

21:04

switch it's not there

21:07

okay so everyone passed the quiz I I

21:10

know I was taking a chance everybody's

21:12

got a full belly the energy levels are

21:14

down but typically that's the way it

21:16

works

21:17

so the vision for the future is that

21:19

people use only the electricity they

21:21

need right so if we can have comfort in

21:24

this room and use less electricity

21:25

through more efficient appliances we'd

21:27

all be happy our bills would be lower

21:30

the electricity could be produced more

21:32

more cleanly than ever before

21:34

in the old days that meant without soot

21:37

particles landing on my head nowadays it

21:40

means without carbon dioxide being

21:42

emitted and if I can have it not only

21:44

during Blue Sky days but during storms

21:47

and it would be more resilient than ever

21:50

before I'd be a very happy person

21:52

so maybe we're not talking about just

21:55

having access to a socket it's it's uh

21:58

it's less it's cleaner and it's more

22:00

resilient than ever before

22:02

we don't have universal access to that

22:05

in the United States and I dare say in

22:07

most parts of the planet today

22:10

so how do we learn from some of the

22:12

impediments that existed in the other

22:14

systems let me let me offer one

22:17

so right now retail rates and many

22:20

policies in the US have said at the

22:22

state level

22:23

and yet we have we heard talk before the

22:26

inflation reduction Act we've heard the

22:29

president speak about electrification of

22:30

Transportation so we have certain

22:32

National objectives that are shared to

22:35

varying degrees at the local level but

22:37

not uniformly so

22:39

so what happens when regulation has

22:41

bifurcation what happens when there

22:43

appears to be a an optimal approach if

22:46

it's uniform but you sacrifice some

22:48

local uniqueness and some of the perhaps

22:53

conflicting ideologies of different

22:56

social practical forms so the thing is

22:58

in the U.S that's how things have always

23:01

happened uh till after Civil War it's

23:05

become more a federal level

23:07

so actually I it's not in the book but I

23:10

have another uh with my colleague

23:11

another colleague a model uh on how

23:14

educations are inspired by how Universal

23:18

education was developed in the United

23:19

States we call a layered diffusion model

23:23

and I'm just going to read a few

23:25

passages from my book If I Could

23:26

intelligent not very long ones uh so

23:29

like in education you know the story

23:31

goes that started in Massachusetts first

23:34

and slowly things spread from

23:37

Massachusetts uh but so like I'm just

23:40

going to read four or five lines here

23:41

and then maybe another passage somewhere

23:43

here so over time the colonies increase

23:46

the minimum level of Education specified

23:48

in the Universal education laws a 1642

23:53

Massachusetts law specified that all

23:55

children should be taught to read that

23:58

was all in

24:00

1660 New Haven colonies there was a new

24:03

colony called new heaven now we have a

24:04

city called New Haven um added a writing

24:07

requirement subsequently colonies

24:10

expanded the scope of universal

24:12

education to history geography geometry

24:14

and so on and so what happens in the U.S

24:17

is uh because we have a federal system

24:20

with very decentralized in each one

24:23

famous judge had called it Brandeis I

24:26

guess uh their Laboratories of democracy

24:29

uh and Innovation occurs here than the

24:31

other states copy and then that's how

24:33

the Innovation spread uh and uh and we

24:38

are all seeing also in education right

24:40

now so like uh I'm going to read a few

24:42

more lines

24:43

so in 2014 Tennessee launched a program

24:47

for tuition-free education at a

24:49

community college in the first two years

24:51

of college

24:52

and now Oregon launched after that and

24:54

now Arkansas the Delaware Kentucky and

24:57

the many other states so in America

25:00

things happen in an incremental way

25:02

states are copying each other uh that

25:04

doesn't mean there's no scope for

25:07

federal action there are certain things

25:09

only the federal government can do

25:11

especially if it's some kind of a market

25:13

national wide Market they want to sit so

25:16

that's my very broad response to you

25:18

yeah I was impressed I did not know that

25:21

Horace Mann was a yeah

25:23

yeah it was also encouraging to me

25:25

because every once in a while

25:27

tend to get a little bit pessimistic

25:29

about some of the polarization that's

25:31

occurring in our country and it's nice

25:32

to know that it was in 1640 that there

25:34

were disagreements over how education

25:37

should be designed in different colonies

25:39

and even today we have that debate going

25:41

on a certain States about what is and

25:43

what isn't a legitimate uh

25:45

uh curriculum I also found the fact that

25:48

I think in broadcasting there was this

25:50

issue as well right do you allow

25:52

Networks

25:54

decide what programming to offer right

25:56

and I can have it tells the microphone's

25:58

going out because

25:59

the the folks who are running it don't

26:01

like what we're saying

26:04

but but in broadcasting there was a

26:06

similar local versus uh Network issue

26:09

was there not right so they're outside

26:12

kind of backfires because the whole

26:14

American Broadcasting uh regulatory

26:18

approach was to preserve what they

26:21

called uh

26:22

local public sphere so they thought if

26:25

they had radio stations in every

26:29

little Community will create local

26:32

programming and there'll be a local

26:34

voice

26:35

they didn't realize that they'll be

26:38

networking developed because the

26:40

transmitters will get centrally

26:42

connected and then once a network

26:45

developed it made the receiving nodes

26:49

more and more passive because it is more

26:52

and more convenient

26:53

or a network like NVC or CBS to

26:57

uh you know collect develop uh high

27:00

quality programming it depends on how

27:02

you define uh quality uh and generate

27:05

the advertising revenue and basically it

27:09

destroyed the local public sphere the

27:11

bigger story there is that when radio

27:14

first came in the corporations

27:17

thought broadcasting was a nuisance

27:19

because the corporation corporations

27:21

were bent upon developing

27:23

Telegraph and it was called the wireless

27:26

because they thought it'll be an

27:28

extension of the wired Network the wired

27:30

Network could not reach ships

27:33

and the radio was like broadcasting was

27:37

actually understood by young boys in

27:39

those days uh teenagers they started

27:43

playing music in the garages and then

27:45

their friends started listening to them

27:47

these are the you know predecessors of

27:50

today's hackers and they started sending

27:52

each other postcards play these music uh

27:55

and then somebody at Westinghouse

27:57

realized hey this is interesting and

27:59

then there's a development of

28:00

broadcasting

28:02

but at some point there were thousands

28:04

of radio stations in the United States

28:06

and there were churches and schools and

28:09

so on but once the networks come in they

28:11

just squeeze out everything else so the

28:13

biggest story there is how much of

28:16

messiness you allow to exist and how

28:20

much I've systemized centralized

28:23

planning you're allowed to exist and

28:24

it's I think very pertinent

28:27

for today's issues in electricity

28:31

because there was a discussion on our

28:33

table there's a talk about mini grids

28:35

and then they're going to be these giant

28:37

networks and then what will happen in

28:39

the future

28:40

and my bet is initially there will be a

28:44

lot of mini grids also happen in

28:47

telephone because utilities wouldn't go

28:49

into rural areas Farmers literally

28:52

started stringing wire and making their

28:54

own networks but once in the longer

28:56

story of course I can go into details

28:59

one say once atnt became dominant

29:01

everything got choked out uh and so the

29:04

issue is how much of balance between

29:07

messiness and highly organized systems

29:10

and I know the grid is a very complex

29:13

you know system and it's not used to too

29:17

much of variance but as new energy

29:21

sources are coming one of the big things

29:22

is what do you plug in

29:24

I think the honest thing for the for the

29:26

electric industry would be to understand

29:29

how much is how much of messiness is

29:31

technically possible and how much you

29:33

are willing to live with so you know

29:36

yeah actually I do want to explore the

29:39

18c learnings

29:41

yeah but so states can learn from each

29:45

other if they have reasonably consistent

29:48

ideological perspectives on what needs

29:51

to take place

29:52

but even if they do in the case of

29:54

renewable energy there may not be access

29:57

to the to the resource you have some

30:00

states that are windier than others and

30:01

some locations that are sunnier than

30:03

others

30:04

a way to bridge that Gap and provide

30:07

universal access is through massive

30:10

infrastructure of transmission so I

30:13

don't know if there's a parallel between

30:15

that and the long lines of ATT uh I

30:19

don't know I can tell you the long lines

30:21

of it I know there's a lot of

30:22

interconnect and there was early morning

30:23

discussion interconnecting Norway and

30:27

Denmark or what is it Britain under the

30:30

ocean

30:31

um yeah so the story at uh the atnt

30:35

story the story to learn there

30:37

is uh at T ignores rural areas just like

30:41

the utilities do and actually the ATT

30:42

story happened before the

30:44

electrification story

30:46

a farmer just started making their own

30:47

networks and uh initially 18d ignored

30:51

them but then the farmers started

30:53

expanding into urban areas the nearest

30:56

small town because the farmer had to

30:58

connect with the agricultural supplier

31:00

and so on and they were about 20 000

31:04

these small telephone entities and there

31:06

became half the U.S market and then ATP

31:10

woke up and their strategy was making

31:11

long lines and the Theodore whale was

31:14

the architect of the Bell System he

31:16

thought if they if they interconnected

31:19

all the att's local networks and they

31:23

made a national network nobody could

31:24

compete with them which was true and

31:27

this was the blind spot of the small

31:29

telephone companies because they were

31:31

growing nearby and they thought hey we

31:33

you know expanding but once they had to

31:37

expand further they just scored

31:39

yeah so I want to come back to the

31:41

geographic differences in a few minutes

31:43

but one of the areas that we haven't

31:45

spent a lot of time talking about is

31:47

universal access when it's being

31:50

limited by economic differences even at

31:54

the same location right somebody who can

31:56

versus somebody who cannot afford

31:58

to buy something a classic example

32:01

nowadays would be rooftop solar right uh

32:04

the attempts to build community solar in

32:07

those areas where

32:09

it's adequate to provide the power but

32:11

perhaps people cannot afford the panels

32:13

another example would be Energy

32:15

Efficiency that that highly efficient

32:18

dishwasher that washing machine that

32:20

that air conditioning unit that will

32:23

save people money over the long term

32:24

costs more money up front and for people

32:27

may not be able to

32:29

to afford it at that point how do you

32:32

how have prior systems overcome the

32:35

income disparities that get in the way

32:37

of universal access so yeah so in the

32:40

world of telephones and internet they

32:43

tried it and I don't think it was

32:44

successful I may be wrong uh they tried

32:47

uh creating community centers so the

32:51

idea was you can't have it in the home

32:52

but you could have it in the community

32:54

uh so maybe there could be a

32:56

neighborhood mini grid I mean people

32:58

fool in money instead of having on their

33:00

rooftop they have it in the neighborhood

33:04

um so that's the one which comes to my

33:06

mind uh I know the Rea also the rural

33:09

electrification Administration also gave

33:12

loans for inside wiring and things like

33:15

that so that's the other part of it in

33:19

general though in Prior systems has has

33:22

social support networks or subsidies if

33:25

I may use the word been an effective

33:28

method or has it really been dependent

33:30

upon technology reducing prices yeah

33:33

whatever greater access was doing

33:35

I can't give you a definite answer on

33:37

that but I can I have another parallel

33:39

there because

33:40

uh what happens in the world of

33:43

telephones is there are actually and

33:47

this is something to be learned here

33:49

there was a lot of fog on what universal

33:51

access actually meant and I have a sense

33:53

same thing is in the electrification

33:56

world right now I see the things I've

33:58

been trying to read

33:59

uh so for example uh

34:03

a t in the 80s was saying uh that attend

34:09

philosophy was one system one policy

34:12

Universal service and the idea was that

34:15

only if 18 he had a monopoly it could

34:18

cross subsidize and it could make sure

34:21

everybody has telephone service and you

34:25

know one of those pieces of scholarship

34:26

I personally respect a lot by a book by

34:30

Milton Mueller um

34:32

he actually went into the old archives

34:36

and of all things at The Archives uh any

34:41

made the case and very convincingly

34:43

actually ATT mythology was that's what a

34:47

Theodore Vale was had articulate the

34:50

philosophy actually what Theodore whale

34:52

was saying was he he wanted all the

34:55

networks to interconnect because when

34:57

there were multiple small networks many

35:00

cities had two three competing networks

35:02

and if you had one telephone Network you

35:03

couldn't talk to the other and ATM they

35:06

wanted

35:07

basically he was saying the only way

35:09

everybody can talk to everybody is by

35:10

giving me a monopoly he did not mean

35:13

that everybody should have telephone

35:16

service why because you can see he was

35:18

not willing to go into rural areas right

35:20

right so he didn't mean that so what

35:23

happens with the telephones is and why

35:25

did ATT and the 80s started saying this

35:28

because it was facing Anti-Trust lawsuit

35:30

which eventually led to the breakup of

35:33

as he was trying to justify its Monopoly

35:35

so what's the silent story of universal

35:37

access in telephones right so what

35:40

happens is till World War One World War

35:42

II only only about 50 percent of the

35:46

population has telephone service in the

35:48

United States uh and in the 65 onwards

35:52

till 1980 is where the real thing takes

35:56

off it reaches you know 95 but it

35:59

happens in a very quiet uh technocratic

36:02

way and what happens is that basically

36:05

The Regulators decide that all the cost

36:11

savings from the technological advances

36:13

in Long Distance

36:15

Communications are going to be used to

36:17

subsidize University Service because the

36:21

last mile problem is there many systems

36:23

uh same thing in electric telephones it

36:25

was the most expensive and the

36:27

politicians liked it because it kept

36:30

people happy with low rates uh and they

36:32

have you see how the technocratic you

36:35

know because allocating money is also a

36:37

complex thing and the whole thing was

36:39

very quiet nobody talked about Universal

36:41

service still the Anti-Trust loss came

36:44

action came into existence

36:47

yeah I failed to mention I should have

36:49

that we will take questions if there are

36:51

some in the group I know that we're live

36:52

streaming we'll just repeat the question

36:54

for the remote audience

36:56

one of the fascinating components of the

36:59

systems you studied I found was the

37:01

postal system yeah and how much it it

37:04

affected life in rural America literally

37:07

changing people's addresses and uh and

37:10

and creating a grid that they never

37:13

thought of on their own how how

37:16

difficult or how compelling does the

37:18

case need to be for the for the

37:21

system-wide deployment the universal

37:23

access to actually change things at such

37:25

a basic level as it was in the postal

37:28

system is that something that's just

37:29

done by force of law or is it a sales

37:31

job uh it's the logic of big Capital you

37:36

know uh so what happens it's a little

37:40

the cost so what happens is

37:42

that when the rural areas start getting

37:46

Postal System the issue was delivering

37:49

the mail to individual Farmers homes so

37:53

earlier the farmers had to go to a

37:55

nearby post office to pick up the mail

37:57

and when the postal system starts

38:00

delivering the mail they would require

38:02

the rural areas to have a logical

38:05

addressing system right and it happens

38:09

even now when the emergency services

38:10

start going to rural areas so the rule

38:13

in many parts of the world you know the

38:15

addressing system is not very logical in

38:17

our sense you know I've been I got

38:19

totally lost in one place because

38:21

interesting system was such a different

38:23

logic which I didn't understand logic

38:25

could be because this number of houses

38:27

one this number is three two and this is

38:29

three it doesn't make sense to me but

38:31

this is grandfathers this is fathers

38:33

this is mine right and you had to have a

38:37

uniform addressing system because it was

38:39

now part of a system and now the male

38:42

van had to come and the mail carrier did

38:45

not have to know the local address and

38:48

then also now the mail carrier had to

38:51

wear a uniform because it's no longer a

38:54

local mail carrier and now you have

38:56

system flows going through the rural

38:58

area so this is also how they totally

39:00

lost being part of rural because in

39:02

rural areas one of the saving Graces is

39:04

everybody knows everybody right and so

39:07

they became a part of a very

39:08

decontextualized grid system basically

39:11

that's a cost yeah yeah I found it

39:14

fascinating how how much benefit there

39:16

was to non-local participants whether it

39:19

was mail-order catalogs of magazines and

39:24

various other participants but it seemed

39:26

that in all of the seven systems you

39:28

studied yeah the the take I had was that

39:31

the motivation was primarily to bring a

39:34

benefit to the individual class that did

39:38

not have access

39:40

was there ever a time when no the

39:42

motivation was the benefits to the

39:45

system yeah I you know I think mostly it

39:48

was benefits to the system you do not

39:50

not articulated

39:51

mostly universal access thoughts when it

39:56

becomes in the interest of the powerful

39:58

people not always though because

40:01

sometimes like I mentioned Farmers

40:04

forcing the hand of utilities by taking

40:08

actions on their own so actually the

40:10

book argues there are two Logics playing

40:12

out in these universal access one is the

40:15

logic of inclusion that everybody should

40:17

be included and everybody talks about

40:19

that and it's in everybody's interest

40:21

you know and there's a beauty to it and

40:23

you can see the farmers wanting

40:24

telephone service is also in their

40:26

logical inclusion but there's also a

40:29

logic of binding that is you want to

40:31

bind everybody into the logic of the

40:34

system like the grid we saw right and

40:36

that is never articulated so like I

40:38

mentioned earlier the powerful people

40:41

the patricians of Boston if you want to

40:43

give the typical metaphoric you know

40:45

stereotype uh then one new immigrants to

40:49

destabilize the American political

40:51

system uh or you know even the libraries

40:54

you know they didn't want they thought

40:56

the libraries will keep people away from

40:57

the pubs or the bars you know and they

41:00

call it the Asylum of the drunk or the

41:02

you know and and so on so all these

41:04

systems were made to stabilize and in

41:07

fact Horace Mann you mentioned uh you

41:09

know I'm sure his motivations were good

41:12

um from what I can make out

41:14

um but one of the ways he had to build a

41:17

coalition to everybody to support

41:19

Universal education one of the things

41:21

which really struck me was

41:23

the metaphor he used he went and told

41:25

the rich that education is a balanced

41:28

wheel of society which really struck me

41:31

because in the world of Education we

41:32

always talk about questioning and you

41:34

know critical critical understanding and

41:36

so on uh so he was basically saying that

41:39

the educated people are unlikely to

41:42

create problems in fact they were sold

41:44

even as a antidote to strikes because in

41:47

the late 1800s there were a lot of

41:49

strikes you know railroad strikes and so

41:51

on Irish immigrants that are and you

41:54

know other Italian immigrants and groups

41:56

there was revolting so it was seen and

41:59

there have been places where the teacher

42:02

has been equated to a policeman or a

42:06

constable you know and so so so it's so

42:10

what happens in these debates is the

42:12

celebratory logic is the logic of

42:14

inclusion and I'm sure even the people

42:16

who have other Logics at play like the

42:19

logic of binding like you know look at

42:21

all our motivations as human beings

42:23

they're not they're always complex you

42:25

know they're always good and selfish and

42:28

we always foreground them you know the

42:30

more which is the celebratory uh and I

42:33

think it does not lead to an honest

42:35

discussion I am accepting you know uh in

42:37

fact I think uh you know the the

42:40

enlightened way of getting Universal

42:43

education like even you know it's

42:45

electricification is people are saying a

42:48

lot of things and it's to me seems very

42:51

diffuse I may be wrong uh but it's it's

42:54

got a loaded with a lot of things going

42:56

on I think the trick would be to find

42:59

the sweet spot where a lot of interest

43:02

intersect in ways which can be you know

43:07

leveraged fruitfully and to understand

43:10

that sweet spot of intersection and to

43:14

come up with a compelling metaphor you

43:17

know a compelling you know vocabulary to

43:21

act to activate that impulse

43:25

so let's talk a little bit because you

43:27

raised the interesting topic of the

43:29

library system about what we mean by

43:31

universal access I think the statistic

43:33

you quote in the book is that 25 of

43:36

Americans have never been to their

43:37

public world it's more than that uh I

43:40

had about 50 60 don't use it regularly

43:42

25 right they're 25 yeah so so even

43:45

though there's either some tens of

43:47

thousands of public libraries this is

43:49

maybe not as relevant internet age but

43:52

it was relevant Once Upon a Time

43:55

what do we mean by universal access does

43:57

it simply mean that individuals have the

44:00

opportunity or does it mean that they

44:02

actually use it because there are

44:04

implications for electricity right if we

44:06

want to make clean carbon free energy

44:08

available but not require its use

44:12

that has some significant implications

44:14

for climate change right I think that is

44:17

the most telling example in the whole

44:19

book I'm you know so thrilled you I

44:22

think you said he was you're brilliant

44:29

I want to be facile about it but that is

44:32

a worth telling example why because uh

44:35

so what is universal access it's just

44:37

the opportunity right so if you create

44:39

when they've created a telecenters you

44:41

know where the idea was you create

44:42

Community networks and people will go

44:44

and use the network if you can't get in

44:46

the home people wouldn't go there is

44:48

that universal access uh and it's also

44:51

very telling because what the Library

44:53

community does and you know Library does

44:55

a lot of good things I'm not criticizing

44:57

I know the libraries are a lot of people

44:59

have a lot of they're very big friends

45:01

or libraries uh I also use libraries but

45:04

it's very telling because what they do

45:06

they will openly acknowledge if you look

45:08

at the reports you know they'll openly

45:10

acknowledge 25 people never come to the

45:12

library never ever right uh and then 50

45:15

come only two three times a year and

45:18

then they'll focus on all the activities

45:20

they'll do and they'll provide all kind

45:23

of statistics about uh you know like how

45:27

much per user what activity so my deeper

45:31

questions just that so is the obligation

45:34

done that okay we are given them an

45:36

opportunity and they'll say how much

45:38

driving distance and it's very

45:40

interesting it's only 15 20 miles I

45:42

forget the statistics everything is very

45:44

close by so is the is the responsibility

45:46

over

45:48

but then you have to think deeper right

45:50

and then we go into the what's the

45:53

mindset of a library the metaphor the

45:55

generative metaphor right so the

45:58

generator metaphor actually if you go

45:59

it's more explicit you know one of the

46:01

good things about the 19th century uh is

46:06

that they were very open about their bad

46:08

thoughts you know like so they were

46:11

clearly articles which we are very much

46:13

more sensitive about you know being

46:14

politically correct and so on um

46:17

but they're basically

46:20

word the basic metaphor is the library

46:22

is a teacher librarian or the teacher

46:25

and the person who comes in is the

46:28

student you know and the sensibilities

46:31

are middle class and you know the

46:34

furniture the Ambiance and they and yeah

46:37

the other telling thing is they they

46:40

actually know at least when I can make

46:41

out hardly anything about who doesn't

46:44

come so they haven't even systematically

46:46

try to find out who doesn't come there's

46:49

some scattered Silhouettes uh and so I

46:52

think and there have been critiques the

46:54

the union leadership scripture

46:57

criticized libraries for having a very

46:59

alienating environment to a blue collar

47:02

worker uh and uh and so

47:06

so what else should the library be right

47:08

uh and the other way of looking at the

47:10

library would be maybe it should be like

47:12

a tool shed you know uh there are a lot

47:14

of Tools around then people come and do

47:17

their stuff you know like maybe the

47:18

maker space which is the upper end now

47:20

uh people come around and then there are

47:23

people who help them do what they want

47:25

and to be fair I saw my local library

47:28

has uh internet of they have a library

47:32

of things it's kind of interesting they

47:34

have a room now with a bunch of things

47:35

so it can't be my book so they are there

47:39

on their own figuring in some things out

47:42

on their own so yeah

47:47

I want us to stick to the the tradition

47:50

of the Jeff is to allow some interaction

47:52

from the from the audience right even

47:54

though we're streaming live if you're

47:55

asking questions your question is going

47:56

to be streamed live to the world so just

47:58

be prepared so I guess David you have a

48:00

question

48:02

it's very interesting so let me just

48:05

extrapolate a little what you said

48:09

and deal with the issue of resilience

48:12

universal access to resilience okay

48:15

we're in an interesting transformative

48:17

industry interesting how do you respond

48:21

to universal access to resilience I'll

48:23

give you a little hint

48:24

distributive generation

48:26

microgrids so

48:28

help me understand

48:30

how we would address the issue of

48:32

universal access to resilience since

48:34

we're all concerned about climate change

48:37

all the challenges that are created from

48:40

climate change all the interruptions of

48:41

electric service help me understand how

48:44

we would apply what you said to us today

48:46

to Universal

48:48

universal access to resilience

48:51

so David I've never heard that term and

48:55

I'm awed by the term it's you know it's

48:57

a great term uh universal access

48:59

to resilience

49:01

I don't have an answer maybe you have

49:03

some thoughts and I can play with those

49:06

maybe you can help me out you promised

49:09

[Laughter]

49:14

well you know it it brings up a broader

49:17

question right because there are ways to

49:19

enhance reliability and resilience

49:22

undergrounding well that's doable in

49:24

Washington it's a little bit tougher in

49:26

Nebraska

49:27

uh backup generation that's possible for

49:31

a large industrial User it's a little

49:33

bit more expensive at the residential

49:35

level

49:36

the issue becomes in my mind at least

49:38

who pays

49:39

right so clearly there are benefits to

49:42

the individual and they should pay for

49:44

some of that and there are benefits to

49:46

society and they should pay for some of

49:48

that who are but how much and who's that

49:50

they I mean if I choose to live in a

49:53

beautiful Wilderness Center area then

49:56

should I really expect somebody who's

50:00

struggling to pay their monthly rent

50:02

maybe even making minimum wage in an

50:04

urban area to pay for my resilience and

50:08

there's no easy way to answer that

50:10

obviously that's the purpose of public

50:11

policy

50:13

it does I think yeah it's a it's a

50:15

wonderfully put question uh so yeah

50:18

they're disparity and resilience I've

50:20

never heard of that uh but that's a very

50:23

interesting way of thinking

50:26

um and we we can see in the United

50:28

States we can see uh the commercial sub

50:32

entities have power supply which is much

50:35

more resilience than uh a household a

50:39

neighborhood so there's a disparity

50:40

there and it's kind of warranted but if

50:43

people are going to live at home and

50:45

work from home then that's an issue but

50:49

I think it's a big issue around the

50:50

world I know for sure because that's

50:52

when I look at the statistics and they

50:54

say only about 700 million people don't

50:58

have electricity I don't buy it because

51:00

there are a lot of places in the world

51:02

there is no resilient power supply and

51:04

their power is not available for half a

51:07

day you know we can't imagine in the

51:09

United States uh so what is that

51:12

connection if I can't have a

51:14

refrigerator I mean like

51:17

so what will be the solution you know I

51:19

can tell you from

51:21

uh the network internet uh telephone the

51:27

communications world

51:29

so one model of resilience was the Bell

51:31

System model and the Bell System model

51:35

they should call them Bell heads you

51:36

know they all had I was a great fan of

51:38

Dell company as a whole

51:40

uh but they they and I think there's a

51:43

parallel with the electrical utility

51:45

world because they were a very

51:48

engineering culture and they were very

51:52

proud of reliability and security and

51:55

you can see it even today people like to

51:57

use facts they're highly secure than the

52:00

internet uh and that was built into the

52:04

engineering mind but then they the what

52:07

put threw them off gear was something

52:09

what's happening with the mini grids

52:10

right here is a Silicon Valley mindset

52:13

where they started local area networks

52:15

and local indiators became expanded it's

52:17

a whole different mindset uh either

52:20

they're flatter Network so the Bell

52:21

System was very hierarchical uh and uh

52:25

and the the computer industry has

52:29

resilience and you can see it in the

52:30

design of the internet itself is by

52:33

having multiple paths you know so it's

52:35

not that any one path is resilient like

52:38

unlike the telephone World they have

52:41

alternate paths

52:42

but how do you in a scarce economy

52:46

economically scarce world where they

52:49

barely can get a single connection how

52:51

do you

52:52

provide multiple ads I do not know

52:56

that's what you're making what that's

52:57

what's making me think it could be a

53:00

combination of some level of

53:02

solar panels and rooftop and and my yeah

53:06

and and centrally powered Supply because

53:09

the reality

53:10

most probably is going to be when the

53:13

utilities

53:14

fully gear up they'll generate economies

53:18

of scale and technological advances just

53:20

because they have the resources the

53:23

capital resources and also ability to

53:26

Marshal human talents

53:28

that at some point

53:30

maybe that's a matter of public policy

53:33

maybe they

53:35

incentivize the utilities to also do

53:38

things will help mini grids so I'm just

53:42

I'm rambling yeah

53:44

two stories come to mind on the

53:46

resilience front uh we had an event as

53:49

many of you remember called superstorm

53:51

Sandy

53:52

in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic region

53:54

10 years ago now and uh somehow

53:57

miraculously my house did not lose power

54:00

I was CEO at the time it may not have

54:03

been a miracle in that and we had a lot

54:06

of fans turned out my son was a senior

54:08

in high school so all of his classmates

54:10

came over to do their college

54:12

applications because we had power I was

54:14

not home for three days four days I

54:16

don't remember what it was but my wife

54:19

kept getting visited by uh some

54:21

neighbors who were Furious that they did

54:24

not have power they were more Furious

54:26

that we did have power and they were in

54:28

their 80s we don't know how they kept

54:30

making their way to the house didn't

54:32

play all the time

54:34

can I ask how did your house of course

54:37

you were the CEO but you had two law I

54:38

mean what was the how did you have

54:39

resilience yeah especially some very

54:42

good construction practices

54:45

I didn't order it it just happened to

54:48

seemed to read it about six months after

54:50

I took the position so um

55:05

about how hard our employees were

55:07

working to restore power and then I

55:09

received the follow-up email from a

55:11

customer who started with uh thank you

55:14

for your very social email response it

55:16

was very kind of you to take the time to

55:17

tell me how hard your employees were

55:19

working but you must be the worst CEO on

55:21

the face of the planet because my

55:22

power's still been out two weeks and

55:24

that was the end of it was the end of

55:25

the email so the the purpose of those

55:27

two stories is not to fill time but

55:29

resilience matters but it is a question

55:32

of who pays for it right David

55:34

any other questions

55:36

yeah please

55:37

one more

55:39

that's always the best way to end

55:41

questions by saying one more question

55:42

that nobody wants to realize we have one

55:44

here yeah table four

55:48

yeah

55:49

hello and thank you so much for the the

55:52

this dialogue it's very much appreciated

55:54

I think the gentleman mentioned uh

55:56

climate of the resilience uh Universal

56:00

resilience angle so I think me uh Cypher

56:03

we were just discussing this just before

56:06

lunch and I think um as we were thinking

56:10

and debating the fact that

56:12

interconnected microgrids and uh I was

56:15

you know and peer-to-peer power trading

56:19

um you know because I think we're

56:21

reaching so where Africa can lead from

56:24

with cell phones and we're going to come

56:27

to the realization that you know

56:29

blockchain Technologies are already you

56:33

know the youth are already looking into

56:34

that so that would be something where

56:37

you're going to have

56:39

you know climate change creating Havoc

56:42

but at the same time you can create

56:45

these uh you can

56:48

um what do you call it Marshall some of

56:50

the the latest Innovations to allow uh

56:53

to address climate resilience or you

56:56

know Power Systems failures sometimes so

56:58

just want to share that thought and you

57:01

know thank you for this dialogue one of

57:04

the issues I think that we'll see are

57:06

made around microgrids is as you as you

57:10

know electricity both its generation and

57:13

its delivery are very Capital intensive

57:15

in fact the delivery of electricity is

57:18

essentially zero marginal cost right I

57:20

mean notwithstanding the required

57:22

maintenance and yet the whenever you

57:24

have a capital intensive industry asset

57:27

utilization determines the economics

57:30

and unfortunately my septuagenarian

57:33

neighbors use their power 30 of the time

57:36

the the hotel might use it 90 of the in

57:39

terms of the hospital uses so so the

57:42

micro grid really is an exercise and at

57:45

a micro level forgive me of who is

57:48

subsidizing who interesting if you have

57:51

a low-income residential Community they

57:53

simply cannot afford a microgrid uh if

57:56

you have a high Net Worth Residential

57:58

Community they can't afford a micro

57:59

group but that doesn't seem fair if you

58:01

have an industrial park they can afford

58:03

a microgrid this is the issue obviously

58:06

with distributed solar uh if I'm not

58:10

home and my panel isn't providing my

58:13

home I really want it connected to

58:15

somebody who is home and can use that

58:17

power otherwise I've got to waste the

58:18

resource so the interconnectivity is

58:22

what we rely on as vertically integrated

58:24

utilities to improve what we call the

58:27

load Factor so that you have it wasn't

58:30

quite as explicit as it was in the ATT

58:32

long lines case you have high load

58:35

Factor custom of subsidizing low loads

58:37

for customers and that's just the way

58:39

which society wants to do things which I

58:41

don't quarrel with

58:44

any other questions or comments if not

58:46

please join me in thanking Professor

58:49

Sonny thank you for having me

58:54

all right so stay in your seats I'm

58:56

going to just ask uh Ralph and the

58:58

professor to get there Mike's off and we

59:01

get the next panel Open Stage so in next

59:03

three minutes we'll start again

01:08:37

um if you think about the typical kind

01:08:40

of business models we've got one

01:08:42

everything

01:08:43

um so we've got a transmission only

01:08:45

distribution only vertically integrated

01:08:46

couple there

01:08:48

um and then mix those things

Next in the archive

Influential Minds: A Conversation with Harmeet Sawhney — Influential Minds