Episode 07Sebastian Mallaby
Influential Minds: A Conversation with Sebastian Mallaby
How venture capital, risk-taking and connected networks turn bold ideas into startups and spread entrepreneurial culture.
Jennifer Sciubba
Ask about this conversation
please welcome to the stage Jennifer
Shuba senior fellow at Wilson Center
United States moderated by Lawrence
Jones senior vice president for
international programs of Edison
Electric Institute United States
welcome again to a new edition of EI
international program influence your
mind today we're coming to you from the
EI Group electrification Forum taking
place here in Washington DC the Jeff
began uh two days ago in January on
April 17 and we're actually now on the
third day of the Jeff and we're going to
be having a conversation today our guess
is Jennifer Shuba Jennifer is a fellow
scholar at the Wilson Center in
Washington DC but she's also a renowned
demographer who's worked with the United
States Department of Defense and she's
also the author of the future faces of
War
today we're going to be discussing her
new book that came out last year 8
billion and Counting house sex death and
migration shape the world Jennifer
welcome thank you so much well let's
just first start this conversation
because you have a very intriguing
career a demographer why did you become
a demographer
so I think it started
um with an interesting population even
as probably a middle schooler who was
focused on environment you know this
idea that we need to look out for the
Earth that got that caught on for me
very early and population is a huge part
of that of course and so when I was in
college
I studied international relations
because I was a Tom Clancy reader and so
I thought you know Cold War baby and let
me get into this and kind of swimming in
my mind was is there something that
causes War and Peace and poverty and
development that are really these
underlying conditions not just the the
things we might read about it in the
textbook and at that same time on one
particular day my favorite professor
came to class late and she paused in the
doorway to the class
wanting us to look at her which we did
and when she was there she was wearing a
black armband and then she just started
marching military style in front of our
desks and she said today world
population has hit 6 billion people and
this is just an absolute travesty for
our world I never had children there's
too many people and you shouldn't either
which is you know not something you
could say these days as a college
professor and I was really intrigued by
that and skeptical also and so as I went
to graduate school as a political
scientist and so my PhD is in political
science I remained really interested in
population as the foundation of our
world I mean people are there are
workers they are our soldiers they're
our consumers and so I have tried in my
career to take my formal training in
political science but add in a deeper
understanding of population and so as I
was working on my dissertation I went to
the Max Planck Institute for demographic
research in Germany and really just
tried to learn about that and follow
that and bring those together in an
interdisciplinary study of how
population makes the world tick what is
so interesting in the book you you
actually talk about three things you
talk about the issue around fertility
you talk about the issue around
mortality and then you also then get to
this whole issue of migration right and
you know the theme of The Jeff this year
is literally power climate action
energizing eight Billion Lives now as I
was reading the book I kept thinking to
myself well do we understand the 8
Billion Lives we like to energize so
let's start from the beginning of the
book
give us the context of how fertility
links to population sure so you know any
population change is driven by those
three building blocks and I think what's
nice about that is it can help us
simplify how we understand things when I
picture fertility mortality migration I
see them as these dials that are just
turned up or down to produce different
outcomes so if we're on this fertility
dial for a little while it's a powerful
one and I think these days it's
probably the most powerful one I would
argue that and
um the number we might want to keep in
mind is two and that is what we call our
replacement level fertility rate the
average number of children born per
woman in her lifetime is if it is at
around 2 2.1 then we know that
population will
um that that generation will replace
itself so what's interesting about that
number is that in the past
um let's say when we were at a world
population of three billion for example
that most of the countries in the world
were well above replacement level so
what we had in the last century was
exponential population growth from 1.6
billion at the start of that Century to
6.1 billion by the end and fertility was
really high in a lot of places right now
and I'm sure that everyone here if you
pick up any news article it's just
absolutely covered with the news about
low fertility
so we have a spreading around the world
below replacement fertility which means
that over time deaths outnumber births
and therefore eventually populations
will shrink and so fertility is really
powerful for shaping overall size of a
population but also the age composition
which is fascinating as well and gives
us plenty to talk about so those
populations that have low fertility over
time they grow older and older on
average
so so that's a fertility aspect of it so
let's get into the mortality rate
because there seems to be something we
could come back to talk about the Divide
between the you know different parts of
the world which is I was reading the
thing about you know the energy divide
is almost parallel with the population
divide where energy access is less you
have
greater population where energy access
is greater you have a shrinking of
population but let's talk first about
mortality because there seems to be this
not necessarily correlation between
more people being born fewer people
dying vice versa right talk about
mortality so if we're on that second
dial it's also been incredibly important
um but I think we're I'm going to argue
here in a second that it's maybe less
important these days in shaping things
than fertility is but population change
follows this General pattern where
before a society has high levels of
development fertility and mortality are
both pretty high and what we see is that
at the start of something called a
demographic transition mortality starts
to fall first you just do a better job
of getting people to live particularly
out of childhood you know get perhap
when those babies are born they will
start to live into adulthood so
mortality starts to fall first in that
first stage of the demographic
transition and then fertility follows
that so when we think about that huge
population explosion from last century
that in large part was due to a change
in mortality and how much we really came
to understand and get power over disease
and death that allowed so many more
people who were born to actually live
into adulthood now I think today uh you
know this is debatable but I think today
mortality
we have a pretty good understanding of
how to get people who are born to live
into adulthood that does not mean that
it happens everywhere so that that's one
aspect of this of course and those
places where people don't have great
access to energy are of course the
places where you know 5 000 children die
a day of diarrheal disease you know we
could be doing much better on that the
knowledge is there but the
implementation may not be so I think
when we talk about the power of that
mortality dial today we are talking more
about end of life
and how to uh you know get people not to
die prematurely of non-communicable
diseases so for the first time ever it's
non-communicable diseases like heart
disease and cancer that are the major
Killers worldwide not communicable
diseases even with covet and I think
that's that's interesting and and it
really means that we're just living
longer yeah
yeah so so we've gotten over we've
gotten past the issue of the fertility
we've talked about the mortality now
before we get to migration which is a
big part of the book I want to come back
and just look at some
countries right let's just talk about
that so today
the Hot Topic is Japan right uh and
we've seen the instead of the shrinking
of the Japanese population uh on the
other thing we see Nigeria right where
you have this vexing explosive
population what's the difference between
those two countries in terms of the
population transition if you may
Japan is a great case for us to talk
about
um because they are leading the way in
this demographic transition seeing it
over time they're the oldest country in
the world population wise so if we lined
everyone in Japan from the youngest
person to the oldest person we ask that
middle person to raise their hand they
would be almost 50 years old so we look
at where's the center of gravity of that
population age-wise and it is much older
and that's because Japan's fertility
fell well below replacement level early
and it stayed there and at the same time
of course people live quite long in
Japan they have the record life
expectancy so that of course would mean
that your average is higher because
people are living a long time Nigeria we
have nearly the opposite if we outlined
everyone in Nigeria up from youngest to
oldest and we asked the middle person to
raise their hand they'd be about 18
years old so it is one of only a few but
a few important countries in the world
where women still have on average five
or more children in their lifetimes and
so Nigeria's population has doubled and
will keep doubling as they stay on this
path of high fertility and in fact even
if fertility comes down so I think this
is important when you're talking about
projecting future energy needs
even if fertility Falls
there are so many people so many young
people today who will be aging into
their reproductive years that you have
what's called population momentum that
will keep that a growing country for
decades and decades and decades to come
it's interesting so we have Nigeria we
got we got Japan two other interesting
countries to look at
one's China right intensive demographics
and the other one is the one we're in
right now the United States talk about
their population Trends if you may so
China has really made the news in 2023
for its historic turn towards
depopulation and you know if you read
the media it's it's newsworthy because
it feels like a surprise to people whose
job it may not be to follow demographic
Trends but you can even read Chinese
policy documents and 40 years ago the
central party was anticipating
population aging I think that's notable
as well so China is a huge country it's
one of our demographic Giants it will
remain one of our demographic Giants I
think that's an important thing to put
on the table even as it shrinks and even
if it shrinks as much as right now if
fertility stayed the same as it is
by the end of this Century China will
lose 800 million people that is a lot
that is if nothing changes by the end of
this Century yes by the end of this
Century which I don't often project out
that far
but it's actually a useful exercise when
you can say if nothing changes this is
what happens and then of course policy
makers it's their job to say well what
might we change so or what can we try to
change that's a difference
part of this so China is going to still
be huge even in the future
and but China is one of over 30
countries that actually have shrinking
populations and I'm not sure how widely
known that is that this is not this is
kind of where we're all headed I think
much as Japan is important to follow
because they're really leading the way
in terms of their aging and shrinking we
can think about China the same way but
the U.S is different and we're different
because of that third dial so I don't
want to you know jump ahead on migration
but it makes a difference so the United
States
has below replacement fertility as well
about 1.6 children born per woman on
average and
um
we
have many places in in the country I
think something like 70 percent of U.S
counties last year had more deaths than
births so
the deaths versus birth thing is the
same here as it is in many other places
and in fact we have an issue with
mortality as well because the United
States is an exception not in a way that
I like that our life expectancy was
already declining pre-covered that's not
really something that should be
happening in a country with living
standards as high as ours but we
continue to be an incredibly attractive
destination for migrants worldwide
even with the political the political
nature of that
um to the extent that that continues so
here we are with a policy choice right
to the extent that that continues it
does make up for the low fertility and
it does keep the US population
continuing to have positive growth in
the decades to come it's interesting you
know what is intriguing about the book
and if you haven't read it I recommend
you do because you will learn a lot
about just when the world is headed
migration
very interesting you talk about
in some cases it doesn't make logical
sense when you look at how migration
patterns are in the expectations so you
hear the media say migration is a big
thing too many immigrants but in the
book you talk you say basically it's
like only two percent of the world's
population
are living in communities where they
were not born yeah just two to four
percent has been steady for decades and
decades and decades doesn't feel like
that when you read the news no it
doesn't
so so talk about you know what's
different now with migration compared to
the past I mean the book you talk about
the situation in Europe with you know
European I guess 84 80 million migrants
something in Europe and then you have
Saudi Arabia so just talk about the
demographics and in terms of migration
in different parts of the world what are
some of the key takeaways sure so I I
think the the thing about migration that
does cause such a splash in the media is
that they're not evenly dispersed around
the globe so at that Global level
it's just two to four percent means most
people stay where they're born
country-wise
but when people do leave they tend to go
to the same places over and over again
such as the United States and so
part of it is the fact that data wise
they really are in in different
um they're not evenly spread around the
world but then I think a large part of
it is also perception
and that's important with demographics
in general and and that might be
something we could talk about later but
it's how people feel about where their
population is is often more powerful
than the actual numbers
once
population numbers get taken into the
political Arena they tend to get used by
all the different sides for their own
political gain I'm actually working on a
book about that about the politics of
demographic Distortion with a couple of
co-authors that should come out in
couple of years
you said a couple of years I was going
to say Can you can you promise to come
here first and talk about it yeah if
we're if we're all still here I'll be
back to talk about that okay yeah no but
go back I mean I started the migration
piece so the migration piece and and
when we think about how can we project
migration you know you read the media
and in fact actually I think politicians
really believe this also I think they
they believe you can't predict it and
it's a total surprise so everything is a
crisis the word migration and crisis
they just seem to go together always
it's a crisis because of uh an
unwillingness to plan for it but it's
not really a surprise we know that these
events like natural disasters or
economic disaster or even crime drive
people out in large waves over and over
again in the same way and there's just
not a lot of political will to deal with
that and I'm not just talking about the
United States this is really globally
um we want to project migration the
safest thing we could do to to hedge our
bets to say it'll look a lot like the
past
and it remains political so it's not as
if
countries are going to be taken over by
migration because politics is an
effective gatekeeper interesting before
I want to go and talk about the
Practical use of demography or
demographics if you may in the context
of climate and even energy which is the
theme of this conference I want to talk
about migration
even within a country and in the book
you talk about urbanization and what I
will call sustained ruralization because
there are people most of them realize it
most of the world still live in urban
communities right just talk about how
urbanization is shaping up and maybe
maybe just say a few words about mega
cities and something I learned from the
book I didn't know meta cities
you know urbanization isn't
is a puzzle in some ways from a research
perspective
[Music]
which I think is it can be difficult
when you're trying to understand things
especially like energy use I mean that
that that's that would be problematic
from from that standpoint we know some
general things
even though many people would talk about
the problematic aspects of cities there
they can be very crowded a city in a
low-income country
feels and looks different and has
different opportunities than in a
wealthy country
on the whole people tend to want to move
from rural to urban areas not everyone
and not everyone will so we think of a
place as being saturated in terms of its
urbanization when it's looking at like
70 and 80 percent urbanized it's not
going to probably get more urbanized
than that but there are lots of areas in
the world where they've not hit that
point so
um to give to paint with broad brush
Strokes Asia and Africa continentally
will
be places we would expect to continue to
urbanize because as of now they haven't
hit those points
and I think what our research does show
so far is that people continue to move
there as long as they think so back
we're back to some perception here life
is better there than it is in the rural
areas and generally it is there's more
access to job opportunities educational
opportunities uh even fun and meeting a
mate and so I would expect that to
continue in the future
yeah
I'm talking about those big cities
though City size I think one of the
things that's a little bit hard to wrap
our brains around with urbanization
though is that you know I'm from a town
in Georgia I'm sure everyone can hear
the southern accent that had had and has
no stoplight and is Metro Atlanta
and I raised goats as a child so I am an
urban
product but that doesn't look anything
like Washington DC or yeah
shiny cities in Singapore et cetera so I
think it's nice to be able to have the
opportunity and in the the book I was
able to do so to say how does each
country even Define urban
um because it's not necessarily mean
City so much
and so I think we'll see much more of
when we when we see urbanization yes
we'll continue to see more and bigger
cities
but also don't just picture cities when
you think urbanization just think people
being more concentrated together
so if we tie this to climate
um you know we in a book you mentioned
refugees right you talk about that an
unfortunate situation so how could
climate change impact demographic
especially in the context of migration
so migration has been one of the
responses that people use to adapt to
climate changes and I would say that you
know since since the beginning of time
we have you know
centuries ago people would experience
famine they would experience drought
they would um you know have floods and
they weren't able to do so would
potentially move in order to adapt to
those changes and it's really quite
similar today
so we often see that kind of migration
happening just to somewhere close by
if it is a long-term environmental
change like the kinds that come from you
know climate change over time
we will we would expect to see people
move permanently some people again it's
not everybody can move not everybody
wants to move not everybody can move not
everybody has somewhere to go because
again it's still political when we have
sudden natural disasters which also can
intensify from climate change people
might move and come back but you can
even think about I'm sure everybody
knows knows some people maybe they're
aging parents or something
um you know sometimes you live somewhere
in the U.S where the environment around
you changes the social environment or
the physical environment you think why
don't you move why don't you move and I
said well no I just don't want to so
don't forget I think it's important for
for all of us to remember that even when
we track climate change over time we
track those Trends don't just assume it
leads to some of these migration numbers
that we see out there in the media
because there's a lot more to why people
move than that yeah and you know we'll
get into the I'll tie it back to the
electricity and energy shortly but I
want to get more into the demographics
aspect of this conversation you talk
about composition that you know you say
the age demographics and within that
context you talk about the factors that
determine that demographic is not just
the numbers the composition it's the
culture talk a little bit about that I
think it's important you know if we're
talking generally I think that's that's
there seems to be a tendency for
everybody in the world to want to
differentiate themselves from other
people we're talking at the group level
we see that happen with demographics as
well
um the project that I've been able to
work on at the Wilson Center this year
is it's a even longer term Book Project
so I don't know where we'll be when this
comes out but it's looking at the
history of the United States through a
population lens and what's been
remarkable with that is I can find
a Life Magazine story from you know 50
years ago or I could find a newspaper
story from a hundred years ago about
different
ethnic or racial groups about
immigration and Natives and it feels
like I am looking at something that
could have been published this week wow
and the same thing really happens
everywhere so composition is important
in terms of not just age composition
which really is important and that's my
my favorite topic to think about
um who in the society is needs education
you know what proportion of that we're
talking about Nigeria you know if half
the population's under 18 a lot of needs
for Education versus who might have aged
out of the workforce and have a lot of
Health Care needs at the end towards the
end of their lives like many countries
in Europe for example or who might have
the bulk of the population in those
Prime working ages but then we layer on
that some ethnic and racial composition
and that's where we really see things
start to get political everywhere around
the world
yeah and look so so we've talked a
little bit about the climate change and
migration piece
um you know just share a few light on
this issue of perspective or perception
perception right because as we Design
Energy Systems
how we perceive
the world yeah and I will receive our
customers and what they will do the
choices they will make will impact what
we do so talk about how important it is
for us to understand
demographics and the perspectives we
should bring to it when we start
applying demographic Trends which is
your expertise to designing Future
Energy Systems
so I think
useful in this case is that demographics
just becomes one of many types of data
so what we might do here is is zoom out
to how do any of us
think about and use data to inform our
work
and I think that there are some traps
that we all fall into with data and when
I can use demographics as an example of
that so one of the traps that we fall
into is a tendency to assume that
whatever the trend is that it continues
and and here's an example of that so
you think back to the story I told about
the six billion with the day I learned
of this this would be 1999 as a fresh
undergraduate
and my professor given her age she first
learned about demographics in the birth
of the U.S environmental movement so
we're talking in the 1960s and then kind
of into the 70s these were her formative
years of demographics and people might
think to themselves right now take a
pause and say you know how old was I
what year would it have been when I
first thought maybe this is important
and maybe it's right now
and I talked to a lot of audiences who
want to really
um
talk about population growth and this
sounds bad but I can kind of look and
think how old is this person and when
did they first form their their opinions
because at the time Paul Ehrlich wrote
the population bomb 1968 huge Splash
there were 125 countries out of our 200
and some plus where women had five or
more children on average
when I learned about
the 6 billion and and it really started
to come to me there were about 38
countries and now there are eight so
with data and perception we have to
constantly update ourselves on the trend
now people don't necessarily have the
time to do that that's why people like
me write these books so you can just
read the book and you're good on your
demographic data but make sure we put
out another Edition in a few years
because things change so update and
understand that things change
um I think there's also we need to
understand that Trends work in Tandem
and they work in context so you can't
just say ah demography is Destiny I mean
that's why I love being a political
scientist who uses demographics because
I know that politics matters so that
same Trend in two different places could
have two different outcomes and that's
because all kinds of factors matter I I
political institutions like democracy or
non-democracy that matters Japan's aging
and China's aging are going to look
different because they have very
different political systems
and then third I think we want to think
about our biases that we bring to the
data so I see this a lot in the National
Security sphere where I've worked at the
United States
wants to see itself as the most powerful
country in the world I think many of our
peers want to see themselves as the most
powerful country in the world
so there's a tendency to look through
that lens at the data I think that
really has happened with China and
Russia as U.S looks at those countries I
know that at the time that I was at the
Department of Defense uh in the
mid-oughts Russia was going through its
some tremendous depopulation like losing
up to 600 000 people a year and there
were all these headlines about their
alcoholism High mortality and low
fertility
and there were articles by high-ranking
military people and influential Minds
who said we don't need to worry about
Russia from a military standpoint
because their demography is their
destiny and then people like me and
there were very few of us to say that's
not how it works and here we sit today
with Russia saying
continuing to have demographic I almost
never say disaster but I think right now
actually I'll say demographic disaster
and continues to push and so I would say
there's a warning about looking at
China's depopulation through the same
lens but what desires are you bringing
to the data do you see what you want to
see or confirmation bias even when you
look at this does it confirm what you
already think
so you know I want to just practically
this is an audience watching this around
the world uh leaders from the energy
sector the lectures of the industry but
other Industries right so why should we
care why should our industry care about
demographics as we look to energize
eight billion people and counting and
counting why should we care about
demographics
so you can kind of tell me this I'm
guessing you want to anticipate where
the greatest needs will be and what
they'll be like right I think
demographics is
if you are ignoring demographics you
will never have a complete picture of
the future you absolutely have to
include it then of course the political
scientist to me says that better not be
the only thing that you're looking at of
course so when we are looking at the
world today we've really never been more
divided demographically this is kind of
what we were starting to talk about at
the beginning I mean when you look at
the 8 billion of us
there are the oldest societies on the
planet that we've ever had thinking
about Japan but not just Japan I mean
we're moving towards this and much many
other parts of Asia in Europe Etc and
then continuing uh young and growing
populations in other areas
and so we need to understand that the
needs of those populations are really
different and they're out of our 8
billion 6 billion are in low and middle
income countries and I think that's
probably the of the most use as you
think through this
and what's interesting about that six
billions like we keep peeling back
layers of the onion here they have
really varied demographic Trends as well
you know I don't know how commonly known
it is but the number of new entrants to
India's Workforce yearly so if we just
took those ages 15 to 17 that already
peaked oh wow that happened last decade
but we think about India as one of the
eight countries that will really drive
us from eight to nine billion between
now and mid-century and that is because
of kind of have I mentioned with Nigeria
earlier
the population momentum it's baked in
from the past but India actually has
below replacement fertility so I think
as you anticipate energy needs part of
it is counting people
of course now how how many people will
there be but then where will they be so
we do know that the number of shrinking
countries it's it's growing uh two out
of every three people of our eight
billion live somewhere with the low
replacement fertility that is a sea
change in global population Trends so
what we look like globally at eight is
not what we will look like at nine or
ten but our the question that that the
energy industry has is the same as many
other Industries have which is how much
will standards of living rise among that
6 billion in low and middle income
countries
demographics is part of this because
it's actually good news economically
when we see fertility falling we know
from the past that
when fertility Falls
we've generally seen better educated
populations and an opportunity not a
guarantee but an opportunity
for those populations for those
countries to really grow the economy
something called the demographic
dividend that we've seen worldwide so of
that 6 billion you know there are some
countries within that that if they play
their cards right they'll see that big
economic growth for they should have a
lot more energy needs and a lot more
consumption
so so more or less than is seeing
demographics as a
almost like a resource and because you
talk in the book about you know you know
how do you harness the information
you've gathered so from a public policy
standpoint a lot of the listeners here
energy leaders and others you know take
their Clues from the policy makers right
so let's talk from a public policy
perspective you're a political science
expert uh what should energy leaders
around the world meaning not the ones
who are running the businesses but more
the policy makers right
how should they
what should they glean out of this
conversation in terms of we want to
energize the world get to 8 billion
people the first conversation at this
Jeff with another influential mind was
on the theme of
the asymmetricity the asymmetry around
uh universal access oh yeah right and so
we have a conversation on Monday and and
then we follow that up with a
conversation talking about uh you know
the World As We Know It with the you
know the author uh Rana farua from CNN
and so now we're talking about
demographics it's getting more specific
right so how should an energy policy
maker understand the importance or the
significance of demographic change as we
design public policy
so I think
you were right to phrase it as a
resource and that that's really
important because
I think the reason there's so much
hand-wringing over low fertility these
days is that national leaders and by
leaders I don't just mean politicians I
mean Business Leaders very much worry
about a society's ability to continue to
flourish as it moves along that
demographic transition towards much
older ages and a shrinking population
but I will keep coming back to
demography as not Destiny and we have to
think about resource with a resource
you've got to use it I mean and with
population you have to invest in it that
really looks the same in some ways
whether or not you are Nigeria or Japan
how do you invest in your Society to to
get the most out of it and of course I
mean very instrumental about population
here pretending like we're not all in
individuals but education is huge you
want to make the most of your population
Nigeria has to invest in education but
then so does Japan that can look a
little different
if we are thinking about retirement ages
we have in fact by the end of this
century worldwide just just from age 65
to 75. there'll be 800 million 65 to 75
year olds are they going to be in the
workforce or not that's partly a
political question
Leah cultural question but then have
they had opportunities for continued
education and retraining or not
I mean there's a huge resource I think
those companies and those countries that
invest in older workers and find more
flexible ways to bring them into the
workforce after traditional retirement
ages they will succeed and other
countries and companies that do not do
so are squandering the resource and
health is the other you're only as as
good as how healthy your population is
so
I think about those 75 or 65 to 75 year
olds the 800 million of them at the end
of the century are they healthy enough
to work
and in many cases right now if things
continue as they are
they would not be and that even includes
in the United States where we are not
doing a great job of making sure that
people have what's called a long healthy
life expectancy uh France Greece Spain
those folks they tend to live up to
decades uh in good health after
retirement
the countries in our peer group in the
U.S
um as far as healthy life expectancy and
how healthy do people how many years of
good health do people have after
retirement we can put together Russia
China Romania Mexico and the U.S are in
a group together where it's only 10 to
11 years
so that really squanders the ability of
your population to be a resource for you
so education and health are two of the
important Investments that every country
needs you know you know two other topics
being discussed this week at the Jeff
one has to do with Workforce uh and and
the other one has to do with critical
minerals okay right both things sort of
a lean to Resource consumption are the
need for resource right so talk a little
bit about you know in terms of it
because in the book you know in the
chapter where you talk about the future
of global population you talk about how
you know you say people either look at a
problem inside out or outside in and and
so from a decision-making perspective
can you describe different approaches to
the problem solving around
demographic inside out outside in how
can we take that into consideration as
we design the future Workforce for the
energy industry that's a great question
I I love this inside out outside and
part of this because you know I
originally started my working career
around demographics thinking about
forecasting and so the inside out
outside in I take straight from Philip
tetlock as we think about predicting the
future and so he gives this great
example
um and then I'll give you a population
example of being at a wedding let's say
you and I were at a friend's wedding and
we're watching them have their first
dance and and maybe I Turn to You and I
say what do you think the chances are
that they get divorced
well if we're looking at them they look
so in love on that dance floor we would
just say well very low and that it would
actually be rude if you said that you
thought they were going to get divorced
but if we have this kind of outside in
perspective we might we look at Baseline
rates for divorce for their group and
then we would add to that though what do
we know about them do we know like do
they fight all the time and they barely
made it to the altar so we want to marry
both the inside out and outside in
perspectives with this and we want to
keep updating and I think that gets to
to something I mentioned earlier with my
professor and then me and I and I'm
constantly surprised by new data keep
trying to learn about this
uh and here's a population example as
you plan for the future let's go back to
Nigeria
I was pulling some numbers recently
about
where will Nigeria's population be
number wise just in 2040. that's really
not that far in the future when you
consider that a lot of the mothers are
already born okay so this is the nice
thing about demographics we follow
fairly predictable patterns and a lot of
the people of the future are already
born so you want to understand about the
workforce you can kind of go ahead and
get some numbers because go to go to the
kindergarten classes like that's your
future Workforce okay
and then some
so I was looking at how different the
projections were for Nigeria's total
population in 2040 and I took two
projections one is the un's medium
variant that's the one you read any news
article they're using that one and
basically the UN just says here's the
universe of projections and we've just
here's the one in the middle
and then I said what if nothing changes
and I pulled what they call their
constant fertility variant
the difference was
you know tens of millions of people
based on whether or not fertility Falls
by a child in a hat so if you are
looking at that Medium variant for the
United Nations and you're looking at
Nigeria's population less than two
decades in the future that Medium
variant assumes fertility There Will
Follow by a child and a half per woman
on average
now we want to understand this we need
to say
what has happened historically with
other countries does it tend to fall at
that rate Botswana it felt faster than
that some places it hasn't fallen nearly
as fast as they thought it would and
then you need to ask some questions
about Nigeria itself do you think that
the leadership
take seriously the need for education
and right space Family Planning and you
know ending child marriage so that it
would lead to a situation where
fertility Falls that fast or not and so
when you think about the future
Workforce think about the kinds of
Investments being made today to
understand the characteristics of that
Workforce in the future
look so uh we I think we have I guess 10
15 more minutes but I just want to get
into one very important thing so climate
power action
is or are the three words the sort of a
surmise this this conference this week
and one of the things that's common with
them is making predictions and
projecting into the future so the energy
industry
climate Advocates governments all make
projections about what we should do we
shouldn't do regarding climate the
actions and in a book you talk about
desirability bias
so we have a lot of goals that have been
set for the world in terms of climate we
have a lot of goals being said by
Business Leaders watching this uh this
this uh this conversation
um and we have a lot of goals set as
individuals so
talk about desirability bias and how
might that affect
how we energize the world
oh now we're getting into the the
juicier part of this I think so so I'm
gonna ask you a little bit about this
what do you think that most of your
leaders would desire to see the most
maybe Trends in
sustainability of resource use for
example or uh you know total energy use
so I think when I talked to Executives
around the world
I think many almost all of them
recognize that something needs to be
something needs to be done around you
know the vexing challenges around
climate change I think they all want to
get the transition going
I think they also want it to be done in
a way that's fair Equitable affordable
it's important but they also want to be
done in a way that the public policies
that are brought to bear are those that
not only enable the building of the
necessary infrastructure but that enable
the transition to be done in a way that
doesn't uh create uh inefficiencies or
inequalities yeah so those are set up if
I should I mean it would differ from
executive to Executive but if I will
take all of their views together those
are the sentences I will use to describe
what they will desire
so I think as we start to interrogate
that then what we might want to do is
say
how much on the path are we for that
which I think a lot of people you know I
might be someone who says there's a
desire to among some groups to see uh
more sustainable energy use if we look
at the immediate trends
not everywhere in the world are we
leading towards more sustainable use so
I think that what checking ourselves on
our desirability bias is saying make
sure when you really take a hard look at
the data that you're not seeing what you
want to see in it I think some people
who are are in an industry in a
particular sector where they will
benefit if you are headed down that
Trend are going to tell you the story
that we are headed on that trend
and that may not actually be true but
then I think we could also
um
sometimes our desires do come true I
think there's a lot of opportunity to
you know I think about India for example
and uh commercial electric vehicle usage
for example technology I mean this is we
haven't mentioned technology yet but but
this is something we got to bring
technology into this so you know
sometimes our desires as long as you're
aware of what they are the first step is
always make sure you name them before
you go into the data and then use that
to to give a really critical look to say
are you actually headed down that path
or not so basically let our desire be
brought to bear yes
and then we can remove the bias and
we'll succinctly look at the data in
terms of understanding are we on the
right path or are we not because of our
desires by driving our decision making
we may actually end up doing the wrong
thing oh absolutely and again I see this
in the National Security Community all
the time but I think you know if you're
sitting down together with your your
senior leadership at the table and
you've got the Whiteboard marker I think
the one of the first things you should
do when you open a meeting is say what
do we desire and what do we think and
name those and put them on the
Whiteboard and then start looking at
your Trends and make sure that you
realize and you know you're constantly
referring back am I just looking for
those and let me make sure I look for
evidence of the opposite as well that's
a very interesting thing makes you
wonder how many of the goals we've been
setting from a business standpoint in
general yeah have been desire driven as
opposed to something that's real
practical achievable and sort of a
grounded in in the data and grounded in
fact and even our measurements for them
I mean it's certainly you can measure
and say oh yes look how well we did this
year on this thing because that's what
you want to see from the data and maybe
that's not maybe there's data to the
contrary as well okay so I saved the
best for last in this conversation
almost the best okay technology
let's talk about how technology can
basically because you said fertility
mortality and migration I would add both
ones yeah we should be technology since
you didn't cover that in the book yeah
give us an idea on how technology shapes
demographics it is all influences I was
going to say so when I think about this
um this line I kind of gave you earlier
that demography is not Destiny and that
the same Trend two different places can
have two different outcomes there are
forces in societies I mentioned like
whether a country is a democracy or not
a democracy that can amplify demographic
Trends or dilute them another one of
those forces is technology and so as I
think a lot about the number of
countries again the majority of people
in the world living somewhere with the
low replacement fertility of course one
of the worries that Business Leaders
have in particular is will they have
enough workers
and so what we've seen
um is that that's a great place for
technology to come in
and it it has done a lot
I think again Japan is a great example
of this
when I first started studying population
aging 20 years ago nobody thought that
an aged country could continue to be
Innovative they were like oh it's like
an aging person you know you just have
all these cognitive declines and and you
know you lose all of that Japan
continues to lead in that and in fact I
think demographic stresses can really
push Innovation yeah so what we see
there is not only do they have of course
these wearable exoskeletons to help
people lift more they also have washing
machines for elderly people they just
wheel somebody in close the door their
head sticks out so it's okay and you
push the button and it helps so there
are lots of jobs in the world where
technology can substitute for labor or
it can make us more productive because
really that's the thing I think there's
a lot of worry about losing numbers of
workers and we've got to shift our
mindset to think more about how do we
make each of us more productive from an
economic standpoint and of course
technology is there technology yeah but
there's a worry I have with technology
as well
so in in those places in the world with
young and growing populations
in the past that path to Economic
Development a lot of it's been
manufacturing lead growth and so you say
are one of our greatest resources right
now is we have tons of young people who
could lead us into economic development
through their labor
if technology comes in and can
substitute for some of that labor I do
have a worry that those young people
will not find the same level of
Engagement and Economic Opportunity and
I think that could be a problem we have
other political science research that I
talk about in the book that says that
when people are expecting to
basically do better than their parents
and then those expectations are not met
there's a much greater likelihood for
political instability so
in the future
is it going to be the case that
sub-Saharan African economies because
they will really be the only populations
with lots and lots of young people
is that going to be their key to
Economic Development or will technology
have come in to replace some of that
labor and I think you know coming back
to what you previously talked about
to harness that demographic dividend in
sub-Saharan Africa or other emerging
economies there has to be an investment
in developing the resource right so you
know using that that analogy so to speak
I want to wrap up
you know before I get to my wrap-up
question we should be a fire sort of a
fire lightning round talking about the
key takeaways I just want to go back to
demographics or population and power
because in a book you give a very
interesting analogy where you talk about
where people see some leaders I mean I
think you mentioned hosting Mubarak for
example in Egypt uh you'd mention other
leaders but why do you think some
leaders see population growth as a size
of power and others may not
you know I think it is historical
because historically speaking those big
populations you know the bigger the
better
I think we got lots of examples now
where that's not the case anymore
Singapore is not large very strong
economy influential in its own ways for
example
um it has been hard to shake that
population as power though some of it is
people are students of History so that
it kind of again what sticks in your
mind uh things are these ideas are
sticky over time
um I think that there are some leaders
in countries with high fertility
who are unwilling to invest in the
population in a way that could help
people have fewer children if they
desire to do so because they see
population as power and in fact I worry
that
all of the media coverage about China's
aging and shrinking population and we're
going to just keep seeing more and more
of that South Korea record low fertility
I really worry that those leaders in
countries that have high fertility
will be unwilling to invest in ending
child marriage you know spreading
education right space Family Planning
health care whatever the the case may be
because they don't want to go down that
path and they'll say well at least we'll
still be young and growing I think that
we need to be attuned to that as a
possibility
so so you know this is Midway into the
Jeff uh Wednesday and we have two more
days to go
um just help the energy leaders
listening to this to understand why each
of them should hire a demographer why do
we need more demographers
in terms of Designing Not Just Energy
Systems but future systems of the world
why is your profession so important
because the more I read the book The
More I realized gee I should have bought
this book two decades ago because it
would have helped me in some of my own
decision making from a business
standpoint why why is that so important
so
I'm happy to come in and do some
Consulting anytime but I think you have
to understand that people are the
foundation of everything we are all your
workers we are all your decision makers
we're your voters consumers Etc so at a
very basic level if you are not
including demographics in your analysis
of what is now and is to come you'll
never have a full picture of things but
I think it can also enhance your
understanding especially when you know
as as we think about future needs if
that's a year from now three years or
decades from now
there's always a range of possibilities
and so understanding that the population
can help you learn about ranges of
possibilities and when we started by
talking about those dials they turned up
and they turn down some of it is uh you
know demographic Trends themselves are
influenced by external factors you know
how many children I might end up having
maybe in part driven by how the economy
is doing
so I think to get our as an exercise and
understanding the range this is a great
uh learning opportunity for us to look
at how demographic Trends have changed
over time what's likely to change them
over time and then that way you're
really having a comprehensive uh
understanding of Technology of
population of energy economic drivers
environmental drivers all put together
to give you a clearer picture of the
future and really understanding that
demographic composition which is
something you also talk about all right
Jennifer let's wrap this composition up
by just quickly going through your key
takeaways towards the end of the book
and just you know just give us your
thoughts on these
six little thoughts here the first one
size Matters why Size Matters really
because of perception so whether or not
you know it actually matters in the same
way that it would have 200 years ago how
many soldiers do you have to field an
army for example
there is still a sticky perception among
leaders that the bigger the better so it
matters because of that perception
aspect of that that means that as we
look to the Future those countries like
China and India and the United States as
the three biggest countries continuing
now and in the next few decades they
will still wield lots of regional
influence and in some cases Global
influence okay people move in somewhat
predictable patterns why so
the places in the world where people
might need to move the most or
so so we know that people tend to move
um we can actually draw some some lines
in in the sand there to say that when a
country hits certain levels of income
people are actually more likely to move
and that kind of makes sense like did
you save up enough to go it's expensive
to move and you need to know how to do
it so we know that there are certain
patterns if you want to project out
looking at the world you know are the
people of Niger likely to be some of the
world's uh you know biggest immigrants
in the next few decades no they're not
they are not likely to be but as
Nigeria's media about median income
Rises perhaps Nigerians would be so this
is an interesting one so as we're
talking about energized in the world of
8 billion people and Counting uh we
decided Energy Systems we have
assumptions about where people will live
this one the world is Urban
yes it is safe for us to say it is a
general Trend towards urbanization now
was we tried to nail it down to more
specifics that's a little harder but
when you're designing systems places
that are not saturated in terms of
urbanization they'll continue to
urbanize and so you are going to have to
account for those energy needs and plan
for those okay uh the other one no
surprise an aging world is coming yeah
and it's really here I think uh when we
are looking at the world of 9 billion
that is a much older World
um for much of it you know it's really
that we're back to this divide here
but with China and India both at the low
replacement fertility these are two huge
countries and they are both aging as
well India is going to keep growing but
their median age is going to be
increasing as well okay two more the one
the next this next one is very important
for this industry
policies can shape the future we want
yes demography is not Destiny it is
incredibly important and you can't get a
sense of the present or future without
it but harnessing the power of your
population that comes from investing in
things like Education Health Care and
that's throughout people's life courses
from Young to very old so we we we've
come to the last one before I asked you
the last one I was just put one little
punctuation mark on something we didn't
talk about and that is the notion of
long-term thinking versus short-term
thinking earlier this month we had a
conversation with a A Neurosurgeon who
talked about the importance of
understanding brain circuitry how the
brain works and you begin the book when
you talk about the uh you talk about the
the growth and you talk about the
differential growth and you describe
what we've seen not so much of a
population exponentially growing but
more of a differential growth so given
our mindset given the fact that we need
to think long term the last one says the
demographic design of divide the
demographic divide divide will shape the
fortunes of countries yeah and it it's
that one is is an important one to end
on so I'm glad we are I've been thinking
a lot about how
as I shared that population hit 8
billion and that was the title of my
book
two camps of people uh would respond to
that one says how can Earth possibly
hold any more people
and I think there's a misunderstanding
when we see the overall number of people
growing in the world the rate of global
population growth has actually been
falling since the 1960s so for the
majority of people in the world they're
headed towards these aging and shrinking
populations they will have very
different needs and policies in place
things they want on the global stage
then those places in the world where
fertility is still really high
in parts of sub-Saharan Africa for
example or Central Asia
the types of things they want to see in
the world are going to look really
different so I think we can actually
extrapolate from what's happening at the
domestic level to how these different
sets of countries will interact with one
another on the global level as well how
they want to see investment maybe how
they decide to cooperate economically or
even have some armed conflict
potentially I mean it could really spill
over into every sphere that will have
fundamentally different interests and I
don't know that our Global architecture
is strong enough to help these Divergent
interests really come together and
certainly energy is a case study for
that where there are Divergent interests
among countries around the world that's
going to continue
well look the book was written in 2022
and it was the year we actually hit it
and I would say to you you're a fortune
teller because you you came up with the
title of the book before we hit 8
billion so so congratulations on that
eight billion and count to have sex
death and migration ship our world uh
Jennifer Shuba this has been a delight
having this conversation with you and
you've exposed me to a whole new
profession uh being a democrified
something I think we should all at least
attempt to do an attempt to understand
so thanks for joining us here the global
electrification forum as part of this
influential mind series thank you so
much thank you for having me it was a
wonderful conversation
Episode 07Sebastian Mallaby
How venture capital, risk-taking and connected networks turn bold ideas into startups and spread entrepreneurial culture.
Episode 06Michael Spence
How growth, innovation and good governance can reduce poverty and inequality while navigating climate and geopolitical shocks.
Episode 02Harmeet Sawhney
Universal access to electricity and public services: who benefits, who pays, and how inclusion can reshape communities.