Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Michael Spence
Ask about this conversation
hello and welcome everyone to the
inaugural episode of influential minds
an eei international conversation series
my name is alikia malavarpu and i'm an
analyst for international programs at
eei influential minds is an evolution
and rebrand of our virtual conversation
series which aims to discuss ideas that
move the needle towards a more
sustainable future with thought leaders
from across the globe for our inaugural
session eei international programs is
honored to welcome michael spence nobel
prize winner and author of the next
convergence the future of economic
growth in a multi-speed world to discuss
economic shifts in light of evolving
global challenges he will be joined in
conversation by our host eei vice
president of international programs dr
lawrence jones
throughout the session please feel free
to ask questions using the chat feature
lawrence will aim to incorporate as many
of them as possible into the
conversation
without further ado i will turn this
over to lawrence to get
started thank you alicia good morning
welcome welcome michael nice to see you
good to see you lawrence
well let me first of all begin by
saying congratulations
uh
after a decade or so since you received
the nobel prize
uh and um it's certainly something that
uh you deserve
but i want to jump in the book and first
of all let me just show the book to the
audience this is what we're going to be
discussing the next convergence that
michael rhodes about uh maybe more than
a decade ago uh and like i said to you
michael i bought this book as i was
going through stockholm a couple of
years ago
and i read it then and i'm reading it
again and i have to say that there are
so many prescient questions you read in
the book which we're going to get into
in our conversation we'll also talk with
you a little bit about some of your
recent articles that you've written for
project syndicate in which you've tried
to lay out some very interesting ideas
about where the world should be headed
but i want to begin first just to talk a
little bit about the nobel prize for
those of us who haven't gotten it and we
never get it uh just tell us
what has life been
what was life like before you got the
prize and what has life been since
well you know before the prize i was i
had basically two lives professional
lives um one is a
as what we i think called applied micro
economic theorist which is closely
related to industrial organization so we
were trying to figure out
really how markets work with realistic
assumptions about you know
information informational structure who
knows what
um and so on and i love that
and then
after about 15 years of that uh the
president of harvard asked me to be the
dean of the faculty of arts and sciences
at harvard
which i thought was
a fairly sudden change in direction but
i anyway i had a lot of fun
learned a lot about a whole lot of
disciplines from my colleagues
and then then moved over to stanford
university and became the dean of the
business school so that academic
administrative period
was basically about 15 years so those
are the two parts pre-nobel and i had
stepped down in 1999
and was sort of minding my own business
and sort of taking a look at the we were
in the middle of the internet bubble by
that point
which was a kind of fascinating early
you know chapter
in the digital transformation that we're
experiencing and then out of the blue
the nobel prize arrived so
so so can you recall where were you when
you got that call
and what was your first reaction when
you did yeah that you were going to be
getting the nobel prize
uh i i was
in hawaii and i didn't get the call
because they didn't know where i was i
was on sabbatical
uh and i'd had a boat with melanoma so i
was sort of recovering from that
um and but a friend of mine they post
these things soon after they make the
calls and a friend of mine at stanford
uh you know it's sort of up early in the
morning i mean i think they do it in the
afternoon in sweden but you know it by
the time you get to california
you're at you know five or six in the
morning and then if you go over to
hawaii and
in the fall that's another
two or three hours so i was basically
fast asleep when my friend phoned me and
i and i was stunned i mean i didn't see
this coming at all
did you ever end your wildest
imagination through your career ever
thought you would be getting that call
nope might have i devoted zero thought
to it i mean you know i it wasn't as if
i hadn't encountered these folks my one
of my thesis advisors was the late
kenneth arrow who had received the prize
early on in the life of the economics
nobel prize
after me actually another thesis advisor
the late tom schelling actually received
a nobel prize
um
so you know there were people around but
you know
with 15 years of academic administration
basically not doing economic research
you know i without even really thinking
about it i think i and others sort of
counted me out so
i i wasn't uh paying attention at all no
so you mentioned your two uh tc's
advisor and i'm sure throughout your
career since you got the prize even
before
you've met several nobel laureates
including obviously not yourself so tell
us you know
what are some of the things you all
share in common in terms of mindset or
even practical day-to-day activities
from an academic standpoint what's
what's like in the mind of a nobel
laureate before he gets the prize
well i think the vast majority of them
aren't thinking about it at all you know
these are people who
are just intensely curious whatever
their field uh you know physics
biochemistry et cetera um
and you know they're certain of the work
i mean my impression of most of them is
that they
or whatever it is
um so that's that's kind of what they
have in common beyond that they're
pretty
group i mean
you know some are kind of vocation
you know
others you know do sort of ice dancing
and as a hobby i mean
they're all over the place
um but i think they share that that
common characteristic and i don't think
most of them you know were sort of
did anything in their careers that would
was designed to to
where it's very rare to find somebody
who was aiming to receive a nobel prize
at least in my experience yeah so it's
that intense curiosity so anybody
listening to this conversation with
michael uh needs to step up the
curiosity uh to sort of be even close to
getting something like a nobel prize
uh let's get into the book um you know
given the current global economy given
the current current challenges facing
the world now with your hindsight and
obviously your foresight
if you were to write a sequel to this
book which i hope you do by the way uh
would this title still be
next convergence part two or will it
will it be something different and why
so i might keep the title and i might
not um depending on
you know
what editors think in publishers but
but i would keep the concept of
convergence um
and i would certainly keep the
multi-speed part um
but what what i but that doesn't mean
i'd write the same book i mean i i think
there's some really important new things
one of them is quite worrying which is
uh you know there are various versions
of this but the lower income countries
are facing a series of challenges and
headwinds
uh
that are beyond normal pandemic you know
very severe climate shocks you know
induced migration
all that kind of thing
that kind of looked like a perfect storm
so so i i would modify the convergence
and say
i'd still pretty sure that the a very
wide range of emerging economies are
going to make it you know they may get
slowed down in this environment for
reasons that we'll probably talk about
in a minute but but i do worry that the
lower income countries you can think of
them as sort of late starters in the
development process
i i worry that they may not
that that will start to see a pattern of
divergence in that in that corner of the
world and and there's a lot of people in
it
okay interesting so so if you think of
think of where we are now and and try to
just
take in consideration the geopolitics
and pandemic and all of the evolved do
you see more convergence or you think
we're gonna head into a sort of a more
diverging world where you have
more underdeveloped countries more poor
more poverty compared to convergence
where you see more growth
so it's a kind of mixed picture you know
so let's take you know major economies
that appear to be succeeding uh other
than the ones that have already made the
journey so we know that japan and
singapore and south korea are now
high-income countries um
and the taiwanese economy however you
kind of describe that in relation to
china is similarly positioned
but i don't really have much doubt in
spite of the fact that there's uh major
challenges facing virtually every
economy um that china and india will
make this journey that's a fairly large
number of people um which makes this
journey means they'll they'll they'll
sustain um higher growth rates in the
developed countries and eventually
they'll be wherever we are
you know as part of the kind of oecd
club
and
and there's a number of others that you
can be reasonably confident about
basically because they have the
resources and the the capability to get
it done and the understanding of how you
how how you have to do it um
but then again you know i think that
there's a subset of lower income
countries you know
i was still pretty confident and
optimistic about them because
um there's you know for example in lots
of african countries there's really
talented young leaders i think it's safe
to bet on them and their capabilities
but when you overlay a pandemic you know
terrible problems with vaccine access
you know climate shocks you know
demographics that are really really
difficult with fertility rates you know
up in the neighborhood of five or more
um and and and you start to sort of
wonder whether
you know whether they can sort of get
into a pattern of sustained growth and
generating employment which supports it
that that so that when when i worry
about
um
you know who's going to sort of pay a
high price for this you know
tough environment that we're in now
that's where i would now sort out the
focus
you talk about economic growth and and
really you do a very excellent job i
think in the book and talking about
growth
um two questions first of all just for
the audience where does growth come from
because for many people they seem to be
a very
nebulous very con
complicated terminology so where does
growth come from and
after you address that maybe then do we
need a new framework for growth based on
what the world is where we are today
so on the second point we certainly you
certainly have to adapt so let me let me
try to answer the first question i think
it'll help with the second one
or the second part
growth growth comes from
the kind of sustained high growth that's
sort of you know life-changing for
people in a country um
comes from
at one level structural change you know
this isn't sort of the same economy you
know every 10 years when you take a
snapshot of it you know it's urbanizing
it has a big export sector it's
importing technology it's educating
people at a fairly high rate you know
the economy is transforming itself and
and so in order to understand growth and
growth patterns
you you really need to understand the
structural transformation and and the
best
description of that at least for the
early stages of growth came from sir w
arthur lewis a nobel prize winner
in uh in the 60s or 70s uh
who uh
who basically laid out the model he
basically said when you have an early
stage developing country that hasn't
started this process
most of the people are in traditional
sectors especially agriculture
and the growth model you know kicks into
high gear
when it connects to the global economy
and they start and people start moving
to cities and to and and and
and producing goods
which are sold into the global economy
and bringing technology into the economy
that makes it more productive
and so on so there's a lot of ways to
describe it productivity skyrockets
as people move you know to more
productive sectors and so on and then
there's a bunch of supporting things you
need pretty high levels of investment
to support sustained high growth but but
that's that's kind of the process um
there comes a time it's called the
middle income transition when the growth
model actually changes you basically you
run out
of
people you can extract from the
traditional sectors and you know and
find employment that's rewarding and
gives them opportunity and higher
incomes and then you be you you
basically start to make a transition
that that where the growth model looks a
little bit more like the growth model
we're familiar with in developed
economies so you're investing heavily
in human capital you're moving up global
supply chains you know you have a bigger
a much bigger domestic economy right so
you're producing more goods and services
for your own economy as opposed to for
the global economy
um
and that transition is a difficult one
as well not lots of countries get caught
and experience a bad growth slowdown at
that point but but that's the idea
um and once you get the hang of it that
this is really a complex kind of
structural transformation
um
then then basically navigating almost
any set of changes including you know
the digital transformation that we're in
you know is more of the same i mean it's
not exactly the same but it's the same
idea which is people have to do
different things they need education and
support
that you need investment levels
ditto the energy transition right i mean
we're we you we you and i will talk
about that i probably in the not too
distant future
but basically
uh that's an enormously big transition
and it requires massive levels of
investment globally to to make it
possible now whether we're going to do
it or not is a different question
yeah we'll get back to that because you
know in addition to growth you also talk
about innovation
and in fact you you talk about the role
of innovation and growth so let's talk
about that and in the context of the
developing countries
how do we spur innovation in the
developing world
that will then lead to growth how do we
do that
well
so if you go back to the kind of you
know the w arthur lewis model
you know he described the domestic part
of that re you know in incredi you know
incredibly well
there's a key feature of it that he
understood well but didn't emphasize
which is the global economy gives you
two things um when you're when you're
embarking on this you know uh sustained
growth um
growth process
one of them is is essentially technology
you know the period when developing
countries uh really experience sustained
growth is the post-war period post-world
war ii
before that
you had a 200 years of divergence
essentially from the british industrial
revolution until the end of world war ii
in which what we now call developed
countries you know sort of
clambered their way up the technological
and scientific and other ladders
but for a variety of reasons especially
colonialism
that didn't spill over
you know into the developing world
and that pattern changed completely in
the post-war period
and that those spillovers
started to happen at a relatively high
rate so
innovation in the early stages of growth
is adaptation and then you see this
continuous change
as countries you know become more
capable
uh both in terms of human capital and
the institutions
that support uh innovation and then they
start innovating themselves you know and
and so the
the
the so-called catch-up effect fades but
the innovation the domestic innovation
um takes over so you move
the early stages of innovation they're
real but they're more like adept
adapting things that came from this
period of divergence to the specifics of
that economy and then as you move up you
know so i mean you take china china was
basically
40 years ago when they started this
high-growth process was essentially
bringing technology in via
multinational enterprises setting up
shop and so on
now it's an innovative powerhouse
because they've invested enormous
amounts of
of their resources in people and
institutions that support innovative
activity
i mean there's more to it than that you
know you need you need
uh
you don't get innovation innovative
ecosystems everywhere so that's a
subject that we may want to pursue later
on there is a kind of global explosion
of entrepreneurial activity which is
one of the things that i find
fascinating and it's really
in the last 10 years
so crisis seemed to spur innovation
because of the challenges that it onset
uh we're now facing three tri-crisis we
have the pandemic we had the war in
ukraine and obviously we had the climate
crisis uh how hopeful are you that
innovation will help get us out of these
crisis
so i you know there's i to answer that i
think you have to have a time horizon so
i think in the short run we just have to
face the fact that these shocks are big
enough you know
supply chain blockages inflation central
banks in a tough position
you know uh etc um
trying to get out of the pandemic in
some parts of the world including china
which affects almost everybody else uh
we're going to have a period of slow
growth and some places are going to have
a recession i mean i'm
they're not forecasting it formally but
i think we'll have a recession in europe
uh as a result of having to make this
very fairly rapid energy transition
diversifying away from dependence on on
russian oil and gas
um
you know i hope i'm wrong but it's
certainly going to be a growth slowdown
and it'll the the only and it'll be
everywhere and the only question is the
magnitude right so i think the united
states slowdown will be a little bit
less uh but we're not we're not you know
immune to this uh
and you know energy prices as you know
better than i are still i'll still set
globally right so
um and priced in dollars so
the short run is you know there ain't
any way to get out of this right i mean
it's it's that's just the way it is
longer term i'm much more optimistic i
mean you know i i
you know i have hopes for the energy
transition but the digital
trans transformation of virtually every
economy that's underway has the
potential to produce just an enormous
productivity surge
now whether it will come to pass is an
open question i mean i don't have
you know a better crystal ball than
anybody else but i think the potential
is certainly there um and if we
you know take advantage of it then
you know rising potential productivity
is is the single most important enabler
of growth and when you live in a world
you know with aging populations in
75 plus percent of the global economy
you know measured in terms of gdp not
numbers of people
um you've got these supply chain
problems you've probably you've got
higher interest rates you've got big
market resets
you've got the what's left over from the
pandemic and then a whole huge array of
com climate shocks which
i'll argue in a minute is going to give
rise to a kind of global pattern of
diversifying supply and demand chains
in that world if you asked you know
what's the single most important thing
that we that we could have
you know that would make things better
if not perfect it would be a surge in
productivity and that would be a
reversal of the recent trends we've had
about a 15-year
pattern of declining productivity growth
so if we do get that surge in
productivity and as you've mentioned
growth is key here
i want to just pivot a little bit to the
un's sustainable development goals and
other goals being set by governments for
climate goals
how critical
is growth to achieving those goals and
if we have slow growth is there a risk
that those goals are not accomplished
yeah so this is something this is
complicated because it again depends on
who you're talking to but you know
which part of the world you're talking
about so to go back to the early stage
developing countries
where you know a significant priority is
simply poverty reduction right or
raising incomes
that for that you just need growth right
um and when when i
sort of teach about the subject you know
i'm i i say and i mean it it's not
because you know that's the thing that
most people care about i mean people
care about productive employment
contributing society the opportunity to
productive and creative they desperately
care about the opportunities for their
children and grandchildren their
education and a whole lot of things
the point is
that sustainably improving all of those
things healthcare is another
you know or just health
sustainably making progress on all of
those things absolutely requires
uh that the incomes rise you just don't
have the resources to do it
now when you get to higher income
countries it's a different story right
then i think you know you really need
this uh
this multi-dimensional assessment of
welfare and if you focus too much on
growth um you're missing a great deal of
the picture right so
one way to think of it is you know
in the early stages of growth with
relatively low incomes you know growth
is a necessary condition for achieving a
broad set
of things that people really care about
once you get past that point and then
you got to start paying attention to
what those things are
and
and how you're going to sort of make
progress on those on those various
fronts and i think it's it's now widely
accepted that you need a
a multi-dimensional uh
framework for assessing economic and
social progress for sure uh now where
where people differ lawrence is whether
you should aggregate that into one
number to get people's attention you
know so throw growth out
and
you know and have another index
overall performance i mean some people
think that's very important i i prefer
the multi-dimensional one but there's no
right answer on this
i i i like the segue into into metrics
because obviously given your nobel prize
and some of the work you've done metrics
is key um so if we were to sort of just
think
of a different framework how would what
would be some of the elements of a new
growth framework so that especially in
developed economies we are not sort of
uh exercising ourselves over gdp gdp gdp
what would be some of the other elements
that we should think about in the
context of growth for the more developed
economies
well
you know growth tells you virtually
nothing about sustainability
for sustainability you have to have if
you think of an economy growing
basically what is underlying that growth
sitting down in the foundation is a
bunch of assets right not just bridges
and roads and airports and
ports but
human capital institutions etc but you
know intangible assets if you like
and if you try to grow without building
in parallel that foundation
then you can't keep growing that
sustainable growth really means that
there's a balance between what's going
on you know year to year in the economy
and the investments that that create
this foundation that enabled it to
continue
and now we face the fact that you know
and and growth simply you know growth in
the sense of year-to-year changes in
essentially incomes and output doesn't
tell you anything about whether you're
driving toward a brick wall or not and
we are
so
in the climate area and a number of
other areas you know if you want to pay
attention to
um the durability
of the growth patterns that you're in
then you then you need broader measures
you know in in this case in the case of
climate uh there are now serious efforts
to to measure
essentially the environmental capital or
sometimes called natural capital are we
running that down to the point where you
know we basically can't sustain our
economies um
some people put this in different ways
are we operating out outside the
planetary boundaries uh is one another
way to say it um so
so that's a that's a that's a simple
dimension in which you know the
conventional national income accounting
just doesn't say anything at all uh
ditto distributional issues so if you
have a rising pattern of in inequality
you can measure that and you can worry
about it and you can have policies that
deal with it but if you stare at you
know aggregate or growth numbers you
won't see it right so you need
most people in some form or other care
about whether there's a reasonable
degree of equity they might not agree on
what exactly that is
uh
you know within a society or across
societies but but nevertheless you know
if you want to pay attention to what's
going on you have to measure it and then
you can argue about it after you measure
it but if you don't measure it i mean i
think one of the things that happened in
the united states is
is you know
it wasn't that we didn't measure these
things but you know basically we didn't
pay enough attention to them and so we
have pretty serious pattern of rising
income and wealth inequality um and are
kind of boxed into a corner you know
where we have to sort of try to figure
out how we're going to get out of this
and of course rising inequality gives
rise to or certainly contributes to sort
of
uh
political and social polarization you
know if you have haves and have-nots i
mean they're various you know various
versions of this globalization
you know was run without attention to
its distributional consequences etc and
there's lots of events that have adverse
distributional consequences
then there you know then there's health
you know and education and a whole lot
of other things that i you know i would
say
i mean
you there is not anything like a perfect
correlation
between economic performance as
conventionally measured and performance
in the healthcare area and the united
states is a good example there's lots of
countries that have lower growth rates
um that are still in the high income
category that have superior
health outcomes in a number of
dimensions so
so i think by this time people recognize
that you know we've got to pay attention
to those things and um and then we're if
we're falling short on one of them we
have to devote the time attention
creativity and resources to dealing with
it
so who who do you think is best
positioned then to
prepare the public
for
dealing with the world where we have
slow growth
but we may still have
an improvement in some of the other
things you've mentioned
is that the role of the economist like
yourself
or is it the role of the the media
politicians who should tell that story
for citizens to understand especially in
democratic societies but more broadly
that we're in a new world it's not about
just gdp it's about gdp plus all these
other issues that we need to think about
who tell us that story
well you know i certainly wouldn't
exempt you know my profession uh
but you know i don't think we're alone
but we certainly need to contribute to
it and the work of
wide range of very talented people
thomas piketty emanuel syes
etc have made significant progress on on
that so that you know massive amounts of
data are available and we can understand
these patterns in the in the short and
the long term i think the media
bears responsibility for this
in reporting on
essentially
societal conditions
um
both challenges and achievements and uh
and i think to some extent they
discharge that responsibility in the
climate area you've got a cast of
literally millions who are now engaged
in uh
in so i think the long battle in climate
change was to go from a relatively small
group of people who knew this was a
serious problem like say 25 years ago
to a world
now
in which the vast majority of people
know there's some kind of problem and
and you do your best you can but i mean
honestly i think the progress in
taking the climate um
and sustainability challenge seriously
is in part attributable to the
evident increase in the frequency and
severity of
you know extreme climate grants
yeah yeah and i think you know the point
you made about you know whose role it is
whose responsibility is an important one
um i want to then tell the audience if
you have any questions for for michael
please go ahead and type it in the chat
we'll get to as many as possible um uh
before we move on to what should be an
exciting activity here for the first
time ever uh michael we're going to be
doing a wheel of books if you may and
we're going to spin a wheel and we're
going to give out three of your books to
the lucky winners so i'm going to ask
elicky on my team to go ahead and
spin the wheel and we'll pick three
winners of a copy of michael's book the
next convergence
oh my goodness
that's clever
okay so registrant number 54 you are a
winner you will receive an email from us
and a copy of michael's book two more
books
spin the wheel
registrant number 134 you're the next
winner you'll get a copy of michael's
book and the last winner will be
what will you do if it comes up you know
with 54 of you
chances are low low thank you so much
winners 18 number 18 will also receive a
copy of michael's book
thanks for for indulging with us this
little activity to get the audience
engaged all right let's let's keep going
on that so
i want to know michael talk a little bit
about development economy you're using a
lot of time on that and growth in the
context of developing countries who are
resource rich a lot of them
but they're still not developing fast
enough
um what do we do now i mean we've been
talking about this for the last three
decades but yes we see the so-called
resource curse so my question is
as we now face a new resource boom in
terms of lithium and
all these critical minerals for the
energy transition
how should developing countries with
those resources
act differently so that they can
actually see growth more broadly in
their countries
so i mean i think that you know
some adaptation of policies for those
who are doing it well is required you
know if you
if you anticipate an energy transition
in which over
even if it takes decades over time you
know the relative prices of you know
fossil fuels and other things it starts
to shift
you you know you probably want to adapt
your uh your policies but but but at a
more fundamental level
i mean the the i think the ingredients
in effect of
you know management of natural resources
with the with the with the goal of
achieving you know growth and
development is first good governance
right it's absolutely crucial you know
if you have a group of people and i'm
not talking about you know the form of
governance i'm not talking about whether
it's a democracy or a single party
system or whatever but whoever's there
if they're systematically trying to
pursue an agenda which is kind of the
long-term public interest
um then then you've you've rounded the
single most important corner but that's
just not true everywhere i mean there's
too many examples
you know of
different agendas you know
ranging from theft to fraud to
you know uh
promoting the interests of uh
of a subset of people in the population
however
their relationship to the governing
group is defined that was very struck
um you know by some of the examples that
came from an earlier
an earlier era uh you know and it seems
pretty clear
um that this kind of you know
that this what the objective function is
really matters
then then there's confidence basically
natural resources relaxes
a constraint that should be used
primarily
to to produce investments that are
supportive of growth uh
and that's not you know i mean when you
get into the technicalities there are
institutions
um that are you know trying to do this
and help countries do it
like the natural resource governance
institute for example
that came from a merger of revenue watch
and the natural resource charter that
paul collier and colleagues started
um i think they're doing very good work
um it's not easy
uh but i think there's a group of
leaders in natural resource countries
that are pretty determined to improve
the management but when you think about
you know the supply chain associated
with this so you have natural resources
you have to do a good job of auctioning
the rights to exploit them right
then you have to tax the rev divide the
revenues up and tax them in the
appropriate way
and then you have to invest
you know
it's easy to say you got to invest the
proceeds in in a portfolio of assets
tangible and intangible assets that
support growth
and then you ask yourself the question
does everybody know how to do that
right from the get-go that's the answer
is you know
that's that's something that
is part of the learning process
yeah um and then if you have a pilot
wait the last thing is if you have a
pile of you know if you have way too
much income
you don't want to sort of spend it now
you've got it you've got to put it in a
sovereign wealth fund you know and treat
it as a resource for the future so
embedded in all that is a whole lot of
capabilities that um that i think we
could do a better job
um
helping countries you know
skills you know capabilities that they
can acquire the other thing is the you
know i think the other set of
initiatives
is are directed at the multinationals in
the natural resource area so
transparency you know and and and and
adhering to you know certain standards
and not participating in uh
in you know
dysfunctional activity in pursuit of
profit is a pretty important part of the
puzzle as well
a lot of questions coming in michael i'm
not surprised uh so let's take one here
from from neil
so neil's question is many believe that
the invisible hand of the free market
best manages economic growth
can this or does this apply to other
voices you have mentioned
no i don't think so i mean it depends on
how you interpret it so
the all of the successful you know
sustained growth cases that i've ever
seen and when we did the growth
commission work we found there were 13
economies that had sustained growth
at or in excess of seven percent a year
for 25 years or more that is
transformational right because at seven
percent a year you're doubling every
decade right so that really is so
that's a definition of sustained and
very high growth
all of those cases have
slightly different but varying versions
of an activist
pragmatic
uh public sector government
and uh and a private sector that is also
innovative
and
incentivized and active
and so
writing the government out of the script
is a bad idea
and writing the private sector out of
the script is also a bad idea and in
somewhere in the middle there's no right
answer
there's a balance but and the reason
this is true
is the private sector can't do certain
crucial things they don't create public
goods at a fast enough rate they don't
invest in certain things at a high
enough rate
because
because the private benefits are
exceeded by the collective or social
benefits of those investments so
so at least the way i think about the
world the model that you want is uh
is a is an effective competent
state you don't want it crowding out the
private sector and if you look at
examples all over the world you i think
you'll find this pattern is is basically
characteristic and you will also find
you know when when you fall too far
toward the extremes
um then you then you start to see
problems developing
so here's a very good question
here's a question from rob edwards who
was a former student of
of
stanford and basically rob is asking do
you believe that business school
curriculums are not better or
sufficiently with societal goals and
equity and inclusion
yeah i think they're definitely better
than they were
now i also think
i mean
business schools are evolving you know
it as they should
in response to sort of business
challenges and needs and you know so in
the united states
um
i as far as i can tell we we have at
least to some extent and probably a
great extent decided that the
shareholder value maximization model
is not going to you know it's not fit
for purpose in this world there are too
many things that corporations
need to do that amount to partnerships
with the public sector to solve major
social problems and that you can see
this in esg
or the discussions of purpose and so on
and all of those things i think are
starting maybe more than starting to be
reflected
in business schools you also have major
programs in lots of business schools in
social entrepreneurship
this is basically entrepreneurial
ventures that who's
from the get-go whose you know goal is
to um survive financially but but they
measure performance not in terms of rate
of return on capital
but impact
on society so yeah i think that maybe
we're not moving fast enough
well i'm out of that world now but um
but you know you can always criticize
for not being you know up to speed
quickly enough but i think there's a
major evolution underway
we'll take some more questions from the
audience there's one here from sandra
bear uh moving from governments and
large institutions can you recommend
actions for individuals to truly
influence the new balance societies face
well i think actually we're starting to
learn that individuals
collectively but not necessarily acting
collectively
are very influential because individuals
are employees
um
and and their consumers
right and their voters
and so on so they have multiple roles
all of which can be influential and i
think we're starting to see that this
really matters so
there are numerous you know stories i
think they're probably accurate
of people you know choosing their you
know employment
based on whether they feel
on balance that that their employer
is operating in a way that's consistent
with their own personal values and it
and if those that divergence gets too
extreme i think people change their jobs
and similarly consumers i don't want to
overstate this you know because you know
when
people at budgets
you know they'll buy
things that are you know
as cheap as they can
uh
and maybe they don't you know
sort of have a fully developed sort of
uh
social
agenda when they go out and purchase
things but but on balance
you know and i think you can see this in
the climate change area especially i
mean people
are really starting to ask the question
you know
is it consistent for me to work with an
entity
that doesn't look like it's very well
aligned with some longer term
sustainability agenda whether it's a
fossil fuel company or what
now i don't think the fossil fuel let me
be care be clear i mean
we are in a transition that's going to
take decades
we cannot flip a switch and turn
everything green you know it's just not
going to happen
so we need natural gas you know to
supplement you know to take out parts of
coal maybe you know we've got lots of
transitions to manage and so a balanced
view of this doesn't mean you know that
every you know anything that sounds like
a fossil fuel is bad at all and it
doesn't mean that you can't
work in that neighborhood it means
that
you know what matters is you know what
what role your employer is taking and
these are just examples so i think
individuals are
increasingly influential as they're
as as they believe that their values
need to be reflected in the choices they
make in life
you you mentioned transition we are
indeed go undergoing a transition and
let's talk a little bit about some of
the bumps we've had so obviously the
warning
okay as well as created a lot of bumps
we've seen a reversal maybe in policies
in some countries in germany for example
in terms of coal and in other countries
how do you see these bombs sort of a
slowing down or accelerating the
transition
so i think in the short run there might
be a bit of a slow down i mean i was on
an emergency basis it really depends on
you know
how much of the
inflow is cut off so
germany as i think everybody knows
made a decision many years ago
to exit nuclear
uh
they haven't completely done that and
they may kind of reverse part of that
decision that would be kind of neutral
or positive
that we may have more uptake of coal as
an emergency measure in the short run
but i think longer term
uh
it it's probably you know balance
positive so for for example
um
you know we have not successfully yet
introduced a kind of kind of
global carbon tax or a global price on
carbon
there are lots of initiatives in lots of
different places europe asia
california parts of the united states
etc so i don't mean we haven't made any
progress but
but all of a sudden we have this great
big increase in um
in
oil and gas prices and coal for that
matter um i checked i thought maybe coal
wasn't part of this but it is
um
so that's you know that's going to
change incentives now
what happens now depends on the policy
responses you know in the developing
world to go back to our earlier
discussion one of the things we
discovered
is that virtually and this is 10 years
ago 10
or more years ago this is changing
virtually every developing country was
subsidizing energy
which at the time meant fossil fuels
so
or the production of
you know electricity using fossil fuels
there's terrible policy right from a
long-run growth point of view i mean
even if you didn't see the climate
change agenda coming at you you know you
build energy and efficient buildings
that last 40 years right
there's all kinds of stuff that goes
wrong
if the pricing goes wrong so
i think the
the countries that are facing these
higher prices and it's pretty much
everybody may need to do something to
buffer the shock because it's happened
very suddenly
but the wrong thing to do would be to
sort of say we're not going to allow
these prices to pass through
um but you know one of the things that
that's been talked about for a long time
and we've never really done
uh
is a kind of stabilization fund you know
energy prices are pretty volatile
uh you get spikes every now and then
because of supply and demand conditions
or geopolitical conditions or whatever
so a reasonable policy
would be
well you know
we'll knock off the peaks right but
we'll also knock off the floors right
why would we knock off the floors
because we want to incentivize
investment in alternatives right
and if everyone every time you know you
sort of think you've got something to
invest in you know oil goes to 30 or
less dollars a barrel it's not great
from the point of view of the risk of
that kind of investment
so there's a reasonable case to be made
for you know protecting consumers when
there's spikes and you know the problem
is we never we never did the bottom part
of that right we never put a floor on
and now we want to put up you know a
ceiling on it right to protect people
from this sudden change
and sort of my answer to that is well
you know that's kind of half the right
answer but it's not a very good policy
if you don't devote
right
so maybe we'll get there i don't know
but
um the other thing i think is worthy of
note lawrence is uh
you know energy relative
energy not so much independence but
resilience
is going to produce
a diversification it's for sure true in
europe the japanese already did it you
know when this when the war started in
the ukraine i checked
the japanese and all of their sourcing
oil gas and coal
is highly diversified you know across
countries completely unlike europe and
europe understands
all the leadership in europe understands
the dependence on russia was a mistake
and they're going to diversify now this
is going to be painful
in the short run
you know because a lot of the gas is
coming into pipelines
italy where i am is 45 dependent on
russian gas coming in on pipelines
germany's higher than that
um
you know the liquefied natural gas isn't
going to appear overnight
um and when it does it's going to be
more expensive but both because of the
technology the transport and all that
and and and the demand for liquefied
natural gas is part of the energy
transition in asia
and these are huge economies right
it's going to go through the roof so it
may be really expensive
in the longer term
but the but the green technologies are
you don't have to import
sun and wind
right
so they so
increasing your resilience with respect
to energy
is actually a positive force you know or
a positive incentive with respect to the
at least that aspect of the energy
transition
so it's hard to know but i think a
reasonable guess when you sort of add
this all up i mean we'll find out by
living through it but it's short-term
headwind longer-term maybe even even an
accelerant yeah we have about ten more
minutes michael i want to get into some
of the other things you've written about
more recently the book is obviously
focused on the multi-speed world but
then we have a multi-polar world the
dipolar world and specifically i want
you to talk a little bit about u.s china
relationship you've written about
projects
you talk about the importance of this
sort of a competition and collaboration
how important is the us general
relationship for the world in tackling
some of the big challenges we face and
how do you do what you talk about
compete but collaborate
well it's more complicated
right then uh
then you know i suppose in in a way we
always we did that but the asymmetries
were so great that the competition
wasn't much
you know of a factor you know in the
early stages right china was a
labor-intensive process-oriented
export-oriented economy and we weren't
so and they weren't terribly advanced in
a technological sense and they didn't
have
sort of uh
non-economic sort of geopolitical
aspirations whatever they are right so
this is certainly a more complicated
environment i mean the simple answer the
question is
how the how the relationship between
china and the united states evolves is
going to affect everybody right if it
evolves badly you'll have spheres of
influence or what some people call
elements of a new economic cold war
there's a vast number of people in a
vast number of countries who don't want
the world to go that way i mean they say
repeatedly we do not want to choose
upsides you know sort yourselves out
so that we are operating in
some version
a more complicated version but some
version of an open
multilaterally organized global economy
that's what they want and that's what we
should deliver
now
on the relationship itself i think you
know the level of trust between the two
countries has fallen to the point that
you can't escape
the notion that there's going to be some
kind of strategic competition
and that the article i think lawrence
was referring to is i said you know
that's not all bad
provided the rules
you know are are uh appropriate right we
might even incentivize uh
you know accelerated progress in some
areas if we're competing with each other
as opposed to you know one of them so
dominant that we're just sleeping at the
switch
but the bad form of competition is not
when you try to advance by investing you
know and and and
magnifying whatever creative abilities
and talents you have but instead you try
to triple the other player right
so in
in sports
you know you can win by running faster
but you can't win by sort of stamping on
the toe of the other
runner just before the race
intrumitarian competition we have rules
right you know you can the incumbents
have certain kinds of ability
um to make life miserable for the new
and potential entrance and that's what
competition policy and antitrust law
is designed however imperfectly to
prevent so it's a real competition and
the people who win on the substance
right on the new technology and
innovation new products and services
win and a version of that will actually
work pretty well if if the united states
and china can can agree
um to compete on that basis and then
finally in terms of cooperation i mean
again we keep talking about climate
change but it's crucial
we on that one we have to cooperate
right
including on the technology side and in
my assessment is
if if in that area in in the
technologies we will need not probably
we can make progress for the next 10
years with the technologies we have but
after that
we need new stuff we need
carbon capture you know fusion if we can
get it
a whole lot of things as well as cost
declines of the stuff we have
but that technology has to flow with
essentially seamlessly with no frictions
all over the world or we don't even have
a chance
um of solving this problem and so
and and key players in that are the
united states and china
um we're not the only players for sure
but we're key players and so on
on
in in in layers like that
we should just agree to suspend whatever
strategic competition we have and act in
a different way
michael i've always wondered about the
we're going to a energy transition
multiple transitions but i also see us
going to a demographic transition
right
and so do you think
uh from a standpoint of trust is there a
way
for the next generation of leaders
to sort of adapt a more trusting
uh approach to one another meaning the
gen z's of the world can we start
working so that they do not replicate
the lack of trust that is currently
existing but that they then define a new
framework for agreeing to live and work
together on this planet and that's
something we can work towards rebuilding
trust
level of the gen z's and others as
opposed to those who are currently
lacking trust towards one another
yeah i think we can uh you know but the
the most important ingredient in that is
contact real contact not zoom contact
contact
you know
remember when we when when um nixon
you know went to china with kissinger
and we decided to sort of open up
uh
an important part of that diplomacy was
a whole it was called ping pong
you know uh
diplomacy right it was designed to
maximize the amount of to the extent we
could
interaction
uh between people and you know we still
have although it's declining and there
are you know storm clouds on their rise
and we still have fairly large numbers
of people
including especially in the united
states from all over the world
um
sorry
that that thing ran out of gas can you
still hear me yes pretty good
yeah we're now using the uh
the computer's audio
so i think we have you know we instill
very large numbers of chinese students
you know we have uh
people from all over the world leading
major corporations are doing important
startups and wanna
i think we
and we can do more of it so the bottom
line is lawrence i think
if we
pay attention
what you don't want is a situation in
which people you know
when people think about some other group
of people another country they think
about people who are sort of 5 000 miles
away and i've never met one right that's
that is not where we want to be
um
and i think this this generalizes i i
think you policies that are designed to
produce this sort of uh
at least as a side benefit this kind of
interaction is important and we still
have some of the assets i mean i have
friends all over china
you know these are people i've worked
with worked beside you know
at times kind of helped with policy you
know
development in in the government and
whatnot
now you know we we may get pushed back
to our
one side or the other because of the
geopolitical tensions and that would be
a great shame but but they're still
there right
these are people who basically share the
same
roughly the same vision about how the
world should work in a kind of uh
mutually supportive cooperative way
so i'd be optimistic about that yeah
well we're going to take two or three
more questions michael before we wrap up
here the first one i want to bring to
you and we'll try to get through them as
quickly as we can a lot of discussions
around economies of scale uh and the
need for that and we also see a lot of
big conglomerates being formed a lot of
the big tech companies you see some
people talking about the new form of
monopolies
how important what is the role you see
for the likes of the apples googles and
others and the facebooks and you name it
in terms of making sure that competition
continues to be a foundation for
innovation and a foundation for growth
what's the role of the big players in
making sure that they do not cannibalize
the rest of the market
right
so the mega platforms which are
essentially almost all located in the
united states and china uh
people that may surprise people but it's
true i mean there's you know mercado
libre and latin america is a pretty big
e-commerce and payments platform
very very successful um but it's in a
slightly smaller market so you know the
the alibabas and amp financials and
googles and amazons
you know you don't find them in europe
at least not you know domicile here
they're enormously powerful
the ecosystems that they are the center
of that they architect are enormously
powerful
um
you know engines for creating inclusive
growth opportunities but
you know they they're going to be
regulated so the the world in which you
know we live 15 years ago was the
internet's a wonderful thing and it's
you know there's a few standards
associated with it that's gone right
it's gonna be regulated everywhere not
the same way
and part of it is competition and you
know and so on um you know and not using
their market power to block access to
markets or buy up everybody before they
get to market so you don't have to
compete with them and that's that's
to use american terminology that's the
job of antitrust
you know and congress is in the middle
of this too so
but there's other issues you know
there's you know how do you regulate if
you want to regulate it all internet
content
you know are do you want to rely on
private sector in you know incentives
for data security
and or defining you know
what are the responsibilities related to
sort of privacy and the use of data can
you sell it to somebody etcetera all of
these things are kind of works in
progress right right now
um and they're important and they're
happening everywhere right so you know
you get on a plane and fly to beijing
and you'll discover there's a you know
probably
certainly in a very aggressive
uh
set of regulatory patterns the same in
fintech right you know you could with
artificial intelligence
you can do a fantastic job of lending to
people who
traditional banks have trouble lending
to because they don't know who they are
they're completely anonymous right no
track record no collateral no nothing
but but they do participate in the
digital economy and it turns out
that the people who have the data you
know can lend money to them but
then the regulators come in and say yeah
but now you're competing with banks
right
the banks have you know capital
requirements underpinning their lending
activity the credit activity and you
don't have any that's not fair we're not
going to do that anymore and besides
it's risky and so you know we're we're
in this world of kind of moving targets
all the way around but you know we'll
get to the end of it eventually
and it'll be
heavily regulated there is an there is a
fairly serious risk
of some degree of balkanization of the
global economy as a result of this
i should tell you story when i used the
word balkanization in a talk in turk in
in istanbul a very nice
participant a woman put her hand up and
said you might want to use a different
term
uh at least in this part of the world so
i said okay i won't use right
fragmentation is a better term
what we're talking about but you know we
have we right now underway are numerous
across a wide range of countries
um restrictions on the on the use of
data whether it can move across borders
whether it can be stored in any country
other than the one for which you know
the data
the data is about etc and then you ask
so digital global supply chains with
with data that can't move across borders
again
we're in this world where we're going to
have to try to figure out
the answers and balance these things but
uh but but it's not simple
yeah i think that's where we are the
other thing i'll mention right you know
real quick lawrence is
the mega platforms get all the attention
you know because that's the thing you
know when you pull out your phone and
you use that's kind of what you see but
um
there is literal explosion of
entrepreneurial activity much of it in
the digital area globally it's
extraordinary it's happened in the last
10 years these are these are entities
they're not small i mean a lot of them
are unicorns meaning companies with
about they get a valuation of a billion
or more before they go public
um
so you have i don't know
300 and some odd in china you know 500
in the united states
100 in india and rising rapidly lots of
them in brazil we even have them in
europe in paris and and berlin
so
i think it's kind of invisible you know
when people focus on the mega platforms
and think they dominate the digital
world they don't
but they dominate part of it
but there's another part that's growing
pretty fast
that
and some of them are going to come up
and
eventually threaten those folks so it's
pretty healthy down at that level this
globalization of
entrepreneurial activity and the support
of ecosystems
there are a lot of things we didn't
cover michael and we could go on for
for more than a year just talking about
some of these issues i want us to end on
two quick topics one is institutions i
mean you talk a lot in your book about
the important role of institutions we
have the g7 g20
world bank a lot of other international
organizations
um how important are their roles and
also do you imagine a situation where
developing countries develop so much so
that there is no longer the need for the
world bank i've gotten that question
many times what happens when developing
countries and poverty is gone
well we still need the world bank
probably not i mean we're not there yet
but you know yeah it the world bank
started as a war recovery bank had
nothing to do with the developing world
of poverty reduction
and they finished that mandate um and
then they
adopted this one which was i think
entirely appropriate and that's been
with us for the last at least 50 years
and you know it would be nice some some
day down the road
if
that weren't the main activity what i
expect to happen then is the world bank
will will move to something else that's
a challenge maybe aggressively funding
you know global public goods in the
sustainability area and so on but
they've already done it once they could
do it again
um
these institutions are very important um
lawrence and and you and i talked
briefly about it before but um the the
problem right now they're in retreat you
know
there's no question about that
it varies you know but the wto is
struggling uh
yeah i think relative to the needs some
of them are under capitalized the imf is
still pretty influential but we probably
could use a larger imf
but but the underlying problem here is
that the you know the the the
the deciders in chief to use george
bush's term are nations right and if
they are are having trouble agreeing on
anything then the casualties will be in
part these important
international institutions so the wto
has been a side swipe not because they
were incompetent is because a major
player started ignoring them
and they had trouble reaching agreement
on on
on
you know
it additional trade agreements but but
the dispute resolution mechanism has
been under attack too
because people sort of say well if i
don't like the answer then i'm ignoring
it and if you're big enough you can get
away with that i mean the g7 can
probably get something done but it's the
kind of it's the developed countries you
know club
and the g20 is much more representative
but if you have china and russia
and the us and europe
you know and a few other india and some
indonesia and some major
developing countries in this environment
with this level of tension
it's hard to see them sort of agreeing
on much of substance right in the short
run i mean indonesia has got them on
this round so they're going to try
and we can always hope that they they
get somewhere and do what lawrence said
a minute ago which is to say okay we're
going to disagree about that but let's
focus on this where we might be able to
agree so i wouldn't write them off and
it's probably still a good idea for them
to get together but
but i wouldn't underestimate the
challenge of engineering any kind of
substantive
you know and reasonably aggressive you
know
international collective action at this
point
well let's end on a note that you are
good at michael wishes growth and i want
to talk very briefly about sustaining
growth and minimizing inequality
so by the year 2030 25th day or between
the year 23rd 25th the world population
is set to grow to between uh nine
billion about nine billion people we
will still have seven billion living in
what we call the developing world or
maybe the emerging economies and we have
about two billion people living in the
rich world
more or less
now
how do we ensure
that this transition is done in such a
way
that we can sustainably
raise the level of standard of living
for these 7 billion people
but still maintain some
common level of sustainability or
lifestyle for those who are already
living in the rich world in essence can
we balance can we do both can we find
this balance without someone having to
give because it seems for me that it's
difficult to have everyone still be rich
and other people get enriched as well so
how do we do this sustained growth
minimize inequality at the same time
it's a very good question i mean
lawrence i don't think it's as hard as
you suggest so let me
i mean i did a few calculations so if
you take the major developing countries
you know they're developed countries
right europe's foreign for 450 million
the united states is 350 million canada
adds you know another 35. japan's 120
million you get up to about a billion
maybe you could go around and find some
more you know if you had south korea and
the taiwanese economy in singapore which
is only has four million people and
stuff you know you start to get
get up there
then you've got the problem that you
described but you know my best guess bet
is that at least
well let's take china and india
but each of them has a population of 1.4
billion
okay
that's that's 2.8 all right so you're
almost you're already at almost three
times the current you know high income
group
and and unless something goes badly
wrong my expectation is these will be
high income countries by the time china
well before 2050 in india you know
following along but probably in that
category by 2050 and and there's a bunch
of other countries that are probably
going to be in the same category so what
i'm trying to say is the problem may not
be as hard as you think you know if you
have a world
in which
let's say
somewhere around 60 percent of of the
world's population is living in high
income countries
then their resources relative to the
needs
of the lower income countries are going
to be absolutely massive right now that
doesn't mean they'll discharge their
responsibilities but it means the
balance
you know
between
the availability of resources and living
well and the ability to invest you know
because it's in our mutual interest to
do it i mean we don't want a whole
continent floundering around
uh or
or under desperately migrating or
whatever i'm not saying that's where
africa the african countries are going
to be i'm a lot more optimistic than
that
but i think
i think what that what in your narrative
what's missing is this continuing high
growth potential of major parts of the
emerging economy so that on your time
horizon
they'll actually be
in the oecd kind of territory
well michael this has been wonderful
again congratulations on the nobel peace
prize after maybe a decade but
congratulations also on the book not
peace i've never been criticized for it
economics economics i sometimes and i'm
blending it all together but really it's
been a fascinating conversation the book
is the next convergence i highly
recommend this book even though it was
written about more than a decade ago it
is still very substantive and michael we
look forward to your next book whenever
it's written i'll be one of the first to
get it and certainly would love to have
you back
on our series of influential minds and
thanks again for agreeing to be our
inaugural guest on this very important
platform thank you so much it was a
great pleasure lawrence thank you thank
you for having me
Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Episode 12Jesper Brodin
How IKEA links affordability, circular design and renewable energy with climate action, purpose-led leadership and sustainable growth.
Episode 07Sebastian Mallaby
How venture capital, risk-taking and connected networks turn bold ideas into startups and spread entrepreneurial culture.