Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Steve Hamm
Ask about this conversation
hello and welcome everyone to
influential minds an eei international
conversation series my name is aleka
malavarpu and i'm an analyst for
international programs
influential minds is an evolution and
rebrand of our virtual conversation
series which aims to discuss ideas that
move the needle towards a more
sustainable future with thought leaders
from across the globe today eei
international programs is excited to
welcome steve hahn freelance writer
documentary filmmaker and author of the
pivot addressing global problems through
local action he joins us today to
discuss pivot projects a global
all-volunteer collaboration launched at
the beginning of the proven crisis and
what opportunities the global
re-emergence from the pandemic provides
to pivot to a more sustainable way of
life
he will be joined in conversation by our
host eei vice president of international
programs dr lawrence jones throughout
the session please feel free to ask
questions using the chat feature
lawrence will aim to incorporate as many
of them as possible into the
conversation without further ado i will
turn this over to lawrence to get
started
thank you alikia and thank you ladies
and gentlemen welcome to this last uh
influence influential mind conversation
before we take a little break for the
summer i'm glad to be joined here today
by our good friend steve steve welcome
to the influential mind it's great to be
here thanks so much lawrence well one of
the things we did a couple of months ago
when we rebranded the series and really
wanted to focus on uh having thought
leaders like yourself to reflect on
where the world is going to help inform
some of the decision-making
was that we really wanted to take a
broad approach and take a broad take a
broad sort of a brush of all the issues
and really bringing thought leaders like
yourself to to bring a diverse set of
ideas as to how we
deal with the challenges facing the
world and i think you know the book uh
the pivot addressing the global problems
uh local action i think is so timely
given where we are and we're going to
get into the book and talk about some of
the ideas you have around this issue
of really addressing global problems uh
using local actions but i think before
we begin steve why don't you just
tell the audience um you know what
inspired you to write pivot
well
i got involved in this organization
called pivot projects
that was launched in march of 2020 at
the beginning of the covid crisis
and i actually i learned about it by
getting an alert from linkedin that a
friend of mine had launched this thing
and he was a guy i knew from ibm he was
the basically the thought leader in
ibm's smarter planet strategy and
campaign which
was very important for a number of years
and
he said you know he basically said can
scientists help
solve this problems can science help
solve this
problem can collaboration
solve this problem and
so basically he had put out a a note to
a bunch of people he knew from many
years in ibm and ibm research and uh
about you know
uh some within the tech industry some in
non-profits some in government and
saying hey you know we're looking at the
stats that that look at incredibly high
death rates from this we've got it
something must be done with covet and
and basically
uh his name is colin harrison
and basically i think the the thing that
he was thinking was that this cova thing
is a terrible global crisis
and it's a wake-up call to the world
that an even bigger crisis is coming and
that's climate change and so
the idea was how can we
how can we use collective human
intelligence
collaborate collaboration techniques
uh think you know new new kind of ways
of thinking new technologies uh
including artificial intelligence
and apply those things both kind of on
a global policy or or government level
all the way down to the community and
getting something done in the community
so i joined that as an embedded
journalist you know the way sometimes
journalists are embedded in in you know
the military in in in the middle of uh
of warfare
and uh
so out of it came and i i thought it
would be an interesting process you know
but out of it came the book which was
published in 2021 by columbia university
press
and uh it was just a wonderful
experience and
the group was full of
people with tremendous expertise and
energy from all around the world
and it was just really a gratifying
experience but i guess at its core
it it represented for me one of the most
endearing
attributes of our species
which is that in times of crisis
there is an impulse to for people to
pull together
set aside their differences
and try to get something done trying to
solve a big complex problem
we will come back to this idea of
collaborative problem solving let me
just
let's go back a little bit to your first
book one of your first books which i
actually picked up and read
many years ago without realizing that
you were the author and there was the
one you wrote on you know the whole
issue around you know
business machines big machines your work
you did at ibm
talk about what got you to go from
writing about technology in the sense of
you know
artificial intelligence and when you
read the book we were actually sort of
predicting a lot of the things that are
happening today right so how do you go
from dealing with that
to now dealing with climate-related
issues talking about that over that
nexus
well i have been a journalist for
more than four decades
and uh so a long time
and uh
in the beginning i had kind of a more
tradition i covered government i come
here you know the kinds of things that
newspapers cover and then quickly i got
into business and then very quickly
after that i got into covering the
global technology industry uh in silicon
valley then in new york and other places
and the thing that appealed to me most
about the global information technology
industry was innovation and a sense of
uh progress that we want to make
progress together and these technologies
can be important tools
in in making todd progress for society
uh and the economy
i was never that interested in the pure
business aspects of it you know just you
know making a lot of money things like
that i i that didn't appeal to me as a
topic so i i wrote i wrote about
infotech because it was about progress
now the book you refer to is called
smart machines
and i wrote that
uh i was at businessweek for more than a
decade and then i went to ibm
in 2009 and i was there for six years
just a beautiful
seat
at the table to see
the fantastic technologies that were
coming out of
ibm research in particular
and
one of the things that happened when i
was there
or actually it started just before i was
there is they invented a machine a
system
that could compete on the the game show
jeopardy which is like a
high-end trivia show and they basically
said we think we can create a question
answering machine that can beat the
smartest humans
and they did that
and it really was a demonstration of the
capability
of
ai
you know the ai's been around since the
50s but mostly
in disrepute because it failed to
you know live up to the the hype and and
the promise
but i think this was a demonstration
that artificial intelligence had really
matured and there were lots of valuable
techniques that now could be applied to
the world i would say the one thing that
was misleading about that was
it presented ai
as a competition with humans
when in fact
the whole philosophy at ibm and my
philosophy is that
that ai isn't about replacing humans
it's about
you know combining the the skills of
humans and artificial intelligence
so that from the ai we get the things
that it can do best and from the humans
we get the the things that it can do
best and the humans are just better at
creativity and it you know at
um
you know collaboration
at you know
a whole variety of things making
judgments
at having ethics and values and applying
them to to how we make decisions so
those are clearly extremely important
parts of how we live and how we decide
things and how we go forward but the
machines can help a lot and
you know uh that book smart machines
really
i mean they've all been a lot of books
about ai over the years but that was
really that book and that project ibm
was really the launch of a massive
adoption of ai
around the world so now that it's really
ubiquitous i would say
one of the things i like about reading
the book is the sort of a
convergence around collaboration right
and the reason i brought up the ibm book
is because there you have collaboration
between the human machine right
collaboration complex problems so let's
go back to pivot projects and talk about
collaboration we seem to be the
foundation for a lot of people
talk about the composition of the of the
uh the group if you may in people
project what were some of their
backgrounds and and how were they able
to collaborate to address some of the
issues and we'll get into some of the
projects but specifically talk about the
composition of the group and and and
what made collaboration possible yeah
well the first thing i'll say is
the group when i first joined which is a
i think the second or third week
um
maybe the yeah probably the second week
and at the time very early on there was
intense interest
some of the early meetings had
you know 150 people on the zoom call
things like that and they were a variety
of people
you know people in business in the tech
industry was a major group
academics
you know problem-solving people uh
you know
uh non-profit people and all and i'll
mention a couple of people uh you know
colin harrison i mentioned was was from
ibm
but he had uh you know just a tremendous
background he was a physicist and a
computer scientist when his first job
was at cern
he basically was managing the the i.t
that controlled you know this incredible
physics experiment in europe
and uh later he was one of the
co-inventors of the first commercial mri
machine
his brain is one of the first images
that were ever created by an mri so
tremendous you know really deep um
expertise another person was peter head
and peter head had been a very famous
bridge builder bridge project leader uh
you know started off as an architect but
he these huge some of the huge bridge
projects around the world you know 10
miles long you know very complex
currents and things like that he managed
those projects and really innovated a
lot of the ways that
that sustainability was incorporated
into the way planning was made for huge
projects like that
uh he later went on
to
um to be a city planner
and then to have a non-profit group
called eco sequestration trust
uh which is really about applying a lot
of the knowledge you've had from big big
project management and and city planning
to uh
to all sorts of sustainability issues
around the world you know another great
guy that was a but you know i think one
of part of the genius of this group was
was we talked about a collective
intelligence well
an element of this is diverse collective
intelligence
different
expertise different points of view
different
experiences in life
and
you know i think one of the
one of the most important things that
happened in the 20th first 20 20th
century was
the development of expertise in
specialties
you know and but that had some flaws
as we specialized deeper and deeper
uh individuals were kind of like in a
silo of knowledge and they weren't
sharing information with each other they
weren't aware of what others were doing
and i think this idea of diverse
collective intelligence goes at that and
says you've got to kind of cross
these areas and expertise and i'm not
just talking about
science or technology or you know
construction projects
when they set this thing up pivot
projects i think they had more than 20
work groups
and some of them were you know one of
them was religion
because they felt that faith was a
really important part of
of thinking about sustainability and
also
certainly
engaging in a community
local faith leaders are
kind of a key to building trust which is
really important
so
you know there was a there was an arts
group arts and culture group
there was uh there was actually early on
there was one about sports i don't know
where that came from i didn't get a lot
of traction but uh some of them did get
a lot of traction and uh
the the people in the religion one
were
very interested because very early on
they said oh we shouldn't just have a
religion group
our religion group should be in all the
other groups that we should be going to
those meetings and raising those issues
there
and they did that and i i think it was
really
you know as a result
kind of spirituality
and just the meaning of life and how we
should behave toward one another what we
owe one another our responsibilities
those were just those core beliefs and
questions
infused the whole process
so basically uh steve so basically the
pivot project i mean for a project to be
considered a pivot project right let's
use that what would you say and we'll
get into climate change and and some of
the who's facing us today but i'm just
trying to get the idea of pivot projects
so that communities around the world
people listening to this call can say
you know what i want to go and start a
pivot project right is there a way to
sort of qualify what what in your view
in your estimation what would you say
are the characteristics of a good pivot
project yeah well i think you know
this really fits in with uh one of the
concepts that came out of the pivot
projects was the idea of
something we call the cellular economy
that
you know so much of our society is
driven by profit motive
but that
and i want to talk about this later
about i think capitalism has gone off
the rails
but
the idea is that communities
people in communities of goodwill
gathering together
and kind of looking at their resources
and setting goals together
can really
make pivots and a pivot
is something major it's not something
incremental it's not just like oh let's
put more of the budget into this
it's really let's ask fundamental
questions about how we're living right
and uh
and and let's make fundamental changes i
mean
a this may seem absolutely ridiculous
but around here
uh i live in a
neighborhood of new haven connecticut
and there's you know old houses not
small lawns but people you know and this
is happening elsewhere in america people
saying they first they said well they
don't like these leaf blowers they're
they're making a big noise and they're
blowing pollen up in the air causes
asthma and then people started saying
well wait a second what about these what
about lawns
you know
people think oh yeah alone that's just
part of life this is part of you know
this is what you want well no as a
matter of fact
our lawns are tremendously destructive
to our local ecology the amount of
the amount of energy that we put into
them i mean the the amount of space they
take that could be used more
you know
in more sustainable ways
so
you know lawns let's get rid of lawns
you know the water they take let's get
rid of internal combustion engines
i mean it's time their time is over
we we should be racing to get rid of
them
right
so
these are the kind of fundamental
questions
that you ask and that requires a true
pivot
a change in outlook
a change in a target and a change in the
way we get things done
so
um in
in in communities you know the pivot
projects have this idea of diverse
collective intelligence
of uh you know using um
systems thinking to really understand
our our environment and how it works
um
applying
artificial intelligence as a tool to
help us think and make connections
and then organizing
locally to get things done and i i think
that there's just tremendous
opportunities for
groups to
be
self-defining and to go at these things
and to
enter pursue projects that really aren't
uh profit focused
but they're they're innovative
flexible
uh quick to experiment to change and by
the way
you know in in chaotic situations which
by the way
the covet crisis and just about
everything else that's happening in the
world today
we've gone into chaotic situations where
traditional problem solving no longer
works
we have to
experiment iterate try this try that see
what works
and that's the that's the way
uh pivot projects thinks that that you
have to be just very nimble you don't
you don't sit down and grind out some
bureaucracy and it's gonna take years to
deliver something
we need to do something now
so let's talk about two global
challenges facing the world today there
are many we can talk about several of
them but i want to specifically focus on
maybe two or three the first one
climate change obviously and i know
you've
given this some thought
and then we'll then talk about uh some
of the issues around the outcome of the
war it's called geopolitics and get into
this whole issue around you know what is
the outcome the aftermath of the ongoing
war in ukraine due to russian aggression
talk a little bit about that and
specifically i guess hone in on some of
the interrelated issues around around
food security and then i think also talk
about the whole idea of you know the
need for a whole new system of thinking
around value right so because that's
another complex challenge facing the
world so using the pivot ideas
help the audience many of folks on this
call have an energy background some well
some have energy some have
other sciences if you mean other
professions but
help the audience understand so that the
takeaway from here is i've listened to
steve hamm
talking to lawrence i can now go and
start my own little pivot project to
tackle climate change at a local level
from my perspective
give some ideas on how you put pivot
interaction to address each of those
let's begin first with climate change
what are your thoughts yeah
well i mean what i have is
a i'll give you an example of what i'm
doing here in new haven and i'll give
you an example of something that's going
on in india
very different situation so in new haven
you know there's a lot this is a very
liberal highly educated town but also
has its share of problems
and
in new haven there there's a lot of
action around climate change but none of
it was about local risks from climate
change
it was kind of like responsible
sustainable living for instance there's
a group called new haven climate
movement that focuses i think very
wisely on one thing
electrification
it's it's about
pressing on government
to electrify buildings
and fleets
on government to change
local ordinances and guidance
so the developers are
putting in
electric ranges not gas ranges and
electric heating electric you know all
this kind of stuff very smart but they
weren't looking at they weren't looking
at the local risks of climate change so
that's when i came back from pivot
saying i'm going to take all that i've
learned here and i want to apply it in
my local town and this this town is a
city of 130 000 people
um
it's got four universities in it and the
college is very
you know but it also has lots of poor
people because it used to be an
industrial city and the
industries left
um and we're right on the coast
so we said well what
a group of us came together and said how
can we deal with this how can we raise
awareness about
local climate risks most people think of
it as something that's happening
elsewhere
we have to act and we have to act ahead
you can't wait for the disaster to
happen
you have to you have to plan ahead
even decades ahead
and so we form this group it's called
reimagining new haven in the era of
climate change
and it's the ideas that we bring
together science and scientific
expertise
with people from the community and
community organizations but also
the arts and artists and it's through a
combination of these three elements that
we can begin to address things and
reimagining is a very we thought that
they thought about that a lot it's
really you have to it has to be a
radically different place
and
it's not just about
environmental sustainability
you have to to have a resilient
community resilient city sustainable
city you have to have a more equitable
city
right you have to have the 40 of the of
the households in new haven that are
living
near nearer under the poverty line they
have to have a voice
and they and their concerns and
interests have to be addressed not just
in climate but in economic opportunity
in health
all of these things so we're reimagining
new haven
in the area of climate change to make a
better place
for all the people of the city so that's
pretty bold right yes yeah so uh
india steve a quick question coming back
because i i i want i i want these
conversations for the audience to leave
with an
action plan of their own so yeah i think
what you've done here now is in creating
this pivot idea of reimagining new haven
in the era of climate you created then
i'm a pro i'm assuming uh same kind of
diverse group of stakeholders within new
haven to have this conversation correct
correct absolutely good good yeah all
right
now you want me to move to india yeah
let's move to india absolutely yeah all
right so this is a beautiful thing
so india
a country of i think 1.4 billion people
uh
the cities the cities are gigantic but
there's still
about 800 000 people living in
villages
and a lot of those villages do not have
i mean and they're it's an agricultural
based economy but a lot of those
villages really don't have dependable
electricity or communications
so
some members of our group are involved
in an organization called sunrise
and sunrise
is about the idea of instead of using
solar panels of using
coatings solar
photovoltaic coatings which are less
expensive
more durable
and actually using these coatings on
public buildings in villages whether
it's the school
the the community center the the city
hall
the train station these kinds of things
and converting and using coatings on the
roofs and other elements of the
buildings
plus other
uh you know energy efficiency things
storage systems batteries the whole
array of things is called active
building technology to uh
and it's being this this is being tested
in some villages in india right now
and um
i just you know the it's out of it's
actually the group is out of
swansea university in wales a place
where there's very little sun but but
they have coding
uh expertise so my friends
uh
ian mabet and also peter head one of the
founders of pivot projects have been
involved in this in this project from
the beginning
uh ian is the kind of the cto of it
and uh so they've been running this and
it's a beautiful thing
uh they they've they've actually put up
a building
uh in a town called
kuded i think that's the way you
pronounce it this is in maharishtra the
the state
and uh
you know it's it's it's demonstrating
that this can work and that this can be
a source of power and also of course one
of the things that you need
uh
constant or consistent power for is
wi-fi
because we know that wi-fi is the key
one of the one of the keys to economic
development anywhere in the world and to
and to a small stakeholder farmer being
able to participate in in the bigger
economy so
you've got the power generation
uh through these buildings
the it's the building as power power
plant basically you can you can run your
municipal wi-fi system off that you can
run little you know little little
factories off it even
but um so that's that's a beautiful
thing so they're demonstrating this
tata
tata group which i'm sure you're all
aware of you know one of the largest
industrial
conglomerates in the world based in
india
is uh their their foundation is is
working on this is contributing to this
so that's something they're doing there
they're also talking about doing it in
latin america and in africa
and so that's a wonderful example and
i've got to tell you this wasn't just
one of those traditional things where
the technocrats parachute in on a town
and say we got the solution for you
a very important part of this project
and this is like a pivot project rule is
that you go out and you engage the
people and you find out what do they
want and what do they need and what are
their concerns
and how and then you you you marry the
vision and the technology you have with
what the people want and you put the
people in the driver's seat you know one
of the things people talk about is oh
you always want to get input from the
people
well
that's not enough anymore
you want to put the people in charge of
their fate and of and of their
and of their future
so
we see this happening there in india
i've see i'm seeing it in the united
states in various places there's a
wonderful program called wellville that
has
five pilot programs around the country
that's about improving health and
communities and in every case
there is a community they they
originally they call them community
advisory boards
but now they call them community action
boards because that signifies you're not
just giving feedback you are in charge
and i think that is a
vital element of these projects whether
they're
in hartford connecticut or or somewhere
in rural under pradesh or something like
that
yeah it's interesting you know and this
week i'm actually at the select usa
conference here in in in
the gala have also in washington dc and
it focuses on economic development uh
and economic community uh development
and i think what you've talked about
this idea of pivot and whether it's
addressing climate or whether it's
addressing some of the other issues in
the community it speaks to the
importance of this sort of a grassroots
uh
creation of these kinds of solutions
which we hope will scale up and that's
something we can certainly come back to
let me just tell the audience if you
have any questions go ahead and type it
in the chat box we'll try to get to as
many as possible um so so steve let's
move on now and think pivot
uh in the book you talk about using the
pivot approaches to solve complex system
systemic problems right um we're facing
two right now right we have the outcome
of the war in iran i mean the war in uh
in ukraine uh as a result of russia
going in there
and now that has created a global energy
crisis uh parallel that with the issue
we're facing because of the
supply chain issues and then of course
the security so given those sets of
problems i mean they set up problems we
just line up a list of year for the
audience
talk about
how can pivot approaches help us to
address
these kinds of systemic
interconnected problems food security is
tied to what's happening in ukraine
which is tied to what's happening on the
supply chain which is affecting the
energy system so it's not solving one
crisis it's trying to use pivot to
address a multiplicity of problems
what are your thoughts on that
well first off
systems thinking i think was one of the
most important inventions of the 20th
century and this is the idea that you
can't solve a big
complex problem or a big problem by
viewing it in isolation you have to
understand how
the world as a system of systems that
they're related to each other and that
they may be have dependencies upon each
other that are not even visible to us
easily so first is a changed mindset
think of systems thinking of things
being connected
and uh
and then i think uh you know
i think i mentioned just briefly before
um you know
systems thinking kind of grew up into in
something called complexity theory and
this is something you know the santa fe
institute some of these other great
think tanks do a lot with this and there
and there's an outfit in
actually in wales again uh there's a guy
named jd snowden has created something
called the conevin framework
and this is a kind of
a conceptual framework used to to aid
decision making and it really it really
addresses
uh the situation we're in now which is
which is chaotic which is
uh
lots of things are happening at once
they're interrelated
uh we don't really understand them
but we have to deal with them and that's
and this is the idea that you you that
you do small
experimental groups trying things out
testing them and then if something works
you scale it up
and you know early on in the
in the coven crisis what did we see we
saw we saw this
new approach to making vaccines that was
radical
the i think it's called
our dna or something i'm getting
mr dna mrds
so this is an example of in a crisis
something that was on the fringe
came to the center because of the need
to
to to deal with it really quickly
i think
another very important element that we
have to address here is when you you
know the un has its disaster
has the undrr this whole approach to
dealing with with uh
trying to prepare for disasters or or
respond to disasters and you know over
the years
this has evolved
and it's incorporating these ideas of
systems of complex systems
and uh but it's also evolved so that it
now takes new effect into into
a fact
politics and other social issues
and of course
you know if you're going to solve a
problem
the first step
in solving a problem is actually having
facts that are understood and agreed to
by people
and the second thing is to have leaders
who actually have the best interests of
people in mind
and in this last few years
we haven't had either
because of science denying which is
rampant around the world
we've had large numbers of populations
basically not agreeing
with what the science says and basically
going the other way i mean in the united
states like i talked before about this
thing about we humans how we we draw
together in a time of crisis in the
united states only half of the people
came together in time of the crisis the
other half pretended as if there wasn't
one and that it was the the people who
were trying to deal with the crisis who
were the problem right so as a result
uh
tens of thousands maybe hundreds of
thousands of people died as a result of
this
unnecessarily and then
you add to this
maligned political
players
like donald trump and like like others
like both narrow in in brazil these
people who
only look opportunistically at a crisis
and say how can i gain from this or how
can i deal with this
and
you know who incite
fear and hatred right so we've seen
these kinds of political leaders there
they are in two of the most powerful
countries in the world and then of
course we've got putin in russia
you know who's who's
a malign player so we have we you know
in the world today
the the leaders of some of the most
important and powerful countries in the
world are malign players
and so the undrr people have started to
take into account analysis of the
political and leadership situations in
countries
for planning and responding to crises
and
one of the one of the things about
planning and responding to a crisis is
it's not the malign leader
who plans for a crisis and puts the
infrastructure in place to deal with it
it is
people of goodwill it's scientists it's
city planners it's it's organization
people so that you
if you plan ahead and you consider all
these angles these the the systems in
there and the way they're interacting
with each other plus
you understand that they may be a malign
leader
in the country or in the state or in the
city that you have to build a system
that can deal with that and that and and
where you can
you can operate
um even with that kind of interference
it's not it's not optimal but you have
to recognize that it's
it's a possibility and in our world it's
a likelihood
interesting so so you you are you are
both a journalist uh you are a film
producer and clearly uh a good author so
that makes you a very interesting
storyteller
and so
i i want you to maybe walk us through a
scenario where
we have these global crisis facing the
world and we need to find solutions and
one of the things we all do
is we seek to get guidance and ideas
from the regulators the policy makers
and others
who inform the decisions made by
businesses in the society at large
what how how can
policymakers and others
benefit from applying the concepts of
pivot what advice would you give them in
terms of
applying the ideas around pivot projects
as they develop
uh solutions for their communities be it
local or or or national
well
at the leadership level i mean there are
there are some smart
policy
recommendations that were made by the
the pivot projects people
and uh
you know some of them are very kind of
you know
like i'd say one of them was was really
the idea that when you take on massive
infrastructure projects
that you
design sustainability in from the from
the beginning so it's not something
tacked on at the end it's it's
considered from the beginning in costs
and cost-benefit analysis
uh of the whole thing and that was
something that
some members of the group actually
presented to the un in the run-up to
cop26
right
and then so that's kind of at a high
level and then you know the down in the
kind of the technocrat stuff there
there's a guy who is very active in
pivot projects early on
named peter williams
who is a really a water specialist but
beyond that
if with undrr he was the author of some
of their guidelines for
for smarter cities
uh for for dealing with crisis for
making uh cities more resilient and he
came up
in the midst of the crisis with
something called cams
which i'm not going to remember with you
but yeah but basically it's the idea
that every place has to take you need to
take an inventory of all the resources
that you have
whether they're human resources
physical resources infrastructure
and and basically build a map of this
because you have to understand your
that's your system that's your system of
resilience and they now have these
guidelines and they're going around the
world and around the united states going
to to to systems and saying you know you
have to here are the things you have to
think about and he told a really good
story
there's a city right down the the harbor
or down the long island sound from mine
called stamford connecticut which is a
boom town it's
right out it's 45 minutes outside new
york city on the train line and suddenly
there was um
a massive development
south of the highway and south of train
right on the waterfront
and
and
but
they didn't consider
sea level rise
and they didn't consider evacuations and
they didn't even bring in the people who
knew about these things when they decide
when they decided to develop this part
of the city
so
at one of the meetings that he attended
the person in charge of emergency
evacuation said
no one ever called me no one ever told
me they were planning this thing
and and i'm the person who has to get 15
000 people out of harm's way
uh
it's a you know it's you know it's in a
hurricane zone so this is the kind of
there's a practical example of if you
don't collaborate that's what you end up
with you know
yeah i think it's interesting i i love
the idea and and certainly you know one
that can be applied to the energy system
one where you kind of design a system
model
of the city of the community and look at
all the different tentacles that inter
interact come together to be able to
have you to make a very informed
decision so that's a very good takeaway
design a system map of your city
and and and let that system map kind of
reflect all of the different interacting
portions of it
um let me give you another example of
systems thinking
so
in the past couple of years there's been
a lot of popular attention to planting
trees
and there's this these billion tree
projects and all this kind of stuff
and
planting trees is good
but it really matters where you plant
them because they're part of a system
for instance
we know
that before the phoenicians and the
romans and the greeks
the mediterranean was ringed by forests
right well what is it ringed by now
it's ringed by deserts
and this happened because those empires
cut down trees
to build to build ships
right
and
with no with no knowledge or sense of
what what could happen what they did is
they changed the weather and the climate
in the mediterranean
so
we have to when we think about well how
can we restore or regenerate
an ecosystem
this is going on
right now in brazil
on the coast
south of sao paulo
and the nature conservancy is very much
involved with it along with local
leaders there's a mountain range there
and there was just like in the amazon
there was a lot of deforestation in this
mountain range and
you know destruction basically the
climate has been the local climate has
been changed the local weather has been
changed so they're working on this on
on planting trees in a way that's going
to have a restorative effect
on that community now
planting trees like
in cities
having shade is extremely important
as climate change advances to make it
more livable to lower the temperatures
several degrees
and shade makes a massive uh change in
that i think up to like five or six
degrees which could be the difference
between
health
and and and not health
so i think these are
you know that's another example of of
applying
you know the system's thinking to some
of these big problems or local problems
here's a here's a question for someone
in the audience here
sandra barrett is asking the question
here steve
how can political leaders do a better
job of communicating how a crisis
or a difficult problem can be addressed
and i would expand that to see a crisis
or crises because we actually have
multiple uh ongoing crisis at the same
time and then also just to complete this
set of questions here is how can you do
a better job of informing and inspiring
uh to touch the head or to touch her
head her heart and her wallet uh so
specifically you know basically how to
do a better job communicating which
you're good at but then also how do you
communicate in a way that gets the issue
of moving hearts
and also impacting their world
yeah
well
with
specifically in cities but well these
days we have
you know
city leaders we have national leader
state leaders all face the challenges of
having
too many crises at the same time
but and
the and climate change
creates additional challenges because
it's so slow-moving in a sense
you know it's not it didn't happen last
week in full force like covet did
cove had got
50 percent of the people in the united
states attention to do something about
it
so
the question is how do you get people's
attention i think the first thing is
awareness
and uh
you have to make it concrete and that's
why our group in new haven
and our city government and our mayor or
totally aware of this are talking about
how do you make people aware of climate
change the the concrete things that are
going to happen
and you know
one thing you can do is you can show
a map from the national oceanographic
and atmospheric agency in the united
states
of
where
the water will be
in the year 2100 for instance
um some people being born today will be
alive then but whole neighborhoods will
be underwater
so you show somebody that map and you
show somebody a map
that where their house is underwater
you're gonna get their attention
so i think it's that kind of very
practical
um
kind of
uh you know a gut
thing that makes it real i mean i one
thing i did recently is i took
nice photographs of the some of the
iconic things in our city and then i
superimposed over them
sea water so you're looking at the place
from the front and you're seeing sea
water up you know two feet on it and
that's another thing that besides the
maps that that brings us home
um
you know
in our you know i think a lot of its
community i mean in our city we have a
lot of people who are interested in
biking and pedestrian as opposed to
roads and we close some streets during
covid
and the pressure's on to open them up
again
but
the push is you know i mean there's the
idea
that
we should take the streets back from
internal combustion engines
which may have seemed something that no
one even thought of
previously hey it's it's thinkable and
in fact we've got to do it
and i think
when
when mayors
can can reach out in communities and get
grassroot groups to actually carry the
ball so it's not just the mayor
you know preaching you know
you may look back on
some of the
in the 1970s we had
some energy crises for various reasons
in the united states and around the
world and jimmy carter
national leader at the time our
president basically urged people to turn
down their thermostats and wear a
sweater and he was widely just mocked
for this as a weak as a weak leader
so it's
it's very difficult
to
uh to lead
around these kinds of issues
i'm convinced that
that blaming people and wagging fingers
at people and making them feel guilty
is is not the way to do it because they
people just shut up
i think storytelling you mentioned
storytelling
um
[Music]
and i've described some some images that
kind of are scary but i think positive
storytelling how could we have a better
place
if you if you paint a picture of a city
where
it's much more flexible maybe some stuff
is on islands it goes up and down
maybe some
maybe parts of the city are given back
to the water
and you but you you paint that in a very
positive way where we're living in
harmony with nature
i think
positive storytelling about a better
future
not oh it's a scary terrible future and
and everybody's going to be miserable
you know
you know i think people they turn their
they turn their heads they they don't
want to look at that
so that is good uh steven and i want to
build on sandra's question here about
how do you inspire people in terms of
moving their hearts their minds and
their wallets
in the midst of the crisis though
because i think the con the challenge we
have here is what i call reactionary
storytelling
and proactive storytelling right yeah
this is the crisis where you have people
struggling to get by
how does one from your perspective what
is the most effective way for leaders
whether it's a corporation or a
government
what is the most effective way to still
inspire a person in myth of a price how
does one do that all right well
i think there is a great example
and the great example is with a
corporate leader
and his name is mark benioff
and he is the one of the co-founders and
he's the ceo
of a company in the united states in san
francisco called salesforce
and salesforce was one of the first
big successful companies to create
a business application that was online
that was run off the internet not run by
yourself in your computers and they they
now have a lot of different things but
it was about sales and marketing and now
they have other
uh they i think they have some hr stuff
and you know systems management stuff
but
from the start
that company was founded based on values
and i think he called it one one one
that one percent of profits
would go to
[Music]
charitable giving
one percent of revenues on top of that
would go to charitable giving and one
percent of the company's time they would
basically give people employees
the ability to to
a volunteer in their community
and get paid for it
right
it was company time now so that was the
foundation of the company in in recent
years
he
mark saw the opportunity he's a he's a
tremendous marketer and he really
believes in marketing the image of a
company but i also
he believes in doing actually doing what
you're saying you're going to do not
just kind of green washing so they
decided they're the first
carbon neutral
uh
or maybe carbon negative
company in america and that includes
their supply chain
and some of that they do with
buying carbon credits
which you know we know that that's
fraught with
danger you have to make sure that
they're good quality but um
and then i think so that that the people
of his company
you know a very sick when a very
successful company does this and the
employees love the company and the
shareholders love the company and other
ceos see
the value of an approach like this
and then i think he's also a good
storyteller he picked oceans he said
we're going to focus on oceans
and so they put a lot of money into
oceans they have a lot of collaborations
with organizations that are doing oceans
and and you know
we humans we do love our oceans
you know we treat them terribly
uh but we love them so if you if you if
you actually love something that is a
lever that people that leaders like mark
and and other leaders can use to um
to get people's attention and to rally
them around a positive cause
do you think then and we have about six
minutes left but do you think
you think that perhaps by
having leaders be participants in some
of these pivot activities
they will be much more in tune with what
is being discussed uh by the citizens of
their communities as opposed to it being
a top down conversation yeah yeah where
where you know the leader will actually
sit there roll off your sleeves and
actually be part of the conversation
instead of just being the one who's
speaking also the one who's receiving
guidance or inputs from their
constituencies yeah you know you raise
an interesting point pivot projects kind
of has an approach to
helping communities organize
but the idea of leaders
is something that the group didn't kind
of formally take on of advising leaders
uh there are a few people in the group
who are in the kind of management and
leadership
consulting uh area and they've kind of
they've incorporated some of this
thinking
in in what they're doing
but you i think that's actually a good
suggestion i think i should take it back
to some of the the kind of the business
consulting folks who've been involved in
pivot projects and say
you know maybe there's a a pivot
leadership institute you know that that
could be useful
i'm going to write that down right now
well i'm glad to help i think we have
five more minutes and i just want to
quickly touch on two topics one you
mentioned values right and i think where
the world is part of pivot is the
collaborative nature of solving problems
and when you're collaborating you have a
shared vision you have a shared sense of
sense of purpose so given the challenges
facing the world today and all the
issues we have to deal with
how does one start you know and i want
you a quick response to this but how
does one even think about creating a
shared sense of a set of values that we
can agree on right what are the values
that are going to drive
a pivot project because they all have to
have a common value they don't have a
common value there's no way the price is
going to work so how do you develop
a common set of values around a certain
project or
in the community
yeah well i think
[Music]
mission is the key word okay
because
mission is where values and aims meet
right
what your goals are and and kind of your
your mission
what you want to accomplish and how you
want to accomplish it kind of the values
that take you there and i think you know
that's an area that is is pretty well
developed the idea that organizations
whether they're non-profits or
businesses and things you know they have
they they do think about mission
early on but i i i think sometimes that
whole mission thing is kind of like
window dressing
i think it has to be done very earnestly
energetically and with lots of input
if not leadership from the grassroots
because yeah i mean i i just think
there's some things like
mark benioff
shows the
the the virtues of having a strong
leader with strong values and that's one
approach
but uh
you know i think one of the things they
did is you know slack do you slack the
the collaboration platform
yeah from the start they actually let
the employees sit in on certain
executive meetings
and in slack give feedback and ideas
about what should be done now i think as
they've gotten older and they went
public you know it's harder to do this
kind of thing but thinking about
novel ways to get the people give the
people a voice
and maybe even give them leadership
uh in creating the mission and then
achieving it i think is
that would be my wish
for organization
well well listen uh steve there's one
last question from the audience and i'm
going to take this question because it
has a lot of parts to it and hopefully
you can get to it quickly but it's
coming from jill to pleases and jill
basically is well she's a fan of dave
snowden by the way she states in
question and and she says here basically
that when she drives around those who
crowd who cry the loudest about climate
change have the most gorgeous lawns to
start with and then she goes on to say
you know what has happened in redwood
california i mean to the redwood forest
in california shame
and then why has california leadership
allowed this to happen and and you know
she talks about you know some of the
issues there but i think in essence
behind her question is
how do we get leaders
to act in a way that matches the
proclamations they make and also how do
we get citizens who want change to also
act in a way that is consistent with the
message they're saying and that comes to
the issue of trust and and and
transparency and also credibility so how
do we do that in a pivot framework to
make sure that people are not just
screaming they're actually like acting
in a way that matthew yeah i mean that's
a tough one i mean gavin newsom governor
of california
has taken very tough action around
climate specifically around water
but also around energy and energy
transmission because of course we've had
these terrible fires and these brownouts
there you know it got him practically
impeached you know i mean you know there
was a recall on him so i would say that
leaders who want to take
you know aggressive action and do the
right things
have to face the real possibility that
they may be
they may be voted out of office
so somehow
balancing things
and you know maybe maybe sometimes it's
worthwhile to actually take a such a
such a a strong stand on a principled
stand that you've got you're ready to
lose
and i think politicians have to be ready
to be voted out of office
for doing the right thing
interesting
well steve i think we're coming up on an
hour and i want in by asking you to do
one last thing what final advice will
you give to the audience who would love
to now go home and put a project or put
pivot ideas into work
what final advice would you give them
how to start their own pivot project
well i i i do have this idea about do it
yourself
save the planet
dyi save the planet yeah so there's a
lot of dyi stuff in this world
and i think that it really
the the notion there's this notion that
people were what could one person do
and i think that notion is
antithetical to
you know what needs to be done
what one person and a small group and a
household and a small group of people
and a community can do
is
significant and must be done so i say
go back figure out what your community
needs
what your what your strengths are
who you know
that can bring other strengths
skills points of view
and just get it going
don't wait for somebody else to do it
yeah i think that's a good that's a good
point because we have oftentimes
especially in many of the developing
countries there is the mindset that the
leader solves all the problems and i
think what we're seeing here is time for
the community to get to work no matter
how big or small it is build your
community to be able to bring about
change uh steve this has been a very
fascinating conversation i really
enjoyed the book pivot i i recommend it
to anyone who wants to get into this
idea of community building uh this is
certainly uh the uh the last uh set of
uh
influential mind conversation before we
take a break from this number
we'll be back in the fall with a whole
new
uh set of speakers from around the world
and also from different disciplines so
thank you so much for joining us and
thanks again steve and good luck on the
project in new hampshire hopefully i
mean in the in uh
uh looking forward to visiting you with
you someday
yeah i said thank you
Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Episode 12Jesper Brodin
How IKEA links affordability, circular design and renewable energy with climate action, purpose-led leadership and sustainable growth.
Episode 08Julio M. Ottino
Connecting art, science and technology to expand creativity, strengthen leadership and navigate a complex, interconnected world.