Episode 0147 minWatch on YouTube

About this conversation

Rethinking globalization through resilient supply chains, local prosperity and a people-centered clean energy transition.

Ask about this conversation

This conversation only
Answers are grounded in indexed transcripts only.

Transcript

00:00

foreign

01:03

all right well thank you so much for

01:05

having me thanks for joining us this is

01:07

the second day of the global

01:08

electrification forum and obviously the

01:11

theme for today homecoming we're going

01:13

to kick it off talking about your book

01:14

homecoming prosperity in the first

01:17

Global World well listen I want to begin

01:19

why don't you first just tell the

01:21

audience a little bit about yourself

01:24

well thank you finally for that

01:25

introduction I'm delighted to be with

01:27

you and thank you so much for the

01:29

consideration

01:30

um and and time with my books

01:32

um I have for my sins been a journalist

01:35

for most of my 32 years of working and I

01:39

had a brief foray at one point into

01:41

Venture Capital which I'll tell you

01:43

about but I basically started my career

01:44

I was a failed pre-med student to be

01:47

honest with you um I went into Columbia

01:49

and did a double major in English and

01:51

pre-med and it's really good I had the

01:52

English because the pre-med didn't work

01:55

um uh but uh it was great because it got

01:58

me into journalism and the thing about

02:00

journalism that I found so addictive

02:03

really is the ability to be curious

02:05

about anything to wake up in the morning

02:07

and be able to call interesting people

02:10

and and ask questions

02:12

um and I start I started out

02:14

uh in business journalism I have thought

02:17

about going into Political journalism

02:19

but it was quite a crowded field and I'm

02:22

really pleased actually that I was able

02:23

to go into business journalism and

02:25

economics because in some ways I think

02:28

in the 30 plus years that I've been

02:30

working that's really been where the

02:31

action is

02:32

um uh I have worked at Forbes I've

02:35

worked at Newsweek Time Magazine

02:38

um and now at the financial times as a

02:40

columnist I've also authored three books

02:44

um I have a TV contract as a contributor

02:47

with CNN and I've done radio podcasts

02:50

speeches so I've you know I've kind of

02:51

been through the Waterfront I guess in

02:55

terms of where I come from uh with my

02:58

world view I would say I'm shaped very

03:00

much by the place that I grew up which

03:02

was rural Indiana my father was an

03:04

immigrant from turkey and my mother's

03:07

family are immigrants too actually

03:08

Swedish and English and settled in the

03:10

rural Midwest and my father's a double

03:13

engineer Industrial Engineer electric

03:16

engineer and he worked in the auto

03:18

supply chain sort of in the Detroit

03:21

um you know ecosystem running factories

03:24

and eventually starting his own small

03:26

manufacturing business

03:28

and I would say that I saw in a very

03:32

real world way how industry worked uh

03:35

how manufacturing worked and I also had

03:38

a different perspective than many of my

03:40

peers

03:41

um you know who who are in media on

03:43

either coast of how globalization itself

03:47

had affected different communities both

03:50

in the U.S and abroad over the last

03:51

several decades so I try to bring that

03:54

um you know Mid-American experience to

03:57

my work I've been a foreign

03:59

correspondent in many countries so I try

04:01

and really blend Global and local and

04:04

that's very much you know at the heart

04:05

of the perspective that I have well let

04:08

me first congratulate on the book so so

04:10

you talked about all of your Global

04:12

perspectives and we'll get into that and

04:13

we talked about the book and more

04:15

details so in essence you're considering

04:17

a sub-in clinics or an economist

04:20

you know I like to call myself a

04:22

journalist although you know I'm deeply

04:24

rooted in economics I'm actually

04:25

teaching it I'm I'm teaching economics

04:28

and business at Columbia University this

04:29

spring so I guess that makes me part of

04:31

the club but you know I I like to think

04:34

of myself a little bit as an outsider to

04:37

the profession uh which I think is

04:39

helpful because

04:41

um economics itself has has come in for

04:44

a bit of an existential crisis I would

04:46

say in in recent decades um you know

04:49

conventional Chicago School Efficient

04:52

Market Theory let's say has worked in

04:55

some ways in the last half century but

04:57

it's also failed to account for a lot of

05:01

negative externalities

05:03

um you know with the sort of

05:05

technological job destruction

05:06

Outsourcing the hollowing out of certain

05:09

parts of oecd Nations

05:12

um you know the last half century has

05:14

seen a tremendous growth in global

05:17

wealth but it's also seen a tremendous

05:19

growth in quality and that's something

05:21

that the economics profession really

05:24

didn't always account for in fact

05:25

something I get into in this book is the

05:28

fact that economists have always thought

05:30

as long as you create jobs at a net

05:33

level globally everything's fine you

05:36

know they didn't really think in terms

05:38

of place well maybe it's a little

05:40

different to create jobs you know just

05:42

when you're thinking about the US for

05:44

example in Austin versus in my hometown

05:46

of Frankfort Indiana or Brooklyn New

05:49

York where I live or at a global level

05:51

Brussels or Nigeria or or Shenzhen

05:55

um I think that economists are realizing

05:57

that job creation and economic Dynamics

06:00

in different communities work in

06:02

different ways and that's something I'm

06:03

really trying to dig into in this book

06:05

so let's talk a little bit about

06:07

diplomacy so we started on the Jeff

06:10

yesterday we had several diplomats

06:12

ambassadors here we had someone from the

06:14

state department talking about the

06:16

importance of diplomacy in the context

06:18

of the energy transition I've never sort

06:20

of a discussing but I did not have a

06:22

decision about this previously so as a

06:26

business perspective when you look at

06:28

people

06:29

talking about the synergies between

06:30

diplomacy and business how can these two

06:33

girls

06:34

come together to have an impact on the

06:37

energy transition

06:39

that's such an interesting question

06:41

um you know it's funny I was just last

06:43

week I was actually at Columbia

06:45

University at the School of

06:46

International and public affairs and I

06:48

was moderating a fireside chat with an

06:51

EU diplomat

06:52

and diplomacy is in a tough spot at the

06:56

moment because I think in some ways

06:58

diplomats were very much a part of the

07:02

neoliberal world of you know the World

07:04

is Flat all boats are rising we're we're

07:06

all going to be on a kind of a an even

07:08

playing field uh history has ended as

07:11

Francis fukuyama would have told us

07:13

but that's not been the case um the

07:16

world is not flat the world is Bumpy and

07:18

we are in more need of diplomacy and

07:21

particularly diplomacy in the political

07:24

economy I would say than ever before

07:28

I think that one thing diplomats are

07:31

struggling with is the fact that we do

07:33

increasingly live in at least a one

07:36

world two systems Paradigm and what I

07:38

mean by that is

07:40

um we have free market economies like

07:43

the US like Europe some other oecd

07:45

countries some developing countries and

07:48

we have a state

07:49

um capitalist system China would be the

07:52

you know primary example there but there

07:53

are others that are coming into the

07:55

Chinese orbit and that's a very very

07:57

different Paradigm than we've seen in

07:59

the last half century so I don't think

08:03

this is necessarily a bad thing

08:06

um you know I'm certainly not for trade

08:08

Wars or or conflict

08:10

um but I think that we have

08:12

overestimated how far we can go with

08:15

Hyper globalization

08:17

um you know one of the things that I

08:19

think has caused some of the political

08:20

polarization and diplomatic problems

08:22

that we've seen is the fact that in the

08:24

neoliberal system there was a certain

08:26

assumption that capital goods and people

08:28

could all travel equally and seamlessly

08:31

across borders but the truth of the

08:33

matter is the capital investment always

08:35

traveled faster than either goods and

08:37

certainly than people and so what that

08:40

has led to is a situation in which you

08:42

do have a sort of a global Elite a

08:45

technocratic elite and certainly an

08:48

investment Elite that are operating 35

08:50

000 feet above sometimes the interests

08:54

of nation states and that is causing

08:57

problems because a lot of Voters in

08:59

nation states are saying hey wait a

09:00

minute are the economic policies being

09:03

put forward by my country working for me

09:05

and so I think that's why you know we're

09:08

seeing a little bit of a pendulum shift

09:10

away from the sort of World is Flat

09:12

Paradigm that a lot of diplomats have

09:14

worked with for the last half century

09:15

and more towards uh regionalism and

09:18

localism that will bring with it some

09:20

conflict but I believe will also bring

09:22

with it a little bit of rebalancing at

09:24

least from an economic perspective

09:27

um you know in the U.S for example we're

09:29

seeing greater hubbing of production and

09:32

consumption all over the world we're

09:34

seeing a questioning of very far-flung

09:37

complex Supply chains do these make

09:39

sense from an energy perspective do they

09:41

make sense from a carbon emissions

09:42

perspective are there new technologies

09:45

that could allow us to harness what is

09:47

best of global and local at the same

09:49

time and so those are some of the

09:51

economic questions that I see diplomats

09:53

are going to have to start really

09:54

incorporating into their world view yeah

09:56

you know so unbelievable why I found

09:59

fascinating was the amount of research

10:01

you did in terms of working together

10:03

anecdotes from you know from different

10:05

walks of life actually I want to talk a

10:07

little bit about this issue you talked

10:09

about in the world regarding efficiency

10:12

and resilience

10:14

words that are very very important in

10:16

for our industry we spend a lot of time

10:18

focusing on Brazilians resilience we're

10:22

keeping the lives on and bringing the

10:23

system back up when you talk about

10:25

resilience and efficiency from a

10:26

different angle in terms of an epidemi

10:36

talk about that

10:38

yeah absolutely you know it's so

10:40

interesting folks that that are in your

10:42

world and dealing with these real world

10:44

problems like keeping the lights on you

10:46

know resiliency is always top of mind

10:48

but for many Business Leaders

10:51

um that are sitting remotely in a corner

10:54

office somewhere in a c-suite and making

10:56

decisions about Supply chains they may

10:59

be quite disconnected from what is

11:01

actually happening in the real world on

11:03

the ground in the factories where those

11:05

lights need to be kept on and in fact

11:09

many of the decisions are being taken

11:12

um you know with the lessons one would

11:14

learn at business school in a finance

11:16

101 class which is Marshall your Capital

11:20

um try and move as much cost off the

11:23

balance sheet as possible treat labor

11:26

like a cost rather than an asset and

11:29

what those truisms let's say of

11:32

conventional Business School teaching

11:34

have led to is a lot of Outsourcing to

11:38

cheaper fiber countries a lot of

11:41

um sort of siloing

11:43

um and and monopolization of Supply

11:45

chains let me give you an example

11:48

when the pandemic hit a few years ago

11:51

we saw a lot of disruption in Supply

11:52

chains and one thing I think that many

11:54

of us felt very cutely was the food

11:56

supply chain so suddenly the pandemic

11:59

hits nobody's going out to restaurants

12:00

anymore those are all closed we're all

12:03

lining up the grocery store though and

12:05

suddenly shelves are empty we can't find

12:07

the tomato sauce or you know the eggs or

12:10

the the the basic products that you

12:12

think how can this be how can there be a

12:14

shortage and farmers are throwing away

12:17

milk or meat or grain and so there's

12:20

this very odd supply and demand mismatch

12:22

that conventional economics would tell

12:24

us really shouldn't exist how did this

12:27

happen well business 101 Finance 101 has

12:32

told the CEOs to basically go into very

12:36

complex siled Supply chains so the

12:38

restaurant industry has one the grocery

12:41

store industry has one there's about

12:42

three or four companies that control

12:44

each one and they don't talk to one

12:46

another

12:47

now that's an efficient system because

12:50

it's fast it's concentrated but it's

12:53

only efficient when there are no

12:55

problems right when there's no pandemic

12:58

when there's not a tsunami that's

13:00

interrupting a supply chain um you know

13:02

in the audio industry as happened in

13:04

Japan a decade ago

13:07

um and it also comes this sort of

13:08

thinking comes with hidden risk on the

13:11

balance sheet so one of those risks

13:13

clearly was being unable to get crucial

13:15

PPE uh being unable to get certain

13:18

antibiotic inputs because they only came

13:21

from China and they were not available

13:23

at a certain period of time

13:24

so I think that Business Leaders

13:27

everywhere are starting to rethink

13:29

Finance 101 and maybe take a page out of

13:33

um the book of engineering you know or

13:35

the book of the defense department where

13:36

you know folks really have that

13:38

resiliency hat on all the time that's

13:41

interesting so this basement that they I

13:44

think they trusted the book when you

13:46

talk about mobilization and you say of

13:48

course Global World now since maybe the

13:51

last three years there have been so many

13:53

books written in globalization

13:54

globalization instead School Renditions

13:58

and you talk about post the post-world

14:00

are you trying to sort of also explain

14:03

it in that you're not saying that

14:04

globalization would stop you're saying

14:06

it's going to be different

14:08

this new mobilization from your

14:10

perspective what emphasis on

14:12

regionalization and localization

14:15

for sure so let me let me step back a

14:18

little bit first and say

14:20

um that I think if we go back in deep

14:23

history economic pendulums always swing

14:26

right they swing back and forth and when

14:28

one system becomes too extreme it swings

14:32

back to the median so you can go back in

14:34

history and look at say you know the

14:36

18th century and say okay mercantilism

14:38

worked until it didn't and then we got

14:41

more laissez-faire trading systems and

14:44

then you could look at say the run-up to

14:45

the 1920s and the the 29 crash in the

14:49

Great Depression then you could say okay

14:50

now we get keynesianism because we need

14:52

a little more government nudging of the

14:54

markets in certain way to create demand

14:56

and then you can move into the 70s and

14:58

say all right well maybe markets became

15:01

a little too sclerotic maybe we needed

15:03

to unleash animal spirits and so we got

15:05

the Reagan Thatcher Revolution now I

15:08

think what we've seen is that hyper

15:11

globalization in which capital has

15:13

become so disconnected from labor and

15:16

Global has become too disconnected from

15:19

local in terms of the needs of specific

15:21

communities we're once again seeing a

15:23

pendulum shift back

15:25

um and I would actually add one more

15:27

thing which is markets Wall Street

15:29

became a little too disconnected from

15:32

Main Street as part of this so you

15:34

started seeing um you know a paradigm in

15:37

which as long as share prices are going

15:39

up and consumer prices are going down

15:40

everything's fine but that doesn't

15:42

account for the well-being of local

15:44

communities as a whole for job creation

15:46

in different parts of the the country

15:48

and the world so where are we now I

15:51

think we're moving towards as you say a

15:53

new regionalism

15:54

a new localism in which governments

15:58

everywhere are saying you know what it's

16:00

not just about share prices and consumer

16:03

prices it's about a larger ecosystem of

16:06

stakeholders it's about making sure that

16:09

individual communities aren't hollowed

16:11

out in such a way that you start seeing

16:13

deaths of Despair that you start seeing

16:16

more political polarization because

16:19

people are angry and hopeless it's about

16:21

creating launch pads it's about creating

16:24

resiliency and redundancy and making

16:26

sure that wealth is not held in just a

16:29

handful of places so how is this

16:31

operating well there are a number of

16:34

things pushing this and I would I would

16:35

point to two particular factors we've

16:37

we've heard a lot about contentious

16:39

geopolitics and you know trade Wars

16:42

between the US and China and that's

16:43

certainly part of the story but well

16:45

before the Biden Administration the

16:47

Trump Administration you can go back to

16:50

2015 and look at China's made in China

16:54

2025 proposal which was it was quite

16:57

interesting it was the Chinese party

16:59

coming out and saying we think we have a

17:02

new economic growth Paradigm here we are

17:04

now a rich enough nation that we can

17:06

both consume and produce we don't want

17:09

to just be the factory of the world we

17:12

want to consume more of what we're

17:14

making at home and regionally we want to

17:17

control more local Supply chains and

17:19

that made a lot of sense from an energy

17:21

conservation from an emissions concert

17:23

conservation standpoint you now see

17:26

other areas

17:28

um the U.S Canada Mexico sort of coming

17:31

together in a I would say a new and

17:34

improved sort of NAFTA Arrangement you

17:36

see discussions transatlantically

17:38

between the U.S and the EU about clean

17:41

energy Supply chains you see in many

17:44

places U.S Europe and Asia are

17:47

rethinking of

17:49

um where and how should we be making

17:52

basic Goods like semiconductors for

17:54

example so you think about the old

17:56

system of globalization very

17:58

concentrated very siled this led us to a

18:01

place in which 92 percent of all

18:04

high-end semiconductor chips were made

18:06

in Taiwan now

18:08

that isn't necessarily good for really

18:11

anybody China the US Europe that's a lot

18:13

of concentration in one Island I mean

18:15

forget about if there's a you know a a

18:18

hot war or any kind of geopolitical

18:20

incident even if you had a tsunami in a

18:22

place like that you could suddenly have

18:25

a global crisis because the the

18:27

lifeblood of the economy semiconductor

18:29

chips would be wiped out so you're

18:31

seeing a move towards more Regional

18:33

resiliency particularly in crucial Goods

18:35

I think you're going to see this not

18:37

only in semiconductors but in in clean

18:39

energy which we need as much of it as we

18:41

can get you know I have no problem with

18:43

the inflation reduction act because I

18:45

think great if the U.S wants to

18:47

subsidize clean energy awesome if Europe

18:49

wants to subsidize it great if China

18:52

wants to do it awesome we need more of

18:54

that rare earth minerals lithium

18:57

batteries

18:59

um uh certain kinds of antibiotics and

19:01

and chemical inputs I think that we're

19:03

going to see countries saying maybe we

19:06

need a little bit more Supply and maybe

19:07

we need redundancy of Supply so that's

19:10

sort of what I mean at the high end Also

19:14

let's say at the lower end in terms of

19:17

lower margin Goods like textiles or

19:20

furniture or you know shoes lighting

19:22

fixtures there's been a rethinking for

19:25

10 15 years of conventional Supply

19:27

chains I think a lot of producers have

19:30

said we want to be faster to Market we

19:32

don't want to spend as much on energy

19:34

you know we probably are going to see a

19:36

period of energy inflation as we make a

19:38

transition to clean energy so that's

19:40

something that a lot of businesses are

19:42

thinking about how can we keep

19:43

production uh more closely hubbed with

19:46

consumption and what's really cool and

19:49

I'll just finish with one final thought

19:51

on this point there are so many new

19:54

technologies that are allowing that to

19:56

happen additive manufacturing 3D

19:58

printing you know this is something I

19:59

get into quite a lot in my book amazing

20:02

you know you can now 3D print entire

20:05

Supply chains for something like a jet

20:07

engine or certain kinds of consumer

20:09

electronics or medical devices you can

20:11

print them all at once in one place

20:13

that's something that was incredibly

20:15

useful in the pandemic so so you know we

20:19

have the theme of this yes

20:22

is energizing in building lives and can

20:26

you talk about globalization let's talk

20:27

about what it means for the perhaps six

20:31

billion who may not necessarily have

20:33

access to energy in the context of

20:35

having it always available and also you

20:38

know in the book you get into this issue

20:40

around system family where you talk

20:42

about literally a little Bitcoin and I

20:45

will put people in the context of some

20:47

energy water the whole sort of a Nexus

20:50

there

20:51

talk about how the world's population

20:54

get into people

20:56

yeah you see globalization working as

20:59

the world gets even more populated in

21:01

terms of regionalization localization

21:04

and even just from a General sharing of

21:08

the resources on the planet have you

21:10

seen these things working together

21:13

yeah that's such a great question let me

21:15

sort of take that in two parts

21:17

um I'll first answer in a kind of a more

21:20

philosophical way

21:22

um one of the problems with Efficient

21:24

Market Theory this kind of Market knows

21:27

best theory is it worked in certain ways

21:31

you know it worked if you're talking

21:32

about maybe consumer products or luxury

21:34

goods we know how to produce plenty of

21:36

those there's demand there's Supply

21:39

but certain kinds of public goods you

21:42

know

21:43

um as you as you said clean water

21:46

um clean energy access to basic

21:49

Technologies in places that are not

21:52

necessarily Rich consumer markets yet

21:55

but might be that someday if they could

21:57

get access to to basic things that they

22:00

need the market hasn't always provided

22:03

so well for those sorts of

22:06

um of needs and and that has been a real

22:09

negative externality

22:11

um you know we have needed for decades

22:13

now to make a shift to cleaner energy

22:15

sources the market hasn't really nudged

22:18

Us in that direction as fast as we need

22:21

to go and so you're thinking you're

22:24

you're seeing at an at a nation-state

22:26

level a rethinking of this different

22:28

countries in different regions saying we

22:31

are going to have to nudge the market in

22:33

this direction ourselves

22:35

um Europe is doing this Asia the U.S all

22:39

in different ways but individual

22:40

countries are too you know we haven't

22:42

talked yet about India India is a

22:44

fascinating Market West Africa another I

22:47

would I would you know speak about

22:49

Nigeria but also other parts of West

22:51

Africa maybe as a single sort of

22:52

regional market you're seeing a lot of

22:55

action of countries coming together and

22:58

saying we now have decentralized

23:00

Technologies we have the ability to kind

23:02

of LeapFrog generationally Technologies

23:05

in ways that can help us to become more

23:08

resistant or sorry resilient

23:10

um we're focusing more on providing for

23:13

the needs of our internal markets we're

23:15

thinking about how to improve you know

23:17

local energy grids we're thinking about

23:19

how to use decentralized farming

23:21

techniques to to make sure that we don't

23:24

end up with a global food crisis as we

23:26

have in the last few years thanks to the

23:28

pandemic so

23:30

I just think that this conversation

23:32

about

23:33

redundancy and resiliency is ultimately

23:36

gonna be a good thing now you're also

23:39

going to see and this this is where it

23:41

could get a little tricky from a

23:42

geopolitical standpoint I think you're

23:44

going to see some some power jocking

23:46

particularly between the U.S and China I

23:49

think that there's going to be and

23:50

you're already seeing this a kind of a

23:52

competition to bring countries into

23:54

these separate economic orbits let's say

23:58

and I think that that jocking is going

24:01

to last for some time in a way though

24:03

this is good for smaller countries

24:05

particularly in Emerging Markets because

24:07

they've got a choice now between a

24:09

couple of different systems and I think

24:11

that both China and the US are really

24:13

going to have to cater more to the

24:15

global South and say Here's what we're

24:17

going to do for you and here's how we're

24:19

going to do it for you and

24:22

um it's going to be interesting to see

24:24

how the chips land there and you know

24:27

and what the charm campaigns look like I

24:29

would

24:32

[Music]

24:35

interviewing a lot of Business Leaders

24:38

and one of the things that fascinating

24:41

when I read the book was the the the

24:44

candidness in which you you've been

24:47

taking the book in terms of engaging

24:48

with them

24:56

do you see them ready to adapt their

24:59

business models and down their mindset

25:01

to the reality that you will have one

25:05

two three billion people across

25:07

sub-Saharan African population who could

25:10

be being served in the new Magnet or for

25:13

uh for the economic group that they

25:15

seemed to want so our Business Leaders

25:19

looking at the potential in Africa the

25:22

potential in Asia the potential yeah but

25:25

they're still concentrated into the sort

25:27

of what they've always done business

25:28

yeah that's well that's very interesting

25:31

I think that they are quickly having to

25:34

get much more geopolitically

25:36

sophisticated you know if you look back

25:39

in the last 20 years in particular so

25:40

China came into the WTO in 2001. and

25:44

from that period onward you saw a major

25:47

flow of capital from Western

25:49

multinational particularly in the U.S

25:51

into Chinese markets into into Asia in

25:54

general but mostly into China a lot of

25:55

that was the Outsourcing of cheap labor

25:57

but also some of it was

25:59

um an entry into the Chinese market with

26:02

a hope that that would become the number

26:03

one consumer market and I think that

26:06

there was a little bit linear thinking

26:09

in that way first of all there was

26:11

perhaps some some naive assumptions

26:13

about how quickly China would

26:15

come into the Bretton Woods system I

26:17

mean I I have to say I've been going to

26:19

China now for you know 25 years I

26:21

remember Landing the first or second

26:23

time and just thinking gosh this is such

26:25

an interesting Rich different country

26:28

why does anyone think that it's going to

26:31

come seamlessly into the Bretton Woods

26:34

system the U.S and european-led system

26:36

it has its own Traditions conventions

26:39

economic rules of gravity and this was

26:43

brought home to me once I remember

26:44

interviewing a global CEO of A Clean

26:46

Energy company

26:48

in China probably uh must be 15 years

26:51

ago or so and at the time they were

26:54

number one in the wind wind energy space

26:56

and I asked the CEO I said so how are

26:59

things going what are your growth

27:01

prospects like and he's like you know

27:03

they're going they're going pretty well

27:04

I think um we're probably going to be in

27:06

the number four spot in the next five

27:08

years or so and I thought gosh well wow

27:12

that's very precise how do you how do

27:14

you know that and two why is that good

27:16

news that you're falling from number one

27:18

to number four and he said well that's

27:19

what Beijing has told us

27:21

and so I thought wow you know we are

27:25

being perhaps a little naive and a

27:27

little arrogant about the idea that

27:30

China is just going to come along with

27:33

um U.S anglo-american style capitalism

27:37

I think that that scrim has now been

27:39

pulled back and so CEOs are thinking wow

27:42

we have to get a lot more sophisticated

27:44

about local economies and local rules of

27:48

gravity and as you point out there is a

27:51

global South and there is um you know

27:53

particularly in places like West Africa

27:55

parts of the Middle East certain parts

27:57

of the Emerging Market this is the only

27:58

place where there's population growth

28:00

and if you think about what is GDP

28:02

growth it's people plus productivity and

28:05

so CEOs are realizing the world is not

28:08

flat there is a very complex

28:11

multi-national system with a lot of

28:15

different polls we're in a very

28:16

multi-polar world now and they have to

28:19

get more sophisticated about you know

28:21

taking this sort of think Global act

28:23

local idea that we've heard floating

28:26

around as a truism for a couple decades

28:28

and really putting some meat on those

28:30

bones and figuring out how to how to

28:32

cater to these markets so Serana you

28:35

also you know some foreign relations and

28:38

we mentioned this the notion of what

28:40

Business Leaders are thinking about

28:42

let's just go back to publicly asking

28:45

for a second and maybe just talk about

28:48

uh politicians in you know Western

28:51

markets in Japan how are they preparing

28:54

their citizens for this new

28:55

globalization in the context in the

28:58

sense that with millions of people

29:00

emerging in Africa or Asian other we

29:04

will have a different world now are they

29:06

comparing their population for this new

29:08

world where the dominance and perhaps

29:10

once existed

29:13

there has to be a new framing of what it

29:16

means to be number one and number two

29:18

so absolutely I love that phrase a new

29:21

framing I mean that is exactly what's

29:22

needed I'll step back and answer that

29:24

question by pointing out that we have

29:27

not done a great job particularly in

29:29

this country of preparing

29:31

citizenry for the changes ahead and I'll

29:33

give you an example in fact

29:35

this is a story that really prompted me

29:38

to write the third book

29:40

um when I was thinking about gosh why

29:43

has the global trading system become so

29:45

fractious and complex I went down to

29:47

Washington to see a source of mine

29:49

Richard trumko who used to be he's

29:51

passed away now but used to be the head

29:52

of the AFL-CIO which is the largest

29:55

labor union and I asked him you know

29:57

what were the conversations that you

29:59

were having with policy makers in

30:02

Washington in the mid-1990s when deals

30:04

like NAFTA were being cut when there was

30:07

discussion about China coming into WTO

30:09

what were you being told about how all

30:11

this was going to work and he said he

30:13

remembers

30:14

um a policy maker coming to him in the

30:16

mid 90s from the Clinton Administration

30:18

and saying look we know some of these

30:20

changes are going to suppress wages in

30:23

the U.S and in other rich countries we

30:25

know there's going to be a period of

30:27

disruption but don't worry eventually

30:29

all boats are going to rise things are

30:31

going to level out level up and in the

30:34

meantime you're going to get a lot of

30:35

cheap stuff right I mean that was the

30:37

bargain that we were going to send jobs

30:38

abroad and we were going to get cheaper

30:40

flat screen televisions in the U.S and

30:43

trumpka said well okay but how long is

30:46

that wage parity that leveling out gonna

30:49

take

30:50

and the policy maker said three to five

30:52

generations

30:54

and I remember hearing that story and

30:57

chat like looking and checking in my

30:59

notebook was that right did I get that

31:01

time for it because if you think about

31:02

it there's a certain arrogance this goes

31:05

back to your first question about the

31:06

economics profession there's a certain

31:07

arrogance to think that a you can model

31:10

perfectly what's going to happen

31:11

globally over five generations and that

31:14

secondly there aren't going to be

31:16

political and social uh secondary

31:19

effects of those changes that are then

31:22

going to cause their own problems and to

31:24

me that's what happened in the U.S we

31:26

did not have a national conversation

31:28

about look there is a rising middle

31:31

class globally a lot more countries want

31:33

to come into the global trading system

31:35

there's going to be trade-offs we need

31:37

to make sure that we really put a floor

31:39

and and more protection and compensation

31:42

and education for dislocated workers in

31:45

the west we also need to accept that

31:48

other countries will come in with their

31:50

ideas about how the global system would

31:51

run we never had that conversation but I

31:54

think we are having that conversation

31:55

now and

31:58

um that's something I've been very

31:59

pleased to see actually within the Biden

32:01

Administration

32:02

um a sense that okay yes we need to do

32:06

better by American labor but we also

32:09

need to do right by allies and and how

32:12

do you that's the conversation that's

32:13

the very

32:14

Rich challenging conversation that we're

32:17

having right now how do you balance the

32:20

interests of national voters and workers

32:23

with the interests of allies and Other

32:25

Nation States abroad so they both have

32:28

16 chapters very well researched I want

32:31

to just quickly talk about a few and

32:33

just get your thoughts and then one of

32:35

them is you call it exalted a privileged

32:38

exhibitive burden talk about that I

32:40

thought that was neuroplasticity oh

32:42

thank you for that um so I'm quoting a

32:44

former French president who said that

32:46

you know being the reserve currency of

32:48

the world the dollar in this case is

32:51

both an exorbitant privilege and an

32:53

exorbitant burden and let's think about

32:56

that why is that so the dollar is the

32:58

global Reserve currency that's been

32:59

pretty much the case in the post-war era

33:01

that means that

33:04

the U.S has the ability to run very high

33:08

um debt and deficit levels if it wants

33:10

to because you know this is the dollar

33:13

and everybody wants the dollar and

33:15

there's always going to be an inflow

33:16

into dollar assets so that allows

33:19

countries a lot of leeway in terms of

33:22

what they do with their budgets what

33:24

they spend on

33:26

um we haven't had to have in this

33:28

country those difficult guns and butter

33:30

debates you know to to use the Vietnam

33:33

War expression are you going to spend on

33:35

defense are you going to spend on social

33:36

programs other countries kind of you

33:38

know get pushed to make these choices

33:39

the US is not forced to make them in the

33:42

same way

33:43

but there are also burdens to being the

33:46

reserve currency so what would be some

33:47

of those burdens well the dollar has

33:50

been very strong relative to other

33:51

currencies for a long period of time and

33:54

that means that American manufacturers

33:57

have a burden when they're selling

33:59

abroad because they're selling products

34:01

in an expensive currency so what does

34:04

that mean that basically sorts for a

34:06

kind of financialization of the U.S

34:09

economy we get a lot of money coming

34:12

into the system from abroad we get a lot

34:14

of folks wanting to buy U.S assets

34:16

t-bills real estate stocks and bonds

34:18

whatever it is that pushes the financial

34:21

economy up and kind of makes it

34:23

preeminent it creates a lot of asset

34:25

price growth

34:26

but it also tends to create Financial

34:28

fragility it creates excesses it creates

34:31

Bubbles and I think that after boy 40

34:35

Years of pretty easy money low interest

34:37

rates as we begin to see a paradigm

34:40

change now where interest rates are

34:42

rising there does seem to be a little

34:44

bit more of a policy in this

34:46

Administration to say you know what

34:47

we're not going to prioritize a strong

34:49

dollar we're going to prioritize more of

34:51

a balance of manufacturing and Industry

34:54

and production and consumption we're not

34:56

going to just assume that everybody in

34:58

this country can be a software developer

35:00

or a banker you know we're going to

35:01

think about a broader range of of jobs

35:05

that is good in a lot of ways but it

35:07

also means that we're probably going to

35:09

see some bubbles bursting you know we've

35:11

already seen with the fall of Silicon

35:13

Valley Bank for example and some of the

35:14

Ripple effects of that or globally what

35:16

we've seen in the UK with uh which is

35:18

another country that has a lot of

35:20

financial access

35:22

um you've seen you know a currency

35:24

correction and some some real problems

35:25

in the economy and UK so we will see

35:28

more of that but again I see the economy

35:30

as a pendulum it shifts when it gets too

35:33

extreme in One Direction it starts to

35:34

swing back to the middle and that's the

35:36

process that we're in right now

35:41

it was very interesting a caring economy

35:44

following everything

35:47

yeah this was one of my favorite

35:49

chapters to research

35:51

um I think that we are in for a major

35:54

shift in the type of Labor that we need

35:57

so let's think about what we've

36:00

prioritized in the last half century or

36:02

so we've prioritized brain work

36:05

um you know if you think about head

36:06

heart hands we've really prioritized

36:08

head work you know cognitive work

36:12

um we've we've prioritized um you know

36:14

moving up the food chain into higher

36:16

value Services desk jobs we haven't

36:19

prioritized empathy we haven't

36:21

prioritized um uh you know work that's

36:24

done with the hands

36:26

if you think about now the technological

36:28

disruption we're going through AI is

36:31

going to disrupt a tremendous number of

36:34

white-collar jobs so everything we've

36:36

seen in the manufacturing space you know

36:39

in the 80s and 90s and the 90s that may

36:41

be coming to higher level Services now

36:42

as artificial intelligence and other

36:44

Technologies can do more brain work so

36:47

what's left well a lot of jobs in the

36:50

care economy if you think about the

36:52

fastest growing job categories out of

36:54

the top 10 in America six of them are in

36:56

the care economy Health Care education

36:59

child care and unfortunately many of

37:03

these jobs have not paid as well they've

37:05

not been as highly prioritized or as

37:07

valued you know we talk about essential

37:09

workers you know but we don't often

37:12

treat folks in these essential

37:13

professions as with as much respect

37:16

perhaps as as they deserve and so I

37:18

think we're going to have to shift now

37:19

as a lot of the cognitive work at a

37:21

higher level will be done by technology

37:23

and yet we have aging populations we

37:26

have tremendous need to change our

37:28

Educational Systems we have a Health

37:31

Care system that has tremendous

37:32

potential but also a lot of challenges

37:34

how are we going to come together and

37:37

really train people for those care

37:39

economy jobs but also create a higher

37:42

value with those jobs how are we going

37:44

to use technology to raise them to raise

37:46

productivity levels to raise pay that's

37:48

something that this Administration in

37:50

the US has been very very focused on

37:53

um I think that's one of the reasons

37:54

you're seeing a new prioritization of

37:56

Union work

37:57

um I think you're seeing a lot of

37:58

Business Leaders talking about gosh you

38:01

know what should the education system

38:02

look like and you're going to see

38:04

business and education and policy makers

38:06

working together to revamp the system if

38:09

you think about it we haven't had a real

38:11

reset of K-12 or college education in

38:15

America since the post-world War II

38:17

period and we are overdue for that so

38:18

the care economy is going to be where

38:20

the action is so I think the care

38:22

economy and I agree with you because

38:24

it's going to involved differently in

38:26

different across the world like this

38:27

indeed economies that have newest

38:30

population where you still would be a

38:32

lot of sort of an unk economy work so to

38:35

speak being done we have a seven or

38:37

eight minutes left I just want to just

38:39

focus on a few keyboards in our

38:41

conversation here so in the book towards

38:44

it and you talk about you know how do we

38:50

thinkification Forum where

38:59

in the context of energy

39:03

well I really think

39:07

that clean energy the transition from

39:10

fossil fuels to cleaner energy sources

39:13

and that balance and how it's shifting

39:15

over time is going to be the economic

39:18

story of our time and there's tremendous

39:21

potential there because if you go back

39:22

in history and you look at when were the

39:26

times where we saw a lot of global

39:28

growth but it was also shared growth

39:31

that tended to be when there was a major

39:34

transformative technology and you had

39:37

standards of that technology that were

39:40

sort of underwritten by the state and

39:42

then private businesses came in and

39:44

worked and and ruled out that technology

39:46

railroads would be a perfect example you

39:49

know at the turn of the century and both

39:51

um Europe and the US and many other

39:53

countries wow new technology the public

39:56

sector comes in and says okay we're

39:57

going to have this kind of gauge we're

39:59

going to have this kind of system they

40:01

set some standards in the U.S you see

40:03

land grants and then boom it's like

40:05

there's a fire that's lit and Private

40:08

Industry comes in and starts rolling out

40:10

this new technology and then for decades

40:13

to follow there are all kinds of

40:15

innovations that come off the back of

40:17

that if you just think of railroads I

40:19

mean it wasn't just the putting in of

40:21

the railroads that created growth it was

40:23

the it was the development of the West

40:24

it was the creation of cities like Los

40:27

Angeles it was the development of mail

40:28

order catalogs that because you know

40:30

deliveries could be made in different

40:31

ways

40:33

um so you get tremendous amounts of

40:35

shared growth and real job creation the

40:37

internet you know which was essentially

40:39

a government project that was then

40:41

commercialized was that clean energy is

40:44

that technology for this era

40:48

in my fantasy world I would love to see

40:50

you know a global price on carbon that

40:53

would really set a floor and allow us to

40:55

all together make this change more

40:57

quickly but what I see and it's you know

41:00

it's a step forward is different regions

41:02

in their own way the inflation reduction

41:05

act in the U.S certain kinds of uh clean

41:08

energy standards in in Europe some of

41:10

the state-run initiatives around

41:13

strategic areas like lithium batteries

41:16

in China I see all these things moving

41:18

us in a direction where clean is going

41:20

to be the future and that's going to

41:23

create a tremendous opportunity I think

41:25

for the private sector so two quick

41:27

questions to wrap up around this has

41:29

been a fascinating conversation let's

41:30

talk a little bit about

41:35

uh to where we should be going uh

41:37

because layout framework of what new

41:40

globalization might not like what it

41:42

should look like performance and

41:43

audience both gear and production DCM

41:45

Glory will watch the World Around the

41:47

World

41:48

how do we move from here and how do we

41:51

move in a way that doesn't create more

41:54

disruption I know it's a little

41:56

difficult to transition yeah

41:58

that would get us to this new globalized

42:02

world as usually without some

42:08

yeah I think we keep talking about

42:10

people you know I'm I'm really pleased

42:12

in this conversation oftentimes we have

42:14

economic conversations that are about

42:16

numbers and statistics and metrics and

42:18

that that's all fine don't get me wrong

42:20

but at the end of the day economics are

42:22

about solving problems for people and I

42:25

think that something that was forgotten

42:27

in the neoliberal system was that you

42:29

can't model

42:32

um The Human Experience perfectly you

42:34

know we have to think about not just

42:36

share prices and um you know very very

42:40

sort of linear metrics we need to think

42:42

about the well-being of communities we

42:44

need to make sure to reconnect capital

42:47

and labor we need to move from a

42:50

shareholder value system to a

42:51

stakeholder value system and energy is

42:54

really the heart of that you know I

42:57

always I often think the energy food

42:58

water Nexus I mean that's where all

43:01

economic action is going to be in the

43:03

future and in the middle of that are

43:06

humans right I mean these are the basic

43:09

necessities that we need to live and we

43:10

need to make sure that people are being

43:13

served by Economic Policy well I'm going

43:15

to wrap up by going where I should have

43:17

thought of this conversation and asked

43:19

me a very interesting question that I

43:20

haven't been I've been thinking about

43:21

for the last couple of days I Was

43:23

preparing the most to have this

43:24

conversation so as a journalist you've

43:27

worked the time you sleep uh you know

43:32

[Laughter]

43:35

you know I haven't run a Google search

43:39

or a Nexus search on that I it's and

43:42

definitely thousands but maybe tens of

43:45

thousands

43:47

for you

43:49

how many

43:51

do you know probably about ten thousand

43:54

oh my gosh okay so I was right oh no I

43:57

don't know where a comment is that's

43:58

what Google said I don't know exactly

44:00

where published but the name popped up

44:02

with articles about ten thousand times

44:03

okay well gosh you told me something I

44:07

didn't know but but be that as it made

44:09

the reset the research I was going to

44:11

ask you where do you get your you know

44:14

the imagination to have written so many

44:17

articles I'm always intrigued by

44:18

gentleman so I don't even come up with

44:19

these new ideas I don't want to go after

44:21

this story or that story where does this

44:24

part come from oh gosh what what an

44:27

interesting I mean from talking to

44:28

people like you from being out here and

44:30

talking and listening I mean it's listen

44:32

it is an amazing privilege to be a

44:34

journalist you know um you don't

44:36

necessarily get rich in this profession

44:37

but boy you're never bored you know uh

44:40

every single conversation every single

44:42

interaction is an opportunity for

44:45

observation and it's it's been my great

44:47

privilege to be able to work in this

44:49

field well listen since you just talk

44:52

about that the book is homecoming the

44:54

path to prosperity in a personal world

44:56

and whenever I have the opportunity and

44:59

privilege to interview people like you I

45:00

always am by asking them when is the

45:02

next move coming up and what's going to

45:04

be entitled to the next book because I

45:06

want to be the first person to interview

45:07

when you get the next book out so okay

45:10

by telling us the title what is the

45:12

topic of your next book well this is

45:15

very nascent I mean really nascent in

45:18

part because there's been such a great

45:19

reception to this book that I've I've

45:21

really it came out in October I've

45:22

really been on this you know kind of off

45:24

talking to groups like you uh like yours

45:27

to people like you for the last several

45:29

months but I'm starting to think a lot

45:31

about uh intellectual property

45:34

um and software data human intelligence

45:38

you know if you look at where 80 of

45:41

corporate value now lives it lives in

45:44

those things it lives in in people and

45:47

in data and

45:49

um how that intellectual property is

45:53

going to be valued how the pie of wealth

45:55

is going to be split up how uh data is

45:59

going to be shared across Industries and

46:02

uh the data harvested from Individual

46:04

consumers how that is going to be

46:06

perhaps repaid to them in some ways I'm

46:09

I'm thinking about that I don't have a

46:10

title yet though well I can tell you if

46:12

you get a book done by a next paper

46:22

regarding us

Next in the archive

Influential Minds: A Conversation with Rana Foroohar — Influential Minds