Episode 061 hr 11 minWatch on YouTube

About this conversation

How growth, innovation and good governance can reduce poverty and inequality while navigating climate and geopolitical shocks.

Ask about this conversation

This conversation only
Answers are grounded in indexed transcripts only.

Transcript

00:02

hello and welcome everyone to the

00:04

inaugural episode of influential minds

00:07

an eei international conversation series

00:10

my name is alikia malavarpu and i'm an

00:12

analyst for international programs at

00:14

eei influential minds is an evolution

00:18

and rebrand of our virtual conversation

00:20

series which aims to discuss ideas that

00:23

move the needle towards a more

00:24

sustainable future with thought leaders

00:26

from across the globe for our inaugural

00:29

session eei international programs is

00:32

honored to welcome michael spence nobel

00:34

prize winner and author of the next

00:36

convergence the future of economic

00:39

growth in a multi-speed world to discuss

00:42

economic shifts in light of evolving

00:44

global challenges he will be joined in

00:47

conversation by our host eei vice

00:49

president of international programs dr

00:52

lawrence jones

00:53

throughout the session please feel free

00:55

to ask questions using the chat feature

00:58

lawrence will aim to incorporate as many

01:00

of them as possible into the

01:01

conversation

01:04

without further ado i will turn this

01:06

over to lawrence to get

01:10

started thank you alicia good morning

01:13

welcome welcome michael nice to see you

01:16

good to see you lawrence

01:18

well let me first of all begin by

01:20

saying congratulations

01:23

after a decade or so since you received

01:25

the nobel prize

01:27

uh and um it's certainly something that

01:30

uh you deserve

01:32

but i want to jump in the book and first

01:34

of all let me just show the book to the

01:35

audience this is what we're going to be

01:37

discussing the next convergence that

01:38

michael rhodes about uh maybe more than

01:41

a decade ago uh and like i said to you

01:43

michael i bought this book as i was

01:45

going through stockholm a couple of

01:46

years ago

01:47

and i read it then and i'm reading it

01:49

again and i have to say that there are

01:52

so many prescient questions you read in

01:54

the book which we're going to get into

01:55

in our conversation we'll also talk with

01:58

you a little bit about some of your

01:59

recent articles that you've written for

02:01

project syndicate in which you've tried

02:03

to lay out some very interesting ideas

02:04

about where the world should be headed

02:07

but i want to begin first just to talk a

02:08

little bit about the nobel prize for

02:10

those of us who haven't gotten it and we

02:11

never get it uh just tell us

02:14

what has life been

02:16

what was life like before you got the

02:18

prize and what has life been since

02:21

well you know before the prize i was i

02:23

had basically two lives professional

02:26

lives um one is a

02:28

as what we i think called applied micro

02:31

economic theorist which is closely

02:33

related to industrial organization so we

02:35

were trying to figure out

02:37

really how markets work with realistic

02:39

assumptions about you know

02:40

information informational structure who

02:43

knows what

02:44

um and so on and i love that

02:47

and then

02:48

after about 15 years of that uh the

02:51

president of harvard asked me to be the

02:52

dean of the faculty of arts and sciences

02:54

at harvard

02:55

which i thought was

02:57

a fairly sudden change in direction but

03:00

i anyway i had a lot of fun

03:01

learned a lot about a whole lot of

03:03

disciplines from my colleagues

03:06

and then then moved over to stanford

03:08

university and became the dean of the

03:09

business school so that academic

03:11

administrative period

03:14

was basically about 15 years so those

03:16

are the two parts pre-nobel and i had

03:18

stepped down in 1999

03:22

and was sort of minding my own business

03:24

and sort of taking a look at the we were

03:26

in the middle of the internet bubble by

03:27

that point

03:28

which was a kind of fascinating early

03:31

you know chapter

03:32

in the digital transformation that we're

03:34

experiencing and then out of the blue

03:36

the nobel prize arrived so

03:40

so so can you recall where were you when

03:42

you got that call

03:44

and what was your first reaction when

03:45

you did yeah that you were going to be

03:47

getting the nobel prize

03:50

uh i i was

03:52

in hawaii and i didn't get the call

03:54

because they didn't know where i was i

03:55

was on sabbatical

03:57

uh and i'd had a boat with melanoma so i

04:00

was sort of recovering from that

04:02

um and but a friend of mine they post

04:04

these things soon after they make the

04:06

calls and a friend of mine at stanford

04:08

uh you know it's sort of up early in the

04:10

morning i mean i think they do it in the

04:12

afternoon in sweden but you know it by

04:14

the time you get to california

04:16

you're at you know five or six in the

04:18

morning and then if you go over to

04:20

hawaii and

04:21

in the fall that's another

04:23

two or three hours so i was basically

04:25

fast asleep when my friend phoned me and

04:28

i and i was stunned i mean i didn't see

04:30

this coming at all

04:32

did you ever end your wildest

04:33

imagination through your career ever

04:36

thought you would be getting that call

04:39

nope might have i devoted zero thought

04:41

to it i mean you know i it wasn't as if

04:44

i hadn't encountered these folks my one

04:46

of my thesis advisors was the late

04:48

kenneth arrow who had received the prize

04:50

early on in the life of the economics

04:52

nobel prize

04:54

after me actually another thesis advisor

04:57

the late tom schelling actually received

04:59

a nobel prize

05:01

so you know there were people around but

05:03

you know

05:05

with 15 years of academic administration

05:07

basically not doing economic research

05:10

you know i without even really thinking

05:12

about it i think i and others sort of

05:14

counted me out so

05:15

i i wasn't uh paying attention at all no

05:19

so you mentioned your two uh tc's

05:21

advisor and i'm sure throughout your

05:23

career since you got the prize even

05:24

before

05:25

you've met several nobel laureates

05:27

including obviously not yourself so tell

05:29

us you know

05:31

what are some of the things you all

05:32

share in common in terms of mindset or

05:34

even practical day-to-day activities

05:37

from an academic standpoint what's

05:39

what's like in the mind of a nobel

05:41

laureate before he gets the prize

05:45

well i think the vast majority of them

05:46

aren't thinking about it at all you know

05:48

these are people who

05:50

are just intensely curious whatever

05:53

their field uh you know physics

05:55

biochemistry et cetera um

05:58

and you know they're certain of the work

06:00

i mean my impression of most of them is

06:03

that they

06:09

or whatever it is

06:10

um so that's that's kind of what they

06:12

have in common beyond that they're

06:14

pretty

06:15

group i mean

06:16

you know some are kind of vocation

06:19

you know

06:20

others you know do sort of ice dancing

06:23

and as a hobby i mean

06:25

they're all over the place

06:26

um but i think they share that that

06:28

common characteristic and i don't think

06:30

most of them you know were sort of

06:33

did anything in their careers that would

06:35

was designed to to

06:37

where it's very rare to find somebody

06:38

who was aiming to receive a nobel prize

06:41

at least in my experience yeah so it's

06:43

that intense curiosity so anybody

06:46

listening to this conversation with

06:47

michael uh needs to step up the

06:50

curiosity uh to sort of be even close to

06:53

getting something like a nobel prize

06:55

uh let's get into the book um you know

06:57

given the current global economy given

06:59

the current current challenges facing

07:01

the world now with your hindsight and

07:03

obviously your foresight

07:05

if you were to write a sequel to this

07:07

book which i hope you do by the way uh

07:10

would this title still be

07:12

next convergence part two or will it

07:14

will it be something different and why

07:19

so i might keep the title and i might

07:21

not um depending on

07:23

you know

07:24

what editors think in publishers but

07:28

but i would keep the concept of

07:29

convergence um

07:32

and i would certainly keep the

07:33

multi-speed part um

07:35

but what what i but that doesn't mean

07:37

i'd write the same book i mean i i think

07:39

there's some really important new things

07:42

one of them is quite worrying which is

07:44

uh you know there are various versions

07:46

of this but the lower income countries

07:49

are facing a series of challenges and

07:51

headwinds

07:54

that are beyond normal pandemic you know

07:58

very severe climate shocks you know

08:00

induced migration

08:02

all that kind of thing

08:04

that kind of looked like a perfect storm

08:06

so so i i would modify the convergence

08:09

and say

08:10

i'd still pretty sure that the a very

08:12

wide range of emerging economies are

08:14

going to make it you know they may get

08:16

slowed down in this environment for

08:18

reasons that we'll probably talk about

08:20

in a minute but but i do worry that the

08:22

lower income countries you can think of

08:25

them as sort of late starters in the

08:27

development process

08:29

i i worry that they may not

08:31

that that will start to see a pattern of

08:33

divergence in that in that corner of the

08:35

world and and there's a lot of people in

08:38

okay interesting so so if you think of

08:41

think of where we are now and and try to

08:44

just

08:45

take in consideration the geopolitics

08:46

and pandemic and all of the evolved do

08:48

you see more convergence or you think

08:50

we're gonna head into a sort of a more

08:52

diverging world where you have

08:55

more underdeveloped countries more poor

08:58

more poverty compared to convergence

09:00

where you see more growth

09:04

so it's a kind of mixed picture you know

09:06

so let's take you know major economies

09:08

that appear to be succeeding uh other

09:11

than the ones that have already made the

09:12

journey so we know that japan and

09:14

singapore and south korea are now

09:16

high-income countries um

09:19

and the taiwanese economy however you

09:21

kind of describe that in relation to

09:23

china is similarly positioned

09:26

but i don't really have much doubt in

09:28

spite of the fact that there's uh major

09:30

challenges facing virtually every

09:32

economy um that china and india will

09:35

make this journey that's a fairly large

09:37

number of people um which makes this

09:39

journey means they'll they'll they'll

09:41

sustain um higher growth rates in the

09:43

developed countries and eventually

09:45

they'll be wherever we are

09:47

you know as part of the kind of oecd

09:50

club

09:52

and there's a number of others that you

09:54

can be reasonably confident about

09:56

basically because they have the

09:57

resources and the the capability to get

10:00

it done and the understanding of how you

10:02

how how you have to do it um

10:05

but then again you know i think that

10:07

there's a subset of lower income

10:09

countries you know

10:11

i was still pretty confident and

10:13

optimistic about them because

10:15

um there's you know for example in lots

10:17

of african countries there's really

10:19

talented young leaders i think it's safe

10:20

to bet on them and their capabilities

10:23

but when you overlay a pandemic you know

10:27

terrible problems with vaccine access

10:30

you know climate shocks you know

10:32

demographics that are really really

10:34

difficult with fertility rates you know

10:36

up in the neighborhood of five or more

10:38

um and and and you start to sort of

10:40

wonder whether

10:42

you know whether they can sort of get

10:44

into a pattern of sustained growth and

10:46

generating employment which supports it

10:49

that that so that when when i worry

10:51

about

10:53

you know who's going to sort of pay a

10:55

high price for this you know

10:58

tough environment that we're in now

11:00

that's where i would now sort out the

11:02

focus

11:03

you talk about economic growth and and

11:05

really you do a very excellent job i

11:07

think in the book and talking about

11:09

growth

11:10

um two questions first of all just for

11:12

the audience where does growth come from

11:15

because for many people they seem to be

11:16

a very

11:17

nebulous very con

11:20

complicated terminology so where does

11:22

growth come from and

11:24

after you address that maybe then do we

11:27

need a new framework for growth based on

11:29

what the world is where we are today

11:33

so on the second point we certainly you

11:35

certainly have to adapt so let me let me

11:37

try to answer the first question i think

11:38

it'll help with the second one

11:40

or the second part

11:42

growth growth comes from

11:45

the kind of sustained high growth that's

11:47

sort of you know life-changing for

11:49

people in a country um

11:51

comes from

11:53

at one level structural change you know

11:55

this isn't sort of the same economy you

11:58

know every 10 years when you take a

12:00

snapshot of it you know it's urbanizing

12:02

it has a big export sector it's

12:05

importing technology it's educating

12:07

people at a fairly high rate you know

12:09

the economy is transforming itself and

12:12

and so in order to understand growth and

12:15

growth patterns

12:16

you you really need to understand the

12:18

structural transformation and and the

12:20

best

12:21

description of that at least for the

12:23

early stages of growth came from sir w

12:25

arthur lewis a nobel prize winner

12:28

in uh in the 60s or 70s uh

12:31

who uh

12:33

who basically laid out the model he

12:35

basically said when you have an early

12:36

stage developing country that hasn't

12:38

started this process

12:40

most of the people are in traditional

12:41

sectors especially agriculture

12:44

and the growth model you know kicks into

12:47

high gear

12:48

when it connects to the global economy

12:50

and they start and people start moving

12:52

to cities and to and and and

12:55

and producing goods

12:57

which are sold into the global economy

12:59

and bringing technology into the economy

13:01

that makes it more productive

13:03

and so on so there's a lot of ways to

13:05

describe it productivity skyrockets

13:07

as people move you know to more

13:09

productive sectors and so on and then

13:11

there's a bunch of supporting things you

13:13

need pretty high levels of investment

13:15

to support sustained high growth but but

13:18

that's that's kind of the process um

13:21

there comes a time it's called the

13:23

middle income transition when the growth

13:24

model actually changes you basically you

13:27

run out

13:29

people you can extract from the

13:30

traditional sectors and you know and

13:32

find employment that's rewarding and

13:34

gives them opportunity and higher

13:36

incomes and then you be you you

13:38

basically start to make a transition

13:40

that that where the growth model looks a

13:42

little bit more like the growth model

13:44

we're familiar with in developed

13:46

economies so you're investing heavily

13:48

in human capital you're moving up global

13:51

supply chains you know you have a bigger

13:53

a much bigger domestic economy right so

13:56

you're producing more goods and services

13:58

for your own economy as opposed to for

14:01

the global economy

14:03

and that transition is a difficult one

14:05

as well not lots of countries get caught

14:08

and experience a bad growth slowdown at

14:11

that point but but that's the idea

14:13

um and once you get the hang of it that

14:15

this is really a complex kind of

14:17

structural transformation

14:20

then then basically navigating almost

14:23

any set of changes including you know

14:25

the digital transformation that we're in

14:28

you know is more of the same i mean it's

14:30

not exactly the same but it's the same

14:32

idea which is people have to do

14:34

different things they need education and

14:36

support

14:37

that you need investment levels

14:40

ditto the energy transition right i mean

14:43

we're we you we you and i will talk

14:45

about that i probably in the not too

14:47

distant future

14:48

but basically

14:50

uh that's an enormously big transition

14:53

and it requires massive levels of

14:55

investment globally to to make it

14:57

possible now whether we're going to do

14:58

it or not is a different question

15:00

yeah we'll get back to that because you

15:02

know in addition to growth you also talk

15:05

about innovation

15:06

and in fact you you talk about the role

15:08

of innovation and growth so let's talk

15:10

about that and in the context of the

15:11

developing countries

15:13

how do we spur innovation in the

15:15

developing world

15:16

that will then lead to growth how do we

15:18

do that

15:19

well

15:22

so if you go back to the kind of you

15:25

know the w arthur lewis model

15:28

you know he described the domestic part

15:29

of that re you know in incredi you know

15:32

incredibly well

15:33

there's a key feature of it that he

15:35

understood well but didn't emphasize

15:37

which is the global economy gives you

15:39

two things um when you're when you're

15:42

embarking on this you know uh sustained

15:45

growth um

15:47

growth process

15:48

one of them is is essentially technology

15:51

you know the period when developing

15:53

countries uh really experience sustained

15:56

growth is the post-war period post-world

15:58

war ii

15:59

before that

16:00

you had a 200 years of divergence

16:03

essentially from the british industrial

16:05

revolution until the end of world war ii

16:07

in which what we now call developed

16:09

countries you know sort of

16:11

clambered their way up the technological

16:13

and scientific and other ladders

16:15

but for a variety of reasons especially

16:18

colonialism

16:19

that didn't spill over

16:21

you know into the developing world

16:23

and that pattern changed completely in

16:25

the post-war period

16:27

and that those spillovers

16:29

started to happen at a relatively high

16:31

rate so

16:32

innovation in the early stages of growth

16:34

is adaptation and then you see this

16:36

continuous change

16:38

as countries you know become more

16:40

capable

16:41

uh both in terms of human capital and

16:44

the institutions

16:45

that support uh innovation and then they

16:48

start innovating themselves you know and

16:50

and so the

16:52

the so-called catch-up effect fades but

16:55

the innovation the domestic innovation

16:58

um takes over so you move

17:01

the early stages of innovation they're

17:03

real but they're more like adept

17:05

adapting things that came from this

17:07

period of divergence to the specifics of

17:10

that economy and then as you move up you

17:13

know so i mean you take china china was

17:15

basically

17:16

40 years ago when they started this

17:18

high-growth process was essentially

17:21

bringing technology in via

17:23

multinational enterprises setting up

17:26

shop and so on

17:27

now it's an innovative powerhouse

17:30

because they've invested enormous

17:32

amounts of

17:33

of their resources in people and

17:35

institutions that support innovative

17:37

activity

17:39

i mean there's more to it than that you

17:40

know you need you need

17:44

you don't get innovation innovative

17:46

ecosystems everywhere so that's a

17:48

subject that we may want to pursue later

17:50

on there is a kind of global explosion

17:52

of entrepreneurial activity which is

17:54

one of the things that i find

17:55

fascinating and it's really

17:58

in the last 10 years

18:00

so crisis seemed to spur innovation

18:03

because of the challenges that it onset

18:05

uh we're now facing three tri-crisis we

18:07

have the pandemic we had the war in

18:09

ukraine and obviously we had the climate

18:11

crisis uh how hopeful are you that

18:14

innovation will help get us out of these

18:16

crisis

18:18

so i you know there's i to answer that i

18:21

think you have to have a time horizon so

18:23

i think in the short run we just have to

18:25

face the fact that these shocks are big

18:27

enough you know

18:28

supply chain blockages inflation central

18:31

banks in a tough position

18:33

you know uh etc um

18:36

trying to get out of the pandemic in

18:38

some parts of the world including china

18:39

which affects almost everybody else uh

18:43

we're going to have a period of slow

18:44

growth and some places are going to have

18:46

a recession i mean i'm

18:48

they're not forecasting it formally but

18:50

i think we'll have a recession in europe

18:52

uh as a result of having to make this

18:54

very fairly rapid energy transition

18:57

diversifying away from dependence on on

19:00

russian oil and gas

19:03

you know i hope i'm wrong but it's

19:05

certainly going to be a growth slowdown

19:07

and it'll the the only and it'll be

19:09

everywhere and the only question is the

19:11

magnitude right so i think the united

19:13

states slowdown will be a little bit

19:15

less uh but we're not we're not you know

19:17

immune to this uh

19:19

and you know energy prices as you know

19:21

better than i are still i'll still set

19:23

globally right so

19:25

um and priced in dollars so

19:28

the short run is you know there ain't

19:29

any way to get out of this right i mean

19:32

it's it's that's just the way it is

19:35

longer term i'm much more optimistic i

19:37

mean you know i i

19:39

you know i have hopes for the energy

19:41

transition but the digital

19:43

trans transformation of virtually every

19:46

economy that's underway has the

19:47

potential to produce just an enormous

19:50

productivity surge

19:51

now whether it will come to pass is an

19:53

open question i mean i don't have

19:55

you know a better crystal ball than

19:57

anybody else but i think the potential

19:59

is certainly there um and if we

20:03

you know take advantage of it then

20:05

you know rising potential productivity

20:07

is is the single most important enabler

20:10

of growth and when you live in a world

20:13

you know with aging populations in

20:16

75 plus percent of the global economy

20:20

you know measured in terms of gdp not

20:22

numbers of people

20:23

um you've got these supply chain

20:26

problems you've probably you've got

20:27

higher interest rates you've got big

20:29

market resets

20:31

you've got the what's left over from the

20:33

pandemic and then a whole huge array of

20:35

com climate shocks which

20:37

i'll argue in a minute is going to give

20:39

rise to a kind of global pattern of

20:40

diversifying supply and demand chains

20:44

in that world if you asked you know

20:46

what's the single most important thing

20:47

that we that we could have

20:49

you know that would make things better

20:51

if not perfect it would be a surge in

20:53

productivity and that would be a

20:55

reversal of the recent trends we've had

20:58

about a 15-year

20:59

pattern of declining productivity growth

21:03

so if we do get that surge in

21:04

productivity and as you've mentioned

21:07

growth is key here

21:09

i want to just pivot a little bit to the

21:11

un's sustainable development goals and

21:13

other goals being set by governments for

21:15

climate goals

21:17

how critical

21:18

is growth to achieving those goals and

21:20

if we have slow growth is there a risk

21:23

that those goals are not accomplished

21:27

yeah so this is something this is

21:29

complicated because it again depends on

21:30

who you're talking to but you know

21:32

which part of the world you're talking

21:34

about so to go back to the early stage

21:36

developing countries

21:38

where you know a significant priority is

21:40

simply poverty reduction right or

21:42

raising incomes

21:44

that for that you just need growth right

21:46

um and when when i

21:49

sort of teach about the subject you know

21:51

i'm i i say and i mean it it's not

21:54

because you know that's the thing that

21:56

most people care about i mean people

21:58

care about productive employment

22:00

contributing society the opportunity to

22:02

productive and creative they desperately

22:05

care about the opportunities for their

22:07

children and grandchildren their

22:08

education and a whole lot of things

22:11

the point is

22:12

that sustainably improving all of those

22:15

things healthcare is another

22:19

you know or just health

22:21

sustainably making progress on all of

22:24

those things absolutely requires

22:26

uh that the incomes rise you just don't

22:28

have the resources to do it

22:31

now when you get to higher income

22:32

countries it's a different story right

22:35

then i think you know you really need

22:37

this uh

22:39

this multi-dimensional assessment of

22:41

welfare and if you focus too much on

22:43

growth um you're missing a great deal of

22:45

the picture right so

22:47

one way to think of it is you know

22:50

in the early stages of growth with

22:51

relatively low incomes you know growth

22:53

is a necessary condition for achieving a

22:56

broad set

22:57

of things that people really care about

22:59

once you get past that point and then

23:01

you got to start paying attention to

23:03

what those things are

23:06

and how you're going to sort of make

23:07

progress on those on those various

23:09

fronts and i think it's it's now widely

23:12

accepted that you need a

23:14

a multi-dimensional uh

23:17

framework for assessing economic and

23:18

social progress for sure uh now where

23:22

where people differ lawrence is whether

23:24

you should aggregate that into one

23:25

number to get people's attention you

23:27

know so throw growth out

23:30

you know and have another index

23:32

overall performance i mean some people

23:34

think that's very important i i prefer

23:37

the multi-dimensional one but there's no

23:39

right answer on this

23:41

i i i like the segue into into metrics

23:44

because obviously given your nobel prize

23:46

and some of the work you've done metrics

23:48

is key um so if we were to sort of just

23:52

think

23:52

of a different framework how would what

23:55

would be some of the elements of a new

23:57

growth framework so that especially in

23:59

developed economies we are not sort of

24:01

uh exercising ourselves over gdp gdp gdp

24:06

what would be some of the other elements

24:07

that we should think about in the

24:08

context of growth for the more developed

24:11

economies

24:14

well

24:15

you know growth tells you virtually

24:17

nothing about sustainability

24:20

for sustainability you have to have if

24:22

you think of an economy growing

24:25

basically what is underlying that growth

24:28

sitting down in the foundation is a

24:30

bunch of assets right not just bridges

24:33

and roads and airports and

24:35

ports but

24:36

human capital institutions etc but you

24:40

know intangible assets if you like

24:43

and if you try to grow without building

24:45

in parallel that foundation

24:48

then you can't keep growing that

24:50

sustainable growth really means that

24:52

there's a balance between what's going

24:54

on you know year to year in the economy

24:57

and the investments that that create

25:00

this foundation that enabled it to

25:02

continue

25:03

and now we face the fact that you know

25:05

and and growth simply you know growth in

25:07

the sense of year-to-year changes in

25:10

essentially incomes and output doesn't

25:11

tell you anything about whether you're

25:13

driving toward a brick wall or not and

25:15

we are

25:17

in the climate area and a number of

25:19

other areas you know if you want to pay

25:20

attention to

25:22

um the durability

25:24

of the growth patterns that you're in

25:26

then you then you need broader measures

25:29

you know in in this case in the case of

25:31

climate uh there are now serious efforts

25:33

to to measure

25:36

essentially the environmental capital or

25:38

sometimes called natural capital are we

25:40

running that down to the point where you

25:42

know we basically can't sustain our

25:44

economies um

25:46

some people put this in different ways

25:48

are we operating out outside the

25:50

planetary boundaries uh is one another

25:54

way to say it um so

25:56

so that's a that's a that's a simple

25:58

dimension in which you know the

26:00

conventional national income accounting

26:02

just doesn't say anything at all uh

26:05

ditto distributional issues so if you

26:08

have a rising pattern of in inequality

26:10

you can measure that and you can worry

26:12

about it and you can have policies that

26:14

deal with it but if you stare at you

26:16

know aggregate or growth numbers you

26:18

won't see it right so you need

26:21

most people in some form or other care

26:23

about whether there's a reasonable

26:25

degree of equity they might not agree on

26:27

what exactly that is

26:30

you know within a society or across

26:32

societies but but nevertheless you know

26:34

if you want to pay attention to what's

26:36

going on you have to measure it and then

26:38

you can argue about it after you measure

26:40

it but if you don't measure it i mean i

26:42

think one of the things that happened in

26:43

the united states is

26:45

is you know

26:46

it wasn't that we didn't measure these

26:48

things but you know basically we didn't

26:49

pay enough attention to them and so we

26:51

have pretty serious pattern of rising

26:54

income and wealth inequality um and are

26:57

kind of boxed into a corner you know

26:58

where we have to sort of try to figure

27:00

out how we're going to get out of this

27:02

and of course rising inequality gives

27:04

rise to or certainly contributes to sort

27:09

political and social polarization you

27:11

know if you have haves and have-nots i

27:13

mean they're various you know various

27:15

versions of this globalization

27:17

you know was run without attention to

27:20

its distributional consequences etc and

27:23

there's lots of events that have adverse

27:24

distributional consequences

27:27

then there you know then there's health

27:28

you know and education and a whole lot

27:30

of other things that i you know i would

27:33

i mean

27:34

you there is not anything like a perfect

27:37

correlation

27:39

between economic performance as

27:41

conventionally measured and performance

27:43

in the healthcare area and the united

27:44

states is a good example there's lots of

27:46

countries that have lower growth rates

27:48

um that are still in the high income

27:51

category that have superior

27:53

health outcomes in a number of

27:54

dimensions so

27:56

so i think by this time people recognize

27:58

that you know we've got to pay attention

28:00

to those things and um and then we're if

28:03

we're falling short on one of them we

28:05

have to devote the time attention

28:07

creativity and resources to dealing with

28:10

so who who do you think is best

28:12

positioned then to

28:13

prepare the public

28:16

dealing with the world where we have

28:18

slow growth

28:19

but we may still have

28:21

an improvement in some of the other

28:22

things you've mentioned

28:24

is that the role of the economist like

28:26

yourself

28:27

or is it the role of the the media

28:30

politicians who should tell that story

28:32

for citizens to understand especially in

28:35

democratic societies but more broadly

28:37

that we're in a new world it's not about

28:40

just gdp it's about gdp plus all these

28:42

other issues that we need to think about

28:44

who tell us that story

28:46

well you know i certainly wouldn't

28:48

exempt you know my profession uh

28:51

but you know i don't think we're alone

28:53

but we certainly need to contribute to

28:55

it and the work of

28:58

wide range of very talented people

29:00

thomas piketty emanuel syes

29:03

etc have made significant progress on on

29:06

that so that you know massive amounts of

29:09

data are available and we can understand

29:11

these patterns in the in the short and

29:13

the long term i think the media

29:15

bears responsibility for this

29:18

in reporting on

29:19

essentially

29:20

societal conditions

29:23

both challenges and achievements and uh

29:26

and i think to some extent they

29:27

discharge that responsibility in the

29:29

climate area you've got a cast of

29:31

literally millions who are now engaged

29:33

in uh

29:35

in so i think the long battle in climate

29:37

change was to go from a relatively small

29:40

group of people who knew this was a

29:42

serious problem like say 25 years ago

29:46

to a world

29:48

in which the vast majority of people

29:50

know there's some kind of problem and

29:53

and you do your best you can but i mean

29:55

honestly i think the progress in

29:58

taking the climate um

30:00

and sustainability challenge seriously

30:02

is in part attributable to the

30:05

evident increase in the frequency and

30:07

severity of

30:09

you know extreme climate grants

30:11

yeah yeah and i think you know the point

30:13

you made about you know whose role it is

30:16

whose responsibility is an important one

30:18

um i want to then tell the audience if

30:20

you have any questions for for michael

30:22

please go ahead and type it in the chat

30:24

we'll get to as many as possible um uh

30:27

before we move on to what should be an

30:29

exciting activity here for the first

30:30

time ever uh michael we're going to be

30:33

doing a wheel of books if you may and

30:35

we're going to spin a wheel and we're

30:37

going to give out three of your books to

30:39

the lucky winners so i'm going to ask

30:41

elicky on my team to go ahead and

30:44

spin the wheel and we'll pick three

30:46

winners of a copy of michael's book the

30:48

next convergence

30:59

oh my goodness

31:01

that's clever

31:07

okay so registrant number 54 you are a

31:10

winner you will receive an email from us

31:12

and a copy of michael's book two more

31:14

books

31:16

spin the wheel

31:26

registrant number 134 you're the next

31:29

winner you'll get a copy of michael's

31:31

book and the last winner will be

31:39

what will you do if it comes up you know

31:40

with 54 of you

31:45

chances are low low thank you so much

31:47

winners 18 number 18 will also receive a

31:50

copy of michael's book

31:51

thanks for for indulging with us this

31:53

little activity to get the audience

31:55

engaged all right let's let's keep going

31:57

on that so

31:58

i want to know michael talk a little bit

32:00

about development economy you're using a

32:02

lot of time on that and growth in the

32:04

context of developing countries who are

32:07

resource rich a lot of them

32:09

but they're still not developing fast

32:12

enough

32:12

um what do we do now i mean we've been

32:15

talking about this for the last three

32:17

decades but yes we see the so-called

32:20

resource curse so my question is

32:23

as we now face a new resource boom in

32:26

terms of lithium and

32:28

all these critical minerals for the

32:29

energy transition

32:31

how should developing countries with

32:32

those resources

32:34

act differently so that they can

32:36

actually see growth more broadly in

32:38

their countries

32:40

so i mean i think that you know

32:43

some adaptation of policies for those

32:45

who are doing it well is required you

32:47

know if you

32:48

if you anticipate an energy transition

32:50

in which over

32:52

even if it takes decades over time you

32:54

know the relative prices of you know

32:57

fossil fuels and other things it starts

32:59

to shift

33:00

you you know you probably want to adapt

33:02

your uh your policies but but but at a

33:05

more fundamental level

33:06

i mean the the i think the ingredients

33:09

in effect of

33:11

you know management of natural resources

33:13

with the with the with the goal of

33:15

achieving you know growth and

33:17

development is first good governance

33:19

right it's absolutely crucial you know

33:22

if you have a group of people and i'm

33:23

not talking about you know the form of

33:25

governance i'm not talking about whether

33:26

it's a democracy or a single party

33:28

system or whatever but whoever's there

33:31

if they're systematically trying to

33:33

pursue an agenda which is kind of the

33:34

long-term public interest

33:36

um then then you've you've rounded the

33:39

single most important corner but that's

33:40

just not true everywhere i mean there's

33:42

too many examples

33:44

you know of

33:45

different agendas you know

33:47

ranging from theft to fraud to

33:51

you know uh

33:53

promoting the interests of uh

33:55

of a subset of people in the population

33:59

however

34:00

their relationship to the governing

34:02

group is defined that was very struck

34:05

um you know by some of the examples that

34:07

came from an earlier

34:09

an earlier era uh you know and it seems

34:13

pretty clear

34:14

um that this kind of you know

34:17

that this what the objective function is

34:19

really matters

34:20

then then there's confidence basically

34:22

natural resources relaxes

34:25

a constraint that should be used

34:27

primarily

34:29

to to produce investments that are

34:32

supportive of growth uh

34:34

and that's not you know i mean when you

34:36

get into the technicalities there are

34:38

institutions

34:39

um that are you know trying to do this

34:42

and help countries do it

34:44

like the natural resource governance

34:47

institute for example

34:49

that came from a merger of revenue watch

34:52

and the natural resource charter that

34:54

paul collier and colleagues started

34:56

um i think they're doing very good work

34:59

um it's not easy

35:01

uh but i think there's a group of

35:04

leaders in natural resource countries

35:06

that are pretty determined to improve

35:08

the management but when you think about

35:10

you know the supply chain associated

35:12

with this so you have natural resources

35:14

you have to do a good job of auctioning

35:16

the rights to exploit them right

35:19

then you have to tax the rev divide the

35:21

revenues up and tax them in the

35:22

appropriate way

35:24

and then you have to invest

35:26

you know

35:27

it's easy to say you got to invest the

35:29

proceeds in in a portfolio of assets

35:31

tangible and intangible assets that

35:33

support growth

35:34

and then you ask yourself the question

35:36

does everybody know how to do that

35:38

right from the get-go that's the answer

35:40

is you know

35:41

that's that's something that

35:43

is part of the learning process

35:45

yeah um and then if you have a pilot

35:47

wait the last thing is if you have a

35:49

pile of you know if you have way too

35:50

much income

35:52

you don't want to sort of spend it now

35:54

you've got it you've got to put it in a

35:56

sovereign wealth fund you know and treat

35:58

it as a resource for the future so

36:02

embedded in all that is a whole lot of

36:04

capabilities that um that i think we

36:07

could do a better job

36:09

helping countries you know

36:12

skills you know capabilities that they

36:14

can acquire the other thing is the you

36:16

know i think the other set of

36:18

initiatives

36:19

is are directed at the multinationals in

36:22

the natural resource area so

36:24

transparency you know and and and and

36:27

adhering to you know certain standards

36:30

and not participating in uh

36:33

in you know

36:34

dysfunctional activity in pursuit of

36:37

profit is a pretty important part of the

36:39

puzzle as well

36:41

a lot of questions coming in michael i'm

36:43

not surprised uh so let's take one here

36:45

from from neil

36:47

so neil's question is many believe that

36:49

the invisible hand of the free market

36:51

best manages economic growth

36:53

can this or does this apply to other

36:55

voices you have mentioned

36:58

no i don't think so i mean it depends on

37:01

how you interpret it so

37:03

the all of the successful you know

37:05

sustained growth cases that i've ever

37:07

seen and when we did the growth

37:09

commission work we found there were 13

37:12

economies that had sustained growth

37:16

at or in excess of seven percent a year

37:18

for 25 years or more that is

37:20

transformational right because at seven

37:22

percent a year you're doubling every

37:24

decade right so that really is so

37:29

that's a definition of sustained and

37:30

very high growth

37:32

all of those cases have

37:35

slightly different but varying versions

37:38

of an activist

37:40

pragmatic

37:42

uh public sector government

37:44

and uh and a private sector that is also

37:48

innovative

37:50

incentivized and active

37:53

and so

37:54

writing the government out of the script

37:56

is a bad idea

37:58

and writing the private sector out of

38:00

the script is also a bad idea and in

38:02

somewhere in the middle there's no right

38:05

answer

38:06

there's a balance but and the reason

38:08

this is true

38:09

is the private sector can't do certain

38:11

crucial things they don't create public

38:14

goods at a fast enough rate they don't

38:17

invest in certain things at a high

38:19

enough rate

38:20

because

38:21

because the private benefits are

38:23

exceeded by the collective or social

38:25

benefits of those investments so

38:28

so at least the way i think about the

38:30

world the model that you want is uh

38:33

is a is an effective competent

38:36

state you don't want it crowding out the

38:38

private sector and if you look at

38:40

examples all over the world you i think

38:42

you'll find this pattern is is basically

38:45

characteristic and you will also find

38:48

you know when when you fall too far

38:51

toward the extremes

38:53

um then you then you start to see

38:55

problems developing

38:57

so here's a very good question

38:59

here's a question from rob edwards who

39:01

was a former student of

39:05

stanford and basically rob is asking do

39:08

you believe that business school

39:10

curriculums are not better or

39:11

sufficiently with societal goals and

39:14

equity and inclusion

39:17

yeah i think they're definitely better

39:18

than they were

39:20

now i also think

39:21

i mean

39:23

business schools are evolving you know

39:25

it as they should

39:27

in response to sort of business

39:29

challenges and needs and you know so in

39:31

the united states

39:33

i as far as i can tell we we have at

39:36

least to some extent and probably a

39:38

great extent decided that the

39:39

shareholder value maximization model

39:42

is not going to you know it's not fit

39:44

for purpose in this world there are too

39:46

many things that corporations

39:49

need to do that amount to partnerships

39:50

with the public sector to solve major

39:53

social problems and that you can see

39:54

this in esg

39:56

or the discussions of purpose and so on

39:59

and all of those things i think are

40:01

starting maybe more than starting to be

40:03

reflected

40:04

in business schools you also have major

40:07

programs in lots of business schools in

40:09

social entrepreneurship

40:11

this is basically entrepreneurial

40:13

ventures that who's

40:15

from the get-go whose you know goal is

40:18

to um survive financially but but they

40:21

measure performance not in terms of rate

40:23

of return on capital

40:24

but impact

40:25

on society so yeah i think that maybe

40:28

we're not moving fast enough

40:30

well i'm out of that world now but um

40:33

but you know you can always criticize

40:35

for not being you know up to speed

40:38

quickly enough but i think there's a

40:39

major evolution underway

40:42

we'll take some more questions from the

40:43

audience there's one here from sandra

40:44

bear uh moving from governments and

40:46

large institutions can you recommend

40:48

actions for individuals to truly

40:50

influence the new balance societies face

40:54

well i think actually we're starting to

40:57

learn that individuals

41:00

collectively but not necessarily acting

41:02

collectively

41:04

are very influential because individuals

41:06

are employees

41:09

and and their consumers

41:11

right and their voters

41:14

and so on so they have multiple roles

41:16

all of which can be influential and i

41:18

think we're starting to see that this

41:20

really matters so

41:21

there are numerous you know stories i

41:25

think they're probably accurate

41:27

of people you know choosing their you

41:29

know employment

41:31

based on whether they feel

41:33

on balance that that their employer

41:36

is operating in a way that's consistent

41:39

with their own personal values and it

41:41

and if those that divergence gets too

41:43

extreme i think people change their jobs

41:45

and similarly consumers i don't want to

41:48

overstate this you know because you know

41:50

when

41:50

people at budgets

41:52

you know they'll buy

41:54

things that are you know

41:56

as cheap as they can

41:59

and maybe they don't you know

42:02

sort of have a fully developed sort of

42:06

social

42:07

agenda when they go out and purchase

42:09

things but but on balance

42:11

you know and i think you can see this in

42:13

the climate change area especially i

42:15

mean people

42:16

are really starting to ask the question

42:18

you know

42:19

is it consistent for me to work with an

42:21

entity

42:22

that doesn't look like it's very well

42:24

aligned with some longer term

42:27

sustainability agenda whether it's a

42:29

fossil fuel company or what

42:31

now i don't think the fossil fuel let me

42:33

be care be clear i mean

42:36

we are in a transition that's going to

42:37

take decades

42:39

we cannot flip a switch and turn

42:41

everything green you know it's just not

42:44

going to happen

42:45

so we need natural gas you know to

42:48

supplement you know to take out parts of

42:50

coal maybe you know we've got lots of

42:53

transitions to manage and so a balanced

42:56

view of this doesn't mean you know that

42:59

every you know anything that sounds like

43:00

a fossil fuel is bad at all and it

43:03

doesn't mean that you can't

43:04

work in that neighborhood it means

43:06

that

43:08

you know what matters is you know what

43:10

what role your employer is taking and

43:13

these are just examples so i think

43:15

individuals are

43:17

increasingly influential as they're

43:19

as as they believe that their values

43:22

need to be reflected in the choices they

43:23

make in life

43:25

you you mentioned transition we are

43:27

indeed go undergoing a transition and

43:29

let's talk a little bit about some of

43:30

the bumps we've had so obviously the

43:32

warning

43:33

okay as well as created a lot of bumps

43:36

we've seen a reversal maybe in policies

43:38

in some countries in germany for example

43:40

in terms of coal and in other countries

43:44

how do you see these bombs sort of a

43:46

slowing down or accelerating the

43:48

transition

43:50

so i think in the short run there might

43:51

be a bit of a slow down i mean i was on

43:54

an emergency basis it really depends on

43:57

you know

43:59

how much of the

44:00

inflow is cut off so

44:03

germany as i think everybody knows

44:05

made a decision many years ago

44:09

to exit nuclear

44:12

they haven't completely done that and

44:13

they may kind of reverse part of that

44:15

decision that would be kind of neutral

44:18

or positive

44:20

that we may have more uptake of coal as

44:22

an emergency measure in the short run

44:24

but i think longer term

44:27

it it's probably you know balance

44:30

positive so for for example

44:33

you know we have not successfully yet

44:35

introduced a kind of kind of

44:37

global carbon tax or a global price on

44:40

carbon

44:42

there are lots of initiatives in lots of

44:43

different places europe asia

44:46

california parts of the united states

44:48

etc so i don't mean we haven't made any

44:51

progress but

44:52

but all of a sudden we have this great

44:54

big increase in um

44:57

oil and gas prices and coal for that

45:00

matter um i checked i thought maybe coal

45:02

wasn't part of this but it is

45:06

so that's you know that's going to

45:07

change incentives now

45:09

what happens now depends on the policy

45:11

responses you know in the developing

45:13

world to go back to our earlier

45:14

discussion one of the things we

45:16

discovered

45:17

is that virtually and this is 10 years

45:19

ago 10

45:20

or more years ago this is changing

45:22

virtually every developing country was

45:24

subsidizing energy

45:27

which at the time meant fossil fuels

45:31

or the production of

45:33

you know electricity using fossil fuels

45:36

there's terrible policy right from a

45:38

long-run growth point of view i mean

45:40

even if you didn't see the climate

45:42

change agenda coming at you you know you

45:44

build energy and efficient buildings

45:46

that last 40 years right

45:48

there's all kinds of stuff that goes

45:50

wrong

45:51

if the pricing goes wrong so

45:53

i think the

45:55

the countries that are facing these

45:56

higher prices and it's pretty much

45:58

everybody may need to do something to

46:00

buffer the shock because it's happened

46:01

very suddenly

46:03

but the wrong thing to do would be to

46:04

sort of say we're not going to allow

46:06

these prices to pass through

46:08

um but you know one of the things that

46:11

that's been talked about for a long time

46:12

and we've never really done

46:15

is a kind of stabilization fund you know

46:18

energy prices are pretty volatile

46:21

uh you get spikes every now and then

46:24

because of supply and demand conditions

46:25

or geopolitical conditions or whatever

46:29

so a reasonable policy

46:32

would be

46:33

well you know

46:34

we'll knock off the peaks right but

46:36

we'll also knock off the floors right

46:40

why would we knock off the floors

46:41

because we want to incentivize

46:43

investment in alternatives right

46:45

and if everyone every time you know you

46:47

sort of think you've got something to

46:49

invest in you know oil goes to 30 or

46:52

less dollars a barrel it's not great

46:55

from the point of view of the risk of

46:57

that kind of investment

46:59

so there's a reasonable case to be made

47:01

for you know protecting consumers when

47:03

there's spikes and you know the problem

47:06

is we never we never did the bottom part

47:08

of that right we never put a floor on

47:11

and now we want to put up you know a

47:14

ceiling on it right to protect people

47:16

from this sudden change

47:18

and sort of my answer to that is well

47:20

you know that's kind of half the right

47:22

answer but it's not a very good policy

47:24

if you don't devote

47:26

right

47:27

so maybe we'll get there i don't know

47:30

um the other thing i think is worthy of

47:32

note lawrence is uh

47:36

you know energy relative

47:39

energy not so much independence but

47:41

resilience

47:43

is going to produce

47:44

a diversification it's for sure true in

47:46

europe the japanese already did it you

47:49

know when this when the war started in

47:50

the ukraine i checked

47:52

the japanese and all of their sourcing

47:55

oil gas and coal

47:57

is highly diversified you know across

48:00

countries completely unlike europe and

48:03

europe understands

48:05

all the leadership in europe understands

48:07

the dependence on russia was a mistake

48:08

and they're going to diversify now this

48:10

is going to be painful

48:12

in the short run

48:13

you know because a lot of the gas is

48:15

coming into pipelines

48:17

italy where i am is 45 dependent on

48:21

russian gas coming in on pipelines

48:23

germany's higher than that

48:26

you know the liquefied natural gas isn't

48:28

going to appear overnight

48:30

um and when it does it's going to be

48:32

more expensive but both because of the

48:35

technology the transport and all that

48:37

and and and the demand for liquefied

48:39

natural gas is part of the energy

48:41

transition in asia

48:43

and these are huge economies right

48:45

it's going to go through the roof so it

48:47

may be really expensive

48:50

in the longer term

48:52

but the but the green technologies are

48:55

you don't have to import

48:57

sun and wind

48:58

right

48:59

so they so

49:01

increasing your resilience with respect

49:03

to energy

49:05

is actually a positive force you know or

49:08

a positive incentive with respect to the

49:11

at least that aspect of the energy

49:13

transition

49:14

so it's hard to know but i think a

49:16

reasonable guess when you sort of add

49:18

this all up i mean we'll find out by

49:20

living through it but it's short-term

49:22

headwind longer-term maybe even even an

49:25

accelerant yeah we have about ten more

49:27

minutes michael i want to get into some

49:29

of the other things you've written about

49:30

more recently the book is obviously

49:33

focused on the multi-speed world but

49:35

then we have a multi-polar world the

49:37

dipolar world and specifically i want

49:39

you to talk a little bit about u.s china

49:41

relationship you've written about

49:43

projects

49:44

you talk about the importance of this

49:46

sort of a competition and collaboration

49:49

how important is the us general

49:52

relationship for the world in tackling

49:54

some of the big challenges we face and

49:56

how do you do what you talk about

49:58

compete but collaborate

50:01

well it's more complicated

50:03

right then uh

50:05

then you know i suppose in in a way we

50:07

always we did that but the asymmetries

50:09

were so great that the competition

50:11

wasn't much

50:12

you know of a factor you know in the

50:14

early stages right china was a

50:16

labor-intensive process-oriented

50:18

export-oriented economy and we weren't

50:22

so and they weren't terribly advanced in

50:24

a technological sense and they didn't

50:26

have

50:27

sort of uh

50:28

non-economic sort of geopolitical

50:31

aspirations whatever they are right so

50:33

this is certainly a more complicated

50:35

environment i mean the simple answer the

50:37

question is

50:39

how the how the relationship between

50:41

china and the united states evolves is

50:43

going to affect everybody right if it

50:46

evolves badly you'll have spheres of

50:47

influence or what some people call

50:49

elements of a new economic cold war

50:52

there's a vast number of people in a

50:55

vast number of countries who don't want

50:57

the world to go that way i mean they say

50:59

repeatedly we do not want to choose

51:01

upsides you know sort yourselves out

51:04

so that we are operating in

51:07

some version

51:08

a more complicated version but some

51:10

version of an open

51:12

multilaterally organized global economy

51:14

that's what they want and that's what we

51:16

should deliver

51:19

on the relationship itself i think you

51:21

know the level of trust between the two

51:23

countries has fallen to the point that

51:24

you can't escape

51:26

the notion that there's going to be some

51:28

kind of strategic competition

51:30

and that the article i think lawrence

51:32

was referring to is i said you know

51:33

that's not all bad

51:35

provided the rules

51:37

you know are are uh appropriate right we

51:40

might even incentivize uh

51:43

you know accelerated progress in some

51:45

areas if we're competing with each other

51:46

as opposed to you know one of them so

51:48

dominant that we're just sleeping at the

51:50

switch

51:52

but the bad form of competition is not

51:54

when you try to advance by investing you

51:57

know and and and

51:59

magnifying whatever creative abilities

52:01

and talents you have but instead you try

52:03

to triple the other player right

52:06

so in

52:08

in sports

52:09

you know you can win by running faster

52:11

but you can't win by sort of stamping on

52:13

the toe of the other

52:15

runner just before the race

52:17

intrumitarian competition we have rules

52:20

right you know you can the incumbents

52:22

have certain kinds of ability

52:25

um to make life miserable for the new

52:27

and potential entrance and that's what

52:29

competition policy and antitrust law

52:32

is designed however imperfectly to

52:34

prevent so it's a real competition and

52:36

the people who win on the substance

52:39

right on the new technology and

52:40

innovation new products and services

52:43

win and a version of that will actually

52:46

work pretty well if if the united states

52:48

and china can can agree

52:51

um to compete on that basis and then

52:54

finally in terms of cooperation i mean

52:56

again we keep talking about climate

52:57

change but it's crucial

52:59

we on that one we have to cooperate

53:02

right

53:03

including on the technology side and in

53:05

my assessment is

53:07

if if in that area in in the

53:09

technologies we will need not probably

53:12

we can make progress for the next 10

53:14

years with the technologies we have but

53:15

after that

53:17

we need new stuff we need

53:19

carbon capture you know fusion if we can

53:22

get it

53:23

a whole lot of things as well as cost

53:26

declines of the stuff we have

53:28

but that technology has to flow with

53:31

essentially seamlessly with no frictions

53:33

all over the world or we don't even have

53:35

a chance

53:36

um of solving this problem and so

53:39

and and key players in that are the

53:42

united states and china

53:44

um we're not the only players for sure

53:46

but we're key players and so on

53:50

in in in layers like that

53:53

we should just agree to suspend whatever

53:56

strategic competition we have and act in

53:59

a different way

54:00

michael i've always wondered about the

54:04

we're going to a energy transition

54:06

multiple transitions but i also see us

54:08

going to a demographic transition

54:10

right

54:11

and so do you think

54:12

uh from a standpoint of trust is there a

54:15

for the next generation of leaders

54:18

to sort of adapt a more trusting

54:21

uh approach to one another meaning the

54:23

gen z's of the world can we start

54:25

working so that they do not replicate

54:28

the lack of trust that is currently

54:30

existing but that they then define a new

54:32

framework for agreeing to live and work

54:35

together on this planet and that's

54:36

something we can work towards rebuilding

54:39

trust

54:40

level of the gen z's and others as

54:42

opposed to those who are currently

54:44

lacking trust towards one another

54:47

yeah i think we can uh you know but the

54:50

the most important ingredient in that is

54:52

contact real contact not zoom contact

54:56

contact

54:57

you know

54:58

remember when we when when um nixon

55:01

you know went to china with kissinger

55:04

and we decided to sort of open up

55:08

an important part of that diplomacy was

55:09

a whole it was called ping pong

55:12

you know uh

55:13

diplomacy right it was designed to

55:16

maximize the amount of to the extent we

55:18

could

55:19

interaction

55:20

uh between people and you know we still

55:23

have although it's declining and there

55:25

are you know storm clouds on their rise

55:27

and we still have fairly large numbers

55:29

of people

55:30

including especially in the united

55:32

states from all over the world

55:35

sorry

55:36

that that thing ran out of gas can you

55:38

still hear me yes pretty good

55:40

yeah we're now using the uh

55:43

the computer's audio

55:45

so i think we have you know we instill

55:48

very large numbers of chinese students

55:50

you know we have uh

55:52

people from all over the world leading

55:54

major corporations are doing important

55:56

startups and wanna

55:58

i think we

55:59

and we can do more of it so the bottom

56:01

line is lawrence i think

56:03

if we

56:05

pay attention

56:06

what you don't want is a situation in

56:08

which people you know

56:10

when people think about some other group

56:12

of people another country they think

56:14

about people who are sort of 5 000 miles

56:16

away and i've never met one right that's

56:19

that is not where we want to be

56:22

and i think this this generalizes i i

56:25

think you policies that are designed to

56:27

produce this sort of uh

56:29

at least as a side benefit this kind of

56:31

interaction is important and we still

56:33

have some of the assets i mean i have

56:34

friends all over china

56:36

you know these are people i've worked

56:37

with worked beside you know

56:40

at times kind of helped with policy you

56:43

know

56:44

development in in the government and

56:47

whatnot

56:48

now you know we we may get pushed back

56:50

to our

56:51

one side or the other because of the

56:52

geopolitical tensions and that would be

56:54

a great shame but but they're still

56:56

there right

56:58

these are people who basically share the

57:01

same

57:02

roughly the same vision about how the

57:05

world should work in a kind of uh

57:08

mutually supportive cooperative way

57:10

so i'd be optimistic about that yeah

57:13

well we're going to take two or three

57:14

more questions michael before we wrap up

57:16

here the first one i want to bring to

57:18

you and we'll try to get through them as

57:19

quickly as we can a lot of discussions

57:21

around economies of scale uh and the

57:23

need for that and we also see a lot of

57:25

big conglomerates being formed a lot of

57:27

the big tech companies you see some

57:29

people talking about the new form of

57:30

monopolies

57:31

how important what is the role you see

57:34

for the likes of the apples googles and

57:36

others and the facebooks and you name it

57:39

in terms of making sure that competition

57:42

continues to be a foundation for

57:45

innovation and a foundation for growth

57:48

what's the role of the big players in

57:50

making sure that they do not cannibalize

57:51

the rest of the market

57:53

right

57:55

so the mega platforms which are

57:57

essentially almost all located in the

57:59

united states and china uh

58:03

people that may surprise people but it's

58:04

true i mean there's you know mercado

58:06

libre and latin america is a pretty big

58:08

e-commerce and payments platform

58:11

very very successful um but it's in a

58:14

slightly smaller market so you know the

58:16

the alibabas and amp financials and

58:18

googles and amazons

58:21

you know you don't find them in europe

58:22

at least not you know domicile here

58:25

they're enormously powerful

58:27

the ecosystems that they are the center

58:30

of that they architect are enormously

58:32

powerful

58:34

you know engines for creating inclusive

58:36

growth opportunities but

58:38

you know they they're going to be

58:40

regulated so the the world in which you

58:42

know we live 15 years ago was the

58:44

internet's a wonderful thing and it's

58:46

you know there's a few standards

58:49

associated with it that's gone right

58:51

it's gonna be regulated everywhere not

58:53

the same way

58:54

and part of it is competition and you

58:56

know and so on um you know and not using

58:59

their market power to block access to

59:01

markets or buy up everybody before they

59:03

get to market so you don't have to

59:05

compete with them and that's that's

59:08

to use american terminology that's the

59:10

job of antitrust

59:12

you know and congress is in the middle

59:13

of this too so

59:15

but there's other issues you know

59:16

there's you know how do you regulate if

59:18

you want to regulate it all internet

59:20

content

59:21

you know are do you want to rely on

59:23

private sector in you know incentives

59:25

for data security

59:27

and or defining you know

59:30

what are the responsibilities related to

59:32

sort of privacy and the use of data can

59:35

you sell it to somebody etcetera all of

59:37

these things are kind of works in

59:39

progress right right now

59:41

um and they're important and they're

59:43

happening everywhere right so you know

59:45

you get on a plane and fly to beijing

59:47

and you'll discover there's a you know

59:48

probably

59:50

certainly in a very aggressive

59:53

set of regulatory patterns the same in

59:54

fintech right you know you could with

59:57

artificial intelligence

59:58

you can do a fantastic job of lending to

01:00:01

people who

01:00:02

traditional banks have trouble lending

01:00:03

to because they don't know who they are

01:00:05

they're completely anonymous right no

01:00:07

track record no collateral no nothing

01:00:10

but but they do participate in the

01:00:12

digital economy and it turns out

01:00:14

that the people who have the data you

01:00:16

know can lend money to them but

01:00:19

then the regulators come in and say yeah

01:00:21

but now you're competing with banks

01:00:24

the banks have you know capital

01:00:25

requirements underpinning their lending

01:00:28

activity the credit activity and you

01:00:30

don't have any that's not fair we're not

01:00:32

going to do that anymore and besides

01:00:34

it's risky and so you know we're we're

01:00:36

in this world of kind of moving targets

01:00:38

all the way around but you know we'll

01:00:39

get to the end of it eventually

01:00:43

and it'll be

01:00:44

heavily regulated there is an there is a

01:00:48

fairly serious risk

01:00:50

of some degree of balkanization of the

01:00:52

global economy as a result of this

01:00:55

i should tell you story when i used the

01:00:57

word balkanization in a talk in turk in

01:00:59

in istanbul a very nice

01:01:02

participant a woman put her hand up and

01:01:05

said you might want to use a different

01:01:08

uh at least in this part of the world so

01:01:10

i said okay i won't use right

01:01:12

fragmentation is a better term

01:01:14

what we're talking about but you know we

01:01:16

have we right now underway are numerous

01:01:20

across a wide range of countries

01:01:22

um restrictions on the on the use of

01:01:24

data whether it can move across borders

01:01:27

whether it can be stored in any country

01:01:29

other than the one for which you know

01:01:31

the data

01:01:33

the data is about etc and then you ask

01:01:36

so digital global supply chains with

01:01:39

with data that can't move across borders

01:01:44

we're in this world where we're going to

01:01:46

have to try to figure out

01:01:48

the answers and balance these things but

01:01:51

uh but but it's not simple

01:01:53

yeah i think that's where we are the

01:01:55

other thing i'll mention right you know

01:01:56

real quick lawrence is

01:01:59

the mega platforms get all the attention

01:02:01

you know because that's the thing you

01:02:02

know when you pull out your phone and

01:02:04

you use that's kind of what you see but

01:02:08

there is literal explosion of

01:02:10

entrepreneurial activity much of it in

01:02:12

the digital area globally it's

01:02:14

extraordinary it's happened in the last

01:02:16

10 years these are these are entities

01:02:18

they're not small i mean a lot of them

01:02:20

are unicorns meaning companies with

01:02:23

about they get a valuation of a billion

01:02:25

or more before they go public

01:02:28

so you have i don't know

01:02:30

300 and some odd in china you know 500

01:02:33

in the united states

01:02:34

100 in india and rising rapidly lots of

01:02:38

them in brazil we even have them in

01:02:39

europe in paris and and berlin

01:02:43

i think it's kind of invisible you know

01:02:45

when people focus on the mega platforms

01:02:47

and think they dominate the digital

01:02:49

world they don't

01:02:50

but they dominate part of it

01:02:53

but there's another part that's growing

01:02:54

pretty fast

01:02:58

and some of them are going to come up

01:03:01

eventually threaten those folks so it's

01:03:03

pretty healthy down at that level this

01:03:05

globalization of

01:03:07

entrepreneurial activity and the support

01:03:09

of ecosystems

01:03:10

there are a lot of things we didn't

01:03:12

cover michael and we could go on for

01:03:14

for more than a year just talking about

01:03:16

some of these issues i want us to end on

01:03:18

two quick topics one is institutions i

01:03:22

mean you talk a lot in your book about

01:03:23

the important role of institutions we

01:03:25

have the g7 g20

01:03:27

world bank a lot of other international

01:03:29

organizations

01:03:30

um how important are their roles and

01:03:32

also do you imagine a situation where

01:03:35

developing countries develop so much so

01:03:38

that there is no longer the need for the

01:03:39

world bank i've gotten that question

01:03:41

many times what happens when developing

01:03:43

countries and poverty is gone

01:03:45

well we still need the world bank

01:03:49

probably not i mean we're not there yet

01:03:51

but you know yeah it the world bank

01:03:54

started as a war recovery bank had

01:03:56

nothing to do with the developing world

01:03:58

of poverty reduction

01:04:00

and they finished that mandate um and

01:04:02

then they

01:04:04

adopted this one which was i think

01:04:05

entirely appropriate and that's been

01:04:07

with us for the last at least 50 years

01:04:10

and you know it would be nice some some

01:04:12

day down the road

01:04:15

that weren't the main activity what i

01:04:17

expect to happen then is the world bank

01:04:19

will will move to something else that's

01:04:21

a challenge maybe aggressively funding

01:04:24

you know global public goods in the

01:04:26

sustainability area and so on but

01:04:29

they've already done it once they could

01:04:31

do it again

01:04:33

these institutions are very important um

01:04:35

lawrence and and you and i talked

01:04:37

briefly about it before but um the the

01:04:40

problem right now they're in retreat you

01:04:43

there's no question about that

01:04:45

it varies you know but the wto is

01:04:47

struggling uh

01:04:49

yeah i think relative to the needs some

01:04:52

of them are under capitalized the imf is

01:04:54

still pretty influential but we probably

01:04:56

could use a larger imf

01:04:58

but but the underlying problem here is

01:05:01

that the you know the the the

01:05:03

the deciders in chief to use george

01:05:05

bush's term are nations right and if

01:05:08

they are are having trouble agreeing on

01:05:11

anything then the casualties will be in

01:05:14

part these important

01:05:15

international institutions so the wto

01:05:18

has been a side swipe not because they

01:05:19

were incompetent is because a major

01:05:22

player started ignoring them

01:05:24

and they had trouble reaching agreement

01:05:29

you know

01:05:30

it additional trade agreements but but

01:05:33

the dispute resolution mechanism has

01:05:35

been under attack too

01:05:38

because people sort of say well if i

01:05:39

don't like the answer then i'm ignoring

01:05:41

it and if you're big enough you can get

01:05:43

away with that i mean the g7 can

01:05:45

probably get something done but it's the

01:05:47

kind of it's the developed countries you

01:05:50

know club

01:05:51

and the g20 is much more representative

01:05:54

but if you have china and russia

01:05:56

and the us and europe

01:05:58

you know and a few other india and some

01:06:01

indonesia and some major

01:06:03

developing countries in this environment

01:06:06

with this level of tension

01:06:09

it's hard to see them sort of agreeing

01:06:11

on much of substance right in the short

01:06:14

run i mean indonesia has got them on

01:06:17

this round so they're going to try

01:06:19

and we can always hope that they they

01:06:21

get somewhere and do what lawrence said

01:06:22

a minute ago which is to say okay we're

01:06:24

going to disagree about that but let's

01:06:26

focus on this where we might be able to

01:06:28

agree so i wouldn't write them off and

01:06:30

it's probably still a good idea for them

01:06:32

to get together but

01:06:33

but i wouldn't underestimate the

01:06:34

challenge of engineering any kind of

01:06:36

substantive

01:06:38

you know and reasonably aggressive you

01:06:41

international collective action at this

01:06:44

well let's end on a note that you are

01:06:46

good at michael wishes growth and i want

01:06:48

to talk very briefly about sustaining

01:06:50

growth and minimizing inequality

01:06:52

so by the year 2030 25th day or between

01:06:55

the year 23rd 25th the world population

01:06:58

is set to grow to between uh nine

01:07:00

billion about nine billion people we

01:07:02

will still have seven billion living in

01:07:04

what we call the developing world or

01:07:06

maybe the emerging economies and we have

01:07:08

about two billion people living in the

01:07:10

rich world

01:07:11

more or less

01:07:13

how do we ensure

01:07:15

that this transition is done in such a

01:07:18

that we can sustainably

01:07:21

raise the level of standard of living

01:07:23

for these 7 billion people

01:07:26

but still maintain some

01:07:28

common level of sustainability or

01:07:31

lifestyle for those who are already

01:07:33

living in the rich world in essence can

01:07:35

we balance can we do both can we find

01:07:37

this balance without someone having to

01:07:39

give because it seems for me that it's

01:07:42

difficult to have everyone still be rich

01:07:45

and other people get enriched as well so

01:07:46

how do we do this sustained growth

01:07:49

minimize inequality at the same time

01:07:53

it's a very good question i mean

01:07:55

lawrence i don't think it's as hard as

01:07:56

you suggest so let me

01:07:58

i mean i did a few calculations so if

01:08:00

you take the major developing countries

01:08:02

you know they're developed countries

01:08:04

right europe's foreign for 450 million

01:08:08

the united states is 350 million canada

01:08:10

adds you know another 35. japan's 120

01:08:13

million you get up to about a billion

01:08:15

maybe you could go around and find some

01:08:17

more you know if you had south korea and

01:08:20

the taiwanese economy in singapore which

01:08:22

is only has four million people and

01:08:23

stuff you know you start to get

01:08:25

get up there

01:08:27

then you've got the problem that you

01:08:28

described but you know my best guess bet

01:08:31

is that at least

01:08:33

well let's take china and india

01:08:36

but each of them has a population of 1.4

01:08:38

billion

01:08:40

that's that's 2.8 all right so you're

01:08:43

almost you're already at almost three

01:08:45

times the current you know high income

01:08:48

and and unless something goes badly

01:08:50

wrong my expectation is these will be

01:08:52

high income countries by the time china

01:08:54

well before 2050 in india you know

01:08:57

following along but probably in that

01:09:00

category by 2050 and and there's a bunch

01:09:02

of other countries that are probably

01:09:04

going to be in the same category so what

01:09:06

i'm trying to say is the problem may not

01:09:09

be as hard as you think you know if you

01:09:11

have a world

01:09:12

in which

01:09:13

let's say

01:09:15

somewhere around 60 percent of of the

01:09:17

world's population is living in high

01:09:20

income countries

01:09:21

then their resources relative to the

01:09:24

of the lower income countries are going

01:09:27

to be absolutely massive right now that

01:09:29

doesn't mean they'll discharge their

01:09:31

responsibilities but it means the

01:09:33

balance

01:09:34

you know

01:09:35

between

01:09:37

the availability of resources and living

01:09:39

well and the ability to invest you know

01:09:42

because it's in our mutual interest to

01:09:43

do it i mean we don't want a whole

01:09:45

continent floundering around

01:09:49

or under desperately migrating or

01:09:51

whatever i'm not saying that's where

01:09:53

africa the african countries are going

01:09:54

to be i'm a lot more optimistic than

01:09:58

but i think

01:09:59

i think what that what in your narrative

01:10:02

what's missing is this continuing high

01:10:04

growth potential of major parts of the

01:10:06

emerging economy so that on your time

01:10:08

horizon

01:10:09

they'll actually be

01:10:11

in the oecd kind of territory

01:10:15

well michael this has been wonderful

01:10:18

again congratulations on the nobel peace

01:10:20

prize after maybe a decade but

01:10:22

congratulations also on the book not

01:10:24

peace i've never been criticized for it

01:10:28

economics economics i sometimes and i'm

01:10:31

blending it all together but really it's

01:10:33

been a fascinating conversation the book

01:10:35

is the next convergence i highly

01:10:37

recommend this book even though it was

01:10:38

written about more than a decade ago it

01:10:40

is still very substantive and michael we

01:10:42

look forward to your next book whenever

01:10:44

it's written i'll be one of the first to

01:10:46

get it and certainly would love to have

01:10:47

you back

01:10:48

on our series of influential minds and

01:10:51

thanks again for agreeing to be our

01:10:53

inaugural guest on this very important

01:10:55

platform thank you so much it was a

01:10:58

great pleasure lawrence thank you thank

01:11:00

you for having me

Next in the archive

Influential Minds: A Conversation with Michael Spence — Influential Minds