Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Steven, Bob, and Jay Novella
Ask about this conversation
please welcome to the stage Dr Steven
Novella Bob Novella Jay Novella author
of Skeptics Guide to the Future
moderated by Lawrence Jones senior vice
president for international programs of
Edison Electric Institute United States
good afternoon and welcome to this
closing session of eei's seven global
electrification forum our closing
session is if conversation with the
authors of the skeptic's guide to the
Future Stevie Novella Bob Novella and
Jay covella gentlemen welcome thank you
for having us here well first of all I
have never had the privilege to
interview Three Brothers
and I've definitely not had a privilege
to interview Three Brothers Who's
written who've written one book
so let's begin by each of you just
telling us briefly about you know
yourself uh we'll start first With You
Stephen go ahead uh so by profession I'm
in academic neurologist uh but alongside
that you know based on the last 30 40
years have also been a science
Communicator a professional skeptic if
there is such a thing
uh and you know author now of you know
two books a couple of blogs we've been
producing a podcast for the last 18
years Skeptics Guide to the universe
where the books derived from
okay
go ahead uh Jay
um so I am a the CEO of
our company in which we started to run
our podcast we started the podcast like
Steve said about 18 years ago I
basically work as a producer I do all
the tech work and I I run all the shows
that we do and we have at this point
we've developed quite a quite a number
of different shows that we do so we have
our podcast we have a science fiction
review show we have a game show we write
books you know it just we do a stage
show we just keep coming up with stuff
to do so whatever whatever we think is
fun we do it okay Bob I'm an I.T I work
with computers during the day but like
these guys of course um I consider
myself a science Communicator co-host
the Skeptics Guide to the universe
podcast and also the alpha quadrant six
Science Fiction podcast done some
blogging for the show as well and I also
run a haunted house
okay so so when I when I told my team
we're inviting you guys for the closing
session their first reaction was look at
the title of the book the skeptic's
guide to the Future and we've had a five
days of discussion here at the global
electrification forum uh addressing
things from the attitude transition
climate change how to deal with
affordability universal access to
electricity and I'm sure the viewing
audience is asking themselves the same
question Lawrence why did you invite
these three guys to have this
conversation to end the chef
are you guys are not Skeptics
even though the book says the Skeptics
Guide to the Future so maybe Steve just
walk us through the whole idea of
skepticism and how the book came about
yes I mean yeah we know that the term
skeptic has some marketing issues but
you know when we chose it again 30 plus
years ago it's really scientific
skepticism in in the model of uh you
know the science grade science
communicators
um okay Carl Sagan and uh you know what
what it means basically is we take a
scientific approach to figuring out
what's real and what's not real right
and the sort of the modern skeptical
movement you know I think has three main
pillars it's trying to promote
scientific literacy critical thinking
skills and media Savvy you have to
understand how to access information how
to tell what's real and what's not real
now of course the term has been used by
other groups including people that we
would consider to be science deniers and
that they're they really are abusing
that term like the moon landing schedule
or climate change deniers or we're
definitely we're anti that that sort of
thing right we're very much not you know
science and highest ethics so I I've
read the books and I know you're not
otherwise you won't be sitting here
but but let's get into just going back
to your your upbringing right so Three
Brothers
into sci-fi tell me about your
upbringing maybe let's let's start with
you Bob how was it growing up with these
two guys and into sci-fi it was great I
talked to my friends and they're like oh
yeah my brothers and I we used to punch
each other in the head all every day and
like we never had any type of fights
like that we got to get we got along so
well but my earliest memories of sci-fi
is my dad showing us Star Trek when we
were
maybe what five six seven eight years
old we were watching Star Trek and he
would bring us to Sci-Fi movies and uh
so that I think he is the first one to
instill the love of sci-fi uh into into
us and that just never we've never let
go to this day and we were doing a
Sci-Fi podcast aq6 I mean we just we
love it we see movies we talk about it
um so that's I give it to my dad for
that your memory as well guys definitely
yeah so Jay how was it at home I mean
with Bob and and and Steve talk about
the sort of the Sci-Fi debate you must
have had as brothers yeah yeah so
the funny thing about our podcast is
it's really the way that our family
talks like that's where that's the vibe
of our podcast it's a it's a common
space where people can talk to each
other very openly
um you know we we heavily debate and
talk about science fiction all the time
but you know as We Grew Older we got
into science and then science became
really the topics that we'd love to to
discuss
um and when we started podcast 18 years
ago it you know it was it was like a
no-brainer like yeah we're just going to
get into a forum and we're going to talk
about you know this this topic that we
really love because mostly what we talk
about on our podcast is current science
actually what fascinated I mean about
the book when I when I you know I got it
fresh and I read it what's the subtitle
which is what what yesterday's science
and science fiction tells us about the
World of Tomorrow
and that's why I wanted you guys to be
the closest actor and the Jeff because
the conversation we've been having was
about 2030 2050 we all of these targets
but where the world is going universal
access eight billion people which is
what you talk about in the book so we'll
get into some of that
um you know let's let's go back to
chapter one in the book where where you
begin with a very interesting uh sort of
a proposition where you say the future
begins with the past
and then you characterize uh you know
the future and the prediction of the
future as some sort of a wild fantasy
that is sort of a design or defined by
our hopes our imagination our fears
talk about that in terms of as we now
look to 2030-2050 how should we be
thinking about that future but
remembering the past maybe we'll start
with you Steve yeah I mean the idea is
that when we speculate about the future
it really says more about us now than
the actual future because you know the
future is going to be crafted bit by bit
by decisions that people make including
future people that are not us and so
it's always very hard to you know again
extrapolate all of those decisions so
we're really just projecting our current
biases our current beliefs you know our
current thinking on to the Future and
the future is very good at destroying
that conceit very very quickly it's very
hard to predict the future because it's
not about just you know us today you
know we're and we often like project
ourselves into the future
um like we will be the people in 2050
who you know that's even pretty fairly
close but no it'll be a new generation
of people who are going to be living
life and making decisions and
interfacing with technology and so we
have to think about that as well how is
everything else going to change the
other sort of thing that I think you
know we talk about these you know
Futures and fallacies as we're Imagining
the future uh is that we think of like
one technology at a time so like we may
be thinking oh what's our energy
infrastructure going to be like in 2050
and we're thinking just about energy
infrastructure it's like yeah but you
also have to be thinking about every
single other technology which is also
advancing over the next 30 Years and
that's going to be changing the game in
many in unpredictable ways uh so I mean
those are just some of the challenges we
face why again it's really we're just
projecting our biases into the future
when we try to make predictions
yeah it's like when you see some
predictions from the 50s or or the 30s
and you see you see people that are
obviously from the 50s or the 30s they
have the Fashions might be very
old-fashioned but they're using a video
phone you know they're using this they
think of one really interesting bit of
tech from the future but everything else
is the same they are basically the same
people
um but with with new technology they're
not really taking enough of the past
into the future and like Steve said it's
really a projection of themselves you
know it's it's they carry all of their
biases and and things that they take for
granted and they they carry that into
the future so yeah it is a great window
into what they're all about and not what
the future is about so so so Jay let's
talk a little bit about sci-fi in the
future because it's fascinating the
examples you guys use in the book when
you talk about sci-fi we'll get into
some of that but coming back to this
whole point about taking our sort of our
current biases if you may and and having
to drive us into the future talk about
the difficulty when you're watching the
sci-fi movie and you try to put yourself
in that future but you just can't do it
because you mentally cannot imagine
yourself being in that sci-fi future how
do you how do you how does one one deal
with that well that's a great question
and first of all you know a good story
is about people so regardless of what
what science fiction movie you're
watching there has to be the that kernel
of you know these were people and they
have a problem and they're trying to
solve it or whatever you could pick any
sci-fi movie if it's good the characters
are good and we can relate to them you
know not being able to relate to the
technology and all that I I think it's
it's the role of the writers and the
director they have to create a
believable universe that's true to
itself you know they can't break your
own rules which happens all the time you
know there's so many times when we're
watching a sci-fi movie and at the same
exact time all three of us are like what
what did they just do you know because
they make a bad decision that doesn't
doesn't jive with the universe that
they've created
um so that you know
that's one thing that we'd love to talk
about you know we'll we'll rip that
movie apart and come up you know with
every everything that we can think of
that mistakes that they made and then
we'll also talk about the great things
you know we love the visions of the
future we love to see people's you know
what their predictions are I mean that's
that's real science fiction is them
making predictions on what the what they
think the future will be like robots for
example
um they come up robot humans have a love
affair with robots they've we've been
making up stories about them since Greek
mythology you know like robots are you
know a part of of The Human Condition I
think and if you go through the history
of robots and you see how robots have
changed and all the different ways that
people have envisioned um robots there
that's a great way to look at futurism
in general if you just take a look at
how people have you know what what do we
want robots to do in the 50s what do we
want them to do in the 60s like it's
that changes at the as the years go by
yeah so look we will before we move on
and get into some of the fallacies about
uh science fiction and the predictions
that people have made
um I just want you all to tell the
audience each of you let's see if
there's you can't say what your brother
has said so you have to come with your
own idea so what's your favorite science
fiction movie
Cinema Jay Star Wars the first one okay
Star Wars number fourth one yeah Star
Wars number four which is the very first
one number four which is the first one
then the follow-up question for that why
was that why was that or is that your
favorite style was uh science fiction
movie well I mean I was I think I was
eight or nine when it came out so I was
in the perfect perfect age to understand
the movie and really appreciate what I
was seeing and it it took me on a
journey that has lasted my whole life
right it's just always been with me
um because there was a magic element in
that movie at that age
um I I just feel like that movie you
know
Lucas you know used Joseph Campbell's
idea of the you know the heroic journey
and all that there's something very
human about the the the core of that
movie so it just rang a chord
um I I just don't think any other movie
could touch it because I was a child
when it happened so any movie I see as
an adult like it just won't even come
near that movie oh I can't pick Star
Wars
all right I'll pick it's an impossible
question I'll pick one of the movies
that are my favorites and that say
Terminator the Terminator series fell in
love with it I remember to this day
this is 8184 after the movie I remember
like being so enthusiastic and talking
about that yeah right it's not a robot
right and that and then is your next
question then why why does this yeah
well I love robots yeah I mean I collect
robots I've got like a hundred I got
100 robots in my collection that I've
been obsessed with them since I was a
little kid so I always love them time
travel who doesn't love time travel and
that is that movie is a very good
example of a time travel movie which
isn't easy to do Arnold Schwarzenegger I
loved Arnold Schwarzenegger ever since
he he came to America and won Mr
Universe I loved him so it was kind of
like a perfect storm of Awesomeness for
that movie okay all right all right you
Steve I have the correct answer of
course
2001 in Space Odyssey here we go that's
to me that's the quintessential science
fiction movie
um I like it for a number of reasons
it's not that far in the future you know
uh so it got totally wrong it's not do
they well of course they did but so it's
not so you know fantasy speculative uh
and it you know it's looking at like
what space travel going to be like in
the near future the introduce ideas of
artificial intelligence they actually
try to get some of the physics correct
in a way that most science fiction
movies don't do uh and it's just of
course it's Stanley Cooper broken
wonderful storytelling so we had all the
elements all the elements were there so
do you guys think and I'm sure you will
say yes because you're a Sci-Fi Fanatics
maybe I should call you but would you
say that every company every
organization should at least hire one
sci-fi expert and I'm asking the
question because of imagination yeah
because because I think one of the
things you see in Sci-Fi movies is that
you like when you're watching like how
could they imagine this right it's
almost the imagination that fascinates
you right and as we talk about the
energy transition we talk about the
future of the world all these big issues
we're facing do we need more sci-fi
thinkers in corporate organizations I
mean I think I would say it slightly
differently I would say futurists which
there's a huge overlap with science
fiction authors I mean science fiction
authors also have to be great
storytellers which you get like and
that's why I actually was going to go
but I went to Jay the storytelling piece
of it I think you know it is important
for a good Sci-Fi but it's not
necessarily going to be helpful
necessarily to a corporation in terms of
Imagining the future but good science
fiction writers have to be good
futurists most almost almost always
depending on on what exactly what
they're writing about and sometimes
they're accidental futurists they're not
really trying to be but they have they
sort of are forced to be for their story
but some of them are very
conscientiously futurists like I said
guys I think is a great example
sometimes they build this story around
their Futures and they have a great idea
like altered carbon a recent you know
book and then the series and science
fiction series is really built around
this idea well what if we divorce the
our minds from our bodies you know in
our and we become a computer stack that
and we just wear bodies like sleeves you
know like putting on a new jacket what
that's the idea of the whole series and
sort of built around this thought
experiment about extrapolating digital
and brain machine interface technology
into the future that kind of futurism
where you know in science fiction just a
play box is just a way of just doing all
these thought experiments of both good
and bad like is it going to destroy the
world is it gonna you know is it going
to save the world what is it what's
going to happen I think
um is really really useful and of course
there's been a lot of climate change
futurism happening on TV now and you
know so that's I think also very useful
yeah yeah let's talk a little bit about
some of the fallacies and I think the
audience both Washington and the Romeo
will find it interesting because uh and
there are 10 of them so we're not going
to go through all of them I picked I
picked a few maybe or I think I think I
picked three the the first one let me
get to my fallacy because I was
intrigued and the audience might be so
we find out who are wrong in terms of
predicting right we have some some of
them still alive today who says certain
things about technology and got it wrong
I'm going to go to number 10. which was
uh the fallacy is failing to consider
how technology will affect people
our option and the choices we make and I
bring that up because we're in a
critical time for the energy industry
we're making a lot of you know
predictions on what we're going to use
what's going to be the energy source of
the future and there's one very well
famous person who made a prediction you
mentioned him and uh regarding
technology and computers so why don't
you talk about his uh
his fallacy that about what was going to
happen regarding computers uh you know
what I'm talking about right but we make
a few in there you talk about asimovic
I thought that was intriguing how you
guys what about Bill Gates in the book
so go ahead and talk about that who
wants to do it well Bill Gates have made
such a flaw when he made it I actually
knew he was wrong which blows my mind
yeah well he didn't include an internet
browser in one version of Windows when
he released it right yeah but those
specific one yeah he said like some
ridiculously small amount of money there
was only it would be more than enough
for anybody and so that's I think an
iconic example because he was saying yes
for how computers are being used right
now this amount of memory is more than
enough how why would we ever need more
and he when he failed to consider was
the iterative process that was going to
happen it's like yeah but when you make
computers more powerful people start
using them in different ways which then
requires more power which then allows
them to use them in other ways still and
the he did not anticipate that things
like video games were actually going to
drive computer hardware more than
anything else that wasn't in his I think
his projection yeah you know you're
thinking of computers as spreadsheets or
whatever you know he was thinking of it
as business application then that was
obso a pre-internet you know so so
there's there is this it you know this
uh you um back and forth between the
technology and how people are using the
technology which then influences
technology which then influences how
people use but it's a it's a great
example though of a forward-thinking
person
running a multi-billion dollar
forward-thinking company like missed
that yeah it just had these it just
doesn't seem like any sense but let's
bring one thing up now since we're going
to go down that route with a
forward-thinking person chat gpg yeah
just came out yeah so tell us about how
could the whole industry miss it yeah so
yeah we were talking a little while ago
about the fact that Google was blown
away when chat GPT 3.5 came out you know
open AI comes out with their product hey
we want the whole world to test this and
it really caught Google with their pants
down and now they're scrambling to catch
up yeah because they their their
technology isn't isn't there it's like
you know 20 behind where open AI is and
that's a big problem but we missed it
the whole world didn't see it coming you
know industry people missed it right
even Google missed it they didn't
realize where that other company was but
I think you know it's we knew that
something like this was coming it's but
it's the details that are difficult we
didn't know exactly where are different
AI platforms we're going to be and when
this has definitely came up quicker than
I thought we thought it was going we
were all shocked when it came out when I
first used it it was like a leap that we
yeah my reaction was like that like I
can't believe that this that this was
simmering in the background and the
public didn't know about it but guys if
you remember I talked about chat GPT
first on the show about a year ago yeah
it came up and then I read the news item
I talked about it on the show I talked
how it can create very realistic
um text yeah and uh and the flow was was
beautifully human it really sounded like
somebody was doing that and it really
was just a predictor it just predicted
the next word with probabilities and
stuff and even then we I didn't really
anticipate what was to come in in the
next seven eight nine months and but you
really can't blame them that much
because by its very nature this is this
is like an emergent phenomenon as you
increase the scale and the complexity
these new abilities arise that you
really it's not it's inherently
unpredictable in a lot of ways so that
yeah it was hard to see this happening
not only that not only did this happen
quicker I think that a lot of people
thought it was going to happen now we're
making the opposite problem now we're in
the over hyping phase people think oh
this is going to change everything it's
like it will slow down a little bit or
even right now they say it's already
artificial intelligence already well
intelligence
forget about the claims that it sent it
they were completely wrong but yeah even
you so now these companies are rushing
to get applications out with AI in them
and that's really premature it's going
to take us years to sort out what is it
good at what is it not good at what is
it really going to do and so that's
another fallacy we talk about where
people tend to underestimate these
long-term progress but they overestimate
short-term good exactly number one yeah
one back one to ten to come back to one
for a very special reason and you just
just what I meant for you to do because
fallacy number one is overestimating
short-term progress and underestimating
long-term progress right right so so
talk about that well short term is is as
we've really recognized on that we talk
about on the show short term progress is
is slow and incremental it's little
pieces over time people like like me
like me in the past I would expect more
dramatic leaps
um but in the in the main though it's
really just small and incremental and
it's frustrating because they're just
tiny little changes but over 10 20 30
years even a lot of incremental changes
there's enough of them where it becomes
it becomes dramatic and some more
geometric and linear people are biased
into thinking linear and so but reality
is more often it's not from here it's
everything but there's a lot of
non-linear phenomena happening but that
works both ways because not only is our
progress non-linear geometric sometimes
but the problems themselves are
non-linear in terms of their
difficulties that's where people
overestimate the short-term progress too
like remember in the 80s when we had the
high temperature superconductors and
pretty much the vibe was any day now
we're going to have room temperature and
here we are 30 40 years later and we're
really no closer to having you know a
wire that is a superconductor in bambien
pressures and and see look at autonomous
cars like we we all thought that we
would be in cars that are driving
themselves but they never could get to
stage four and stage five in the air and
the ability for the cars to drive safely
but that last five percent takes most of
the effort right but that's why I wanted
us to have this conversation I'm so
excited sitting here because you're
doing exactly what I thought you would
do uh raise the concerns many have about
how we go about transitioning the Energy
System yeah because we have to do it in
the way that is not going to create
hardships for many you know we want it
to be affordable reliable resilient and
that means you have to sort of really
understand these Technologic
technological Trends and the
non-linearity that that exists within
them so so this is this is this is great
let's go ahead and being flexible you
know because like again we're old enough
to remember the coming hydrogen economy
right in the two in the odds the 2000s
when they underestimated the how
difficult or like storage was going to
be and and so you know here we are again
20 years later and they still haven't
cracked that problem that they that it
was right around the corner and how many
years ago and they also failed to
consider competing technology yeah in
the interim while you're failing to to
figure out the core problem of of like
driving around in a car storing lots of
hydrogen safely Battery Technology just
you know continually progressed in the
background and completely blew away you
know these a hydrogen fuel cell car kind
of concept gee there's another fallacy I
want to come to fallacy number six and I
think it's more in line with your your
part of the the trio here because it
says blessing current people and culture
into the future
very interesting
when we design technology
what do we do wrong when it comes to
where we place people I think it's a
it's a bottomless pit of of questions
you know we don't know what people are
going to be like in the future I mean
look at how much our society has changed
just in the last 10 years so you know we
were saying we're going to develop
you know technology for people in the
future I think what's happening is
people are developing technology you
know companies are investing in
technologies that they think you know a
year or two down the road you know could
make money it could be beneficial I
don't think we can really make
technology for people beyond that I just
think it stumbles along companies come
up with the technology that they do and
they make decisions on what they're
going to invest billions of dollars into
to develop and sometimes they get it
right and sometimes there's a big payoff
and the people aspect of it you know
does it how much could you really Factor
it in we have no idea I didn't know who
I was going to be 10 years ago I just
don't think we can predict that think
about this you know our children have a
completely different relationship with
technology than we do absolutely we
can't we couldn't really predict it one
generation away and and even when we
know that they have a different
relationship with that we still have a
hard time wrapping our heads around it
and our kids grew up living in a social
media fishball they just they're just
different people than we were we would
we could never get to that kind of
relationship do you remember when
texting was like I'm never going to text
texting was not popular we were still
opposed to all you'd be using video
phones yeah we thought we would be using
video phones and now everybody texting
is the big is probably the primary form
of communication that most of us use so
this raises very interesting societal
question because you then have what I
call mixed demographics right you have
those who thought they would never text
and those who are texting those who are
on Facebook and those who will never get
on Facebook so how do how does society
converge when you have five generations
who have a completely different set of
future outlook but even current sort of
a means of existence how do we do that
it's a great question I don't know that
we have an answer to that and it won't
necessarily I told my team I ran out of
questions for the day for the week but I
mean I think you got to follow the money
you know companies are gonna if there is
a way to make money off of Boomers
they'll do it and there is plenty of
ways to make money with technology off
of people in that generation to their
concerns yeah I mean so there's multiple
you know multiple categories that
technology can fall in depending on the
the age range I just think I really
don't think that companies could could
say we know that this is going to work
and they have to they have to bet their
money and their energy and time you know
like a pharmaceutical company developing
a new drug they don't know what what the
end result is going to be they just they
pick the one that they think fits the
slot best and they go for it right this
and this gets to the inherent inability
to sort of predict the future because
you know we're you're trying to to
imagine the collective Decisions by
eight billion people and you can't do
that all you could do is just keep
throwing stuff against the wall and see
what sticks and that so we you know we
sort of learn as people make choices and
interact with technology like the
Segways like an example from the book it
was supposed to transform the way people
get around cities and you know because
the technology works you know it is cool
technology
um but you know people just felt dorky
writing those things and that was enough
to pretty much kill it it was also an
infrastructure problem and people always
failed to forget infrastructure it
doesn't matter if the technology works
if the infrastructure wasn't there it's
not gonna it's not going to be
incorporated they were assuming that
infrastructure would build itself around
we can reconfigure itself around this
technology that's a tough sell this is
so fascinating because one of the topics
at the Jeff this week was around
infrastructure it was around building
infrastructure permitting and citing so
as we talk about the energy transition
and right we need the infrastructure to
be built what you were alluding to uh
Steve is actually the fallacy number
seven which I had selected he brought it
up uh because it was one of the four
that I took because that's interesting
everything that happens in the future
will be planned and deliberate yeah
that's what we think right that's the
fallacy plan yeah and if you read past
futurists they always say this will
happen because people will engineer it
specifically to happen this way for this
specific reason because they're
optimizing convenience again they're
projecting their priorities onto the
future and saying that we will engineer
my priorities into the future and of
course that's not what happened
everything else happened you know lots
of things happen the future isn't going
to be just one thing when you ask me
what will happen or how will people use
technology well it'll be everything well
it's going to happen it's really just a
matter of proportion and which which
ones are going to dominate uh and and
it's not planned it's going to be
different than whatever you think it is
you know like we talk about one of the
most disruptive Technologies in our
lifetimes is the smartphone
you know you talk about it's we still
call it a phone which is probably the
least used function of this device ice
which again it gets we bring
incorporates so many things that we just
talked about like you you can't
anticipate how this other functionality
may become dominant and then that
changes the technology and now where
technology isn't moving in the direction
of this new way of using the technology
even though it emerged for this other
specific purpose I can't even get my
daughters to answer a phone like they
they get the idea that a smartphone is
an actual phone is like so secondary to
them they don't use it as a phone at all
a smart device I guess or whatever but
it's who would have thought that most of
us would be doing most of our shopping
on one website yeah yeah
so so these I mean this is very
interesting because again you you all
are racism very pertinent issues here
yeah specifically as we talk about the
energy transition because energy is so
fundamental right and when people talk
about disruption what they don't realize
it's not just the technology it's what
will people do with the technology so
you can warn people to do certain things
in terms of you know uh fallacy number
seven where you sort of a thing you can
plan the future but you really can't
right yeah so there's a lot of a lot of
things that we talk about like we think
about like will cars as a service become
a thing will people like it I don't know
we'll have to see people may love it
people may hate it and that will
determine whether or not unknowable
what we do know is we do need to revamp
the grid like we know that that's coming
and we know that that companies and the
government have to get on board and
that's not happening I think that's a
no-brainer yeah yeah so so I think so
we'll get into the technology because
you guys lay out three different sets of
Technology the ones we have today the
ones that are coming and the ones that
probably crazy for you crazy crazy
future we'll get to that but but you
know so one of the things that drive a
lot of change in society is public
policy right and and obviously that's an
important part just help us to
understand from your perspective
how could these ideas around futurism
and some of the things we've talked
about perhaps jokingly when it comes to
some of the technological mistakes but
what should policy makers listening to
this conversation glean in terms of how
can we apply futurism and maybe be
realistic about some of the fallacies
yeah when we design public policy
yeah I think being humble right is
probably the most important thing
supporting General scientific research
general research invest a lot of money I
I think I don't know what the figure is
but for every dollar that's invested in
in general science I think the payback
is is it's insane magnitude
um yeah and don't pick a horse right
like don't pick one up with a hydrogen
economy people were saying oh the
government should invest in the hydrogen
economy Arnold Schwarzenegger who you
love is Governor the governator right
California said we're going to build the
the hydrogen infrastructure in
California and then people will come
it's like build it and they will come
that is sort of true it turned out not
to be true in that case so it's not
always true so you know we do have to be
projecting a little bit into the future
like we have to decide where we're going
because again sometimes it you know
infrastructure makes technology possible
you can argue and a lot of people have
argued that we could be driving electric
cars right now if the sequence of events
was a little bit different 100 years 100
years ago if yeah if if the elect
electrical grid you know was maybe 10 or
20 years earlier in the discovery of
crude oil was maybe 10 or 20 years later
we might all be driving electric cars
now to begin with right that's all
infrastructure it's not the technology
at all
um and now so now we're trying to
imagine all right for the next Century
what what infrastructure choices are we
going to make that will guide you know
how technology gets used and we're also
trying to like be trying to
top down it a lot you know because
you're saying the the market may lead in
this direction but we don't want it to
go in that direction we want to go into
this other direction because we don't
want to destroy the climate you know of
our own Planet so we're going to force
it you know to go in the direction we
want it to go in and that's I mean we
may have no choice because here we are
you know we don't have that much time
but that's really hard to do it's hard
to do it's very picking like say fusion
power I mean it seems like oh yeah we're
just waiting for our Fusion reactors
right and and they've had some major
successes in the past decade with that
but we're not even sure now you know how
much of a player infusion you know
Fusion reactors are going to be in
energy production you know solar and
wind may may be so much cheaper that
there really isn't isn't a place for a
huge Fusion footprint although I think
Fusion will have uh applications and
other things plenty of other things like
spaceships for example is another is one
but uh so it's it's so hard you just
gotta try to lay the groundwork and uh
and let it almost decide itself right
don't trust
my bottom line would be yeah you have to
invest in the things that make the most
sense but hedge your bets man hedge your
bets because let's talk about hedging
the business right so so Jay I want to
to come back as a Storyteller on well
your storytellers but since you're the
one running the podcast I guess uh how
do we talk about what Bob mentioned you
know we want to have electric electric
vehicles and all these technological
things but would then also come the need
for vertical minerals so how do we
balance the interdependencies of these
choices we make it's not just having
this to have this I must have that and
sometimes we forget about that right so
you want you want when you want EVS but
you also need critical minerals right
you needed to come from say Africa or or
other parts of the world right how do we
balance those interdependencies when we
start to pick
windows or we try to project are we
projecting one thing but forgetting by
the other thing so we want this we
project to have five billion EVS I'm
just making this up but we don't think
about where we're going to get the
critical minerals from so we make one
line of projection because that's
something we we want maybe it's based on
our experience right the current sense
but we forget that by the way we're
going to need critical minerals so how
do we do this sort of a simultaneous
projection if you may I think I think
right now we're in a we're in a Tipping
Point I feel like a governments are
betting on to come like oh we'll somehow
get the stuff that we need that's a
dangerous position to put yourselves in
you know and on top of that like again
we don't have the infrastructure to
handle all the new batteries that are
going to be coming onto the grid I I
don't hear conversations happening where
they're talking about the next five
years of what needs to be done or what
you know the the idea that we don't
actually know if there's enough minerals
on this planet to handle the battery
requirements of the 2050s what are we
going to do like we we need to you know
we need to invest in companies like what
was that company see that doubled the
capacity ambryos yeah like this company
ampere is we just we just interviewed
the CEO of that company and they made a
minor change to their battery and they
doubled its capacity and they're using
less um Rare Earth Minerals Well that's
the Next Generation yeah the next one
yeah but yeah they're predicting that if
they if they fixed this one mature upon
them we don't need the Cobalt and then
you also have the sodium batteries which
are not as dense but they're cheaper and
they don't use the Copa so the thing is
these complex webs evolve over time and
and they take a lot of time for things
to slide into place and if you force it
it's it then you you can buy Fiat rather
than letting it naturally evolve then
you run the risk of a collapse so
there's a good historical lesson I have
to bring up because it was amazing to me
when I first learned this you know the
the transition from bronze to iron was
not because of Any inherent superiority
of iron over bronze it was because
bronze required two minerals right it's
copper and tin and the the bronze
economy the bronze civilization
collapsed because they couldn't maintain
the supply lines of these two metals and
irons one metal and it was easier and so
that that predominated then steel once
steel Technologies go over then it was a
no-brainer but plus iron kills vampires
and that's very that's true that's
hugely happened so that was just two
metals that collapsed the civilization
because they couldn't maintain those
long trade routes and bring them all
together and think about the complex web
that we have built in our modern society
it is scary it's very brittle it's very
fragile the pandemic reveals think about
Minor disruptions I mean we were
literally fighting over toilet paper
because because
of it yeah it's true it could happen so
you know if those minerals don't don't
somehow come from somewhere we aren't
going to make batteries yeah so yeah
there's got to be a lot of investment
but man you got to stay Nimble you got
to stay Nimble and because it's if you
lock yourself in that's that's where I
get scared we talked on the show about
mining the ocean there's like some some
minerals that we may think is scarce now
we said well with certain technologies
that are coming up we can mine the ocean
and we could have
enough of this mineral for like a mil
like a thousand years no no there's
enough lithium in the oceans to provide
that our current use for a million years
so but what's the technology of getting
it out what are the downsides what's it
going to cost always come down to cost
right so there's there just a matter of
you know uh how it all shakes out but
again that just takes time it's not a
shake out just making it happen is is
very tricky would you identify that such
a bottleneck then you start looking into
the backups and so you're ready to hit
the ground rack up some backup or worst
case
scenariosity that's why I like what you
said by the we the government's World
governments need to invest in their
people with education you know we need
more Engineers we want female Engineers
you know what I mean we want we want
more people involved in science because
the more people that are there the more
answers we'll get it's interesting so uh
before we get into some of the
technology that because yeah guys wrote
some very interesting technology I
wasn't aware of some of them I just want
to come back to people who a lot of
things wrong in terms of their
prediction and I want to come to our own
venerable Thomas Edison and tell us
about his prediction about phonograph
maybe she got it wrong right
yeah so I can't remember off top of my
head now with that specific prediction
well as he said was going to be it
wasn't going to be uh it was generally
useful yeah he said would it be
generally useful yeah yeah yeah right
right right so that's yeah so that's a
lack of imagination for Howard
technology might be
who I'm done with medicine
there's always these two pieces of like
the technology itself and how the
technology gets used and sometimes you
have you have like the desire to do
something but you don't have the
technology to make it happen like
hydrogen or whatever then sometimes you
have a technology looking for an
application that's like again like the
Segway for example and like you can do
it but we don't do things just because
we can do things a lot of again Futures
and fallacy people think we're going to
do it this way in the future because we
can't because we'll have the technology
to do it that way no we won't do it just
because we can't people will make
decisions based upon a lot of things
about their life and so this is similar
to you know the computer prediction
problems like a million people eight
billion people have more imagination
than you do people will figure out a way
to use a technology if there is some
utility there and you kind of just have
to put it out there and see what happens
so that's why you do pre- making a
prediction again you're just making
you're just saying what in your own
biases or your own life is but we we
underestimate how many freaking people
there are in the world he knows eight
billion people in the world that's a lot
of different experiences different
priorities and you know you you know you
can't incorporate that all into one
person's imagine look at the electron
when the electron was discovered it was
just you think that'd be a pretty big
Discovery but they had no clue what we
would do with the lowly electron and
they were people they were making fun of
it one guy famously toasted the electron
after it was discovered it's like made
come to nothing ever because nothing
ever if I didn't anticipate it ever
being useful for anything other than a
you know a footnote the Ancients imagine
this Society without taking advantage of
the election yeah isn't it also a little
risking from an investment standpoint
because oftentimes those giants who make
those predictions they shape the markets
right so when when when Edison said what
he said I'm sure he had an impact on the
phonograph you know and and probably
when Gage said his thing it did at the
time so how should Society set up a
temper our sort of uh hubris if you may
when it comes to hearing one big famous
person say we shall do this and
everybody invests in that right how
should we you know guard ourselves
against jumping quickly based on what
some famous person is saying especially
when we want to transition something as
complex as the Energy System yeah I mean
we call it the argument from Authority
right which is relying on one person's
Authority this is this is a big industry
leader so he must know what he's talking
about or she must know what he's talking
about really
um as much as possible if you could rely
more on the consensus of as many
opinions as possible you're much more
likely to to have a better a more
accurate vision of the future or
whatever it is whatever be trying to
wrap your head around being
scientifically illiterate absolutely
helps and right more more people that
were scientifically later I think would
be easier better more you know likely to
you know to end the way you wanted to
end I would say actually because of
science just because somebody's a
billionaire doesn't actually mean
they're smart or they know what's coming
right right most of them are just lucky
right before they have wealthy debts but
there's a Survivor bias means you look
at the people who did well or the people
who survive and so what did they do they
must have done something right it's like
yeah but they also might have just got
lucky and you can't really reverse
engineer their success because you have
so many people placing so many bets of
somebody wins the lottery right of
course somebody's gonna win do you talk
to lottery winners and say what did you
do to pick your numbers how did you do
it kind of intuitively no they just got
lucky and I think you know we don't like
to think that industry is that way
because it we lose a sense of control
when we think that but if you really
look at the data it is more luck than
anything else I'm not saying that people
haven't made good bets or good choices
of course they have but but you know we
tend to underestimate that the role of
luck and success does not necessarily
mean that they that it was engineered it
could you can't that doesn't mean that
there wasn't uh an element of luck in it
so you know like like with science in
general
your goal should always be to understand
the consensus of expert opinion not
listen to One Guru if you think of
technology or science as a guru you're
going to be led astray by whatever their
biases are and it's very unlikely for
any one person to have the whole picture
so like you said Steve you said you know
we have the world of 8 billion people
and Counting uh you know India just
passed one you know 1.4 billion uh China
is there Africa is there so so how do we
you know the theme of this what the
theme was you know energizing eight
billion people right so how do we sort
of apply your thinking regarding
futurism if you made
to public policy because I think I think
at the end of the day what you're saying
is that public policy issued should have
a bit of a long-term perspective but it
should also be grounded in reality yeah
how do we do that maybe we can go first
and yeah I mean so we talk about the
fact in the book that there's this sweet
spot in the future right like you can
extrapolate a certain distance into the
future and then beyond that it's like
predicting the weather it just becomes
impossible Beyond a certain point
um and so that's I think where I do
think policy should be aiming is when
you know like we know we're headed in a
certain direction it's pretty reliable
and and so that we could make
investments but again they also have to
realize that they're both following and
leading technology right so they're
trying to follow the signs and follow
the technology as it develops and and
follow the markets and the and how
people are using it Etc and the needs of
the of their people but they're also
creating and influence in the market by
the choices they make about who you know
who to subsidize are we going to
subsidize the fossil fuel industry are
we going to subsidize you know the the
solar industry right and by what
infrastructure you build you know if you
build the infrastructure it doesn't get
doesn't give you a guarantee but at
least it creates the possibility that
this technology can Thrive because that
would have the infrastructure to thrive
and so what we always like to see is
again make these humble modest but you
know sometimes they need to be bold
choices
hedge your bets and build in a
self-porrecting mechanism like science
in general right science is science
because it's self-correcting they don't
just make a prediction that's true now
forever it's like this is true for now
until we get new information when new
information comes in we have to stay
Nimble enough to change because we know
we can't predict so Jay so science
there's one science I want us to talk a
little bit about and I promise you we'll
get into these technology areas because
but Behavioral Science
because it ties into the human factor
the people side of this right
how do we factor that in when we're
making these kinds of decisions because
you just said that 8 billion people in
the world I have no idea how they're
going to react so when I'm designing
public policy
how should I be predicting how
consumers are going to behave we had a
case in Australia for example I think it
was Australia where you you know a
rooftop solar right the expected one
public response to the public policy
they got something completely different
we had the same thing in in Europe one
public policy expectation behavior
science completely different so does it
mean that behavioral forecasting is much
more difficult than technology
forecasting absolutely I mean you know
trying to protect predict human behavior
again like we go back to the cell phone
we didn't know how the world was going
to react to that I don't think I don't
think that Steve Jobs really knew that
this was going to be the the biggest
thing like everyone was going to have
one of these in their pocket it was
that's unpredictable I just don't see a
way to really predict that I think I
think again going back to what Steve
said you know we shouldn't focus on
trying to to unravel how the human mind
works and what people are going to do in
the future I think we just need to
provide people the things that they want
and need and file follow the you know
the needs of the market you know beyond
that what could we do in bonus groups
yeah sure yeah you do the best you can
but then you gotta have some kind of
maybe rather than betting huge you know
like like Schwarzenegger did with
hydrogen you know maybe spread your bets
out a little bit see what works and then
then go with what should be working
rather than trying to
going 10 steps ahead you know that's
that said I like the idea of what NASA
does they they've got programs where
they do their their basic research but
they also have these prizes these I
think they're X prizes yeah where they
will give you they will give researchers
money based on a proposal that's a long
shot something that is not very likely
but it's grounded in good science but if
they actually succeeded it would be not
an incremental advance but it would be
it would be a Quantum Leap it would be a
jump and and I like the idea of having
some of your investments in the long
shots that could really pay off like the
first the first company or a country
that creates the first artificial true
artificial general intelligence
um it will have such a such a lead over
of any other company or country that is
the major you will control our days
probably the one big win-win in all of
this right like the r d is just that's
just giving you new raw material to work
with you know you can do usually
important what you can with the elements
you have but this is sort of changes the
game for you so for those who haven't
read the book I must say there are there
are four categories of technology in the
book the first one the technology that
exists today the ones that don't exist
yet uh and the the one that they called
isn't even possible right so I'll just
pick one and either you can talk about
it talk about the brain machine
interface in terms of where we are now
yeah whoever wants to do it only has one
minute if you have a neurologist right
here
yeah so yeah it's just a minute Steve
just a minute so this is the the ability
for a brain to communicate to a computer
and a computer to communicate to your
brain already exists now I think it's
one of those Technologies again where
we're underestimating the long-term
potential of it you know this really
we've done enough research now to know
that theoretically it works and there's
no reason why we can't have a matrix
style sort of interaction where
you know your your brain will accept a
digital virtual reality completely
because it's we construct our reality
anyway so it's actually really easy to
just slip in digital information into
the reality that our brains are
constructing so it could be rather
seamless so
we can imagine how people will use that
technology but they'll probably be using
it in ways that are even different than
what we could imagine that but what we
can say is that that is an incredibly
powerful technology that you know is
going to hit its stride sometime in the
future and and will absolutely transform
society and by the way so you you all do
cover you know machine learning Quantum
Computing other part of the future so I
can leave that for the audience to buy
the book and read it but I want to get
into the future technologies that don't
exist yet and one that I found in very
interesting synthetic life
okay
well uh first off I love the topic I
think I think we're going to have
synthetic life I mean we are we are
machines
so I it's it's not beyond the realm of
physics for humans to be able to create
synthetic life I think the real question
is consciousness will we actually be
able to create a Consciousness and how
would we even know if if some you know
something that humans made became
conscious
um I have this thing I keep telling
these guys I'm horrified by this idea
that we create artificial intelligence
it becomes conscious and we just create
and Destroy and create and Destroy like
as as some guy in a lab is is testing
copy and paste yeah we're just you know
virtually at that point we're killing
sentience every time they run a test I
think we have to be very careful when we
start getting into that because that's
that is a game changer and there's as
ethics involved at that point and the
other angle to synthetic life when you
said synthetic life my first thought was
um biological synthetic life we are we
are creating organisms from hand like
homemade genomes we're creating the
genome from scratch trying to determine
like what's the smallest possible genome
you can create and create Life as we
know it so that's another it's another
angle and that in terms of sentience or
something that is kind of conscious
that's I think would be easier because
it's it's biological we know that
biological life you know it we know it
works whereas creating an artificial in
life from silicons is much more
problematic much more difficult and
complex I think because it's so foreign
to us I would like us to take care of
the biology that we have today right
let's take care of us people that are
already here that you know there's a lot
of suffering like we don't need to
create new new entities like we'll make
and we could use them they're
utilitarian of course yeah but then
it'll go from there but the concept so
yeah it's one question so I always like
to think about the unintended
consequences yeah right so oh yeah so
when we create these things anywhere
have you guys read of any inventor
scientists who as he's creating
something he's also immediately thinking
about the unintended consequences of his
creation
that happens pretty much right but the
reason I asked the question to Steve
I've never seen any technology provider
who will tell you all the things that
could go wrong with his technology yeah
I mean there is the culture of like we
talk about the fake it to you make a
kind of Silicon Valley culture and
although right now interestingly you
know we talked about AI it's moving so
fast that even people in the industry
like we should slow down you know we
need like industry-wide slow down
because otherwise we're like racing to
keep up with each other in a kind of a
reckless way and I think there's also a
lot of geneticists who are like you know
this is awesome like the the crispr
technology the the power that we have to
control genetics is awesome but the
geneticists are saying we need to really
think very carefully about the applying
this technology to the human germ lines
or really any germline of any species so
they are saying it they are saying like
when you get to that technology like
holy crap we could all be altering life
at a fundamental level in a way that
gets into the general population
we should not do this until we have
really carefully thought about it okay
well look we're going to wrap it up here
pretty soon now I can see me getting
some some signals from my staff that
we're gonna you don't want to talk for a
few more hours
no but I but I I do want to just for
those listening uh because I always want
to find some practical applications even
of skepticism right yeah
um so just
I don't want you to answer the question
so should we trust futurist
um yes and no right so I like futurists
I think are running very important
critical really thought experiments
about how to project and how to think
about the future
but I you know if a futurist makes a
detailed prediction I wouldn't I
wouldn't trust that so we actually are
careful to say like in the book even
though we do make sure to make
predictions we're not really that's why
I'm asking the question because I want
to read the book I'm like okay so you
really don't make predictions it's more
about this is what could happen
depending on the choices we make it's
more about possibilities because yeah
there's a utopian possibility here's a
dystopian possibility and anything in
between try not to put our head you know
to put our dime down on on one
specifically sometimes we do but for the
big ones is like here's the
possibilities I think a good futurist
will do this and that's why I like it
with a book in that it's not necessarily
a prescription it's a guy that we all
can use when we start a thing but two
other quick questions skepticism so the
book The Skeptics Guide to the Future
you're not denialist but just reason
skepticism should we teach people how to
be skeptical oh my gosh absolutely oh my
God yes absolutely only one person can
ask by the way
aspect that that I think is very
important with with teaching scientific
skepticism is how to evaluate evidence
yes a lot of people I think are horrible
at how determining what is good evidence
what is bad evidence that kind of
thinking has led people down the path of
like I don't need to get vaccinated you
know it's like because if you look at
what their evidence is it's probably not
very good evidence because that's what
what they considered evidence convinced
them that they don't need to get
vaccinated for cobit and that decision
you know took lives it's got a body
count that kind of that kind of thinking
well listen we're we're going to wrap up
here the book the skeptic's guide to the
Future what yesterday's signs and
science fiction tells us about the world
tomorrow I was so happy when I found
this book I enjoy reading it it really
opened my eyes to a lot of things and so
the closing issue you have 30 seconds to
wrap up here I give you 30 second
warning now so you'll be the last Jason
will stop with you Steve
um
what would be your another prediction
2050
give us a taste of the world in 2050.
so oh yeah I think I think in 2050 one
of the trends that I think is going to
really be accelerating by then is the
not only is the work the virtual world
you know the the electronic world that
we live in becoming more digital the
physical world that we're living in is
going to become more digital we're going
to be increasingly connecting our
digital world with physical reality like
3D printing I think is a perfect example
of that where you go directly from a
digital design to a physical object and
that is that trend is just going to be
continuing and I think we may be getting
maybe close to an inflection plan
digital triplets uh digital quadruples
whatever right okay whatever you above
what's your 2050 2050 I I would have to
predict that
artificial general intelligence and
quantum computers will be transforming
the world in ways that we can't possibly
predict right now and then I'll be you
Jay I was going to talk about artificial
intelligence but I think the
electrification is truly going to be a
real thing by 2050. I think we will be
everybody will be driving electric
vehicles I think that you know energy
use by Regular People is mostly going to
be electric and oil will be on majorly
on the way out and just full full
disclosure she and I didn't talk before
he made that last comment by
electrification this wasn't a plant so
anyway thank you all for joining us a
pleasure please join me Jay and and Bob
and Steve thank you so much
Episode 16Ann Christine Duhaime
How brain science, rewards and social connection can reshape consumption and motivate lasting action on climate change.
Episode 12Jesper Brodin
How IKEA links affordability, circular design and renewable energy with climate action, purpose-led leadership and sustainable growth.
Episode 08Julio M. Ottino
Connecting art, science and technology to expand creativity, strengthen leadership and navigate a complex, interconnected world.